Kick-Off September 30th.  This game will challenge MA1 student to invest in a virtual portfolio of 4 assets on the long run (1 year)  This is a chance.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Management Challenge an exploration of business This computer simulation give you and the others: an opportunity to manage a “real” business for several.
Advertisements

Valuing an Acquisition
Accenture Plc (ACN) Analysts: Chris Landqvist, Justin Pippitt, Kelli Coldiron & Wei Pi.
Coca-Cola Garrett Roberts ACG2021 Sec Executive Summary Coca-Cola was established in 1886 and today has plants in 200 countries world wide. Coca-Cola.
 3M is expected to pay paid dividends of $1.92 per share in the coming year.  You expect the stock price to be $85 per share at the end of the year.
Financial Statements Forecasting
Goal of This Presentation What is an Investment Bank? What are the opportunities? Learning more about the business What is an Investment Bank? What are.
Business plan overview (1)
FIN ©2001 M. P. NarayananUniversity of Michigan Valuation methods An overview.
Fin 4201/8001 Topic 4a: Valuing Companies The adventure continues….
Valuing an Acquisition
J. K. Dietrich - FBE 532 – Spring 2006 Value-Based Management and Course Summary Week 14 – April 20, 2006.
Valuation Chapter 17: 6,9,11,13,15. Myths about valuation Since valuation models are quantitative, valuation is objective A well-researched and well-done.
Financial Statements Economics 98 / 198 Fall 2007 Copyright 2007 Jason Lee.
CHRIS DELL’AMORE COLGATE FINANCE CLUB 2/12/11 Introduction to Discounted Cash Flow Analysis.
Valuation Terms and Ratios Tanveer Chandok (Director of Mentorship)
MSE608C – Engineering and Financial Cost Analysis
This week its Accounting Theory
Business Model: Capital Budgeting, Equity Valuation and Returns Attribution FMRC Conference Vanderbilt University By Thomas S. Y. Ho Thomas Ho Company.
FOUNDATION BUSINESS SIMULATION
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Analysis Tutorial This presentation is to be used ONLY as a template for DCF Analysis presentations. In no way should it reflect.
Today’s mission  To get everyone to understand the basics of DCF valuation.
BU Finance & Investment Club Joseph McNiff & Xun Yao Chen Spring 2013 Introduction to Valuation.
Copyright ©2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning Chapter 3 Evaluation of Financial Performance.
Chapter 12 Investing in Stocks Copyright © 2012 Pearson Canada Inc
Financial Accounting Dave Ludwick, P.Eng, MBA, PMP, PhD Chapter 20 Ratios Analysis.
Lecture 5 - Financial Planning and Forecasting
- Brijesh Pitroda. The analysis of a Business' Health starts with Financial Statement Analysis.
Business Analysis Types of Business Analysis  Credit Analysis  Equity Analysis  Business Environment and strategy Analysis  Financial Analysis  Prospective.
F305 Intermediate Corporate Finance Indiana University September 5, 2001.
1 CHAPTER 12 Financial Planning and Forecasting Financial Statements.
FINANCE BASIC FACTS. Sources of funds Internal Retained profits Sale of assets Using trade credit Investing surplus cash Reducing inventory External Personal.
Introduction Financial Statement Analysis Prepared By: Anuj Bhatia, Professor, Shah Tuition Classes Ph
Service Challenge an exploration of business This computer simulation gives you and the others: an opportunity to manage a “real” business for several.
REVIEW OF ACCOUNTING (Chapter 2) §Financial Statements l Balance Sheet l Income Statement l Statement of Cash Flows §Free Cash Flow §Corporate Taxes §Individual.
The Nuts & Bolts of Investment Banking: Understanding Key Financial Concepts Andrea O’Neal & Patrice Mitchell Investment Banking Program Managers.
Role of Financial Management Objectives Liquidity Profitability Efficiency Growth Return on Investment Strategic role To provide and manage the financial.
Evaluating Cash Flow 1. Key questions for cash flow statement analysis How did this year’s cash flow impact the company’s:  Credit profile?  Liquidity?
FINANCE MAP By Gaylen K. Bunker. Objectives of Workshop Principles: Time lag between investment and return. Compounding versus Summing Value = Discounted.
Valuation FIN 449 Michael Dimond. Michael Dimond School of Business Administration Financial Statements What are the four financial statements, and the.
Valuing Business Methods of valuation DCF valuation (e.g. using WACC) DCF valuation (e.g. using WACC) Relative valuation (comparables) Relative valuation.
Chapter 2 Financial Ratio Analysis. 2-2 Example 2.1 Problem  Rylan Enterprises has 5 million shares outstanding.  The market price per share is $22.
Chapter 2 Introduction to Financial Statement Analysis.
1 Equity Valuation Process  Valuation?  The Scope of Equity Valuation Stock Selection Extracting Market Expectations Evaluation of Corporate Events/Business.
Understanding Financial Statements Chris Droussiotis June 2011.
Financial Planning & Forecasting Pro Forma Financial Statements.
Merrill Lynch Matt Western ACG2021 Section 002. Executive Summary Overall Merrill Lynch had a great year in They increased their revenues 11% from.
Analyzing Financial Statements
Investment and portfolio management MGT 531. Investment and portfolio management Lecture # 21.
1 CHAPTERS 15 & 25 Corporate Valuation and Merger Analysis.
23-1 Intermediate Accounting,17E Stice | Stice | Skousen © 2010 Cengage Learning PowerPoint presented by: Douglas Cloud Professor Emeritus of Accounting,
 Fundamental Analysis By Martin Brenner. What is Fundamental Analysis?  A method of evaluating a security that entails attempting to measure its intrinsic.
DES Chapter 4 1 DES Chapter 4 Estimating the Value of ACME.
Financial Statements and Ratios Look up your stock portfolio at Howthemarketworks.com.
 Methods in Valuation Part II. Valuation Methods  Comparable Companies Analysis  Discounted Cash Flow  Leveraged Buyout  Risk Adjusted (NPV)
Ratio Analysis…. Types of ratios…  Performance Ratios: Return on capital employed. (Income Statement and Balance Sheet) Gross profit margin (Income Statement)
Estimating the Value of ACME 1. Steps in a valuation Estimate cost of capital (WACC) – Debt – Equity Project financial statements and FCF Calculate horizon.
FIN 419 HELP Learn by Doing / fin419help.com. FIN 419 HELP Learn by Doing FIN 419 Entire Course FOR MORE CLASSES VISIT FIN 419 Week.
Estimating the Value of ACME
Chapter 13 Financial performance measures for investment centres and reward systems.
Tyler Mumbleau Sunday January 29, 2017
Financial Planning and Forecasting Financial Statements
Potential red flags – Business environment
Estimating the Value of ACME
Intro to Financial Management
Linking Supply Chain and Finance
CHAPTER 3 Financial Statements, Cash Flow, and Taxes
Professor Chris droussiotis
Financial Statements, Cash Flow, and Taxes
Management Challenge an exploration of business
Presentation transcript:

Kick-Off September 30th

 This game will challenge MA1 student to invest in a virtual portfolio of 4 assets on the long run (1 year)  This is a chance for the students to put into practice their theoretical skills learned during their 3 last years (Macroeconomics, Corporate Finance, Accounting, Control, Marketing..)  You will have to select 4 stocks  2 Long positions = 2 stocks which are underestimated by the market (Consensus)  2 Short positions = 2 stocks which are overestimated by the market (Consensus) Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

 Among those 4 stocks, one pair has to be chosen (2 companies in the same sector) in 2 different directions (long and short)  Stocks' selection is limited to Europe, US and Japan.  Selection is based on fundamental analysis VS. Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

 GLG case study 1 : Fortis, Long Share Price, Pence Exposure, % 13 brokers covered Fortis 3 long 10 short 5 brokers covered Fortis 1 long 4 short 8 brokers covered Fortis 7 long 1 short 10 brokers covered Fortis GLG was long on Fortis from November 2008 to June 2009 Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

Step 1: Idea Generation  Following the “collapse” of Fortis, the Dutch and Belgian governments intervened to establish a solution.  As a result, the main brokerage firms dropped coverage of the stock which made the situation all the more opaque  Market was focusing on liabilities : vote, spv (Special purpose Vehicle)…We were focusing on assets: Value of insurance companies [Companies with a little Cash Flow].  Balance sheet: Fortis had excess cash and could create lot of value by buying its debt at a discount price.  Having been active in Fortis since 2007, we were aware of the sum valuation of their assets; upon collapse, we decided to revisit the stock and form a new opinion. CF = 1 X10 [Multiple and DCF]  10 Assets =100 X1.5-3 [Multiple]  Market focused on liabilities and cash flows We focused on assets ≠ Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

Step 2: Hypothesis Verification  Working alongside GLG’s credit teams, we analysed all of Fortis’s debt instruments and structured credit portfolio as well as their insurance and banking businesses  We spoke to specialist Belgian and Dutch lawyers, activist groups and the company at great lengths Step 3: Investment Structuring  Given the high risk (volatility), we decided to take a reduced position of around 2% within the fund, despite our high conviction rate Step 4: Execution  We starting building our position in Fortis at 59 cents and traded around our price target, trimming and building positions where based on earning releases and news flow >< The markets Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

 GLG case study 2 : Burberry, Long GLG bought at the end of March Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

Step 1: Idea Generation  The consumption of luxury goods declined due to the credit crunch => Sales growth was down for luxury sector  But Burberry was more vulnerable due to its distribution strategy. Burberry had 15% of own distribution channel and 85% of wholesale >< Competitors (Louis Vuitton)  Spain was down, and Burberry market concerned by Geographical exposure strongly relied on Spain and Japan  As results, Burberry had a high level of inventories and working capital requirement, and Profit margin (EBIT margin ) was under pressure (Burberry Net Income was low compared to the sector).  But Burberry had the same margin gross than the sector  Burberry had to have a product problem. (Costs were too high compared to competitors (i.e. LVMH) ). Gross Margin sectorBurberry Net Income  CF Multiple was lower than the sector Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

Step 2: Hypothesis Verification  Working alongside GLG’s analysts teams, we analysed Burberry cost cutting program implemented by the Management.  We spoke to McKinsey to review product positioning and to assess SAP implementation potential. Step 3: Today Results  Management now focus on getting the back end operations as good as the front end operations with the help of their new global head of supply chain and the final roll out of SAP.  Burberry is now shipping product rather than air freighting.  Purchasing is being done at group level not by product line. Improving EBIT margin will have a double leverage effect on Burberry valuation CF Multiple X = Valuation Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Introduction

Presentation Team registrati on Stocks selection Stocks/Firms va luations Report Uploadi ng Follow-upScoringEnd Final Speech an d Best teams pr esentations On October On November End of November 2010 February 2011 Kick-off Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Stock Simulation Step by Step

AssetsLong 1Short 1Long 2Short 2 Choicepair (in the same sector)No constraints External Analysis1 quantitative argument 1 qualitative argument Internal Analysis 2 qualitative arguments which might significantly impact company ’ s valuation Valuation using the 3FCF methods (WACC, Adjusted present value and Flow to equity) Assumptions (Revenue growth rate, Capital expenditures, Cost of equity, cost of assets, Cost of debt…) Questions: 1) Which value drivers (Revenue Growth, Sales margin, ….) are changing and what the market is missing? 2) Compare the intrinsic value calculated and the market cap observed ( In Millions) 3) Which FCF-valuation method is for you the most accurate one in this case? 4) Compare enterprise ratios with sector and/or peer ratios Risks2 risks which might modify your thesis Stocks’ selection Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Your Work

AssetsLong 1Short 1Long 2Short 2 Choicepair (in the same sector)No constraints External Analysis1 quantitative argument 1 qualitative argument Internal Analysis 2 qualitative arguments which might significantly impact company ’ s valuation Valuation using the 3FCF methods (WACC, Adjusted present value and Flow to equity) Assumptions (Revenue growth rate, Capital expenditures, Cost of equity, cost of assets, Cost of debt…) Questions: 1) Which value drivers (Revenue Growth, Sales margin, ….) are changing and what the market is missing? 2) Compare the intrinsic value calculated and the market cap observed ( In Millions) 3) Which FCF-valuation method is for you the most accurate one in this case? 4) Compare enterprise ratios with sector and/or peer ratios Risks2 risks which might modify your thesis Stocks’ selection Example: Share price vs. Interest rate Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Your Work

AssetsLong 1Short 1Long 2Short 2 Choicepair (in the same sector)No constraints External Analysis1 quantitative argument 1 qualitative argument Internal Analysis 2 qualitative arguments which might significantly impact company ’ s valuation Valuation using the 3FCF methods (WACC, Adjusted present value and Flow to equity) Assumptions (Revenue growth rate, Capital expenditures, Cost of equity, cost of assets, Cost of debt…) Questions: 1) Which value drivers (Revenue Growth, Sales margin, ….) are changing and what the market is missing? 2) Compare the intrinsic value calculated and the market cap observed ( In Millions) 3) Which FCF-valuation method is for you the most accurate one in this case? 4) Compare enterprise ratios with sector and/or peer ratios Risks2 risks which might modify your thesis Stocks’ selection Examples: New regulation, new competitors, new markets, new Policy… Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Your Work

AssetsLong 1Short 1Long 2Short 2 Choicepair (in the same sector)No constraints External Analysis1 quantitative argument 1 qualitative argument Internal Analysis 2 qualitative arguments which might significantly impact company ’ s valuation Valuation using the 3FCF methods (WACC, Adjusted present value and Flow to equity) Assumptions (Revenue growth rate, Capital expenditures, Cost of equity, cost of assets, Cost of debt…) Questions: 1) Which value drivers (Revenue Growth, Sales margin, ….) are changing and what the market is missing? 2) Compare the intrinsic value calculated and the market cap observed ( In Millions) 3) Which FCF-valuation method is for you the most accurate one in this case? 4) Compare enterprise ratios with sector and/or peer ratios Risks2 risks which might modify your thesis Stocks’ selection Examples: Management Shift, New products, Capital structure, Bond rating change, Restructuration, New acquisition… Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Your Work

AssetsLong 1Short 1Long 2Short 2 Choicepair (in the same sector)No constraints External Analysis1 quantitative argument 1 qualitative argument Internal Analysis 2 qualitative arguments which might significantly impact company ’ s valuation Valuation using the 3FCF methods (WACC, Adjusted present value and Flow to equity) Assumptions (Revenue growth rate, Capital expenditures, Cost of equity, cost of assets, Cost of debt…) Questions: 1) Which value drivers (Revenue Growth, Sales margin, ….) are changing and what the market is missing? 2) Compare the intrinsic value calculated and the market cap observed ( In Millions) 3) Which FCF-valuation method is for you the most accurate one in this case? 4) Compare enterprise ratios with sector and/or peer ratios Risks2 risks which might modify your thesis Stocks’ selection Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Your Work

AssetsLong 1Short 1Long 2Short 2 Choicepair (in the same sector)No constraints External Analysis1 quantitative argument 1 qualitative argument Internal Analysis 2 qualitative arguments which might significantly impact company ’ s valuation Valuation using the 3FCF methods (WACC, Adjusted present value and Flow to equity) Assumptions (Revenue growth rate, Capital expenditures, Cost of equity, cost of assets, Cost of debt…) Questions: 1) Which value drivers (Revenue Growth, Sales margin, ….) are changing and what the market is missing? 2) Compare the intrinsic value calculated and the market cap observed ( In Millions) 3) Which FCF-valuation method is for you the most accurate one in this case? 4) Compare enterprise ratios with sector and/or peer ratios Risks2 risks which might modify your thesis Stocks’ selection Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Your Work

AssetsLong 1Short 1Long 2Short 2 Choicepair (in the same sector)No constraints External Analysis1 quantitative argument 1 qualitative argument Internal Analysis 2 qualitative arguments which might significantly impact company ’ s valuation Valuation using the 3FCF methods (WACC, Adjusted present value and Flow to equity) Assumptions (Revenue growth rate, Capital expenditures, Cost of equity, cost of assets, Cost of debt…) Questions: 1) Which value drivers (Revenue Growth, Sales margin, ….) are changing and what the market is missing? 2) Compare the intrinsic value calculated and the market cap observed ( In Millions) 3) Which FCF-valuation method is for you the most accurate one in this case? 4) Compare enterprise ratios with sector and/or peer ratios Risks2 risks which might modify your thesis Stocks’ selection Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Your Work

Website Handbook Answer-Template Registration/ uploading forms Up-to-date Performance data (follow-up) + Examples Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward Material

Valuation Stocks selection Calculations Questions Data/Resources Charts/Calculations Statements Justifications/ Arguments Report scores (30% of your Advanced finance grade) _____ _____Report and Performance prize 3 days in New York - 4 Flight tickets - 2 nights in Manhattan - Visit of the NY Stock Exchange Introduction MaterialStep by StepYour Work Scoring/Reward