2 Challenge reach its 20% energy reduction goal by to help a mid-sized city in the United States Increase energy efficiency of 150 public buildings

3 Objective Staff Engagement and Education Informed and Targeted Solutions Real-Time Energy Management

4 REACT Approach Occupant Driven Efficiency REACT-RC Monitoring Device Occupant Engagement Building Driven Efficiency REACT Diagnostic Tool Public-Private Partnerships

5 REACT-RC Monitoring Device

6 Occupant Engagement

7 Intervention Levels Minor RetrofitDeep Retrofit Re-evaluation of Building Use

8 REACT Diagnostic Tool

9 Diagnostic Tool - Step 1

10 Diagnostic Tool - Step 2

11 Diagnostic Tool - Step 3

12 Public - Private Partnerships Benefits Integration of private knowledge and expertise No upfront capital cost in favor of long term installments Risk transferred to private sector (technology, finance) REACT - Best Practice Contract and technology automation and control to reduce time and resource allocation One-step payment Bonus system to incentivize private sector engagement and performance Smaller contracts increase competition

13 Financing with PPP

Presentation

16 Public-Private Partnerships Integration of private knowledge and expertise No upfront capital cost in favor of long term installments Faster project completion Risk transferred to private sector (technology, finance) Reduction of budget deficit; does not count into new indebtedness Benefits Drawbacks Outsourcing of expertise More expensive Profits can vary Increased legal demand Limited number of private competitors Countermeasures contract and technology controlling one-step payment solution, low administrative demands, cost caps, risk minimization incentive and bonus system long-term partnerships and best practices smaller project packages to improve competition