Packet Loss NLM HEAnet Michael Gill National Library of Medicine (NLM) Bethesda, Maryland USA Victor Reijs HEAnet, Dublin Ireland Internet2 High-performance.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

1 QoS monitoring and SLS auditing TNC-2002, Limerick June 4 th, 2002 Victor Reijs

Advertisements

Network Resource Broker for IPTV in Cloud Computing Lei Liang, Dan He University of Surrey, UK OGF 27, G2C Workshop 15 Oct 2009 Banff,

Pathload A measurement tool for end-to-end available bandwidth Manish Jain, Univ-Delaware Constantinos Dovrolis, Univ-Delaware Sigcomm 02.

Telecommunications Industry AssociationTR-30.3/

Tiziana Ferrari Differentiated Services Test: Report1 Differentiated Service Test REPORT TF-TANT Tiziana Ferrari Frankfurt, 1 Oct.

Design and Monitor Your Network to Deliver Optimal Quality of Service Steve Kelley Director, Solutions Specialists NetSolve, Inc.

Campus LAN Overview. Objectives Identify the technical considerations in campus LAN design Identify the business considerations in campus LAN design Describe.

Chapter 10 Congestion Control in Data Networks1 Congestion Control in Data Networks and Internets COMP5416 Chapter 10.

High Speed Networks and Internets : Multimedia Transportation and Quality of Service Meejeong Lee.

1 Synchronizing Management Information using Traffic Pattern Matching Technique Kohei Ohta, Yohsuke Takei, Nei Kato, Glenn Mansfield, Yoshiaki Nemoto Cyber.

1 K. Salah Module 2.1: QA – Putting it all together What is the max number of users/connections/sessions a particular network can support for handling.

Introduction Future wireless systems will be characterized by their heterogeneity - availability of multiple access systems in the same physical space.

Shadow Configurations: A Network Management Primitive Richard Alimi, Ye Wang, Y. Richard Yang Laboratory of Networked Systems Yale University.

Communication Links Communication Link = Physical connection or Physical Medium Types: Wire Pair or Twisted Pair Coaxial Cable Fiber Optics Bandwidth,

User Experiments of Using Congestion Pricing to Allocate Access Link Bandwidth Jimmy Shih, Randy Katz, Anthony Joseph.

Application Layer  We will learn about protocols by examining popular application-level protocols  HTTP  FTP  SMTP / POP3 / IMAP  Focus on client-server.

QUTE’98 Workshop Heidelberg, October 1998 Telebit Communications A/S An independent Danish vendor of multiprotocol routers and switches.

Readying Data Networks for Converged Services Presented by: Jaye Armstrong-CCIE Director of Data Services.

What is Actual Internet Speed? Seung Il Lee Network Engineer NTT Com ICT Solutions.

Internet Traffic Management Prafull Suryawanshi Roll No - 04IT6008.

Routing. A world without networks and routing  No connection between offices, people and applications  Worldwide chaos because of the lack of centralized.

Internet Traffic Management. Basic Concept of Traffic Need of Traffic Management Measuring Traffic Traffic Control and Management Quality and Pricing.

LBE TF-NGN Budapest October Agenda GÉANT D9.9 deliverable summary Test reports for LBE on GÉANT (Nicolas) Tests for LBE at the edge Limerick.

Top-Down Network Design Chapter Thirteen Optimizing Your Network Design Oppenheimer.

Maximizing End-to-End Network Performance Thomas Hacker University of Michigan October 26, 2001.

How do loss and delay occur?

Performance Monitoring - Internet2 Member Meeting -- Nicolas Simar Performance Monitoring Internet2 Member Meeting, Indianapolis.

Introduction to Quality of Service. Engineering Internet QoS2  What is QoS?  Why QoS?  Large Bandwidth vs QoS?  Networking Trends Leading to QoS 

Quality of Service in the Internet The slides of part 1-3 are adapted from the slides of chapter 7 published at the companion website of the book: Computer.

Chapter 5: Summary r principles behind data link layer services: m error detection, correction m multiple access protocols m link layer addressing, ARP.

AIMS’99 Workshop Heidelberg, May 1999 Linking User Acceptance and Network Performance Miles Wilkins (BT) P807 (JUPITER2)

Document Number PXE PacketExpert™ - IPLinkSim WAN Link Emulator (PXE200)

1 Terena Networking Conference 2000, Lisboa May QoS in IP over ATM Networks Terena Networking Conference 2000 Lisboa, May The BTI field trials.

Sharing Information across Congestion Windows CSE222A Project Presentation March 15, 2005 Apurva Sharma.

CS/IS 465: Data Communication and Networks 1 CS/IS 465 Data Communications and Networks Lecture 28 Martin van Bommel.

Multicast Routing Algorithms n Multicast routing n Flooding and Spanning Tree n Forward Shortest Path algorithm n Reversed Path Forwarding (RPF) algorithms.

Making the Best of the Best-Effort Service (2) Advanced Multimedia University of Palestine University of Palestine Eng. Wisam Zaqoot Eng. Wisam Zaqoot.

V Telecommunications Industry AssociationTR-30.3/

A Practical Approach for Providing QoS: MPLS and DiffServ

Nicolas Simar – DANTE - Sequin: Monitoring Infrastructure Monitoring Premium IP.

Analysis of QoS Arjuna Mithra Sreenivasan. Objectives Explain the different queuing techniques. Describe factors affecting network voice quality. Analyse.

Campus Case Studies in Implementing Advanced Services Cas D’Angelo

AIMS Workshop Heidelberg, 9-11 March 1998 P616 - ENHANCED ATM ISSUES Network Layers over ATM Rüdiger Geib Deutsche Telekom Tel Fax +49.

Terena Networking Conference, Lisbon, May

CS 3830 Day 4 Introduction 1-1. Announcements  No office hour 12pm-1pm today only  Quiz on Friday  Program 1 due on Friday (put in DropBox on S drive)

1 Capacity Dimensioning Based on Traffic Measurement in the Internet Kazumine Osaka University Shingo Ata (Osaka City Univ.)

. Large internetworks can consist of the following three distinct components:  Campus networks, which consist of locally connected users in a building.

CSE5803 Advanced Internet Protocols and Applications (14) Introduction Developed in recent years, for low cost phone calls (long distance in particular).

Spring 2004 Member Meeting Vendor Tools e2e Tools BOF John H. Moore Technical Director NC-ITEC.

Internet2/Abilene Perspective Guy Almes and Ted Hanss Internet2 Project NASA Ames -- August 10, 1999.

Router Basics MM Clements.

1 QoS monitoring activities TF-STREAM November 127 th, 2000 Victor Reijs

1 QoS monitoring and SLS auditing TEQUILA, Amsterdam January 25 th, 2001 Victor Reijs.

© 2006 Cisco Systems, Inc. All rights reserved. 3.2: Implementing QoS.

1 Video and Voice over IP performance over a Satellite link Bob Dixon, Ohio State University/OARnet Prasad Calyam, OARnet Joint Techs Workshops, Columbus,

Thoughts on TEIN2 Operation and Collaboration Xing Li

Confidential Rapid Troubleshooting for Data, VoIP, and Video VoIP Performance Manager.

CSEN 404 Introduction to Networks Amr El Mougy Lamia AlBadrawy.

1 Network related topics Bartosz Belter, Wojbor Bogacki, Marcin Garstka, Maciej Głowiak, Radosław Krzywania, Roman Łapacz FABRIC meeting Poznań, 25 September.

Multimedia Communication Systems Techniques, Standards, and Networks Chapter 4 Distributed Multimedia Systems.

19 – Multimedia Networking

Network Overview.

MDC METHOD FOR HDTV TRANSMISSION OVER EXISTING IP NETWORK

Error Recovery Supplemental Slides.

Real-time information

Monitoring Appliance Status

Technical Communication

Duke – NIH Videoconference End-End

CIS679: MPEG-2 Review of MPEG-1 MPEG-2 Multimedia and networking.

Use of Simplex Satellite Configurations to support Internet Traffic

Presentation transcript:

Packet Loss NLM HEAnet Michael Gill National Library of Medicine (NLM) Bethesda, Maryland USA Victor Reijs HEAnet, Dublin Ireland Internet2 High-performance Applications Support October 31 st, 2000 Atlanta, Georgia

Preparation for interactive multimedia demonstration Learning Collaboratory (at NLM) Centre for Healthcare Informatics (at Trinity College Dublin) – Using MPEG-2 Codecs at each end –Camvision-2, from Litton Network Access Systems –1.5 => 15 Mbit/s, low-latency video –Litton supplied demo unit for each end –Loan from TERENA –NLM later purchased three units

Early results (March) showed consistent packet loss –Tools were limited: PingPlotter ( cv2sim.exe (simulates video loading without hardware codec, supplied by Litton) –More than 1% loss destroys acceptable MPEG-2 video transmission Time Zone difference –USA=>Dublin=+5 hours Initial testing

Routing/Peerings Asymmetrical routing NLM -> vBNS+ -> Abilene -> DANTE -> HEAnet First using vBNS+ (over West of America): long delays NLM -> Abilene -> DANTE -> HEAnet msec Rerouting due to upgrading links from OC-3c to OC-12c

Equipment/cable/configuration issues Different connectors then ordered cables Both sides need to be PAL or NTSC Exploring Huge buffer settings for all routers in path Ethernet cable rotten Mismatching ATM PVC configuration OC-12c fiber had to replaced Rotten OC-12c ATM interface

Bandwidth 34 Mbit/s transatlantic at IP level (T3) –USA=>HEAnet heavy traffic Overbooked ATM link QoS: Committed Access Rate (CAR) –HEAnet=>USA lighter traffic –Testing during holidays/low-usage hours Upgrading –Teleglobe (OC-3c -> OC-12c) –Abilene (shared OC-3c -> OC-12c) –HEAnet (T3 -> OC-3c: 2Q 2001)

Present conclusions Chain of networks –multi kingdom problem Check all router interfaces in the whole path Operational network management is not run to have very low (<1%) packet drop

Changed test scenario QoS grid –Service Level Mangers –Service Access Points –IPPM measurements E.g. Surveyor, RIPE Test Traffic project (both using GPS) –Proprietary solutions: Chariot/Qcheck by NetIQ Install test points in the path –At server, client and peering locations –Provide these test points as part of network service

All in a row We had all kind of problems –Formal demonstrations postponed twice March 2000: Testing with tools (packet loss) May 2000: First video pictures (unacceptable quality) July 2000: Good quality video for a few days!!! Oct 2000: Unacceptable quality and still testing –NLM => HEAnet still unacceptable quality –HEAnet => NLM fairly good on short tests Abilene Premium service and HEAnet bandwidth upgrade QoS grid needed

Questions? Michael Gill, Victor Reijs.