The Unfulfilled Promise of DFA for P&C Insurance Companies 2001 DFA Seminar Bill Wilt, VP/Sr. Analyst Property & Casualty/Reinsurance Moody's Investors.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
What one person writes and another person reads are often two different things!
Advertisements

ICP 20 Public Disclosure Yoshihiro Kawai IAIS-ASSAL Conference 22 April 2014.
Midwest Actuarial Forum Aon Center March 26, 2002.
Better Regulation workshop on Rate of Return Guidelines
A.M. Best’s Insurance Market Briefing - Canada Reinsurance Overview Greg Reisner A.M. Best Company September 8, 2010.
Joseph L. Petrelli President & Co-Founder, Demotech, Inc.
ERM in the Rating Evaluation CAMAR Fall Meeting November 29, 2007 Thomas M. Mount, ACAS, MAAA Andrew Colannino, Vice President A.M.Best Company.
Enterprise Risk Management and the Own Risk Solvency Assessment Act Michelle M. Rogers, JD Director of Financial and Regulatory Policy National Association.
1 Risk Management at Progressive Insurance How we got started Getting corporate support Capital Management Examples of deliverables The value risk management.
4 July 2005 Global Research of Investment Managers with Increasing Focus on SRI 13th Australian Colloquium of Superannuation Researchers Bruce Gregor.
Linkage of Risk, Capital, and Financial Management CAS and SOA Spring 2008 Meeting – Joint Day of the SOA, CIA, CAS, and IAA June 18, 2008 ADVISORY.
MODELING CORPORATE RISK AT FORD Freeman Wood Director Global Risk Management.
CHAPTER 7 ACCEPTING THE ENGAGEMENT AND PLANNING THE AUDIT Fall 2007 u Client Acceptance and Retention u Planning the Audit u Obtaining an Understanding.
DFA and Securitization Presentation to the Casualty Actuarial Society July 13, 1998.
Company Enterprise Risk Management & Stress Testing Case Study.
1 Developing a Culture of Financial Discipline Issues and Challenges for Integration of Risk and Return Commentary and Audience Survey Russ BinghamCAS.
RISK MANAGEMENT FOR INSURERS IN ISRAEL A Regulatory Perspective.
CORPORATE RISK MANAGEMENT & INSURANCE BY R P BLAH D.G.M. INCHARGE THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED REGIONAL OFFICE BHUBANESWAR.
Zsuzsanna Fluck Broad MBA Business Plan Competition Preparatory Workshop What makes a business plan successful to raise venture capital funding?
A Framework for Financial Statement Analysis Chapter 11.
Lloyd’s Strategy January © Lloyd’s2 Lloyd’s vision Key Characteristics A subscription market backed by mutual security A broker market;
Enterprise Risk Management: Benefit or Fad? CAS: Risk and Capital Management Seminar July 29, 2003 Washington, D.C Claus S. Metzner, FSA, FCAS, MAAA, Aktuar-SAV.
The Challenge of Shadow Banking Marcus Stanley Policy Director Americans for Financial Reform.
Sapient Insurance Partners. Overview & Services We have almost four decades of combined experience in the property & casualty insurance and reinsurance.
Half Year Results Presentation to Media David Murray 12 February
Permission to reprint or distribute any content from this presentation requires the prior written approval of Standard & Poor’s. Copyright (c) 2006 Standard.
1 RCM-1 Broadening and Evolving the Ratemaking Role in Insurance Company Management Russ BinghamRatemaking Seminar Vice President Actuarial Research Atlanta,
Function of Financial Management and Financial Accounting in the Health and Fitness Sector.
Information Disclosure Strategy B. Lev (1992) Presented by: Ken Chong Robyn Fulkerson Allison Taylor Terry Woods.
Solvency Regulation in Iceland – Future Environment credit market securities market pension- market insurance market Willis Re’s Nordic Seminar 20th June.
MBAD/F 619: Risk Analysis and Financial Modeling Instructor: Linda Leon Fall 2014
Shaping a Constructive Regulatory Environment Musings from a Credit Rating Agency Roger Sellek Managing Director, Global Financial Services IIS 46 th Annual.
Chapter 1 Assurance Services. Need for Assurance Why do you need assurance? Potential bias in providing information. Remoteness between a user and the.
Enterprise Risk Management at Nationwide Emily Gilde Session: Implementing DFA 2003 CAS Risk and Capital Management Seminar.
Individual Capital Assessments – so what? Mohammad Khan The 3 rd Younger Members Convention November 2004, The Chesford Grange Hotel, Kenilworth.
1602: Current Trends in Risk Management for Life Insurance Companies LOOKING BACK…focused on the future.
1 Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar September 14, 1999 Presented by: Susan E. Witcraft Milliman & Robertson, Inc. DYNAMIC FINANCIAL ANALYSIS What Does It Look.
The Impact of Reinsurance on Primary Company Financials A Case Study Casualty Actuarial Society Loss Reserve Seminar Washington, D.C. September 18 – 19,
Presented at: 1998 DFA Seminar July 13-14, 1998 Presented at: 1998 DFA Seminar July 13-14, 1998 lmn Dynamic Financial Analysis: Objectives & Design Gerald.
+ OTC Derivative Clearing Summary Making Great Ideas Become Reality”
DFA and Reinsurance Structuring Presented by Joseph W. Wallen, FCAS General Re Capital Consultants CAS Ratemaking Seminar March 9-10, 2000 General Reinsurance.
STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND TECHNIQUES.
Managing the UW Cycle CARe Hamilton Bermuda June 2005 John Doucette.
1 Economic Benefits of Integrated Risk Products Lawrence A. Berger Swiss Re New Markets CAS Financial Risk Management Seminar Denver, CO, April 12, 1999.
Chapter 1 Accounting Information and Managerial Decisions.
© 2007 Towers Perrin Market update – ERM in Insurance CAMAR November 29, 2007 March 5, 2007 Michael J. Belfatti, FCAS, MAAA Philadelphia Location Manager.
Permission to reprint or distribute any content from this presentation requires the prior written approval of Standard & Poor’s. Copyright (c) 2006 Standard.
RISK MEASUREMENT AND CAPITAL MANAGEMENT SEMINAR 1 European Perspective on DFA Casualty Actuarial Society Risk and Capital Management Seminar Washington,
1 ERM - Post 9/11 Presented by: Susan Witcraft Guy Carpenter July 8, 2002.
31 st Annual GIRO Convention October 2004 Hotel Europe Killarney, Ireland Stress Testing and Scenario Analysis – Risk Assessment and Quantification.
Evaluation of Fundamental Tax Reform Proposals President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform Leslie B. Samuels Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP.
Jim Rozsypal Partner Risk Management Practice - Ernst & Young ERM Symposium focus | support | accelerate t.
Solvency II Andrew Mawdsley. Overview The challenges in preparing for Solvency II Adequate financial resources Supervisory Review Process Disclosure Timeline.
Governance for SMEs Nigeria
1 The Value Proposition of DFA Presented by: Susan Witcraft Manuel Almagro June 7, 2001.
Moody’s Perspective on Enterprise Risk Management Ted Collins - Moody’s Investors Service CAS/SOA ERM Symposium Washington, D.C., July 29, 2003.
0 CHAPTER 2 The Roles of Managerial Accounting Information © 2009 Cengage Learning.
1 RCM 2: Risk and Return Analysis (in Ratemaking and Elsewhere) Russ BinghamRatemaking Seminar Vice President Actuarial ResearchSalt Lake City, Utah Hartford.
Dolly Dhamodiwala CEO, Business Beacon Management Consultants
Capital Modeling for Benefit Pools: A Case Study How Much is Enough (for us)?
Ratio Analysis…. Types of ratios…  Performance Ratios: Return on capital employed. (Income Statement and Balance Sheet) Gross profit margin (Income Statement)
2005 Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar Loss Reserve Analysis and Statements of Actuarial Opinion Robert E. Farnam Senior Financial Analyst and Actuary A.M.
Industry Reserve Adequacy - Beyond The Statement of Opinion 2000 Casualty Loss Reserve Seminar Minneapolis, MN.
Property/Casualty Insurance
Successfully Leading Change
Capital Management using DFA
Black Rock- A sense of Purpose
Governance and Audit Oversight for Capital Market
Overview of Financial Statement Analysis
Presentation transcript:

The Unfulfilled Promise of DFA for P&C Insurance Companies 2001 DFA Seminar Bill Wilt, VP/Sr. Analyst Property & Casualty/Reinsurance Moody's Investors Service June 7 & 8, 2001

Moody's Investors Service The Unfulfilled Promise of DFA Discussion Points n The Case for DFA in P&C Capital Management n The Reality of DFA Use Among P&C Insurers n Barriers to Wider Adoption of DFA in P&C n Role of DFA in Rating Process

Moody's Investors Service The Case for DFA n Conclusion –Holds ‘great promise’ for insurers’ efforts to optimize use of capital –Although slow to evolve - optimism is warranted n Impetus for DFA –Among several…shareholder pressures

Moody's Investors Service The Case for DFA n Benefits of DFA –Among several….balance competing demands of security (PH), return/risk (shareholder) and mix of two (creditors n Challenges Related to DFA Modeling –Sophistication Vs. ease of use –Event Risk... “yeah, but what about…”

Moody's Investors Service The Reality of DFA Use n Use Among Specialty Mono-lines n A Growing Commitment to Study n Internal Development Yet to Translate into Broad Usage n Less Sophisticated Capital Management Approaches Still Hold Sway

Moody's Investors Service Barriers to Wider Adoption in P&C n Challenges Inherent in Building Models –Modest ambitions, evolve into complex models n Model Complexity Can Erode Confidence in Output n Significance of Underwriting Discipline to P&C –Competing resources, detractions from Job One n Precedence of Other Business Constraints –Regulatory, industry norms, rating agencies...

Moody's Investors Service Role of DFA in Moody’s Analytical Process n By all means…let’s discuss it –“…thoughtful, sophisticated and rigorous analysis on the part of business managers is always a good thing.” n Use of Models integral in ratings of –Monoline Cat reinsurers; Financial Guarantors; Finite Risk and Credit Insurers

Moody's Investors Service Role of DFA in Moody’s Analytical Process n Observations…Rating Process and DFA –Rating Process: »Industry Assessment »Company evaluation: n Where is the company today…look through financial statements n Where is the company going…quality of management, risk management process, risk appetite, etc. –DFA »Attempts to marry these concepts…this is a tall order

Moody's Investors Service Role of DFA in Moody’s Analytical Process n An Alternative… in the interim –Separate Past from Future »Consider use of existing tools to perform probability of ruin analysis on company »Separately…discuss proforma results, ranges of earnings estimates, capital consumption –Benefits »Immediate use of existing tools »Elevate familiarity with company tools and assumptions »Avoid being ‘bogged down’ in go-forward assumptions

Moody's Investors Service Role of DFA in Moody’s Analytical Process n Some Specifics –Discussion of process in creating model –Focus on Prob.(Default) and E(Severity Default) –Focus on assumptions, analysis of adverse outcomes –Discuss how used internally, has it had a meaningful impact on company’s business decisions or strategic plans? –Be prepared to discuss annually -- whether results are favorable or unfavorable