ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 1 MULTIPACTORING SIMULATIONS IN CAVITIES AND HOM COUPLERS Nikolay Solyak, Ivan Gonin, Jiajian Li Fermilab.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
D. Lipka, MDI, DESY Hamburg, July 2012 Simulation of fields around spring and cathode for photogun D. Lipka, MDI, DESY Hamburg.
Advertisements

Accelerator Science and Technology Centre Prospects of Compact Crab Cavities for LHC Peter McIntosh LHC-CC Workshop, CERN 21 st August 2008.
ILC Wakefest Workshop, Dec 11-13, 2007 WakeFest Summary 2.
90°-Cavities With Improved Inner-Cell HOM Properties Shannon Hughes Advisor: Valery Shemelin.
Electromagnetic Coupling between Mobile Wireless Devices and Wiring Systems in Vehicles Yaping Zhang, John Paul, Christos Christopoulos ( George Green.
D. Li and R. Rimmer, RF Workshop, Fermilab, MHz Cavity Refurbishment and suggestions on future tests Derun Li and Robert Rimmer* Lawrence.
L. Ge, C. Adolphsen, K. Ko, L. Lee, Z. Li, C. Ng, G. Schussman, F. Wang, SLAC, B. Rusnak, LLNL Multipacting Simulations of TTF-III Coupler Components *#
R&D For Accelerating Structures H. Padamsee. TESLA Niobium, one meter length, rf = 1.3 GHz Copper, 53 cm, rf = 11.4 GHz.
Thin Films for Superconducting Cavities HZB. Outline Introduction to Superconducting Cavities The Quadrupole Resonator Commissioning Outlook 2.
RF background, analysis of MTA data & implications for MICE Rikard Sandström, Geneva University MICE Collaboration Meeting – Analysis session, October.
RFQ Thermal Analysis Scott Lawrie. Vacuum Pump Flange Vacuum Flange Coolant Manifold Cooling Pockets Milled Into Vanes Potentially Bolted Together Tuner.
Simulation Technology & Applied Research, Inc N. Port Washington Rd., Suite 201, Mequon, WI P:
Zenghai Li SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory LHC-CC13 CERN, December 9-11, 2013 HOM Coupler Optimization & RF Modeling.
Acceleration gradient limitations in room temperature and superconducting acceleration structures Nikolay Solyak Fermilab.
DEFLECTING CAVITY OPTIONS FOR RF BEAM SPREADER IN LCLS II
XFEL SRF Accelerating Module Prototypes Tests at DESY Fermilab Seminar, July 21st Denis Kostin, MHF-SL, DESY.
Experimental Comparison at KEK of High Gradient Performance of Different Single Cell Superconducting Cavity Designs. F. Furuta, K. Saito, T. Saeki, H.
SRF CAVITY GEOMETRY OPTIMIZATION FOR THE ILC WITH MINIMIZED SURFACE E.M. FIELDS AND SUPERIOR BANDWIDTH The Cockcroft Institute of Accelerator Science and.
KEK R&D for LHC Plan of 800MHz Cavity Calculation of 400MHz Cavity 16 th September 2009, LHC-CC09 at CERN K.Nakanishi.
Nikolay SolyakILC-GDE, Beijing, Feb.4-8, Fermilab 3 rd Harmonic Cryomodule Status N.Solyak, H. Edwards, D.Mitchell, M.Foley, T.Khabiboulline, E.Harms,
Coupler Multipactor Studies F. Wang, B. Rusnak, C. Adolphsen, C. Nantista, G. Bowden, Lixin Ge.
CLARA Gun Cavity Optimisation NVEC 05/06/2014 P. Goudket G. Burt, L. Cowie, J. McKenzie, B. Militsyn.
2.1 GHz Warm RF Cavity for LEReC Binping Xiao Collider-Accelerator Department, BNL June 15, 2015 LEReC Warm Cavity Review Meeting  June 15, 2015.
Multipactor Phenomenon in Dielectric-Loaded Accelerating Structures: Review of Theory and Code Development O. V. Sinitsyn, G. S. Nusinovich and T. M. Antonsen,
Group 6 / A RF Test and Properties of a Superconducting Cavity Mattia Checchin, Fabien Eozénou, Teresa Martinez de Alvaro, Szabina Mikulás, Jens Steckert.
Self-consistent non-stationary theory of multipactor in DLA structures O. V. Sinitsyn, G. S. Nusinovich, T. M. Antonsen, Jr. and R. Kishek 13 th Advanced.
1 Al Moretti, APC, Fermilab MAP- Winter Meeting February 28 - March 4, 2011 TJNAF Newport News, VA.
A. Bross MICE CM17 February MuCool RF Program 805 and 201 MHz Studies.
Sensitivity of HOM Frequency in the ESS Medium Beta Cavity Aaron Farricker.
Trapped Modes in LHC Collimator (II) Liling Xiao Advanced Computations Department SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory.
State of art and R&D plans on multipacting
D. Lipka, V. Vogel, DESY Hamburg, Germany, Oct Optimization cathode design with gun5 D. Lipka, V. Vogel, DESY Hamburg, Germany.
TESLA DAMPING RING RF DEFLECTORS DESIGN F.Marcellini & D. Alesini.
Multipacting Simulation for the Muon Collider Cooling Cavities* L Ge, Z Li, C Ng, K Ko, SLAC R.B. Palmer, BNL D Li, LBNL The muon cooling cavity for the.
IHEP GHz 9-cell Cavity R&D Status and Plan The Third IHEP-KEK 1.3GHz SC Technology Collaboration Meeting Dec. 7-8, 2010, IHEP, Beijing GAO Jie,
Status of work on the HOM coupler. 2 nd Harmonic cavity Meeting 11/II-2016 Thermal analyses with shims (Y.Terechkine). Gennady Romanov On behalf of Y.Terechkine.
Update on LHC 800MHz Crab Cavity Conceptual Design Liling Xiao, Zenghai Li Advanced Computations Department, SLAC Presented at LARP-CM12, April 9, 2009.
Multipacting Simulation for the PITZ RF Photo Gun Igor Isaev Unwanted Beam Workshop 2012 Humboldt-University Berlin, The PITZ RF Photo Gun.
SRF COLLABORATION MEETING MAY.2016 ESS MEDIUM BETA CAVITY MANUFACTURING CEA Saclay/ESS ECCTD WU Cavités | Enrico Cenni.
RF Modeling of the LHC Crab Cavity Zenghai Li SLAC Zenghai Li LARP CM20 April 8-10, 2013.
1 Project X Workshop November 21-22, 2008 Richard York Chris Compton Walter Hartung Xiaoyu Wu Michigan State University.
Linac Design: Single-Spoke Cavities.
TTF-III Coupler Parts Processing and Multipacting Simulation using Magic Faya Wang Dec Wake Fest 07 – ILC wakefield workshop at SLAC.
Dark Current in ILC Main Linac N.Solyak, A.Sukhanov, I.Tropin ALCW2015, Apr.23, 2015, KEK LCWS'15, Tsukuba, 04/2015Nikolay Solyak1.
Sub-Task HOM-BPM HOM based Beam Position Monitors – Planned and Extant Measurements N. Baboi, DESY, Hamburg EuCARD WP 10: SRF, Annual Review Meeting.
Possible Relationship Between Defect Pre-Heating and Defect Size H. Padamsee Cornell S0 Meeting, Jan 26, 2009.
Cornell Updates Commissioning of T-map for ILC single cell starts.
RF Dipole HOM Electromagnetic Design
Electropolishing of Dressed ILC 9-cell Cavity
XFEL beamline loads and HOM coupler for CW
TESLA Type Cavity HOM Coupler Multipacting
MICE RF Cavity Simulations and Multipactor
Surface Analysis of the Quench Area Sample of Cavity Z111
LHC Crab Cavity Conceptual Design at SLAC
Design Fabrication and Processing Group H. Padamsee
HOM power in FCC-ee cavities
Jiyuan Zhai ( IHEP ) TTC Meeting, JLAB, 6 Nov 2012
Y. Yamamoto, H. Hayano, E. Kako, S. Noguchi, M. Sato, T. Shishido, K
The broken HOM Couplers on 3.9 GHz Cavity #2
High Efficiency X-band Klystron Design Study
Dipole Antennas Driven at High Voltages in the Plasmasphere
PARALLEL FINITE ELEMENT MODELING TOOLS FOR ERL DESIGN AND ANALYSIS
Minimizing the RF fields
Multipacting Simulations of TTF-III Coupler Components*#
Multipacting Simulation for the Muon Collider Cooling Cavities*
SRF Cavity Designs for the International Linear Collider*
CEPC Main Ring Cavity Design with HOM Couplers
Status of HOMS Spectra Measurements in 1.3 GHz Cavities for LCLS-II
PARALLEL FINITE ELEMENT MODELING TOOLS FOR ERL DESIGN AND ANALYSIS
Cryomodule Design for CW Operation 3.9 GHz considerations
Presentation transcript:

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 1 MULTIPACTORING SIMULATIONS IN CAVITIES AND HOM COUPLERS Nikolay Solyak, Ivan Gonin, Jiajian Li Fermilab

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 2 Analytical Model MatCad simulations. Simple 1-D RF fields. High order resonances. Impact energy and SYE file for simulation of the enhanced function Quasi 2D model for cavity field near cell equator (V.Shemelin) MultiPac 2.1 Package Axis-symmetric RF components, such as coupler, cavity, windows 2D electromagnetic field distribution in cavities and couplers Graphical MATLAB user interface, easy to use Analyst (Omega3P) Powerful tool for MP phenomena investigation for complex RF devices in real 3D fields High order FE for electromagnetic field simulation Paralleling algorithm allows to run a few million FE at the reasonable time Simulation Tools

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 3 Codes benchmarking - 3 rd harm. cavity Transmitted /Reflected power. Temperature sensors on HOM couplers cavity #2: Vertical test Results Strong MP in both HOM couplers Both HOMs coupler fractured after high power vertical tests. No MP in cavity (0-mode) Surface magnetic field in “0”-mode.

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 4 MP in notch gap 0.6 mm 3D simulation Omega 3P(Analyst ) MP in 2 mm Leg-wall gap 3 rd Harmonic Cavity: MP in old HOM design Cavity No.3. Results of vertical test: MP observed at Eacc~0.7MV/m (Q drop). Quench at Eacc~14MV/m. Second resonance frequency of HOM was tuned higher than designed value.

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 5 Cavity No.3: Results of the Cold Test #3 QvsT at Pi-mode. F= MHz. Cavity baked 150C 48 h. Rres=25 nOhms. At Eacc=12 MV/m quench in the bottom HOM. Q vs. max. surface H-field for some modes. Quench in HOM for Pi and 8/9Pi modes and in the cavity cells for lower modes. T-sensor between welds of the bottom HOM go up to maximum 6 K. RF fall time 20 msec. MP 12MV/m

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 6 New Designs of the HOM coupler F 2 =4400 MHz 1-post design F 2 =4080 MHz F 2 =4280 MHz Trimmed Initial design -1a Initial design No.1 HOM-1post HOM1-original 1 1 HOM1-modif cavity Hpk/H Epk/E HOM field - Comparison No MP up-to 23 MV/m in modified design

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 7 Egap ~ 3.8 V/m; MP in TESLA cavity and HOM coupler FE mesh, ~1 million second order elements E max ~ 48.1 V/m  = E gap / E acc ~ mm Enhancement function for gap 1.73mm and 1.3GHz E MP_analytical ~ 200 kV/m E acc = E MP /  ~ 1.25 MV/m Analyst results E max ~ 3.8 V/m HOM coupler 1-D 3-D Test: Q vs. E acc MP in the gap

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 8 MP in TESLA cavity HOM coupler (cont.) E gap ~ ( ) V/m;  = E gap / E acc ~ ( ) E acc = E MP_analytical /  ~ 28 – 45 MV/m E>2V/m Enhancement Counter Function for gap 8.2mm and F=1.3GHz in Analytical MP model MP_analytical ~ kV/m MP in gap 8.2mm

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 9 MP in TESLA cavity HOM coupler (cont.) Analyst results

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 10 MP in TESLA cavity CF, Impact Energy and ECF. No MP. Small activity at E acc ~24 MV/m. Resonance trajectories near equator Eacc~24 MV/m

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 11 FE mesh and E&H Fields distribution in LL mid-cell MP in Low Loss cavity

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 12 MP in LL cavity (cont.) Start points for MP calculations (top) and secondary yield plot (below) Counter (CF) (top) and Enhanced Counter Function (ECF) (below). No MP because ECF < 0.001, E peak /E acc ~2.36 ~30 MV/m

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 13 MP in LL cavity (cont.) At the equator resonance trajectories was found, but impact energy is too small to create enough secondary electrons Distance map

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 14 FE mesh and E&M Fields distribution in RE mid-cell MP in Re-entrant cavity

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 15 MP in Re-entrant cavity (cont) Start points for MP calculations (top) and secondary yield plot (below) CF (top) and ECF (below). No MP because ECF < 0.001, E peak /E acc ~ MV/m

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 16 MP in Re-entrant cavity (cont) At the equator resonance trajectories was found, but impact energy is too small to create enough secondary electrons Distance map

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 17 MP in ICHIRO cavity (2D) Start points for MP calculations (top right), Counter Function/Impact Energy and Enhancement CF (bottom) MP levels (E peak /E acc ~2.36): Resonance order: E-surface pk field: MV/m E acc : 16; 18.6; 19.5; 24; 30; 33 MV/m E&H fields in ICHIRO cavity

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 18 MP in ICHIRO cavity (2D)

Global Design Effort 19 E max ~ 285 V/m E ~ 5V/m or E max FE mesh ~200K elements Resonance trajectories: E acc ~28.5MV/m MP in ICHIRO cavity (3D) Electric Fields

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 20 Ichiro#1 w/ HOM MP in ICHIRO cavity (3D) cont. Ichiro#0 (w/o HOM)

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 21 Ez vs z for β=0.61 cavity in 2D (Omega2P) SC SNS cavities β=0.61 and β=0.81 have end tubes with different diameters. β= mm and 130mm β= mm and 140mm 2D simulations of cavities show the different E-field strength in planes of HOM coupler: β = % and 11.3% of E max β = % and 9.2% of E max Therefore MP activity in HOM coupler can be predicted in coupler placed at the larger diameter end-tube, where the field is higher. SNS β=0.81 cavity

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 22 Analytical simulations show the possibility of multipacting in 4 and 5.3mm gaps between HOM coupler cylindrical body and flat surface of antenna leg. Analytical simulations for MP and Enhanced Counter Function (ECF) after 20 impacts in 4mm (left) and 5.3mm (right) gaps for F=805MHz and n=1. Calculation shows: MP_analytical =~( ) kV/m for 4 mm and ~( ) kV/m for 5.3 mm 4mm 5.3mm Gap = 4mm Gap = 5.3 mm SNS β=0.81 cavity (cont.)

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 23 Electric field distribution FE mesh, ~1 million second order elements E max ~ 26.6 V/m E gap ~ ( ) V/m;  = E gap / E acc ~( ) E acc = E MP_analytical /  ~ mV/m zoom E-field in HOM Ratios: E max / E acc ~ 2.19 E gap ~ 0.5 V/m; E acc = E MP_analytical /  ~ 5.1MV/m 5.3mm  = E gap / E acc ~ E>0.75V/m E>0.25V/m SNS β=0.81 cavity (cont.) Fields in Cavity and HOM coupler

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 24 Enhanced Counter Function and plots of resonance trajectories after 20 impacts in HOM coupler. ANALYST shows two ranges of multipacting, first one around 5-6MV/m is strong and narrow and second have one order less enhanced counter values but is very wide. SNS β=0.81 cavity (cont.) E acc = 5.1 MV/m - analytical model E acc =(10-26) MV/m - analytical model

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 25 Experimental results on a high-β cavity showing typical multipacting behavior. Black circles show the Q and the blue triangles shown the radiation level measured outside the dewar. “The analysis of vertical test data on high-β cavities shows that the onset occurred from 9.5 to 18.6 MV/m with a mean of 11.7 MV/m, and a standard deviation of 1.8 MV/m. Onset of multipacting was defined as the gradient at which a sudden drop in Q-value was first observed. Typical results are shown in Fig. below.” SNS β=0.81 cavity (cont.)

ILC 07 May 30-June 3, 2007 N.Solyak 26 Summary Develop Tools for 1-D, 2-D and 3-D MP simulations in complex SRF cavities and couplers Programs are benchmarked using experimental data for 3 rd harmonic cavity MP was simulated for TESLA-ILC, LL, Reentrant, ICHIRO and SNS cavities.