BeforeAfter Eutrophication
Eutrophication – nutrient enrichment of waters Major nutrients -phosphorus and nitrogen Consequences -increased plant growth -decreased water quality
Eutrophication of lakes, reservoirs and rivers ranks as one of the most widespread environmental problems. Eutrophication can have significant negative ecological, health, social and economic impacts on use of a primary and finite resource, water.
Decreased water quality Algal blooms –Decreased transparency –DOC and chlorination disinfection products –Toxic cyanobacteria and dinoflagellate Growth of aquatic plants Anoxia
Effects of Eutrophication Source: Issues in Ecology #2 (1998)
Laguna de Bay, Philippines
US East Coast Source: Issues in Ecology #2 (1998)
Fish Kills and Anoxia in the Chesapeake
Decreased water quality Elevated nitrate concentrations Species changes Increased incidence of water-related diseases
Positive features of eutrophication - increased fish yield - increased plant production and nutrient reuse
Indicators of eutrophication Secchi disk transparency Chlorophyll concentration Phosphorus concentrations Nitrogen concentrations
Chemical Forms – P PO 4 3- (Phosphate) Organic
The cycling of Phosphorus Dissolved InorganicParticulate Organic uptake excretion Runoff upwellingsinking decomposition Balance maintained via weathering of rock
Chemical Transformations – P Assimilation PO 4 3- → Organic Phytoplankton or other autotrophs Remineralization Organic → PO 4 3- Heterotrophs Excretion Organic → Dissolved Heterotrophs and Autotrophs
Experimental Lakes Area Lake 227
Lake 226 C, N, P Eutrophic algal blooms C, N
Lake 227
Effects of Eutrophication Source: Issues in Ecology #2 (1998)
Classification of Lakes Source: Principles Env. Sci. & Eng. (Davis & Masten)
Probable, not certain… Eutrophic Source: Principles Env. Sci. & Eng. (Davis & Masten)
Total P vs. Chlorophyll a Source: Principles Env. Sci. & Eng. (Davis & Masten)
Meybeck, 1982
N fixation N 2 reactive N –(e.g. NH 3, NH 4 + ) Mostly biological free- living bacteria (asymbiotic) symbiotic
Synthetic fertilizer production is considered N fixation takes N 2, reacts it with natural gas, producing NH 3 and CO 2
Agriculture…
(Townsend et al. Frontiers Ecol. Environ. 2003)
(Tilman et al. Nature, 2002)
Percent Increase in Nitrogen Fluxes in Rivers Source: Millennium Ecosystem Assessment
Gulf of Mexico Dead Zone Source: NOAA
US East Coast Source: Issues in Ecology #2 (1998)
Fish Kills and Anoxia in the Chesapeake
(Townsend et al. Frontiers Ecol. Environ. 2003)
Source: Principles Env. Sci. & Eng. (Davis & Masten)
Is N or P limiting? – Assessment Concentration ratios Experimental enrichments Supply and recycling ratios Physiological assays
Algal bioassays – addition of known quantities of nutrients to algal suspensions and measurement of physiological or ecological responses
Watershed factors which moderate degree of eutrophication – * climate * hydrology * biogeochemistry * land use
Climatic Variability … rainfall in Goleta Non-El Niño El Niño
Hydrologic Response… Arroyo Burro Creek, WY 2001
SBC-LTER Study Region… Santa Clara River, 4200 km 2 Santa Barbara Channel (50) Watersheds ranging from km 2 Ventura River, 590 km 2 Los Angeles, CA Multi-source Land Cover Data (2002 v1) California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection
Parcel Scale… Residential Site Parcel Scale… Residential Site
Parcel Scale… Greenhouse Site Parcel Scale… Greenhouse Site
Analysis of Cause and Effect Low Nutrient Supply Low N & P conc. in lake Low algae productivity Low chlorophyll a Lake more transparent Greater Secchi disc depth High Nutrient Supply High N & P conc. in lake High algae productivity High chlorophyll a Lake less transparent Smaller Secchi disc depth Gradient of Conditions Toxic inflow High Sediment High Flowrate
Within-lake factors which moderate degree of eutrophication * food web structure * sediment regeneration * basin morphology * hydrodynamics
Technically effective control of eutrophication is possible but not always economically feasible
Solutions… Source Reduction –Eliminate excess fertilization –Wastewater treatment plants In Lake Control: –Mechanical harvesting of aquatic plants –Chemical control (algaecides) –Biological control (increase grazing) –Flow augmentation –Deep water aeration –Selective removal of deep water –Sediment removal