What can go wrong with DNA profiling Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Forensic DNA Profiling Video Series Forensic Bioinformatics (www.bioforensics.com)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Creating informative DNA libraries using computer reinterpretation of existing data Northeastern Association of Forensic Scientists November, 2011 Newport,
Advertisements

Evaluating forensic DNA evidence Forensic Bioinformatics ( Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Steelman Visiting Scientist.
Evaluating forensic DNA evidence: what software can and cannot do Forensic Bioinformatics ( Dan E. Krane, Wright State University,
Scientific aspects of cold case reviews Presented by: Ian Hamilton Biology Manager SPSA (Glasgow) SIPR Annual Conference
LYNDAL BUGEJA Keynote Presentation MANAGER CORONERS PREVENTION UNIT.
August 12,  Crime-scene investigators (police) arrive to find, collect, protect, and transport evidence. (More on this later!)
Crime Laboratories Forensic Science Mr. Glatt
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting). What is DNA Profiling? A technique used by scientists to distinguish between individuals of the same species using.
"The Unexpected Consequences of Open Discovery: One Laboratory's Experience" Christine Funk General Counsel Department of Forensic sciences 401 E Street.
Hypothesis Testing After 2 hours of frustration trying to fill out an IRS form, you are skeptical about the IRS claim that the form takes 15 minutes on.
The Basics of CODIS Combined DNA Index System
Nicholas Cowerdy QC, DPP Was pioneered in Australia by state Forensic Science Laboratory and introduced into casework in July 1989 As a result the following.
By Lucy Johnson Forensic Anthropology By Lucy Johnson.
Fundamentals of Forensic DNA Typing Slides prepared by John M. Butler June 2009 Chapter 13 Quality Assurance.
Forensic Anthropology By Lucy Johnson. Forensic Anthropology “Forensic anthropology is the examination of human skeletal remains for law enforcement agencies.
Kern Regional Crime Laboratory Laboratory Director: Dr. Kevin W. P. Miller TRUEALLELE® WORK AND WORKFLOW: KERN COUNTY’S FIRST CASES APRIL 23, 2014.
Crime Scene Investigation Science in Motion Cedar Crest College.
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
How can DNA be used to solve Crimes?
Doug Raiford Lesson 15.  Every cell has identical DNA  If know the sequence of a suspect can compare to evidence  But wait… Do we have to sequence.
Statistical weights of mixed DNA profiles Forensic Bioinformatics ( Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Forensic DNA.
How is DNA used to solve crimes? 8 th Grade Forensic Science T. Trimpe
How is DNA used to solve crimes?
Development of ISO Standards ISO PC 272 Forensic Science Kermit B. Channell II TC272, U.S. TAG Chair.
Artifacts and noise in DNA profiling Forensic Bioinformatics ( Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Forensic DNA Profiling.
Implications of database searches for DNA profiling statistics Forensic Bioinformatics ( Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton,
 Intro to DNA Analysis Forensic Science 11/20/14.
Warm-Up October 6, 2014 What do you already know about DNA? Be specific.
Statistical weights of single source DNA profiles Forensic Bioinformatics ( Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Forensic.
The Time Has Come to Analyze DNA Profile Databases Forensic Bioinformatics ( Dan E. Krane, Ph.D., Wright State University, Dayton,
How is DNA be used to solve crimes? 8 th Grade Forensic Science T. Trimpe
Observer effects in DNA profiling Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Forensic DNA Profiling Video Series Forensic Bioinformatics (
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting)
DNA Evidence How can DNA be used to solve Crimes?.
How is DNA used to solve crimes? 8 th Grade Forensic Science T. Trimpe
Disputed DNA Stats for a Low-level Sample: A Case Study By Dan Krane – Carrie Rowland –
Seventh Annual Prescriptions for Criminal Justice Forensics Program Fordham University School of Law June 3, 2016 DNA Panel.
Generating forensic DNA profiles
Forensic Specialist.
DNA technology in court
Developing the Overall Audit Plan and Audit Program
Statistical Weights of DNA Profiles
Misinterpretation of sample contamination in a Hungarian casework
DO NOW What is a restriction enzyme?
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
DNA Profiling and using electrophoresis
Rules for DNA Comparison Analysis
How is DNA be used to solve crimes? General Science
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting)
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
How can DNA be used to solve crimes?
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
UNUSUAL INCIDENT REPORTS AND MAJOR UNUSUAL INCIDENTS
How is DNA be used to solve crimes? Honors Forensic Science
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
Forming a Cold Case Unit and Unit Expectations
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
DNA Profiling (DNA fingerprinting).
How is DNA be used to solve crimes?
Presentation transcript:

What can go wrong with DNA profiling Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Forensic DNA Profiling Video Series Forensic Bioinformatics (

What could go wrong? The science of DNA profiling is sound Not all of DNA profiling is scientific Especially true in situations involving: small amounts of starting material, mixtures, and analyst judgment calls.

Documenting errors: DNA Advisory Board Quality Assurance Standards for Forensic DNA Testing Laboratories, Standard 14 [Forensic DNA laboratories must] “follow procedures for corrective action whenever proficiency testing discrepancies and/or casework errors are detected” [and] “shall maintain documentation for the corrective action.”

Documenting errors Cross contamination:

Documenting errors Positive result in negative control:

Documenting errors Positive result in negative control, due to tube swap:

Documenting errors Analyst contamination:

Documenting errors Separate samples combined in one tube....

Documenting errors Separate samples combined in one tube leading to corrective action:

Samples mixed up Documenting errors

Suspect doesn’t match himself but then, staff is “‘always’ getting people’s names wrong”:

Victorian Coroner’s inquest into the death of Jaidyn Leskie Toddler disappears in bizarre circumstances: found dead six months later Mother’s boy friend is tried and acquitted. Unknown female profile on clothing. Cold hit to a rape victim. RMP: 1 in 227 million. Lab claims “adventitious match.”

Victorian Coroner’s inquest into the death of Jaidyn Leskie Condom with rape victim’s DNA was processed in the same lab 1 or 2 days prior to Leskie samples. Additional tests find matches at 5 to 7 more loci. Review of electronic data reveals low level contributions at even more loci. Degradation study further suggests contamination.

Degradation, inhibition When biological samples are exposed to adverse environmental conditions, they can become degraded –Warm, moist, sunlight, time Degradation breaks the DNA at random Larger amplified regions are affected first Classic ‘ski-slope’ electropherogram Degradation and inhibition are unusual and noteworthy. LARGELARGE SMALLSMALL

Degradation, inhibition The Leskie Inquest, a practical application Undegraded samples can have “ski-slopes” too. How negative does a slope have to be to an indication of degradation? Experience, training and expertise. Positive controls should not be degraded.

Degradation, inhibition The Leskie Inquest DNA profiles in a rape and a murder investigation match. Everyone agrees that the murder samples are degraded. If the rape sample is degraded, it could have contaminated the murder samples. Is the rape sample degraded?

Degradation, inhibition The Leskie Inquest

Victorian Coroner’s inquest into the death of Jaidyn Leskie “8. During the conduct of the preliminary investigation (before it was decided to undertake an inquest) the female DNA allegedly taken from the bib that was discovered with the body was matched with a DNA profile in the Victorian Police Forensic Science database. This profile was from a rape victim who was subsequently found to be unrelated to the Leskie case.”

Victorian Coroner’s inquest into the death of Jaidyn Leskie “8. The match to the bib occurred as a result of contamination in the laboratory and was not an adventitious match. The samples from the two cases were examined by the same scientist within a close time frame.” Leskie_decision.pdf

Steps in Preparing a DNA Case Obtain all lab reports Red flags: –unfamiliar techniques –equivocal matches (profile “similar but cannot be definitively included nor excluded”); –partial/incomplete profiles; –mixtures; –unusually modest statistics; no statistics; likelihood ratios

Steps in Preparing a DNA Case Initial discovery –Full history of all samples from collection to current disposition –Complete DNA lab notes (bench notes) –Electronic data –Analysts’ credentials, proficiency test record –Lab’s incidence reports; unexpected event files; accreditation files Obtain expert assistance for initial review

What could go wrong? The science of DNA profiling is sound Not all of DNA profiling is scientific Especially true in situations involving: small amounts of starting material, mixtures, and analyst judgment calls.

What can go wrong with DNA profiling Dan E. Krane, Wright State University, Dayton, OH Forensic DNA Profiling Video Series Forensic Bioinformatics (