An Evolving Landscape: Addressing Access Issues in Academic and Research Publishing Today Richard Fyffe Rosenthal Librarian of the College Grinnell College.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Partnering with Faculty / researchers to Enhance Scholarly Communication Caroline Mutwiri.
Advertisements

Richard Jones The Edinburgh Research Archive The Edinburgh Research Archive: ERA Institutional Repository Theses & Dissertations Conference Papers/Posters.
DSpace: the MIT Libraries Institutional Repository MacKenzie Smith, MIT EDUCAUSE 2003, November 5 th Copyright MacKenzie Smith, This work is the.
OPEN ACCESS PUBLISHING Sally Scholfield UTS Library.
Open Access to Research in the United Kingdom Organic.Edunet Conference, Budapest Jackie Wickham Open Access Adviser Centre for Research Communications.
Electronic publishing: issues and future trends Anne Bell.
Promoting Open Digital Scholarship - A Canadian Library Perspective Leila Fernandez Rajiv Nariani Marcia Salmon York University Libraries, Canada.
OPEN ACCESS PUBLICATION ISSUES FOR NSF OPP Advisory Committee May 30, /24/111 |
Februrary 2005UCSF Library & Center for Knowledge Management Scholarly Communication.
Learn more about Open Access Breakfast meeting at BMC March 30th 2010 Aina Svensson and Karin Meyer Lundén Electronic Publishing Centre, Uppsala University.
Open Access and Scholarly Communications Tyler Walters Julie G. Speer Library Faculty Advisory Board November 20, 2009.
DAWN PASCHAL ALAN CRUMP GREG VOGL JANUARY 9, 2009 The Digital Repository Initiative at CSU: Building a Scholarly Archive.
Open Access, Open Education, Open Minds Lisa Goddard Memorial University Libraries edge 2010 October 13 th, 2010.
Protecting Your Scholarship: Copyrights, Publication Agreements, and Open Access Harvard University Office for Scholarly Communication May 11, 2009 Kenneth.
Case Studies in New Models of Collaboration: CANADA’S UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES Carole Moore Chief Librarian, University of Toronto Chief Librarian, University.
2009 Ex Libris Mid-Atlantic User Group (EMA) Meeting November 5, 2009 Elizabeth Brown Scholarly Communications Officer Binghamton University Libraries.
November 2, 2009 SFU Library Tools & Support for Open Access Publishing.
Introduction to Implementing an Institutional Repository Delivered to Technical Services Staff Dr. John Archer Library University of Regina September 21,
Greater Reach for your Research: Author’s Rights & the Shifting Landscape of Scholarly Communication Lisa Goddard & Shannon Gordon Memorial University.
Faculty Roles in the Evolving Scholarly Communications System Mark Kamlet University Provost.
What does the community of scientists “own”?  What do authors own?  What does the scholarly community own?
ⓒ UNIST LIBRARY UNIST Institutional Repository ⓒ UNIST LIBRARY
Daniela Nastasie, PhD BEng(Hons) AALIA Senior Metadata Librarian Repository and Archive Metadata Services UniSA Library Open Access Publishing and UniSA.
New Crossroads Transitions & Transformations Science Librarians in the 21st Century Mary M. Case University of Illinois at Chicago.
2 © ACADEMY OF FINLAND Open Access – Support for Research? Jyrki HakapääResearch seminar at Aleksanteri Institute Graduate School 20 Sept 2013.
Presented by Ansie van der Westhuizen Unisa Institutional Repository: Sharing knowledge to advance research
Presenter Name Hosting Institution Date OPENNESS: CONTRIBUTE, ACCESS, USE ACRL Scholarly Communications Roadshow: From Understanding to Engagement.
Developing Effective Scholarly Communication Advocates: A Case Study Pam Brannon Sara Fuchs Electronic Resources & Libraries 2008 March 19, 2008.
INFORMATION SOLUTIONS Mary L. Van Allen 21 September 2005 Open Access Journals and citation patterns International Seminar on Open Access for Developing.
Copyright Management for Scholarship Julia Blixrud, Association of Research Libraries/SPARC Rodney Petersen, EDUCAUSE John Vaughn, Association of American.
Alternative Models of Scholarly Communication: The "Toddler Years" for Open Access Journals and Institutional Repositories Greg Tananbaum President The.
Libra: Thesis and Dissertation Submission. What is Libra? UVA’s institutional repository, providing online archiving and access for the scholarly output.
Self-archiving The term usually refers to the self-archiving of peer reviewed research journal and conference articles as well as theses, deposited in.
Open Access Catherine Boden, Health Sciences Liaison Librarian David Fox, Head of Monographs Presentation to the Musculoskeletal Journal Club College of.
Sociologists for Women in Society: Open Access Publishing Panel Julie G. Speer Summer Meeting 2010 August 15, 2010.
MARCH 13, :00 PM – 4:00 PM WFU Scholarly Communications Workshop.
Open Access: The revolution in academic publishing Henry Hagedorn Editor, Journal of Insect Science Department of Entomology and Office of Scholarly Communication.
Open Access Resources: An Introduction to Public Library of Science and BioMed Central ANCHASL Spring Meeting April 1, 2005 Rick Peterson Duke University.
1 Libraries and Open Access to Scientific Information Ivana Hebrang Grgić, PhD Department of Information Science Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences.
Open Access Publishing Overview David Fox UofS Technology Week November 2, 2010
Creating Change in Scholarly Communications Heather Joseph Executive Director, SPARC September 21, 2009 TCAL, Austin, TX.
Amy Jackson UNM Technology Days July 22,  An institutional repository (IR) is a web-based database of scholarly material which is institutionally.
Publishing Trends: Open the University of Florida Presentation to IDS 3931: Discovering Research and Communicating Science October 21, 2010.
1 1 SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING & ACADEMIC RESOURCES COALITION An initiative of the Association of Research Libraries Gaining Independence through.
Scholarly Communication, Author Rights, and GT Library Services Julie G. Speer Faculty Advisory Board Meeting April 14, 2009.
Networked Information Resources SPARC, E-prints & Open Access initiatives.
1 ARRO: Anglia Ruskin Research Online Making submissions: Benefits and Process.
Smathers Libraries in Support of UF Research and Scholarship: Open Access and The Presentation to the Latin American Studies Colloquium, March 17,
2015 Julia E. Rodriguez Assistant Professor- Nursing, Health Sciences & Faculty Research Support Librarian, OU Libraries This work is.
Open Access and Universal Deposit David Fox Librarians Forum May 11, 2009.
Antti Rousi Aalto University Library
Introduction: The Scholarly Communication System Presenter: Richard Kearney VALE Scholarly Communication Workshop March 14, 2011.
Traditional Distribution Electronic Distribution User Florida Entomologist Issues Reprints FTP.
Your rights to your published work: a workshop addressing these questions: 1. “Can I post my publications in full text on… my web site my departmental.
Institutional Repositories July 2007 Intellectual property management : the DISA experience Dr D Peters DISA: Digital Innovation South Africa.
Open Access & REF202*.  Green OA  Deposit of pre-print or post-print of accepted paper for publishing within a repository.  Gold OA  Published version.
Launching the Dean digitally : the Jonathan Jansen Collection in UPSpace eIFL.net in co-operation with the Research Library Consortium Institutional repositories.
Information Accesibility for learning December 11, 2015 University Policy on Open Access to scientific literature Chiara Cenderelli University Library.
Open Access Defined An Introduction by Patti McCall.
Greater Visibility, Greater Access QSpace QSpace Queen’s University Research & Learning Repository.
Filling institutional repositories: considering copyright issues Susan Veldsman eIFL Content Manager
Institutional Repository “A university-based institutional repository is a set of services that a university offers to the members of its community for.
Open Access/ Parallel publishing at the JU What, Why, How? Marja-Leena Harjuniemi JU.
Open Access Initiatives Memorial University Libraries Lisa Goddard Scholarly Communications Librarian April 2011.
Copyright and RoMEO RSP Summer School Jane H Smith Services Development Officer, SHERPA
Library Space Design (virtual) Marilyn Billings Scholarly Communication Librarian University of Massachusetts, Amherst
UCF Libraries - Scholarly Communication Lily Flick & Sarah Norris June 9, 2016 Using SHERPA RoMEO: Finding policies for self-archiving articles.
Wanted: The Right Content and The Content Rights Putting Knowledge to Work: Building an Institutional Repository for Your Campus California Polytechnic.
Changing Scholarly Communications and the Role of an Institutional Repository in the Digital Landscape Marilyn Billings Scholarly Communications Librarian.
Presentation transcript:

An Evolving Landscape: Addressing Access Issues in Academic and Research Publishing Today Richard Fyffe Rosenthal Librarian of the College Grinnell College Marquette University 26 September 2008

Scholarly Communication The technological and institutional means by which theories, interpretations, and findings are submitted to the scrutiny of disciplinary experts and critiqued, endorsed, disseminated, synthesized, and archived on behalf of a broad community of teachers and learners (novice and advanced, lay and professional).

4 Key Trends 1.Increasing availability to a broader range of users for a broader range of purposes (“open access”)‏ 2.Blurring of boundaries between “formal” and “informal” scholarly communication 3.Increasing attention to the processes of scholarship and the enduring value of works created at different stages in the research process 4.Increasing collaboration among the traditional agents in the scholarly communication process (research centers, publishers, libraries, information technology departments)‏

Opportunities Lost? “… access to the internet and World Wide Web is ubiquitous; consequently nearly all intellectual effort results in some form of “publishing”. Yet universities do not treat the publishing function as an important, mission-centric endeavor … and the result has been a scholarly publishing industry that many in the university community find to be increasingly out of step with the important values of the academy.” Source: Laura Brown, Rebecca Griffiths, and Matthew Rascoff University Publishing in a Digital Age. Ithaka.

What Has Made These Changes Possible? Desktop authoring tools The Internet Repository and social networking technology Copyright law

What Has Motivated These Changes? Competition for research impact New disciplinary practices New social norms (e.g., taxpayer expectations)‏ Increasing prices and numbers of scholarly journals

Topography of This Evolving Landscape 1.Repository and social networking technologies 2.Legal issues: copyright 3.Open-access scholarship 4.New collaborations: libraries, IT departments, university presses

Repository Technologies and Enduring Scholarship Structured metadata Harvesting protocols Durable citations (persistent addresses)‏

Social Networking Technologies Blogs Wikis Photo-sharing sites (e.g., Flickr)‏ Video-sharing sites (e.g., You-tube)‏

Copyright 101 Authors own their work Copyright is a bundle of rights Ownership can be transferred OR specific rights can be licensed

Authors’ Rights “Scientists and scientific publishers have an opportunity to take a leading role in the creative use of licensing or copyright transfer to build a new publishing system”—AAAS, “Seizing the Moment: Scientists’ Authorship Rights,” July 2002 Source:

New Models of Copyright Management Creative Commons Licensing: Amending copyright transfer agreements:  SPARC:  Science Commons:

Open-Access Scholarship: A Coat With Many Colors Business models  Commercial and non-commercial Revenue models  “Author pays” and subsidized Access models  Pure open-access and mixtures of open-access and subscription-access content  Immediate vs. embargoed access

Open-access Content 1.Journals 2.Articles / Repositories 3.Theses and dissertations 4.Data

Open-access Journals Include peer-reviewed and editor-reviewed journals Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) registers 3,653 individual journals Source: 20 Sept. 2008

Open-Access Articles “Self-archiving”  Working papers  Manuscript as submitted  Final corrected manuscript  Article formatted as published NIH requirement (2008)‏  PubMed Central repository

Open-Access Repositories Directory of Open Access Repositories has registered over 1200 article repositories May include data, texts, images, and other ancillary materials not formally published Source: 20 September 2008

Open-Access Repositories Disciplinary:  e.g., arxiv.org: "Open access to 493,088 e- prints in Physics, Mathematics, Computer Science, Quantitative Biology and Statistics" Institutional

[SCREENSHOT OF KUScholarworks]

Publisher Policies Some form of self-archiving of papers published in conventional journals is permitted by 68% of 414 scholarly publishers surveyed:

Publisher Policies 137 publishers permit self-archiving of accepted pre-prints and PDF post-prints (“Green” publishers)‏ 97 publishers permit self-archiving of the corrected accepted manuscript but not the publisher’s PDF (“Blue” publishers)‏ 49 publishers permit self-archiving only of the pre- refereed manuscript (“Yellow” publishers)‏ Source: SHERPA (Securing a Hybrid Environment for Research Preservation and Access), University of Nottingham: (28 August 2008).

Research Impact A 2004 study of citation rates for specific journals concludes that “OA journals have a broadly similar citation pattern to other journals” “Open access” here means “unqualified open access” not including author self-archived copies. Source: “The Impact of Open Access Journals: A Citation Study from Thomson ISI” (

Research Impact A 2005 study analyzed one million articles in about 1000 journals between 1992 and 2003 and concluded: the percentage of OA articles ranges from 5% - 20% depending on discipline, specialty and year;

Research Impact In four disciplines and 28 subfields analyzed, the OA articles have a citation advantage ranging from 25% - 250%. Disciplines = Biology, Business, Psychology, Sociology Source: Hajjem, C., Gingras, Y., Brody, T., Carr, L. and Harnad, S. (2005) Open Access to Research Increases Citation Impact. Technical Report, Institut des sciences cognitives, Université du Québec à Montréal (

Open-access Theses and Dissertations Visibility for student authors Visibility for advisors and institutions National Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations (NDLTD)‏ Questions about impact on future publication

Open-access Data Open Data  NIH Requirement since 2003 for grants over $500,000.  “Recorded factual material commonly accepted in the scientific community as necessary to validate research findings.”

Open-access Data “Open-notebook science”  Often blog- or wiki-based  Questions about preservation  Example: UsefulChem:

[screenshot of open notebook]

Open-access Dissemination: Data “ … examined the citation history of 85 cancer microarray clinical trial publications with respect to the availability of their data. The 48% of trials with publicly available microarray data received 85% of the aggregate citations. Publicly available data was significantly (p = 0.006) associated with a 69% increase in citations, independently of journal impact factor, date of publication, and author country of origin using linear regression.” Source: Piwowar, H. A., Day, R. S. and Fridsma, D. B. (2007). Sharing Detailed Research Data Is Associated with Increased Citation Rate. PLoS ONE, March 21, 2007.

U.S. University Policies Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences (February 2008) Harvard Faculty of Law (May 2008) Stanford Department of Education (June 2008)

New Collaborations Libraries Research Centers Graduate Schools IT Departments University Presses Museums

2 Seminal Papers 2003: Clifford A. Lynch, "Institutional Repositories: Essential Infrastructure for Scholarship in the Digital Age," ARL Bimonthly Report 226 (February 2003), 1-7. Available: : Laura Brown, Rebecca Griffiths, and Matthew Rascoff, University Publishing in a Digital Age. Available: nADigitalAge

Richard Fyffe Rosenthal Librarian of the College Grinnell College grinnell.edu

Copyright Richard Fyffe, 2008 You are free: to copy, distribute, display, and perform the work to make derivative works Under the following conditions: Attribution. You must give the original author credit. Noncommercial. You may not use this work for commercial purposes. Share Alike. If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may distribute the resulting work only under a license identical to this one. For any reuse or distribution, you must make clear to others the license terms of this work. Any of these conditions can be waived if you get permission from the copyright holder. Your fair use rights are not limited by these restrictions.