Natural Law – Revision

The spec – What you need to know Main features of the theory That it is absolutist and deontological The relationship that Aquinas said existed between the four levels of law The importance Aquinas placed on human rationality How reason links to the primary and secondary precepts How Aquinas believes that humans have a final purpose The types of virtues within natural law The difference between interior/exterior acts The difference between real/apparent goods and how these relate to sin How to apply Natural Law to situations and examples How Natural Law is compatible with one major world religion Be able to evaluate these issues

Absolutism & Deontological Absolutism – Laws are the same regardless of the situation. There are universal norms. Deontological – Acts are intrinsically good – good within themselves. You don’t commit an action for the consequences. Legalism – The idea that people should obey religious laws in order to be good.

Happiness and Eudemonia Aristotle believed there was a law written in nature for humans to know how to act morally He believed following these laws would lead to Eudemonia Aquinas was influenced by this, and believed that humans lean towards the good Aquinas believed that eudemonia would be a reward in heaven for good actions on earth

Purpose Aquinas was also influenced by Aristotle’s belief that all humans have a purpose For Aquinas, this was a GOD GIVEN ideal purpose. Similarly to the parable of the talents, Aquinas believed we have God given purposes and talents For Aquinas, fulfilling our purpose will lead us to the ‘final cause’ ‘the requirements of the law are written on their hearts, their consciences also bearing witness’ – St Paul in Romans 2

Reason & Rationality Again, similarly to Aristotle, Aquinas believed that all humans possess the unique ability to REASON. This GOD GIVEN REASON helps humans identify how to act morally The use of our reason reveals to us the ultimate ‘goods’ in life. ‘The moral life is the life according to reason’ - Aquinas

The 4 Laws Natural Law is split up into 4 channels: Eternal Law: God creates everything and his will and wisdom is revealed to us through... Divine Law: the sacred text and teachings of the Church, which are made known through... Natural Law: the innate human ability to know what is naturally right. From which... Human Law: is derived eg laws found in the legal system HIGH GRADE: Gerard Hughes says in ‘the Cambridge dictionary of philosophy’ that it is through natural law in which humans are made distinct to everything else in the natural world i.e. animals

Primary and Secondary Precepts The primary precepts help us to identify our GOD GIVEN purposes in life. They identify which actions are good and are absolute. They are: To worship God To live in an ordered society To reproduce To learn To defend the innocent (to live)

Primary and Secondary Precepts Secondary precepts are laws made to uphold the primary precepts. Unlike primary precepts, they are not absolute and can change in certain situations. For example, Polygamy and Monogamy both lead to reproduction and are both secondary precepts, despite being different

Virtues Aquinas said that there is a link between happiness and virtuous behaviour Virtues represent the human qualities that reason suggests help us to live a moral life The four cardinal virtues are what Aquinas believed were necessary for the basis of a moral life. They are: Prudence, Justice, Fortitude and Justice

Virtues There are also three revealed virtues that we access, not through reason, but through Holy Scripture. These have been revealed to us in the Bible. Faith, Charity, Hope.

Interior and exterior acts As Aquinas was a deontologist, it acts were important to him, as he believed that acts are in themselves good or bad. Interior acts: The intention behind the act Exterior acts: The act that is preformed To be truly good and glorify God, BOTH the interior and exterior acts must be good. High Grade: The principle of double effect

Real and Apparent Goods Aquinas believed that humans often sin or fall short of nature He believed that they do this because they confuse real with apparent goods A real good: is a characteristic which will help people become closer to God An Apparent good: is one in which sin takes people further away from God’s will with apparent goods Examples: Apply this to homosexuality

How it is compatible with religion God made the world and a sense of order within it It should be the goal of every human being to return to God The primary precepts reflect the main purposes for humankind as outlined in religious scriptures People sometimes fall short of God’s purposes and sin (John 8) God creates all that exists, including eternal law which is revealed in Divine law. There are examples of religious rules in the Bible (Exodus 20) The motive for committing an act is important as well as the act itself (Matthew 6)

How it isn’t compatible with religion It is based on reason and not love. Jesus, however, told people to ‘Love one another as I have loved you’ (John 13) Jesus said good actions should not be done for reward but for their own sake. Some religious denominations i.e the Quakers, reject the use of absolute rules Some believers reject the existence of a universal human nature – gay believers would argue that they were created this way by God Joseph Fletcher argued that Jesus was opposed to legalism It can conflict with some moral teachings, for instance ‘turn the other cheek’ – in natural law you would break the teaching in order to preserve one’s own life

Evaluative issues Examiners are looking for quality and not quantity in AO2. They want to see you evaluate and analyse the ‘fors’ and ‘againsts’ rather than simply list a few of them. Common mistakes need to be avoided: Don’t just answer AO2 as strengths and weaknesses Don’t list – evaluate Add a conclusion