How Men & Women See Themselves Chapter 8.1
Long-standing Questions What makes A man a man? A woman a woman? Is there an intrinsic difference? Is it merely biological? Is it societal?
Various views: Rigid differences, roles particularly visible in patriarchal societies Other philosophers: men & women share the same basic nature Others emphasize differences but do not support either sex being placed in an inferior role
Gender in Ancient Greece For the most part, men & women were not of equal status Each sex had distinct social roles Men: public affairs, voting… Women: home, secondary place
Plato’s view of women men & women can be equally skilled at most occupations They should receive the same education See page
Review Plato on Nature & Role of Women If men & women do the same tasks, they should have the same education Men & women have the same natural aptitudes
Aristotle The essential nature of men & women is determined by biology Nature, not nurture Biology, not experience Determines what makes us the men and women we are
Aristotle believed Society should be organized around biology Women: defined by biological & reproductive role Men: embody power in family & society Page 264
Aristotle on: Men & Women Male > female Male rules Female ruled Same difference as between soul & body Marital Authority Head of household rules over wife & children Like a statesman Male naturally fitter to command