Ad Hominem  “to the man”  Attacking a person’s views by attacking his or her character  Ex: “Mayor Burns is divorced and estranged from his family.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Q3,J4 A) “Hitler was a vegetarian, therefore, I don’t trust vegetarians.” B) “You can’t prove that there aren’t Martians living in caves under the surface.
Advertisements

Text Table of Contents #5 and #8: Evaluating the Argument.
Understanding Logical Fallacies
Logical Fallacies.
Rhetorical Fallacies. What is Rhetorical Fallacy? Rhetorical fallacy Rhetorical fallacy Is a failure of discussion or argument Is a failure of discussion.
Logical Fallacies AKA “How NOT to Win an Argument”
Logic and Reasoning Panther Prep North Central High School.
Persuasive Media.  Persuasive media includes any text that attempts to sell a product or a service to a consumer.  All persuasive media attempts influence.
Critical Thinking (and Logical Fallacies) All men are mortal. Socrates is a man. Therefore, Socrates is mortal. All cadets wear uniforms. Thompson wears.
Chapter 6 Lecture Notes Working on Relevance. Chapter 6 Understanding Relevance: The second condition for cogency for an argument is the (R) condition.
Logical Fallacies Introduction. What is a logical fallacy? A fallacy is an error of reasoning. These are flawed statements that often sound true Logical.
 Read the following argument. Examine it closely. Do you think it is logically sound? Why?  [T]he acceptance of abortion does not end with the killing.
Fallacies Information taken from Purdue OWL, Nancy Wood’s Perspectives on Argument and Annette Rottenberg’s Elements of Argument.
Flawed Arguments COMMON LOGICAL FALLACIES.  Flaws in an argument  Often subtle  Learning to recognize these will:  Strengthen your own arguments 
 In this task you will see 16 different arguments.  You have to identify which of the 8 common fallacies is being used by the argument.
Game Plan Go over Speech to Virginia Convention HW Logical Fallacies Go over Colonialism Tests “Common Sense” – A pamphlet by T. Paine Class Starter: on.
Logical Fallacies.
Logical Fallacies. Syllogism (not a fallacy) A logical argument presented in terms of two statements and a conclusion which must be true if the two statements.
LOGICAL FALLACIES Errors in Reasoning.
Logical Fallacies Invalid Arguments.
INFORMAL FALLACIES. FALLACIES OF RELEVANCE Errors resulting from attempts to appeal to things that are not relevant, i.e., not really connected to or.
PERSUASION. “Everybody Hates Chris”
Common Logical Fallacies #3: Misjudging or Misusing People Arguments.
Logical Fallacies1 This line of "reasoning" is fallacious because pity does not serve as evidence for a claim Just to get a scholarship does not justify.
Fallacies Of Thinking A fallacy is flawed logic or misguided thinking.
Fallacies To error in reason is human; to analyze divine!
Logic Fallacies Debate Class Production Spain Park High School
Let’s see some more examples!
Logical Fallacies Guided Notes
Logical Fallacies.
C OMMON L OGICAL F ALLACIES English O VERGENERALIZATION : Statements that are so general that they oversimplify reality.
Fallacies of Irrelevance
Look for these in the arguments of others and avoid them in your own arguments.
LOGIC 2+2=4… right?. Logical Reasoning Statements formed from sound thinking and proof of reasoning.
Standard: Delineate and evaluate the argument and specific claims in a text… identify false statements and fallacious reasoning.
LOGICAL FALLACIES Created by Abraham, Sept. 2013
Fallacy An error of reasoning based on faulty use of evidence or incorrect interpretation of facts.
Look for these in the arguments of others and avoid them in your own arguments.
Fallacies The quickest ways to lose arguments. Introduction to Logic O Argument: The assertion of a conclusion based on logical premises O Premise: Proposition.
Effective Persuasion Avoiding Logical Fallacies. Avoid Logical Fallacies These are some common errors in reasoning that will undermine the logic of your.
Academic Vocabulary Unit 7 Cite: To give evidence for or justification of an argument or statement.
Errors in Reasoning. Fallacies A Fallacy is “any error in reasoning that makes an argument fail to establish its conclusion.” There are two kinds of fallacies.
Logical Fallacies A logical fallacy is an element of an argument that is flawed If spotted one can essentially render an entire line of reasoning invalid.
Lecture Notes © 2008 McGraw Hill Higher Education© 2008 McGraw Hill Higher Education 1 Critical Thinking Chapter 5 Logical Fallacies I Fallacies of Relevance.
Common Logical Fallacies Flawed Arguments. Logical Fallacies… Flaws in an argument Often subtle Learning to recognize these will: – Strengthen your own.
Common Logical Fallacies Flawed Arguments. Logical Fallacies… Flaws in an argument Often subtle Learning to recognize these will: – Strengthen your own.
Common Logical Fallacies FLAWED ARGUMENTS SUBTLE ERRORS IN JUDGEMENT AND CONSTRUCTION.
GOOD MORNING! NOVEMBER 16, 2015 Journal Entry: Think of a time when you thought a person or an organization was unsuccessful in proving his/her/their point.
Logical Fallacies.
Ad Hominem (Personal Attack) An attempt to discredit the argument by discrediting the character of the person advancing it.
Talking points 1. Would Neil still have committed suicide if Mr. Keating had never come into his life? Who is most to blame for Neil’s death? Mr. Keating?
Logical Fallacies. Slippery Slope The argument that some event must inevitably follow from another without any rational claim. If we allow A to happen.
P ERSUASION & L OGICAL F ALLACIES. W ARM -U P Answer True or False to each of the following questions: 1) A really good commercial could convince me to.
The Art and Craft of Persuasion Based upon: Moser, Joyce, and Ann Watters, ed. Creating America: Reading and Writing Arguments, 3 rd Ed. New Jersey:Prentice.
Persuasive Speech Unit Logical Fallacies Fallacy: A mistake in an argument that automatically invalidates it.
Logical Fallacies Overview Logical fallacies are instances of “broken reasoning.” Fallacies avoid the actual argument. We want to avoid fallacies, be.
Rhetorical Devices and Fallacies
Rhetorical Fallacies.
Logical Fallacies.
Common Logical Fallacies
Logical Fallacies Unit 2.
Errors in Reasoning.
Common Logical Fallacies
Logical Fallacy Notes Comp. & Rhet. ENG 1010.
A Guide to Logical Fallacies
Fallacious Reasoning a.k.a. Fallacy.
Common Logical Fallacies
Living in the Media Age (Fallacies)
1. Could I receive an A for this class
Logical Fallacies Introduction.
Presentation transcript:

Ad Hominem  “to the man”  Attacking a person’s views by attacking his or her character  Ex: “Mayor Burns is divorced and estranged from his family. How can we listen to his pleas for a city nursing home?”  Why is it a fallacy? How he handles his personal life has no logical bearing on his views on the nursing home.

Appeal to Tradition  Appealing to a long standing practice or tradition and claiming validity/viability because people have done it for a duration.  Ex. They can’t have an opening night game before opening day because the Cincinnati Reds have always played the first game of the season on Opening Day.  Why is it fallacy? The fact that they have always been the first game doesn’t mean it makes sense to keep it that way if other ways of doing it make more sense.

Argumentum Ad Baculum  An argument based on an appeal to fear or a threat.  Ex. If you don’t vote for this candidate then the country will crumble.  Ex. Eating too much of that product may cause you to become fat.  Why is it a fallacy? Fear is an emotion, and by nature, not logical. Logic might tell you that voting for a certain candidate may change things, but the likelihood of causing the country to fall is not logical. Similarly, eating too of anything may cause you to become fat.

Argumentum Ad Populum  An argument aimed to sway popular support by appealing to sentimental weakness rather than facts or reason.  Ex. You can’t write me up for that because my mother will kill me. Please don’t do it, I can’t take another weekend without my phone. I will be the biggest loser in the school.  Why is it fallacy? The student is trying to get the teacher to feel sorry for him/her not arguing what they did, and why it doesn’t deserve the punishment.

Bandwagon Fallacy  Concluding that an idea has merit simply because many people think, believe, or practice it.  Ex. Everyone else is doing it.  What is it a fallacy? The numbers of people doing something or believing something does not validate the thing they are doing. Think Nazis, slave owners, fans of dubstep. Just because people are doing it doesn’t make it good/right.

Begging the Question (or Assuming the Answer)  This is when you assume that something you state follows a logical track of reasoning.  Ex. We must encourage our children to stop playing violent video games to reduce the number of shootings in this country.  Why is it a fallacy? It begs the question: do violent video games produce violent people who shoot other people? The statement above assumes that it does without proving it.

Confirmation Bias/ Observational Selection  This refers to selective thinking that focuses on evidence that supports ideas you already believe and ignores evidence to the contrary. If your beliefs are not founded in logic – faith, tradition, prejudice) they are susceptible to this fallacy.  Ex. Kids that wear hats are delinquents. Every time I am in the hallways I see kids in hats being late to class.  I am pointing out the times I am in the hall that I see students with hats, but ignoring those times that I don’t. I ignore that these students are very much the minority of overall students that are late, but choose to focus on them. Lots of “see I told you so.”

Confusion of Correlation and Causation  Cause and effect is a difficult thing to prove. Just because something has a high correlation doesn’t mean we can say it “causes” something else.  Ex. Using Twitter causes your attention span to shorten because all information is condensed to 140 characters.  There may be a high correlation between short attention spans and those who use Twitter, it may even contribute to that, but it is not the lone contributing factor. Thus, one does not happen as a direct result of the other.

False Dichotomy (Excluded Middle)  Considering only the extremes.  Painting a subject in terms of black/white, good/bad, excluding any middle ground.  Many times phrased as an “either/or” statement.  Ex.

Half Truth  A statement intended to deceive that omits some facts necessary for an accurate representation.  Ex. You: Mom, can I go to this party tonight? Mom: Who is going to be there? You: Bob, Tim, and Albert. (You tell her knowing that she likes them, while excluding that Sam, Ed, and Drew will be there too.) Mom: Yes, they are wonderful young men. Why is it a fallacy? Since you know that your mother does not approve of those other boys, and you are intentionally excluding them. Thus, you are only telling her half of the truth, the half she wants to hear.

Non Sequitir  Latin for “It does not follow…”  An inference or conclusion that does not follow from the established premise or evidence.  Ex. There occurred an increase in births during the full moon. Thus, full moons induce labor.  Why is it a fallacy? There are a number of factors that could help explain the increase in births. The conclusion arrived at based on that one premise does not lead to the arrived at conclusion.

Red Herring  When the arguer diverts the attention by changing the subject.  Ex. There is a lot of commotion regarding saving the environment. We cannot make this world an Eden. What will happen if it does become Eden? Adam and Eve got bored there! (literarydevices.net).  The logical argument is about saving the environment, not the merits of Eden. Distracting the audience to take away their attention.

Slippery Slope  When a change in procedure, law, or action, will result in adverse consequences.  Ex. If we allow doctor assisted suicide, then eventually the government will control how we die.  Why is it a fallacy? It does not necessarily follow that just because we make changes that a slippery slope will occur.

Statistics of Small Numbers  A statistic from a small sampling that you imply represents a much larger majority.  Ex. My parents smoked all of their lives and never got cancer.  Why is it a fallacy? Simply because someone can point to a few favorable numbers says nothing about the overall chances.

Straw Man  Creating a false scenario (straw man) and then attacking it.  Ex. Most athiests believe in evolution. You know who else believed in evolution, Hitler and the Nazis. How could you support something that was supported by Nazis. That is unconscionable.  Why is it fallacy? You are transferring the negativity of Nazis onto another group by saying that they shared one idea. What is really under attack is Nazism, not evolution or Atheism, as the argument demands.