METHODS She Said, He Said - Resident Perceptions of Gender and Leadership in Acute Resuscitations: A Qualitative Analysis Jasmine S. Mathews 1, Alan H.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University ®
Advertisements

SIDS Mid-Atlantic Peer Contact Training. SIDS Peer Contacts Responsibilities of Peer Contacts Responsibilities of Peer Contacts Procedures for Peer Contacts.
"What I really needed was the truth" Exploring the information needs of people with CRPS. Sharon Grieve 1,2, Jo Adams 2, Candida McCabe 1,3. 1 Royal National.
Communicating Effectively
Qualitative research methods in psychology (Case studies and Interviews only) Javana Hardman.
Developing Best Practice in Ascertaining LMP in Adolescent Patients Ami Cook Dr Christine Ferris.
Research Methods in Psychology (Pp 45-59). Observations Can be used in both experimental and nonexperimental research; can be used quantitatively or qualitatively.
A Survey on Handoff Communication Between Paramedics and Physicians During the Care of Critically-ill Patients Will Enochs 1, Emily Hillman 1,2, Steve.
Leadership, Gender and Stereotypical Concordance during Trauma Patient Resuscitation SUMR Scholars: Brittany Harris and Brittany Milliner Mentor: Maureen.
Our Group Plan for a Qualitative Research Study by John W. Creswell, Ph.D. and Vicki L. Plano Clark, M.S. University of Nebraska-Lincoln
Rehabilitative care approach in a specialist palliative day care centre: a study of patient’s perspectives Author: C.A. Belchamber October 2003.
Dynamics of Communicating Climate Change Information Hebba Haddad Centre for Sport, Leisure and Tourism, Capacity Building Centre Showcase event 8 th June.
Copyright © 2015 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved
“Female Leadership for a sustainable European Management Model (EMM)” Literature study.
 Department of Family and Children Services, Santa Clara County  San Jose State University School of Social Work  Santa Clara County Children’s Issue.
Teacher and Leadership Preparation in Non-Formal Educational Settings: The experience of the Bangladesh Rural Association Committee (BRAC) in Bangladesh.
Teacher-Student Relationships: A Study of Teachers’ Perceptions of Their Roles and Responsibilities and Their Relational Management Practices Elizabeth.
Conflict Resolution.
A pilot study into the experiences of counsellors in training A traditional dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree.
Clinical Leadership Skills Acquisition in Nurse Residents
Warm-Up List as many ways that you can think of that people communicate with each other. Circle the three that you do most. Think back 5 years. Were these.
Cardiopulmonary resuscitation frequently marks end of life. Less than 17% of successful resuscitations survive to discharge. Current healthcare practice.
COMMUNITY Needs Assessment Overview
Dr. Susan M. Lawlor Engaging service users 10 TH June 2009, Cork.
Family & Professional Networks in Disability Policy: A Qualitative Inquiry.
ADOLESCENTS’ PERCEPTIONS OF THEIR RELATIONSHIP TO A SIBLING WITH CHRONIC PAIN Ayala Y. Gorodzinsky 1, Susan T. Heinze 1, Jessica M. Joseph 1, Gustavo R.
Cleveland Clinic Science Internship Program for Nursing How do Families of Surgical Patients Perceive Communication of their Family Members’ Surgical Status?
Outcome Measures of Triple Board Graduates: Marla J. Warren, MD,MPH; David W. Dunn, MD; Jerry L. Rushton, MD,MPH. Section of Child Psychiatry.
P UTTING T HE F IVE P RACTICES OF E XEMPLARY L EADERSHIP I NTO P RACTICE.
AN INTRODUCTION Managing Change in Healthcare IT Implementations Sherrilynne Fuller, Center for Public Health Informatics School of Public Health, University.
CUMG.NET \ nouvelle version \ Journal Club Journal Club cumg UCL 24th June 2005 Valérie Dory Jean-Marc Feron.
Qualitative Research Paper 3. Qualitative Research: Theory & Practice.
Process Intervention Skills
Lesson 2 People use many different ways to communicate their feelings. Writing a note Facial expressions Communication is critical to healthy relationships.
People use many different ways to communicate their feelings. Writing a note Facial expressions Communication is critical to healthy relationships. Communicating.
By: Dalila Ochoa Mary S Garcia
How a Persons Disability Can Affect Access to Healthcare Deserae Ishoy Sophia Ortiz Steven Bleak Thanh Nguyen Vanessa Villegas Sonu Gurung.
Communication and Social Styles
Program Evaluation for Nonprofit Professionals Unit 4: Analysis, Reporting and Use.
Chapter 8: Constructing Understanding of Change Intervention Mushrooms 1.
Social Influences on Gender INTRODUCTION:. Two types of socializing ‘forces’ Informal socializing agents People in which close contact occurs:- Parents.
Youth Leadership SummitYouth Leadership Summit Ice Breaker: Networking CircleIce Breaker: Networking Circle.
The Psychological Effect of Exposure to Gang Violence on Youths: A Pilot Study The Psychological Effect of Exposure to Gang Violence on Youths: A Pilot.
Template produced at the Graphics Support Workshop, Media Centre Background There is no evidence to suggest that people with dementia experience any less.
Abstract References Methods Introduction Results Conclusions Figures/Graphs Click headings to further view content Click Here to insert brief content.
10.2 Human Relationships Ms. Binns.  Discuss considerations involved before, during and after an interview (sample, method, data record etc)  Explain.
Background The occurrence of bedside teaching rounds has declined over the decades, with various barriers. One barrier sited is patient discomfort with.
WORLD-CHANGING LEADERSHIP CHRISTIAN SINCLAIR, MD, FAAHPM.
Career success of women managers in the Thailand petroleum industry Dr. Ubonwan Rawd-iam 15 th April 2009.
Myanna Duncan Doctoral Researcher Work & Health Research Centre Loughborough University.
Midterm Report Presenter: Eunice Lai Instructor: Patricia Su Date: 19 th April, 2012.
Introduction Is there a difference between what residents believe best facilitates their learning and how preceptors teach and believe residents want to.
‘Find a sport and carry on’: Posttraumatic growth and achievement in British Paralympic athletes Hanna Kampman (MSc.) & Dr. Kate Hefferon (PhD.) Method.
Introduction Methods Objectives Results Conclusions Figures/Graphs Implementation of clinical innovations are often evaluated at the operational and patient.
OBJECTIVE INTRODUCTION Emergency Medicine Milestones: Longitudinal Interrater Agreement EM milestones were developed by EM experts for the Accreditation.
School of Medicine Department of Family Medicine The Path to Leadership Among Community Health Center Medical Directors: Implications for Medical Training.
“We can take care of that for you here”: Providers’ perspectives on discussing available abortion services Alyce Sutko MD MPH, Megan Hatcher-Lee MS3, Carie.
Trusting Telework in the Federal Government
Between the Flags (BTF) program introduction and resultant changes in nurses’ workplace culture Ms Cathy Maginnis Mrs Maryanne Podham Dr Judith Anderson.
The Charge Nurse Role in Today’s Environment
IENG 451 / 452 Voice of the Customer: Analysis (KANO, CTQ)
HISTORY TAKING BSNE I. The purpose of medical practice is to relieve patient suffering. In order to achieve this, one must make a diagnosis to guide therapeutic.
Michael Jong, MD1, Bryan G. Kane, MD1,3, Nicole C
CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU
CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU
Communicating About Clinical Trials
CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU
What are risk-scoring tools?
Nesma El Melligi Dr. Dina Rateb MOIS 433
Presentation transcript:

METHODS She Said, He Said - Resident Perceptions of Gender and Leadership in Acute Resuscitations: A Qualitative Analysis Jasmine S. Mathews 1, Alan H. Breaud 1, Patricia M. Mitchell 1,2, Michael Dempsey 1, Douglas Kauffman 2, Jeffrey I. Schneider 1,2, Kerry M. McCabe 1,2, Brian Clyne 3, Jessica L. Smith 3, Rebecca Barron 3, Tracey Dechert 1,2, Leslie E. Halpern 1, Judith A. Linden 1,2. 1 Boston Medical Center, Boston, MA; 2 Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA; 3 Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI LEADERS- LEADership in Emergency ResuscitationS This IRB approved, exploratory qualitative study was conducted from April to June 2015 at 2 Level I trauma centers where EM residents lead medical/surgical resuscitations Inclusion Criteria: PGY 2-4 EM residents Interview guide pilot tested A trained qualitative interviewer conducted anonymous, in depth, semi-structured interviews with open ended questions until theme saturation reached Data Analysis: Interviews were audiotaped, transcribed, de-identified, coded, and analyzed using MAXQDA v12 software Resident physician, nurse, and non-clinical research assistant met as a group to code all segments and reached agreement in coding 16 EM residents participated: 6 female, 10 male, (6 PGY2, 6 PGY3, 4 PGY4) 100% of females reported gender impacted nursing relationships and team dynamics compared to 60% of males 83% of females reported the need to gain trust and respect of nurses to effectively lead resuscitations versus 10% of males Directive and commanding behavior in females was often perceived as overly assertive, which was more likely to be accepted as a leadership quality in males 83% of females and 80% of males felt that females faced an uphill battle being accepted as effective resuscitations leaders EM residents who lead resuscitations perceived gender as having a major effect on team dynamics Several themes regarding barriers to effective leadership were perceived as disproportionally affecting females Findings suggest gender related differences may impact team leadership dynamics Our results suggest the impact of gender on team leadership may need to be addressed in EM training and education Effective communication and team dynamics are critical to successfully led ED resuscitations Literature suggests that gender influences leadership style and how leaders are perceived To explore EM residents’ perceptions of gender and its impact on leadership and resuscitation team dynamics OBJECTIVE LIMITATIONS INTRODUCTION CONCLUSIONS RESULTS Inability to further validate residents’ perceptions on resuscitation experience Researcher presence may influence resident reporting Researcher biases may impact result gathering and interpretation Results may not be generalizable Figure 1. Frequency of Themes by Resident Gender

Table 1. EM RESIDENT PERCEPTIONS – IN THEIR OWN WORDS Key Themes Representative Quotes Team Dynamics "I do think people can perceive it as being mean. Or, in females, it's just bitchy. It's not directive. It's bitchy." [Interviewer] So if you're directive as a female, it's bitchy? "It's bitchy." [Interviewer] If you're directive as a male, it's...? "It's just aggressive or a leader leading, or whatever it is. Not bitchy." Trust/Respect of Team "Just, I think that they have to prove themselves a little more. Like I said, you know, a big, tall male walks in the room with a loud voice...I think...people would default to respecting and listening to what they have to say first and questioning them second. But, if a woman walks in, I think you have to prove yourself over time first before you get the same respect that maybe their peers would get." Gender Inequity/Uphill Battle "I think there's a natural, and unfortunate as it is built in our system, a natural preference for male leaders in medicine, and in general. They don't have to know peoples' names and they're accepted more. The nurses don't get offended if they don't know their names. But if I don't know their names there's much more....I've worked very hard to get on the good side of those people."