Parameters for Rating Municipal Councillors ParameterMarks Past 1 (Education qualification, PAN Card, Criminal cases)7 Present 2 (Attendance, No. of Question, Participation in Discussions (GBM), Questions compared to Citizen's Complaints & Importance of questions asked by issues raised, Usage of Area Development Fund 4 ) 63 Perception (through an citizen survey of 22,850 people for their perception on their Councillor’s accessibility/availability, performance, corruption, and satisfaction with quality of life, services provided by government) 30 Negative for new FIR cases till December 2014 post elections 3 Minus 5 Negative for pending Charge Sheet 3 Minus 5 Total100 2 RTI Data Source: 1 Municipal Secretary, MCGM (MCGM Head Office and BEST) and Assistant Engineer (Maintenance), MCGM (from all the 24 Administrative Wards of MCGM); 2 Election Commission Department, MCGM; 3 Mumbai Police. 4 Area Development Fund relates to the period April’14 to March’15 (Rs.60 lakhs).

Mumbai Report Card Municipal Councillors Grade A – Between 100% to 80% Grade B – Less than 80% to 70% Grade C – Less than 70% to 60% Grade D – Less than 60% to 50% Grade E – Less than 50% to 35% Grade F – Less than 35% (Period under consideration – April 2014 to March Ranking of 220 councillors)

4

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS by RANK 5 Ward Constituen cy No. Political PartyCouncillor name Score (out of 100) Rank R/S22 BJPSunita Ramnagina Yadav D210 INCNoshir Rusi Mehta R/S25 INCAjanta Rajpati Yadav G/S188 SSHemangi Hareshwar Worlikar P/N40 BJPGyanmurti Ramchandra Sharma L160 SSSanjana Kishor Mungekar K/W60 SSSanjay Kashinath Pawar F/S199 SS Hemangi Hemantkumar Chemburkar E208 INCManoj Pandurang Jamsutkar F/N169 SSShradha Shridhar Jadhav

6 BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS by RANK Ward Constituency No. Political PartyCouncillor name Score (out of 100) Rank S116MNSAvinash Bhaskar Sawant K/W53INDChangez Jamal Multani H/W97INC Mohammed Tanveer Mohammed Ali Patel H/E82MNSSukhada Rahul Pawar M/E139SSDinesh Harishchandra Panchal F/S198SSSanjay (Nana) Gajanan Ambole P/N37SSManisha Sadashiv Patil M/W142INCSeema Rajendra Mahulkar F/N172IND Manojkumar Martandrao Sansare N128MNSMangal Prameshwar Kadam

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS for MOVEMENT 7 WardC.No.PartyCounciilor name Score 2015 (out of 100) Rank Move mentReasons H/W94INCSunita Wavekar No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance K/W57NC Devendra Amberkar No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance P/S47SSJitendra Valvi No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance F/S195INCSunil More No. of questions, Quality of questions; Perceived Performance R/C13MNSChetan Kadam Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance K/E80INDJyoti Alavani Quality of questions; Perceived Performance F/N174INCNayna Sheth Quality of questions; Perceived Performance P/S51SSPramila Shinde Attendance; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance F/N169SSShradha Jadhav Quality of questions; Perceived Performance A225INC Sushama Salunkhe No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

8 BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS for MOVEMENT WardC. No.PartyCounciilor name Score 2015 (out of 100) Rank Move mentReasons G/N181MNSShraddha Patil Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance A224SSGanesh Sanap No. of questions; Quality of questions P/N42MNSDeepak Pawar Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance K/W62BJPAmeet Satam Attendance; No. of questions P/S45INCSneha Zagade Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions D213SSAnil Singh No. of questions K/E67SSManjiri Parab Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions F/N168BJPSelvan R. Tamil Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions H/E82MNSSukhada Pawar Attendance; No. of Question; Quality of questions H/E87BJPKrishna Parkar Attendance; No. of Question

TOP 10 COUNCILLORS for Participation in Discussion(GBM) 9 Ward Constituency No. Political PartyCouncillor nameNos. F/N170SSTrushna Chandrakant Vishwasrao27 K/W61INCMohsin Haji Haider25 S110NCPDhananjay Sadashiv Pisal20 K/W57INCDevendra Shridhar Amberkar19 M/E132SPRais Kasam Shaikh18 G/N185MNSSandeep Sudhakar Deshpande16 C220SPYaqoob Janmohammed Memon16 L159SPAshraf Azmi Aslam Ansari15 B222INCWaqarunnisa Ansari15 T103BJPManoj Kishorbhai Kotak14

Spread of Participation in Discussion(GBM) 10 CategoryNo. of councillors to to to 157 Above 167

Highlights (1/2) 11 For the first time ‘A’ grade has been assigned to a councillor Average committee meeting attendance down to 68% in from 81% in Proportion of questions asked compared to civic complaint's just 29.1%. Awareness and accessibility scores have increased from 35% in to 52% in % have asked less than 10 questions in

12 Highlights (2/2) Ward Constituency No. Political PartyCouncillor name No. of question asked Rank P/N37SSManisha Sadashiv Patil K/W53INDChangez Jamal Multani K/E73INCKesarben Murji Patel H/E82MNSSukhada Rahul Pawar H/W97INC Mohammed Tanveer Mohammed Ali Patel S116MNSAvinash Bhaskar Sawant N120NCPPratiksha Raju Ghuge N128MNSMangal Prameshwar Kadam M/E136SSManju Bholeshankar Kumare Councillors haven’t asked a single question this year (FY )

FIRs registered against counicllors as of 31 st December CategoryNo. of councillorsNo. of FIRs to to Above Total Total of current municipal councillors who have FIRs registered: 57 Councillors with most FIRs: Raju Shripad Pednekar(12), Anant Bhiku Nar(11) and Ramesh Gajanan Korgaonkar(8)

Committee wise data 14 Note: (*) Only those who were present form April 2014 to March 2015 have been taken, also former Mayor and current Mayor have been excluded No. of members* No. of meeting Attendance in (%) No. of question asked No. of councillor have not single asked question Avg. question per meeting General Body Meeting (GBM) Ward Committee BEST Committee Education Committee Improvements Committee Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee Markets and Gardens Committee Public Health Committee Standing Committee Tree Committee Women and Child Welfare Committee Works Committee (City) Works Committee (Suburbs)

15 THANK YOU!!!