And Intelligent Life in the Universe The Occurrence of Planets and Mass-Radius Relation from Kepler Keck Tel Aviv 7 December 2012 Kepler Thanks to: Shay.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
A Search for Earth-size Planets Borucki – Page 1 KEPLER; Data Validation and Follow Up Observations CoRoT Symposium W.J. Borucki & the Kepler Team 5 February.
Advertisements

Courtney Dressing Advisor: David Charbonneau All Souls College, Oxford July 4, 2011.
K2 Kepler’s Second Mission 1 K2 - a 2-wheel Kepler mission; The second highest peak in the world, a worthy ascent Steve B. Howell NASA Ames Research Center.
AST 111 Exoplanets II. What can we measure? Orbital period – Look at doppler shift or just watch it Orbital distance – Kepler’s 3 rd Law with orbital.
NEAT: Very high precision astrometry to detect nearby planetary systems down to one Earth mass F. Malbet, A. Crouzier, M. Shao, A. Léger and the NEAT collaboration.
Investigating the structure of transiting planets, from hot Jupiters to Kepler super Earths Jonathan Fortney University of California, Santa Cruz Thanks.
Lecture 1: Introduction & Methods 1.Introduction 2.Techniques for discovery & study 3.The NASA Kepler mission Planetary Systems Orbiting Diverse Stars.
Prospects for measuring η-Earth from RV David W. Latham Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics 5 Octoberber 2013.
Exoplanet- Asteroseismology Synergies Bill Chaplin, School of Physics & Astronomy University of Birmingham, UK EAHS2012, Oxford, 2012 March 15.
Science Opportunities for HARPS-NEF David W. Latham PDR - 6 December 2007.
Characterizing Extrasolar Planets from their Transit Lightcurves Jason W. Barnes Assistant Professor Department of Physics University of Idaho ECE Seminar.
Exoplanet Transits and SONG Angelle Tanner. Venus Transiting the Sun.
All About Exoplanets Dimitar D. Sasselov Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
New Results from Kepler: Systems of Multiple Transiting Planets w/ Correlated TTVs Eric B. Ford Extreme Solar Systems II September 12, 2011 Based on a.
Lecture 11: The Discovery of the World of Exoplanets
KOI-730 as a System of Four Planets in a Chain of Resonances Daniel Fabrycky UC Santa Cruz Matthew Holman, Joshua Carter, Jason Rowe, Darin Ragozzine,
INTRINSIC PLANETARY FREQUENCIES BASED ON KEPLER OBSERVATIONS William Borucki, NASA Ames Kepler Mission Objectives; Determine the Frequency of Earth-size.
Lecture 8 Extrasolar planets detection methods and strategy.
Lecture 16: Searching for Habitable Planets: Remote Sensing Methods and parameters we can measure Mean density measurements: internal structure Measurements.
PLAnetary Transits and Oscillations of stars Thierry Appourchaux for the PLATO Consortium
Extrasolar planets. Finding planets Finding planets around other stars is hard!  need to look for something very faint very close to something that is.
Dr. Matt Burleigh 3677: Life in the Universe DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS AND ASTRONOMY 3677 Life in the Universe Extra-solar planets: Revision Dr. Matt Burleigh.
What stellar properties can be learnt from planetary transits Adriana Válio Roque da Silva CRAAM/Mackenzie.
The Grand Tour of Exoplanets The New Worlds around Other Stars The Grand Tour of Exoplanets The New Worlds around Other Stars Dániel Apai Space Telescope.
Search for planetary candidates within the OGLE stars Adriana V. R. Silva & Patrícia C. Cruz CRAAM/Mackenzie COROT /11/2005.
KEPLER Discovery Mission # 10 William Borucki, PI NASA Ames.
Subaru HDS Transmission Spectroscopy of the Transiting Extrasolar Planet HD b The University of Tokyo Norio Narita collaborators Yasushi Suto, Joshua.
A Turtorial Lecture on Exoplanets Wing-Huen Ip Institutes of Astronomy and Space Science National Central University August 31, 2012.
A Search for Earth-size Planets Borucki – Page 1 Roger Hunter (Ames Research Center) & Kepler Team March 26, 2010.
Investigating the structure of transiting planets, from hot Jupiters to Kepler super Earths Jonathan Fortney University of California, Santa Cruz Thanks.
Modern Concepts for a Terrestrial Planet Finder Space Telescope James Kasting Department of Geosciences Penn State University.
Toward Detections and Characterization of Habitable Transiting Exoplanets Norio Narita (NAOJ)
Targets for JWST: Kepler and K2 Steve B. Howell NASA Ames Research Center March 2014.
Corot Week 9 ESTEC 5-9 Dec 2005 Frédéric Pont Geneva Observatory Lessons from the OGLE planetary transit survey Francois Bouchy (Marseille/OHP), Nuno Santos.
A STEP Expected Yield of Planets … Survey strategy The CoRoTlux Code Understanding transit survey results Fressin, Guillot, Morello, Pont.
A Dedicated Search for Transiting Extrasolar Planets using a Doppler Survey and Photometric Follow-up A Proposal for NASA's Research Opportunities in Space.
Lecture 14: The Discovery of the World of Exoplanets Indirect methods for planet detection The Astrometric method The Doppler shift method The Transit.
Extra-Solar Planet Populations Stephen Eikenberry 4 November 2010 AST
1 Neptune Mass Exoplanets Jeff Valenti M Jupiter / 19 = M Neptune = 17 M Earth Geoff Marcy (Berkeley)Debra Fischer (Yale) Andrew Howard (Berkeley)John.
Exoplanet Science Don Pollacco QUB. Overview PLATO’s objectives and space Work packages in the definition phase Timescales and aims of the definition.
Leslie Rogers Hubble Fellow California Institute of Technology Kepler Science Conference II – November 4, 2013 Glimpsing the Compositions.
Kepler Mission Progress: Day 808 William Borucki, Principal Investigator, Kepler Mission, NASA Ames Research Center Dave Latham, Harvard-Smithsonian Center.
Extrasolar Planets The Next Decade Dante Minniti, Católica Steve Vogt, UC Santa Cruz Chris Tinney, UNSW Pamela Arriagada, Católica The discovery of extrasolar.
Spitzer Space Telescope Spitzer Meets K2 M.Werner, J.Livingston, V.Gorjian, JPL/Caltech; C.Beichman, D.Ciardi, J.Christiansen, R.Akeson, NExSci; J.Krick,
Kepler Finds Earth’s Cousin
Extrasolar Planets & The Power of the Dark Side David Charbonneau California Institute of Technology Fermilab – 24 April 2002.
K2 Observations of Open Clusters Ann Marie Cody NPP fellow at NASA Ames November 2, 2015.
The University of Tokyo Norio Narita
Gijs Mulders, Ilaria Pascucci, Daniel Apai University of Arizona An Increase in Planet Formation Efficiency around Low-Mass Stars.
Page 1 Completeness of Kepler Data and Implications for K2 Jessie Christiansen, Bruce D. Clarke, Christopher J. Burke, Fergal Mullally, Jeff L. Coughlin,
Most 1.6 Earth-Radius Planets are not Rocky Introduction Sub-Neptune, super-Earth-size exoplanets are a new planet class. They account for 0% of the solar.
The Role of Transiting Planets Dave Latham (CfA) 30 May 2008.
Jet Propulsion Laboratory California Institute of Technology Kepler Estimate #3: An Analysis and Implications of Kepler’s Photometric Uncertainties Wesley.
Discoveries in Planetary Sciencehttp://dps.aas.org/education/dpsdisc/ A Thousand New Planets Prior to 2011, scientists knew of about 500 planets around.
Kepler + Keck: Planet Masses and Densities Kepler + Keck: Planet Masses and Densities Geoff Marcy UC Berkeley + Preliminary Results.
A Census of the Solar System. 1 star and 8 major planets Mercury Venus Earth Mars Jupiter Saturn Uranus Neptune terrestrial giant (1) (2) (17) (18) (21)
1 The Validation of Kepler planets F. Fressin, G. Torres & the Kepler team.
Planets In Transit: The Shadow Knows! David Charbonneau California Institute of Technology STScI May Symposium – 3 May 2004.
Recent Results from the Kepler Mission Ron Gilliland - STScI - 9 June 2010.
Astrophysics Missions, Grants, and Forum Nuggets for December 2012.
How many of these ? Out there. At least One in Six stars has an Earth-size planet Francois Fressin, G. Torres, D. Charbonneau & the team.
Planetary Sizes Dimitar Sasselov Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Jet Propulsion Laboratory California Institute of Technology Exoplanet Exploration Program Analysis Group #8 Kepler Mission Status Kepler Mission Manager:
Lecture 22: The Search for Life, Part 1: Kepler update Meteo 466.
Characterizing Planets from their Transit Lightcurves Jason W. Barnes NASA Postdoctoral Program Fellow NASA Ames Research Center Advisor: William J. Borucki.
Kepler/K2, TESS, and Opportunities for Australia
Asteroseismology of Kepler
Exoplanet Host Stars.
3677 Life in the Universe: Extra-solar planets
The University of Tokyo Norio Narita
Presentation transcript:

And Intelligent Life in the Universe The Occurrence of Planets and Mass-Radius Relation from Kepler Keck Tel Aviv 7 December 2012 Kepler Thanks to: Shay Zucker Amiel Sternberg Geoff Marcy University of California

And Intelligent Life in the Universe The Occurrence of Planets and Mass-Radius Relation from Kepler Keck Tel Aviv 7 December 2012 Kepler Tsevi Mazeh Thanks to: Shay Zucker Amiel Sternberg

Acknowledgements Acknowledgements William Borucki David Koch Stephen Bryson Jason Rowe Roger Hunter Marcie Smith Susan Thompson Bruce Clark Rob Lewis Guillermo Torres Francois Fressin Jean-Michel Désert Lars Buchhave Sam Quinn Dan Fabrycky Debra Fischer Dimitar Sasselov Natalie Batalha Thomas Gautier Steve Howell Charlie Sobeck Tsevi Mazeh David Latham Fergal Mullally Joe Twicken Elisa Quintana Ron Gilliland Eric Ford Elliott Horsch Tom Barclay Jessie Christiansen Jack Lissauer Jon Jenkins Mike Haas Doug Caldwell Jeff Kolodziejcak Martin Still Shawn Seader Jie Li David Charbonneau David Ciardi Chris Burke Leslie Rogers Martin Still Martin Stumpe Peter Tenebaum Lucianne Walkowicz Bill Cochran Mike Endl Kepler’s Heavy Lifters

Andrew Howard, Lauren Weiss, Howard Isaacson, Jason Rowe, John Johnson Special Thanks: Acknowledgements Acknowledgements William Borucki David Koch Stephen Bryson Jason Rowe Roger Hunter Marcie Smith Susan Thompson Bruce Clark Rob Lewis Guillermo Torres Francois Fressin Jean-Michel Désert Lars Buchhave Sam Quinn Dan Fabrycky Debra Fischer Dimitar Sasselov Natalie Batalha Thomas Gautier Steve Howell Charlie Sobeck Tsevi Mazeh David Latham Fergal Mullally Joe Twicken Elisa Quintana Ron Gilliland Eric Ford Elliott Horsch Tom Barclay Jessie Christiansen Jack Lissauer Jon Jenkins Mike Haas Doug Caldwell Jeff Kolodziejcak Martin Still Shawn Seader Jie Li David Charbonneau David Ciardi Chris Burke Leslie Rogers Martin Still Martin Stumpe Peter Tenebaum Lucianne Walkowicz Bill Cochran Mike Endl Kepler’s Heavy Lifters

Jupiter-size Neptune-size Earth-size Orbital Period in days Size Relative to Earth Extended mission domain Earth analogs Small Exoplanets

Jupiter-size Neptune-size Earth-size Orbital Period in days Size Relative to Earth Extended mission domain Earth analogs Small Exoplanets Earth-Size Close-in

Multiple Transits yield sufficient S/N Ratio for detection. Data binning yields obvious transit signatures Francois Fressin et al Kepler: Hundreds of Earth-size Planets – in Tight Orbits 0.87 R 1.03 R + + P = days P = days

Jupiter-size Neptune-size Earth-size Orbital Period in days Size Relative to Earth Extended mission domain Earth analogs Small Exoplanets R=1-4 R Earth - Not in S.S. - Interior: Rock + ? - Formation ?

Define Planet Occurrence For each R PL and Period:

Define Planet Occurrence For each R PL and Period:

Define the Stellar Domain: Stellar Parameters and SNR of Transit Stellar Domain: FGK Main Sequence Teff = 4100 – 6100 K log g = 4.0 – 4.9 Kepmag < 15 mag Target Star Parameters: Teff= K, log g= , Kepmag<15

Define the Survey Domain: Stellar Parameters and SNR of Transit Stellar Domain: FGK Main Sequence Teff = 4100 – 6100 K log g = 4.0 – 4.9 Kepmag < 15 mag Target Star Parameters: Teff= K, log g= , Kepmag<15 Note: Only 59,000 Kepler Target stars meet these stellar criteria

Define the Survey Domain: Stellar Parameters and SNR of Transit Stellar Domain: FGK Main Sequence Teff = 4100 – 6100 K log g = 4.0 – 4.9 Kepmag < 15 mag Target Star Parameters: Teff= K, log g= , Kepmag<15 SNR Threshold of Transit: 10 Demand SNR > 10 in Quarter 3 Note: Only 59,000 Kepler Target stars meet these stellar criteria

Define the Survey Domain: Stellar Parameters and SNR of Transit Stellar Domain: FGK Main Sequence Teff = 4100 – 6100 K log g = 4.0 – 4.9 Kepmag < 15 mag Target Star Parameters: Teff= K, log g= , Kepmag<15 SNR Threshold of Transit: 10 Demand SNR > 10 in Quarter 3 SNR Depends on planet radius # of transits Photometric noise Note: Only 59,000 Kepler Target stars meet these stellar criteria

15 Number of Target Stars Capable of Achieving SNR > 10 in Quarter 3 mag Target Star Parameters: Teff= K, log g= , Kepmag<15 Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team. (2011)

Define Planet Occurrence For each R PL and Period:

17 Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011)

18 Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011)

19 Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011)

20 Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011)

21 Focus on a single domain In Period and Radius Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011)

22 Naïve: Count the planets in this domain. Focus on a single domain In Period and Radius Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011)

23 Focus on a single domain In Period and Radius Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011) Naïve: Count the planets in this domain. Best: Augment each planet by its # of “inclined” twins: a/R STAR.

Augment Each Transiting Planet by the # of (undetected) Inclined Twins # Planets at All Inclinations = a / R STAR a R STAR

25 Focus on a single domain In Period and Radius Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011) Naïve: Count the planets in this domain. Best: Augment each planet by # of “inclined” twins: a/R STAR :

26 Focus on a single domain In Period and Radius Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team (2011) Naïve: Count the planets in this domain. Best: Augment each planet by # of “inclined” twins: a/R STAR : Typically 5-20.

Define Planet Occurrence within each cell:

Distribution of Planet Radii For Orbital Periods < 50 Days Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team, as of Sept % of G stars have a planet of R Earth 10% of stars have Planets R Earth. 1% of stars have Planets 8-11 R Earth.

Howard et al. Analysis: Redone with Planet Candidates through Quarter 6 from Batalha et al. 2012

Distribution of Planet Sizes Petigura, Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team - Nov 2012 Is Decline to 1 R Earth Real ?

Jupiter-size Neptune-size Earth-size Orbital Period in days Size Relative to Earth Extended mission domain Earth analogs Small Exoplanets Batalha et al Earth-Size: Not many…

Distribution of Planet Sizes Petigura, Howard, Marcy, Kepler Team - Nov 2012 Is Decline to 1 R Earth Real ? Or is it due to Incompleteness in The Kepler pipeline? SNR (SES) ~ 1 for R=1 R Earth

New Kepler Pipeline by Erik Petigura New CBVs New Search Algorithm

Petigura’s Kepler Pipline Adopted CDPP Threshold: “Best 12,000 Kepler Stars” Best 12000

Planets Detected in “Best 12000” Kepler Stars Petigura et al Now: - Assess completeness - Compute occurrence ala Howard et al.

Completeness Measurement Petigura et al Detection Completeness: > 80% - Radius = 1.2 – 4 R Earth - Period > 50 d Inject Mock Transits into Actual Kepler Raw photometery

Planets Detected in “Best 12000” Kepler Stars Petigura et al Now make Same corrections As in Howard et al.

Fressin et al. Occurrence Occurrence is Flat Shortward of 2 R Earth Agreement with Petigura & Howard

39 Mass-Radius Diagram b 20c Planet Mass-Radius Diagram

Kepler Planet Masses and Radii KOI-94

KOI-94 Photometry: 4 Transiting Planets P=3.74 d R=1.7 R E P=10.42 d R=4.3 R E P=22.34 d R=11.3 R E P=54.32 d R=6.56 R E Lauren Weiss et al. 2013

Doppler Measurements of KOI-94: Masses for two planets. Only Upper limits for two. Lauren Weiss et al. 2013

135 Exoplanets with Mass and Radius

Planet Radius vs Mass Two mass domains: M CRIT = 150 M EARTH Affect of stellar Flux on Planet: M>150 M EARTH : Bloated M<150 M EARTH : Smaller Weiss, Marcy, et al. 2013

Planet Radius vs Mass Weiss, Marcy, et al Planet Radius vs Mass

Constant Density: R ~ M 1/3 Radius rises faster than solid interior! Implication: Admixture of more volatiles with Increasing mass. i.e. Water or H + He. Planet Radius vs Mass

Electron Degeneracy: R ~ M -1/3 Radii rises faster Than e- degeneracy. Implication: Admixture of more volatiles with Increasing mass. i.e. Water or H + He.

Planet Density vs Mass

Models: Mordasini et al. Chiang & Laughlin: Rock + Gas

Up next: Habitable Zone Earths Jupiter-size Neptune-size Earth-size Orbital Period in days Size Relative to Earth Extended mission domain Earth analogs Small Exoplanets

Planet R(M,Flux) becoming defined. Planet R(M,Flux) becoming defined. Two Domains: Critical Mass at 150 M Earth Two Domains: Critical Mass at 150 M Earth Radii increase faster with Mass than Expected: : Radii increase faster with Mass than Expected: : Amt. of Volatiles increases with mass. Amt. of Volatiles increases with mass. Planet Occurrence: Planet Occurrence: Rises from 20-2 R Earth Rises from 20-2 R Earth Flat from 2.0–1.2 R Earth Flat from 2.0–1.2 R Earth Questions: Questions: -Interiors 2-4 R Earth and 1-2 R Earth -Interiors 2-4 R Earth and 1-2 R Earth -Occurrence of Planets from 2 – 0.5 R Earth -Occurrence of Planets from 2 – 0.5 R Earth Summary