Barriers to Quality End of Life Care in the ICU – Results of a Multicenter Survey Todd Sarge MD 1 ; Sharon O’Donoghue RN MS CNS 1 ; Lynn Mackinson RN MS.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

End of Life Care Education

Advertisements

Advanced Illness Management Sutter Health Lois Cross RN BSN ACM Sutter Health

Quality Measures in End-of-Life Care DPH Office of Health Planning and Ad Hoc End-of-Life Care Workgroup Presentation to SQAC June 16, 2014.

Becoming Conversation Ready

Copyright 2014 Center to Advance Palliative Care. Reproduction by permission only. Palliative care is specialized care for people with serious illness.

PMTCT FAILURE: THE ROLE OF MATERNAL AND FACILITY –RELATED FACTORS ICASA Presentation 8 th to 12 th Dec 2013 Onono Maricianah 1, Elizabeth A. Bukusi 1,

 Residents report using different modes of communication with LEP patients depending on the clinical encounter.  Variation in professional interpreter.

The Standards of Practice for a Tobacco Treatment Specialist (TTS) Gaylene Mooney, M.Ed., RRT-NPS, CTTS Program Director, Respiratory Therapy San Joaquin.

A controlled trial was conducted in the medical ICU of an 820-bed, tertiary care, academic medical center. Phase 1 (P1) was a 3-month period of standard.

Ensuring Excellence in End-of-Life/Palliative Care Rochester Health Care Forum Report to the Community 11/29/01 Patricia A. Bomba M.D. Excellus Medical.

Christina Roberts, Faisal Yayah, Randy Sell, ScD and Shonta Collins, RN, BSN, MPA, MSN-FNPc Explorers Sans Frontieres Acknowledgements The West Philadelphia.

Clinical Science Investigator’s Toolkit: An Evidence Based Practice Resource for the Bedside Nurse Beth Lacoste RN, APRN, CNS, MSN, CCRN Nicole Jones RN-BC,

Challenges in Conducting Multi-Center Clinical Studies: Results from the Rapid Empiric Treatment with Oseltamivir Study (RETOS) Kendra Thompson, Kelly.

MyICU: An Electronic Patient Engagement Portal for ICU Patients and Families Sigall Bell, MD; Tricia Bourie, RN, MS; Samuel Brown, MD*; Sylvain Bruni**;

Engaging the Stakeholders: Views of Clinical Healthcare Providers Cynthia S. Kelly, MD John Meurer, MD, MBA Marielena Lara, MD, MPH Elisa Nicholas, MD,

Centers of Excellence Monterey Bay Public Employees Trust Centers of Excellence 2014 Centers of Excellence are selected after careful review by.

STD Testing Protocols, STD Testing, and Discussion of Sexual Behaviors in HIV Clinics in Los Angeles County Melanie M. Taylor MD, MPH Los Angeles County.

Palliative Care Consultation Team An Introduction Basics of Pain Management

NAC Board Leadership Preparation Prepared by Linda Kay Walline Ph.D. RN.

TRANSITIONAL CARE NURSING JASON MARCHI, RN, BSN CAROLYN FENN, MS, LSW April 23, 2012 Maristhill Nursing & Rehabilitation Center.

Patient- and Family-Centered Care — What is it? Patient- and family- centered care is working with, rather than doing to or for.

Evaluating A Patient-Centered Medical Home from the Patient’s Perspective Betty M. Kennedy, PhD Community Outreach Specialist Community Outreach Specialist.

Program Development for ICU Palliative Care Sean Omahony MB BCh BAO, MS Rush University Medical Center.

Transitional care management (TCM): A team approach to facilitating transitions of care in a Gerontology Clinic Carol O’Leary, Jeffrey Kochka, Virginia.

Partnering with Patients and Families in the PICU and Pediatric Emergency Department Liz DuBois MS, RN NE,BC, Tuesday Cirillo RN, MA, APN, Patricia Cupka.

The NIDCR funded Collaborating Research Centers to Reduce Oral Health Disparities (CRCROHD) represent an innovative approach to understanding determinants.

Excellent Transitions: Reducing Readmissions Lana McKinney RN, Continuity of Care Service Director Mark Taylor MD, Hospital-Based Services Kaiser Permanente.

Provider knowledge of California confidentiality laws: Associations with self-confidence and training Kapphahn C, MD, MPH 1, Rao S, MS, MPH 2, Jesser C,

®® Practice based research networks (PBRN) have developed rapidly in the US in response to the pressing needs for research in routine clinical care. 1.

The Emergency Severity Index (ESI), A Triage System: Research and Implementation AHRQ Annual Meeting 2008 Paula Tanabe, PhD, MPH, RN Northwestern University,

Reduced resident work hours in the SICU: The nurses’ perspective Zara Cooper, MD, MSc Ian Shempp, BS Selwyn O. Rogers, MD,MPH Department of Surgery Brigham.

Nurs 324 Evidence based practice group presentation

Differences in the Quality of the Patient- Physician Relationship Among Terminally Ill African American and White Patients: Impact on Advance Care Planning.

Painting a portrait of utilization: Medicare and nurse managed health centers American Public Health Association 140 th Annual Meeting San Francisco, CA.

Charlene Harrington PhD, Terence Ng MA Department of Social & Behavioral Sciences University of California, San Francisco 3333 California Street, Suite.

2007 Safety Rules AS REAL AS IT GETS Mike Daly BSN, Nurse Manager Diane Vacarro MS, CNS Florence Toy PharmD Arnold Dignadice RN Mylene Espiritu RN Daisy.

The Patient-Centered Medical Home: A Work in Progress Alliance for Health Reform Briefing Washington D.C. September 22, 2008 Diane R. Rittenhouse, MD,

+ End-of-Life Care in the ICU: The Impact of Nursing Care on the Spiritual and Religious Needs of Patients and Families.

Using web-based quality data to choose a primary care physician: which information do patients rely on most? Gary Fanjiang, Ted von Glahn, Hong Chang,

Pediatric Quality Management Unit. Hospitals and other healthcare organization across the globe have been progressively implementing total quality management.

Communicating the value of the work and the role of caregiver is essential. A caring team works together to promote harmony and healing among themselves.

SOURCE: The Kaiser Family Foundation/Commonwealth Fund 2015 National Survey of Primary Care Providers (conducted January 5 – March 30, 2015) Primary Care.

Challenges using Safety Monitoring Systems A review of Integrating Incident Data from Five Reporting Systems to Assess Patient Safety: Making Sense of.

Results Providers (n=20) were more willing to share patient data when: Sharing with universities vs. private firms and non-government organizations No.

You or your loved one have been in the hospital and it’s time to go home. A hospital stay can be a stressful time. While you’re probably happy to be heading.

Inputs Outputs Outcomes ActivitiesParticipantsShort TermIntermediateLong Term Georgia Hospital Association Disseminate information on best practices in.

M. Kay M. Judge, EdD, RN Marjorie J. Wells, PhD, ARNP.

Role of Palliative Care Clinical Nurse Specialist Sheila McConville Community Specialist Palliative Care Nurse Southern Health and Social Care Trust.

The Challenge of Practice Variations And the Future of Primary Care 2009 Blanchard Memorial Lecture John E. Wennberg May 1, 2009.

Conversation Stopper: What’s Preventing Physicians from Talking With Their Patients About End-of-Life and Advance Care Planning Media Webinar – April 14,

Overview of Palliative Care Suzann Bonzo, MD. The Greatest Barrier  The greatest barrier to end of life care is Clinicians  Due to the lack of confidence.

Textbook of Palliative Care Communication Section VIII: Opportunities for the Future.

Emergency Physician Attitudes and Knowledge of ACEP’s Choosing Wisely Recommendations Thomas Nguyen, MD 1, Lynne D. Richardson, MD 2, Jeremiah D. Schuur,

Ready, Set, Goal! Sruthi Veeravalli, MSW Social Work Clinician February 27, 2015.

Background The occurrence of bedside teaching rounds has declined over the decades, with various barriers. One barrier sited is patient discomfort with.

Academic Nursing’s Commitment to Ensuring Quality Palliative Care Deborah E. Trautman, PhD, RN, FAAN President and Chief Executive Officer American Association.

4. Acceptable Case Load Safe patient care is possible only if there are well rested providers responsible for a reasonable number of women in labor. No.

John A Stoukides MD ScD Regional Chief Medical Officer CharterCare Provider Group RI Chief, Division of Geriatrics and Palliative Medicine Roger Williams.

Dana Farber/Harvard Cancer Center Breast Cancer Advocate Group

Kathleen Brady, MD; Coleman Terrell; Marlene Matosky, MPH, RN

Better Together Dashboard Template Name of Hospital Date

Palliative Care Question Prompt Sheet

Tamara L. Sims, MA1, Jeanne L. Tsai, PhD1 and Mary K

A qualitative assessment of factors impacting adoption and implementation of USPSTF age-based hepatitis C virus screening recommendations Amy B. Jessop,

SAMPLE – Preliminary Results

TITLE Authors We appreciate the support of the:

CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU

Mayo Clinic Children’s Center, Rochester MN

National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization’s Palliative Care Resource Series Understanding the Importance of the Interdisciplinary Team in Pediatric.

Presentation transcript:

Barriers to Quality End of Life Care in the ICU – Results of a Multicenter Survey Todd Sarge MD 1 ; Sharon O’Donoghue RN MS CNS 1 ; Lynn Mackinson RN MS 1 ; Ariel Mueller MA 1 ; Priscilla Gazarian RN PhD 2 ; Lisa Lehmann MD PhD 2 ; Kathleen Turner RN 3 ; Wendy Anderson MD MS 3 ; Sarah Beesley MD 4 ; Samuel Brown MD MS 4 1 Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston MA; 2 Brigham & Women’s Hospital, Boston MA; 3 University of California, San Francisco CA; 4 Intermountain Medical Center, Murray UT BACKGROUND  In the US, approximately 20% of patients die during or shortly after an ICU stay.  End of Life (EOL) care practices can vary widely between hospitals and may often be inconsistent with patient preferences, values or goals.  Our goal was to survey ICU health care workers (HCWs) to determine the education, knowledge and perceived barriers to providing high-quality EOL care. RESULTS METHODS  We conducted a multicenter survey of ICU HCWs at 4 academic medical centers across the US (Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Brigham and Women's Hospital, University of California San Francisco, Intermountain Medical Center).  All physicians, nurses, respiratory therapists and social workers working in any of the participating ICU's during a two-week study period were eligible and invited to participate in the study.  A total of 440 HCWs responded (62% nurses, 24% physicians, 11% respiratory therapists and 3% social workers).

RESULTS Cont’d All Barriers Surveyed Barriers to Quality End of Life Care in the ICU – Results of a Multicenter Survey Todd Sarge MD 1 ; Sharon O’Donoghue RN MS CNS 1 ; Lynn Mackinson RN MS 1 ; Ariel Mueller MA 1 ; Priscilla Gazarian RN PhD 2 ; Lisa Lehmann MD PhD 2 ; Kathleen Turner RN 3 ; Wendy Anderson MD MS 3 ; Sarah Beesley MD 4 ; Samuel Brown MD MS 4 1 Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston MA; 2 Brigham & Women’s Hospital, Boston MA; 3 University of California, San Francisco CA; 4 Intermountain Medical Center, Murray UT  Overall, 35% of respondents reported receiving EOL education; however, this varied widely among centers ranging from 22% to 68%.  The majority of HCWs (57%) were unaware EOL guidelines existed at their institution. 1 EOL Education RESULTS Cont’d  HCW perceptions of barriers to providing high quality EOL care were predominantly centered around the clinician - patient/family interactions rather than symptom management. CLICK TO ENLARGE FIGURE CLICK TO ENLARGE FIGURE CLICK TO ENLARGE FIGURE

RESULTS Cont’d Barriers to Quality End of Life Care in the ICU – Results of a Multicenter Survey Todd Sarge MD 1 ; Sharon O’Donoghue RN MS CNS 1 ; Lynn Mackinson RN MS 1 ; Ariel Mueller MA 1 ; Priscilla Gazarian RN PhD 2 ; Lisa Lehmann MD PhD 2 ; Kathleen Turner RN 3 ; Wendy Anderson MD MS 3 ; Sarah Beesley MD 4 ; Samuel Brown MD MS 4 1 Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston MA; 2 Brigham & Women’s Hospital, Boston MA; 3 University of California, San Francisco CA; 4 Intermountain Medical Center, Murray UT  There is an ongoing need for quality improvement and education around EOL care in the ICU setting.  Future work should focus on improving and ensuring early clinician - patient/family discussions on goals of care, improving education for ICU HCWs on quality EOL care with specific emphasis on institution specific guidelines, and developing quality assurance metrics to track adherence to guidelines as well as patient/family satisfaction. CONCLUSIONS NEXT STEPS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Highest Rated Barriers This study was supported by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation. Statistical support was provided by the Center for Anesthesia Research Excellence (CARE) at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center.  Design and Test a comprehensive Bundle for EOL Care  Focus on patients not process  Humanize dying  Bring education to the bedside  Getting ourselves “conversation ready” in the ICU  Learn from success (UCSF)  Measure what we do  Incorporate EOL care into QI measures  The highest rated barriers identified included: 1) Differing expectations or understanding of prognosis between the patient's family and clinicians; 2) Differing expectation or understanding of the prognosis among family members; 3) The patient's wishes or values are unknown or not documented; 4) Under-utilization of palliative care services. CLICK TO ENLARGE FIGURE

EOL Education and Awareness

All Barriers Surveyed

Highest Rated Barriers