INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20121 Correlation systematics versus RHIC/LHC theories Lanny Ray, The University of Texas at Austin The Ridge Workshop Institute.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Zi-Wei Lin (ECU) 28th WWND, Puerto Rico April 10, Update of Initial Conditions in A Multiple Phase Transport (AMPT) Model Zi-Wei Lin Department.

Advertisements

Two-particle correlations on transverse rapidity and the momentum dependence of angular correlation features in Au+Au collisions at = 200 GeV at STAR Elizabeth.

TJH: ISMD 2005, 8/9-15 Kromeriz, Czech Republic TJH: 1 Experimental Results at RHIC T. Hallman Brookhaven National Laboratory ISMD Kromeriz, Czech Republic.

Rapidity Dependence of Transverse Momentum Correlations from Fluctuating Hydrodynamics Rajendra Pokharel 1, Sean Gavin 1 and George Moschelli 2 1 Wayne.

Effects of minijet degradation on hadron observables in heavy-ion collisions Lilin Zhu Sichuan University QPT2013, Chengdu.

Probing Properties of the QCD Medium via Heavy Quark Induced Hadron Correlations Huan Zhong Huang Department of Physics and Astronomy University of California.

References to Study the New Matter. Study QGP in different Centrality Most Central events (highest multiplicity), e.g. top 5% central, i.e. 5% of the.

ICPAQGP, Kolkata, February 2-6, 2015 Itzhak Tserruya PHENIX highlights.

J/  nuclear modification factor in nucleus-nucleus collisions Xiao-Ming Xu.

High-p T spectra and correlations from Cu+Cu and Au+Au collisions in STAR Marco van Leeuwen, LBNL for the STAR collaboration.

Based on work with: Sean Gavin & Larry McLerran arXiv: [nucl-th] Long Range Correlations and The Soft Ridge George Moschelli 25th Winter Workshop.

Understanding Jet Energy Loss with Angular Correlation Studies in PHENIX Ali Hanks for the PHENIX Collaboration 24 th Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics.

Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics, Feb 2011 Centrality dependence of number and transverse momentum correlations in Au+Au collisions at 200 GeV Monika.

Resolution of Several Puzzles at Intermediate p T and Recent Developments in Correlation Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Quark Matter 05 Budapest,

Luan Cheng (Institute of Particle Physics, Huazhong Normal University) I. Introduction II. Interaction Potential with Flow III. Flow Effects on Light Quark.

7th Feb Prospects for untriggered di-hadron correlations in Pb+Pb 2.76 TeV collisions… Anthony Timmins for the ALICE collaboration.

Jana Bielcikova (Yale University) for the STAR Collaboration 23 rd Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics February 12-18, 2007 Two-particle correlations with.

5-12 April 2008 Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics STAR Particle production at RHIC Aneta Iordanova for the STAR collaboration.

Collective Flow Effects and Energy Loss in ultrarelativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Zhe Xu USTC, Hefei, July 11, 2008 with A. El, O. Fochler, C. Greiner.

Soft Contribution to the Hard Ridge George Moschelli Wayne State University 26,WWND, January 2-10, 2009 Ocho Rios, Jamaica The Ridge Hard Ridge: jet trigger.

Two-, Three-, and Jet-Hadron Correlations at STAR Kolja Kauder for the STAR Collaboration Rencontres de Moriond – La Thuile, Mar

DPG spring meeting, Tübingen, March Kai Schweda Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory for the STAR collaboration Recent results from STAR at RHIC.

Interaction between jets and dense medium in heavy-ion collisions Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon TsingHua University, Beijing, China May 4, 2009.

1 Observation of dramatic transition in 2D correlation data Lanny Ray For the STAR Collaboration University of Texas at Austin April 7, th Winter.

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Radial flow fluctuations:

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Transverse flow fluctuations:

Low-Q 2 Partons in p-p and Au-Au Collisions Tom Trainor ISMD 2005 – Kroměříž, CR August, 2005.

Nov 2001 Craig Ogilvie 1 Angular Correlations at High pt: Craig Ogilvie for the Phenix Collaboration Energy-loss: increased medium-induced gluon-radiation.

Strange and Charm Probes of Hadronization of Bulk Matter at RHIC International Symposium on Multi-Particle Dynamics Aug 9-15, 2005 Huan Zhong Huang University.

Hydrodynamic Tests of Fluctuating Initial Conditions George Moschelli & Hannu Holopainen Transport Meeting 24 January 2012.

What’s Missing in our Current Picture from High p T Measurements at RHIC? Saskia Mioduszewski Texas A&M University 23 March, 2007.

Identified Particle Ratios at large p T in Au+Au collisions at  s NN = 200 GeV Matthew A. C. Lamont for the STAR Collaboration - Talk Outline - Physics.

Two Particle Correlations and Viscosity in Heavy Ion Collisions Monika Sharma for the Wayne State University STAR Collaboration Outline: Motivation Measurement.

As one evolves the gluon density, the density of gluons becomes large: Gluons are described by a stochastic ensemble of classical fields, and JKMMW argue.

Flow fluctuation and event plane correlation from E-by-E Hydrodynamics and Transport Model LongGang Pang 1, Victor Roy 1,, Guang-You Qin 1, & Xin-Nian.

Longitudinal de-correlation of anisotropic flow in Pb+Pb collisions Victor Roy ITP Goethe University Frankfurt In collaboration with L-G Pang, G-Y Qin,

1 A NLO Analysis on Fragility of Dihadron Tomography in High-Energy Nuclear Collisions Enke Wang Institute of Particle Physics, Central China Normal University.

Background introduction Model introduction Analysis method Results and discussions Conclusions G.L. Ma, S. Zhang, YGM et al., Phys Lett B 641, 362 (2006)

Jan. 13, 2004QM 2004 Poster Session1 The Geometry of Hadronization in Au-Au Collisions at s NN 1/2 = 130 and 200 GeV Studied with Two-Particle, Charge-Dependent.

Flow fluctuation and event plane correlation from E-by-E Hydrodynamics and Transport Model Victor Roy Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China Collaborators.

What is the ridge? And why you should care Christine Nattrass University of Tennessee at Knoxville.

Ridge Formation and Long Range Correlations in pp Collisions at CMS C.B. Yang Institute of Particle Physics Central China Normal University Wuhan ,

STAR Modification of high-p T hadro-chemistry in Au+Au collisions relative to p+p Anthony Timmins for the STAR Collaboration 31st July 2009 Heavy-ion III.

1 Transport description of viscous effects Che-Ming Ko Texas A&M University  Introduction  A multi-phase transport (AMPT) model  Anisotropic flow -

Correlations at Intermediate p T Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Correlations and Fluctuations in Relativistic Nuclear Collisions MIT, April 2005.

1 Do two-dimensional correlation data falsify RHIC paradigms? Lanny Ray University of Texas at Austin and STAR Collaboration Outline:  Introduction 

Correlation of Hadrons in Jets Produced at RHIC Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Workshop on QCD and RHIC physics Wuhan, June 22, 2005.

Bulk Correlations 1 Thinking about the correlation landscape in terms of What’s this talk about?? Paul Sorensen 9:06 PM Agnes Mocsy 9:05 PM.

Glasma, minijets, strings  long range  correlations  Venugopalan Ask: how does viscous flow modify these correlations? Viscosity, Flow and the Ridge.

1 The away-side ridge in two-dimensional correlation data from STAR Lanny Ray University of Texas at Austin STAR Collaboration.

1 The transition observed in two- dimensional correlation data from STAR Lanny Ray University of Texas at Austin STAR Collaboration Outline:  p-p phenomenology.

Kirill Filimonov, ISMD 2002, Alushta 1 Kirill Filimonov Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Anisotropy and high p T hadrons in Au+Au collisions at RHIC.

JET Collaboration Meeting June 17-18, 2014, UC-Davis1/25 Flow and “Temperature” of the Parton Phase from AMPT Zi-Wei Lin Department of Physics East Carolina.

Japanese Physics Society meeting, Hokkaido Univ. 23/Sep/2007, JPS meeting, Sapporo, JapanShinIchi Esumi, Inst. of Physics, Univ. of Tsukuba1 Collective.

1 Azimuthal quadrupole correlation from gluon interference in 200 GeV and 7 TeV p+p collisions Lanny Ray – University of Texas at Austin The 2 nd International.

1 High p T Hadron Correlation Rudolph C. Hwa University of Oregon Hard Probes 2006 Asilomar, CA, June 10, 2006 and No Correlation.

Angular Correlations with ALICE Jan Fiete Grosse-Oetringhaus, CERN for the ALICE collaboration EPS-HEP, Vienna Muon-hadron correlations (p-Pb)

Jana Bielcikova (Yale)ISMD 2007, Berkeley1 Near-side di-hadron correlations at RHIC Jana Bielcikova (Yale University)

Toward a  +Jet Measurement in STAR Saskia Mioduszewski, for the STAR Collaboration Texas A&M University 1.

Production, energy loss and elliptic flow of heavy quarks at RHIC and LHC Jan Uphoff with O. Fochler, Z. Xu and C. Greiner Hard Probes 2010, Eilat October.

TWO PARTICLE CORRELATION MEASUREMENTS AT PHENIX Takahito Todoroki For the PHENIX Collaboration University of Tsukuba & RIKEN Nishina Center Hard Probes.

I. Correlations: PHOBOS Data, Flux Tubes and Causality II. Ridge: Transverse Flow, Blast Wave Long Range Correlations and Hydrodynamic Expansion Sean Gavin.

Monika Sharma Wayne State University for the STAR Collaboration

Strangeness Production in Heavy-Ion Collisions at STAR

ATLAS vn results vn from event plane method

Outline First of all, there’s too much data!! BRAHMS PHOBOS PHENIX

Introduction Results Methods Conclusions

Near-Side Ridge and Early Parton Momentum Distribution

of Hadronization in Nuclei

张汉中 Institute of Particle Physics, Central China Normal University,

Presentation transcript:

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20121 Correlation systematics versus RHIC/LHC theories Lanny Ray, The University of Texas at Austin The Ridge Workshop Institute of Nuclear Theory May 7-11, 2012

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20122 Introduction and Outline A-A collision theories must include (among other things):  pQCD processes including minimum p t biased jets, and their evolution in the dense, energetic collision system  event-wise fluctuations in initial conditions, e.g. N part and N binary In this talk I will review and discuss:  Experimental challenges for theory  Theoretical expectations for data  Initial state fluctuation model predictions  Jet + medium interaction model predictions  Ideas from pQCD  Conclusions

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20123 Correlation data challenges for Theory  Smooth evolution to the p-p collision limit  Coexistence of Glauber superposition of jet structure with large v 2  Sharp transition in same-side peak and away-side ridge 1) increased yield beyond binary scaling 2) elongation on   – “soft ridge” 3) reduced azimuth width Two-particle angular and transverse momentum correlations Au-Au 62,200 GeV STAR data arXiv: same-side 2D peak dipole quadrupole

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20124 Correlation data challenges for Theory  Transverse momentum structure peak at 1 – 1.5 GeV/c 1) persistence from p-p to central Au-Au 2) increased away-side width on y t  = y t1 -y t2, “K T broadening” 3) evolution of same-side unlike-sign peak; from single to double peaks away-side unlike-sign same-side unlike-sign STAR preliminary From E. Oldag

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20125 Correlation data challenges for Theory  Transverse momentum content of “soft ridge” 1 – 1.5 GeV/c with no softening at larger   (within 2 units) or with increasing centrality  Correspondence between p t correlations and spectra (Tom Trainor’s analysis)  Charge-ordering (US > LS) along    , and y t  volume of SS 2D peak on (y t,y t ) STAR preliminary From E. Oldag

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20126 General expectations: jet + medium interaction pQCD minijets are expected to dissipate with increasing A-A centrality. Surprisingly, jet-like correlations follow Glauber linear superposition (GLS) to mid centrality. In transport/hydro models (strong parton interactions) jet-related correlation widths should increase, amplitudes decrease, parton p t. Hadronic corona + opaque core: away-side dijet correlations persist but fall off relative to SS jet-related correlations. Sarcevic, Ellis, Carruthers, PRD 40, 1446 (1989) Kajantie, Landshoff, Lindfors, PRL 59, 2527 (1987) Pang, Wang, X.-N. Wang, Xu, PRC 81, (2010) Nayak, Dumitru, McLerran, Greiner, NP A 687, 457 (2001) Shin, Meuller, J. Phys. G 29, 2485 (2003) STAR preliminary

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20127 Theoretical ideas for the same-side   elongation Initial stage fluctuations plus hydro pressure driven radial flow:  Beam jets – Voloshin, Shuryak  Color-glass condensate flux tubes; glasma – many authors  Initial Energy/momentum density fluctuations in hydro – Gavin, Alver & Roland, Sorensen Spherio (3+1 event-wise hydro; no jets) Jet + medium interactions:  Jet parton + thermal parton recombination – Chiu and Hwa  Momentum kick – C-Y Wong  AMPT – 2-to-2 parton cascade  HYDJET (CMS) – collisional and gluon radiation jet quenching  NexSpherio (3+1 hydro with NEXUS initial cond. & hard scattering) pQCD preliminaries:  Color coherence – 2-to-3 soft gluon radiation  BFKL emission interference

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20128 Initial fluctuations plus radial flow  Voloshin, Nucl. Phys. A749, 287c (2005); Shuryak, Phys. Rev. C76, (2007) – beam jet fragments pushed out by strong radial flow; ridge shaped by flow and path length attenuation. Reduced L absorption ridge projection onto azimuth  S. Gavin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, (2006) – initial state fluctuations with shear viscosity; driven by hydrodynamic radial expansion STAR p t angular correlation peak widths  Alver & Roland, Phys. Rev. C 81, (2010) – initial state fluctuations produce triangular flow and ridge

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/20129 CGC glasma predictions for the “ridge” Dumitru et al., Nucl. Phys. A 810, 91 (2008) Dumitru et al., Phys. Lett. B 697, 21 (2011) Gavin et al., Phys. Rev. C 79, (R) (2009) Gavin, Moschelli, Nucl. Phys. A 854, 106 (2011); ibid. 836, 43 (2010) T. Lappi, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 187, 134 (2011); arXiv: Lappi, Srednyak, Venugopalan, JHEP 01, 66(2010); arXiv: Gelis et al., Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part Sci. 60, 463 (2010) radial flow From Gavin & Moschelli: Same-side amplitude;  s -1 (Q s ) adjusted to fit most-central data  width determined by radial flow blast-wave parameters STAR data: arXiv: [nucl-ex]

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ CGC glasma predictions for the “ridge” The correlation amplitude is predicted to increase with centrality, however the overall magnitude is adjusted to the data. Predicted azimuth width is generally too broad, requiring extreme radial boost  B =2 (0.96c) to agree with data* (0.7-1 rad). Pseudorapidity widths are not predicted. Dumitru et al., Nucl. Phys. A 810, 91 (2008); What about the p t structure of the ridge? *See: STAR, arXiv: Daugherity (STAR-QM08), J.Phys.G 35, azimuth projection vs radial boost

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ Same-side Away-side Glasma two-gluon (p t,p t ) correlations T. Lappi, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 187, 134 (2011); arXiv: Lappi, Srednyak, Venugopalan, JHEP 01,66(2010); arXiv: extraneous self-pairs per-gluon pair correlation No radial boost

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ Comparing glasma (p t,p t ) predictions to data Glasma predictions, gluon-gluon correlations Charged hadron correlations in p-p collisions* This model has no radial flow. Radial boost cannot reproduce the correlations at larger p t. T. Lappi, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 187, 134 (2011) Glasma model misses this peak associated with the ridge. *See: Phys. Rev. C 84, (2011) Assume LPHD

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ AMPT Essential aspects of the model [Lin, Ko, Zhang, Pal, Phys. Rev. C 72, (2005)]: HIJING production of F.S. hadrons (MC Glauber w. LUND & Pythia) In “string melting” mode all F.S. hadrons represented as q, anti-q at space-time positions corresponding to MCG and assumed formation time. Parton cascade via pQCD 2-to-2 elastic scattering; adjustable cross section. Hadronization via coalescence – 3-momentum conservation, no E cons. Hadron cascade & chemistry using ART

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ LUND string fragmentation parameters (a = 0.5, b = 0.9 GeV -2 ); “string melting,” w/out parton cascade and/or jets (> 2 GeV; no quenching) 200 GeV Au-Au 46-55% - jets, parton cascade on/off No Jets,  parton = 0 No Jets,  parton = 12 mb With Jets,  parton = 0 (same as Hijing) With Jets,  parton = 12 mb with hadron scattering AMPT: Jets and parton cascade From E. Oldag

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ AMPT: Jets with varying parton cross section LUND string fragmentation parameters (a = 0.5, b = 0.9 GeV -2 ); “string melting,” with parton cascade and jets (> 2 GeV; no quenching) 200 GeV Au-Au 46-55% - vary  parton (using screening mass  ) 0 mb 3 mb 6 mb 12 mb  (mb) Data quad (2) A 2DG (7)   (5)   (2) Model fit parameters Why doesn’t the (y t,y t ) peak move down? Why does the azimuth width decrease? Increasing  enough to reproduce v 2 grossly overestimates the SS 2D peak amplitude and   width STAR data arXiv: From E. Oldag

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ GeV Au-Au – centrality fixed  =12 mb 84-93% 46-55% 18-28% The data approximately follow GLS up to ~3; AMPT with  ~ 0 follows GLS but produces no quadrupole (v 2 ). AMPT: centrality dependence LUND string fragmentation parameters (a = 0.5, b = 0.9 GeV -2 ); “string melting,” with parton cascade (12 mb) and jets (> 2 GeV; no quenching) From E. Oldag STAR arXiv:

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ AMPT: parton correlations The preceding results are counter-intuitive. We therefore studied the predicted parton correlations as a function of parton cross section (0,1.5,3,6,9,12 mb) with no coalescence 200 GeV Au-Au 46-55% - parton correlations 0 mb 1.5 mb3 mb0 mb1.5 mb3 mb 6 mb9 mb12 mb 6 mb9 mb12 mb angular (      correlations (y t,y t ) correlations SS peak: amplitude and widths  increase Quadrupole: increases to exp. value at ~6mb Jet peak: strong dissipation as expected. What is coalescence doing? From E. Oldag

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ AMPT: parton correlations  (mb) Data quad (2) A 2DG (7)   (5)   (2) Model fit parameters  (mb) quad A 2DG     Model fit parameters LUND string fragmentation parameters (a = 0.5, b = 0.9 GeV -2 ); “string melting,” with parton cascade and jets (> 2 GeV; no quenching) 200 GeV Au-Au 46-55% - vary  parton Quadrupole increases smoothly with  parton in both cases. The SS 2D peak evolves very rapidly in both cases. The parton SS peak azimuth width increases when parton’s scatter. Final-state hadrons: coalescencePartons at end of cascade Initial width increase, then a decrease. Is the latter due to radial flow in the parton cascade? From E. Oldag STAR arXiv:

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ Monte Carlo Models: NexSPHERIO Sharma et al., PRC 84, (2011) Au-Au 200 GeV Number correlations p t correlations   width for same-side p t correlations STAR data nexspherio Jet-like peak predicted;   width increase not predicted No away-side double ridge

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ Color coherence – pQCD soft gluons p-p at 7 TeV, N > < p t < 3 GeV/c CMS Collaboration, JHEP 1009,091(2010). Rick Field – ISMD, ECT* 2010  extended jet correlations Higher order 2→3 or 2→4 matrix elements. Color coherent soft gluon radiation: Ellis, Nucl.Phys. B286, 643 (1987) p1p1 p2p2 k Soft gluon – jet angular correlations (LR) Phys. Rev. D 84, (2011) With varied IR, collinear cut-offs

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ BFKL emission and interference E. Levin and A. H. Rezaeian, Phys. Rev. D 84, (2011) Angular correlation –   independent peak at   = 0, but also away-side! azimuth quadrupole See Amir Rezaeian’s talk tomorrow morning! Two-Pomeron exchange with two-gluon emission interference See also: Kopeliovich, Rezaeian, Schmidt Phys. Rev. D 78, (2008).

INT Ridge Workshop - 5/10/ Summary and Conclusions Observed correlation structure on relative angles and (y t,y t ) pose strict challenges for theoretical models: centrality evolution of the ridge (y t,y t ) composition of the same-side ridge (y t,y t ) correlation peak – persistent position and increasing amplitude General expectations for strong jet + medium interaction, with possible thermalization, disagree with data trends. Initial state fluctuation + radial flow (e.g. Glasma) produce SS   elongation but does not produce sufficient (y t,y t ) structure at p t ~ 1 – 2 GeV/c. Jet + medium interaction models (e.g. AMPT, NexSpherio) can produce SS   elongation. But can they account for the azimuth narrowing and (y t,y t ) peak’s persistence? pQCD models for the quadrupole are appearing in the literature which do not require hydro. Perhaps the same will be developed for the ridge.