STRENGTHENING FORENSIC SCIENCE IN THE UNITED STATES: A PATH FORWARD Committee on Identifying the Needs of the Forensic Science Community February 2009.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The National Commission on Forensic Science and the formation of the Organization of Scientific Area Committees (OSAC) ABA CRIMINAL JUSTICE SECTION SIXTH.
Advertisements

Criminalistics  Also known as Criminalistics  The application of science to the law.
State and Local Government
LYNDAL BUGEJA Keynote Presentation MANAGER CORONERS PREVENTION UNIT.
FACULTY DEVELOPMENT DAY Brown Bag on Merit Advancement Christine Miaskowski, Shari L. Dworkin & Sally Marshall.
County Judge Phase II: Theoffice of The office of.
August 12,  Crime-scene investigators (police) arrive to find, collect, protect, and transport evidence. (More on this later!)
Forensic Pathology & Death Investigations in Pima County
NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL STRENGTHENING FORENSIC SCIENCE IN THE UNITED STATES: A PATH FORWARD Geoffrey S. Mearns Dean and Professor of Law Cleveland-Marshall.
The Vermont Medical Examiner System Paul L.Morrow, MD Forensic Pathologist, Glebe, NSW Former Chief Medical Examiner, VT USA.
1 Maine Fire Protection Services Commission Missions & Goals.
The Role of the Forensic Nurse in the Medicolegal Death Investigation.
Proposed Forensic Center Presentation Public Safety Committee March 19, 2012.
ORGANIZATION OF PUBLIC HEALTH IN NEVADA Randall Todd, DrPH Director, Epidemiology & Public Health Preparedness Washoe County Health District.
Maryland Higher Education Commission’s Presentation to GWIB Board June 8, 2005.
By: Megan Shafer
Conference Themes DH Kaye ASU College of Law School of Life Sciences.
New Employee Orientation (Insert name) County Health Department.
Capacity Task Force Virginia Health Reform Initiative January 14, 2011
 Forensic science is the application of the science of physical anthropology to the legal process.  Not only does the scientist work with the deceased,
ONELEGACY AND CORONER’S CASES Christopher Rogers, M.D. Los Angeles County Coroner.
GSU-NACDD-CDC Chronic Disease and Public Health Workforce Training Training Needs Survey and Public Health Certificate in Chronic Disease Training for.
District Planning Council Program Overview. District Planning Concept Local Elected Officials Emergency Managers Emergency Responders Local Business Community.
Yakima County Emergency Medical Services Candace Hamilton, EMS Manager 2011.
Careers in Forensic Science. 2 Copyright and Terms of Service Copyright © Texas Education Agency, These materials are copyrighted © and trademarked.
Local Health Authority in Texas Presented by: Department of State Health Services Department of State Health Services Public Health Improvement Program.
Chapter 13.2 County Governments. Counties The county is normally the largest territorial and political subdivision of a state. Counties vary greatly in.
Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward FRSC Professional Preparation Professor Bensley Spring 2013.
Medical Examiner v. Coroner Systems. Coroner System Brought to the United States from Great Britain where it had enjoyed some 500 years of relative success.
Forensic Pathology-international perspectives Helen L Whitwell-Durham, 2009.
Department of Health and Social Services Office of the Chief Medical Examiner Joint Finance Committee Hearing Fiscal Year 2014 Richard T. Callery, M.D.,
Criminalistics  Also known as Criminalistics  The application of science to the law.
FORENSICS How to become a crime scene investigator become-crime-scene-investigator.html.
Morgan laster Ms. Hatmaker, 2nd Period
Orange County Medical Examiner Ordinance Board of County Commissioners Public Hearing August 4,
By: Jose Salas. Education You need high grades in English, Math and especially science. Need 4 years if Medical School 3 years in Bachelor’s degree.
Forensic Pathology Pathology 1. The Science of Pathology Branch of medicine associated with the study of structural changes caused by disease or injury.
Forensic Science Death Investigation The Medical Examiner System and the Role of the Forensic Pathologist.
Medical Examiner Division Department of Public Protection County of Volusia, Florida October 13, 2015Citizens Academy.
Click to edit Master subtitle style 9/8/11 Mpumalanga Department of Health FORENSIC PATHOLOGY SERVICES 6 September 2011.
Promotions on the Clinician Educator Track Larry L. Swift, Ph.D. Vice Chair for Faculty Affairs Department of Pathology, Microbiology & Immunology.
Massachusetts Health Disparities Council Recommendations of the Health Disparities Commission Russell D. Aims Chief of Staff Massachusetts Board of Registration.
Legislative bases of forensic activity in Ukraine ass.-prof. Valentine V. Franchuk.
Medical Examiner By: Ben Lehmann. WHAT DO THEY DO?  The Medical Examiner is a forensically trained physician, that investigates violent, suspicious or.
An anatomical pathology technicians (APTs) role is to provide assistance to a pathologist in conducting post mortems. This is a vital area of work as.
County Government The United States Constitution grants no power to local or county government. The State grants local government power in a charter.
Crime Scene Investigator. About Crime scene investigators (CSIs) go by many names, including: –evidence technician, –crime scene technician, –forensic.
Promotions on the Physician Scientist/Basic Science Investigator Track Larry L. Swift, Ph.D. Vice Chair for Faculty Affairs Department of Pathology, Microbiology.
14.2 County Governments How County Governments are Organized County Characteristics 1.States are comprised of counties 2.Many sizes: L.A. County: 10 million.
County Government CH. 13 SEC. 2/CE.7a Mr. Collins and Mrs. Kozlik.
Priority Action Report Medicolegal Death Investigation Crime Scene/Death Investigation SAC John Fudenberg Jan 29,2016.
Careers in Forensic Science. Definitions Also known as Criminalistics The application of science to the law 2UNT in partnership with TEA, Copyright ©.
Death Investigation in Wisconsin and The United States Michael A. Stier, MD Assoc. Prof. of Forensic Pathology UW School of Medicine & Public Health.
Sheriff’s Office – Police Department CJ I Warm up: In your own words (30) – What Differentiates the two? (Keep in your notebook)
STRENGTHENING FORENSIC SCIENCE IN THE UNITED STATES: A PATH FORWARD The Future of Forensic Science John Marshall Law Center, Cleveland, OH 19 March 2009.
NAS Report Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward Research & Education.
HI-140 Unit 9 Learning Outcomes
National Academy of Sciences Strengthening Forensic Science
Careers in Forensic Science
Crouse Health Hospital
Counties, Towns and Townships
Careers in Forensic Science
LARIMER COUNTY 101 THE CORONER/ MEDICAL EXAMINER
Kuwait Ministry of Interior General Department of Criminal Evidence
ADMINISTRATIVE DUTIES OF DISTRICT JUDGES
Autopsy Chapter 8.
Local Government and Finance
Promotions on the Physician Scientist/Basic Science Investigator Track
Careers in Forensic Science
Establishing a career in Nutrition and Endocrinology
Presentation transcript:

STRENGTHENING FORENSIC SCIENCE IN THE UNITED STATES: A PATH FORWARD Committee on Identifying the Needs of the Forensic Science Community February 2009

Marcella F. Fierro, MD Forensic Pathologist Emerita Professor and Chair Department of Legal Medicine Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine and Chief Medical Examiner Commonwealth of Virginia, Retired

Charge to the Forensic Science Committee Relative to Medical Examiners, Coroners and Forensic Pathology (1) Assess the present and future resource needs of the forensic science community to include…..medical examiners and coroners (ME/C) (2) Make recommendations for maximizing the use of forensic technologies and techniques to solve crimes, investigate deaths, and protect the public;

Charge to the Forensic Science Committee Relative to Medical Examiners, Coroners and Forensic Pathology (4) Make recommendations for programs that will increase the number of qualified forensic scientists and medical examiners available to work in public crime laboratories; (5) Disseminate best practices and guidelines……to solve crimes, investigate deaths, and protect the public;

Issues Covered Issues covered during deliberations: Structure and function of ME/C Structure and function of ME/C The effectiveness of coroner systems as compared with medical examiner systems The effectiveness of coroner systems as compared with medical examiner systems Future needs, and priorities of the …coroner and medical examiner systems Future needs, and priorities of the …coroner and medical examiner systems Accreditation, certification and licensing of ….medical death investigation systems Accreditation, certification and licensing of ….medical death investigation systems

History 9 th /10 th century Coroner – crowner in common law to identity, C&M, confiscate property, collect death duties, investigate treasure troves… transplanted to USA 9 th /10 th century Coroner – crowner in common law to identity, C&M, confiscate property, collect death duties, investigate treasure troves… transplanted to USA 1860 MD -coroners may require MD at inquests 1860 MD -coroners may require MD at inquests 1877 First ME system in MA 1877 First ME system in MA 1890 ME in Baltimore, MEs did autopsies 1890 ME in Baltimore, MEs did autopsies 1918 NYC institutes ME system 1918 NYC institutes ME system

History – Attempts to Improve 1928 NAS “The Coroner and Medical Examiner” 1928 NAS “The Coroner and Medical Examiner” Abolish Coroner (an “anachronism”) Abolish Coroner (an “anachronism”) Vest medical duties of Coroner in an ME system Vest medical duties of Coroner in an ME system Led by trained pathologist under civil service Led by trained pathologist under civil service ME be provided with tox, bacti, and other sciences ME be provided with tox, bacti, and other sciences Develop medicolegal institutes to affiliate with hospitals and universities Develop medicolegal institutes to affiliate with hospitals and universities 1932 NRC again produced review – advised larger role for physicians 1932 NRC again produced review – advised larger role for physicians 1954 Nat. Conf. of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws (CCUSL) - produced Model Post- Mortem Examination Act – need pathologists 1954 Nat. Conf. of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws (CCUSL) - produced Model Post- Mortem Examination Act – need pathologists

Deficiency in any one area results in inadequate/faulty death investigation

Death Investigation In the US ME/C Systems Structure and Function Missions: Missions: Aid criminal justice and the public health Aid criminal justice and the public health Investigate sudden, unexpected, violent death – collect medical evidence Investigate sudden, unexpected, violent death – collect medical evidence Determine cause and manner of death Determine cause and manner of death 500,000 of 1,000,000 reported cases / year 500,000 of 1,000,000 reported cases / year 1 in 6 deaths investigated and examined; 1 in 6 deaths investigated and examined; N 50%, A 27-40%, S 12-15%, H 7-10, U 1% N 50%, A 27-40%, S 12-15%, H 7-10, U 1%

Death Investigation In the US ME/C Systems Structure and Function 2,342 separate death investigation jurisdictions 2,342 separate death investigation jurisdictions 54 are accredited by NAME 54 are accredited by NAME Distribution: Distribution: 16 State ME systems 16 State ME systems 14 County Coroner 14 County Coroner 7 County ME systems 7 County ME systems 13 Mixed county C/ME 13 Mixed county C/ME 8 hybrid C/ State ME system 8 hybrid C/ State ME system DC has ME DC has ME Cleveland/Cuyahoga Co Coroner is forensic pathologist Cleveland/Cuyahoga Co Coroner is forensic pathologist Hodgepodge and multiplicity of systems makes standardization of performance difficult? Actually it is IMPOSSIBLE!

ME v Coroner Physicians Physicians CME required CME required Appointed - based on credentials Appointed - based on credentials As civil servants are insulated As civil servants are insulated Subject to peer and other review – licensed Subject to peer and other review – licensed Selection pool is national Selection pool is national Position Requirements: Position Requirements: Licensed MD Licensed MD Pathologist with boards Pathologist with boards Forensic Pathologist Forensic Pathologist Required CME Required CME Peer Review Peer Review Varies by state; not all are physicians 82 % elected constitutional officers Independent but report to public Selection pool is local, small Minimum requirements: Registered voter Minimum age Not a felon Complete training course of weeks Other qualifications per jurisdiction

Shared Deficiencies of ME/C Systems Imperfect code/legal structure Imperfect code/legal structure Inadequate expertise to medically assess deaths Inadequate expertise to medically assess deaths Inadequate resources Inadequate resources Shortage of forensic pathologists Shortage of forensic pathologists Inadequate facilities, equipment and new technologies Inadequate facilities, equipment and new technologies Inadequate forensic laboratory support Inadequate forensic laboratory support Lack of best practices and standards Lack of best practices and standards Lack of QA Lack of QA Lack of laboratory information systems Lack of laboratory information systems Lack of translational research and associations with medical universities Lack of translational research and associations with medical universities

Validity of Forensic Pathology For forensic pathology validity of the science is less of an issue than the establishment and distribution of the science throughout death investigation systems For forensic pathology validity of the science is less of an issue than the establishment and distribution of the science throughout death investigation systems The science of forensic pathology is the science of medicine The science of forensic pathology is the science of medicine Need incentives for jurisdictions to adopt and adhere to standards and best practices of medicine Need incentives for jurisdictions to adopt and adhere to standards and best practices of medicine A carrot and what stick are needed to improve the situation A carrot and what stick are needed to improve the situation

The Core Questions Should medical diagnoses for cause of death and for manner of death be made by physicians with specialized training or by elected officials who may or may not have any medical training? Multiple studies say YES! If competency in death investigation matters, how shall the present system be fixed?

Recommendation #11 To Improve Medicolegal Death Investigation : Establish NIFS Establish NIFS Congress to provide Incentive funding for states/jurisdictions to establish ME systems with the goal of replacing coroner systems (LEAA model) Congress to provide Incentive funding for states/jurisdictions to establish ME systems with the goal of replacing coroner systems (LEAA model) Fully fund Coverdell NFSIA – only source for MEs Fully fund Coverdell NFSIA – only source for MEs Fund building regional ME offices, equipment, staffing, education and training and for modernization Fund building regional ME offices, equipment, staffing, education and training and for modernization Congress to fund NIH and NIFS and allocate funding for collaborative basic forensic pathology research with medical universities Congress to fund NIH and NIFS and allocate funding for collaborative basic forensic pathology research with medical universities

Recommendation #11 Fund fellows training in forensic path Forgive medical student loans if train in FP as career Fund fellows training in forensic path Forgive medical student loans if train in FP as career Establish SWG with NAME and ABMDI to develop and promote standards, best practices, admin, staffing, education, training, and CME for MEs and MDIs Establish SWG with NAME and ABMDI to develop and promote standards, best practices, admin, staffing, education, training, and CME for MEs and MDIs Restrict funding to accredited offices or those working toward accreditation Restrict funding to accredited offices or those working toward accreditation Require accreditation of all ME/C offices Require accreditation of all ME/C offices Require board certified forensic pathologists to perform or supervise all medicolegal autopsies Require board certified forensic pathologists to perform or supervise all medicolegal autopsies

STRENGTHENING FORENSIC SCIENCE IN THE UNITED STATES: A PATH FORWARD Committee on Identifying the Needs of the Forensic Science Community February 2009