Lt-col Esmeralda Kleinreesink MSc Disillusionment in Afghanistan Content-analysis als methode

Ministry of Defence 2 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Agenda Officier in Afghanistan Mediabeleid Proefschrift Scoping & collecting Kwalitatief vs kwantitatief Software ondersteuning Eerste resultaten

Ministry of Defence 3 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Officier in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 4 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Officier in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 5 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Officier in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 6 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Officier in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 7 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Officier in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 8 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Agenda Officier in Afghanistan Mediabeleid Proefschrift Scoping Kwalitatief vs kwantitatief Software ondersteuning Eerste resultaten

Ministry of Defence 9 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Mediabeleid …Het is daarom van belang om open, helder en uitgebreid te (laten) vertellen en te laten zien op welke wijze onze militairen hun opdrachten in Afghanistan uitvoeren. Hierbij gaat het steeds om het schetsen van een realistisch beeld. Het is immers essentieel dat de perceptie van de Nederlandse samenleving niet afwijkt van de realiteit […] Een goed geïnformeerde samenleving, waarin een waarheidsgetrouw beeld van de missie aanwezig is, zal zich grotendeels bewust zijn van de aanwezige risico’s. MvD (2006) Communicatieplan Uruzgan

Ministry of Defence 10 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Mediabeleid

Ministry of Defence 11 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Mediabeleid

Ministry of Defence 12 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Mediabeleid

Ministry of Defence 13 Disillusionment in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 14 Disillusionment in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 15 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Fictie vs non-fictie

Ministry of Defence 16 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Waarheidsgaranties

Ministry of Defence 17 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Agenda Officier in Afghanistan Mediabeleid Proefschrift Scoping Kwalitatief vs kwantitatief Software ondersteuning Eerste resultaten

Ministry of Defence 18 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Proefschrift Photo:

Ministry of Defence 19 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Scoping

Ministry of Defence 20 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Afbakening tijd ( ) Time periodMissionBooks WWII14 Dutch East Indies Korea1 New Guinea Libanon4 the Balkans Iraq2 Afghanistan4 Total71 Bron: Checkpoint

Ministry of Defence 21 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Scope: languages

Ministry of Defence 22 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Scoping: autobiography Self publication Edited publication Ghost written Written by other autobiographical biographical

Ministry of Defence 23 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Scoping: autobiography

Ministry of Defence 24 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Scoping: Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 25 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Scoping Who are these soldiers who write autobiographical books about their recent deployment experiences in Afghanistan, what do they write about, and why do they write?

Ministry of Defence 26 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Collecting

Ministry of Defence 27 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Collecting Country# Books The Netherlands7 Germany7 United States22 United Kingdom15 Canada3 Total54

Ministry of Defence 28 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Collecting

Ministry of Defence 29 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Kwalitatief vs Kwantitatief

Ministry of Defence 30 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Kwantitatief: Who & Why

Ministry of Defence 31 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Kwalitatief: What

Ministry of Defence 32 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Grounded theory

Ministry of Defence 33 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Kwalitatief: What Based on: Friedman (1955) Forms of the Plot, p

Ministry of Defence 34 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Friedman

Ministry of Defence 35 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Friedman Gebaseerd op: Friedman (1955) Forms of the Plot, p

Ministry of Defence 36 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Veldonderzoek: Why

Ministry of Defence 37 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Software: SPSS

Ministry of Defence 38 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Software: Atlas

Ministry of Defence 39 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Andere software

Ministry of Defence 40 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Who: profession (kinetic)

Ministry of Defence 41 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Who: professionals vs reserves

Ministry of Defence 42 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Who: still working for MoD?

Ministry of Defence 43 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Research question Do military-authors from different countries write different plots?

Ministry of Defence 44 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Results Significant (p=0,039)

Ministry of Defence 45 Disillusionment in Afghanistan The Netherlands

Ministry of Defence 46 Disillusionment in Afghanistan

Ministry of Defence 47 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Results: Reservist? Not significant (p =0,885)

Ministry of Defence 48 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Results: (non) kinetic? Significant (p=0,026)

Ministry of Defence 49 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Results: Still working for MoD? Significant (p= 0,005)

Ministry of Defence 50 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Germany

Ministry of Defence 51 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Germany

Ministry of Defence 52 Disillusionment in Afghanistan United Kingdom

Ministry of Defence 53 Disillusionment in Afghanistan United Kingdom

Ministry of Defence 54 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Result: gentlemen analysis? Not significant (p= 0,626)

Ministry of Defence 55 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Results: Ghost? Significant (p= 0,026)

Ministry of Defence 56 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Result: Ghost writer influence? Significant (p= 0,028)

Ministry of Defence 57 Disillusionment in Afghanistan Conclusion Do military-authors from different countries write different plots? YES

Ministry of Defence 58 Disillusionment in Afghanistan