Constraints on symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting with HICs Yingxun Zhang ( 张英逊 ) 合作者: Zhuxia Li (李祝霞) China Institute of Atomic Energy,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Survey of Issues Misak Sargsian Florida International University.
Advertisements

Detector Design and Data Analysis for Heavy Ion Collision Experiments Peter, Chan Chak Fai SURE 2011 Supervisor: Prof Betty Tsang(NSCL, MSU)
Ilona Bednarek Ustroń, 2009 Hyperon Star Model.
Fragmentation of very neutron-rich projectiles around 132 Sn GSI experiment S294 Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, Spain Centre d’Etudes Nucleaires.
The Dynamical Deformation in Heavy Ion Collisions Junqing Li Institute of Modern Physics, CAS School of Nuclear Science and Technology, Lanzhou University.
Spin polarization phenomena in dense nuclear matter Alexander Isayev Kharkov Institute of Physics and Technology Ukraine.
Neutron Number N Proton Number Z a sym =30-42 MeV for infinite NM Inclusion of surface terms in symmetry.
Single Particle Energies
The National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory Michigan State University Betty Tsang 5th ANL/MSU/JINA/I NT FRIB Workshop on Bulk Nuclear Properties.
Transport phenomena in heavy-ion reactions Lijun Shi NSCL MSU and Physics Department, McGill University Catania, Italy, Jan. 23, 2004.
The National Superconducting Cyclotron State University Betty Tsang Constraining neutron star matter with laboratory experiments 2005.
利用重离子碰撞确定对称能 密度依赖形式 核物理前沿热点问题研讨会 10月27日 广西 桂林 张英逊 中国原子能科学研究院 合作者: 李柷霞 (CIAE) P.Danielewicz, M.B.Tsang, W.G.Lynch (NSCL/MSU)
Equation of State of Neutron-Rich Matter in the Relativistic Mean-Field Approach Farrukh J. Fattoyev My TAMUC collaborators: B.-A. Li, W. G. Newton My.
Zbigniew Chajęcki National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory Michigan State University Probing reaction dynamics with two-particle correlations.
Constraining the EoS and Symmetry Energy from HI collisions Statement of the problem Demonstration: symmetric matter EOS Laboratory constraints on the.
Isospin effect in asymmetric nuclear matter (with QHD II model) Kie sang JEONG.
重离子碰约束对称能中的相关问题 张英逊 (Yingxun Zhang) 中国原子能科学研究院( CIAE ) 2015 强子物理与核物理前沿研讨会 Frontiers in Hadron and Nuclear Physics (FHNP’15) 国科大, 1 月 10 日,怀柔.
Constraints on symmetry energy and the n/p effective mass splitting.
Higher-Order Effects on the Incompressibility of Isospin Asymmetric Nuclear Matter Lie-Wen Chen ( 陈列文 ) (Institute of Nuclear, Particle, Astronomy, and.
Pornrad Srisawad Department of Physics, Naresuan University, Thailand Yu-Ming Zheng China Institute of Atomic Energy, Beijing China Azimuthal distributions.
Reaction mechanisms in transport theories: a test of the nuclear effective interaction Maria Colonna INFN - Laboratori Nazionali del Sud (Catania) NN2012.
Fragmentation mechanism and enhanced mid-rapidity emission for neutron-rich LCPs Yingxun Zhang( 张英逊 ) 中国原子能科学研究院 Colloborator: Chengshuang Zhou 周承双 (CIAE,GXNU),
Tensor force induced short-range correlation and high density behavior of nuclear symmetry energy Chang Xu ( 许 昌 ) Department of Physics, Nanjing Univerisity.
Effect of isospin-dependent cluster recognition on the observables in heavy ion collisions Yingxun Zhang ( 张英逊 ) 2012 年 8 月 10 日, 兰州 合作者: Zhuxia Li, (CIAE)
Shanghai Elliptic flow in intermediate energy HIC and n-n effective interaction and in-medium cross sections Zhuxia Li China Institute of Atomic.
Ning Wang 1, Min Liu 1, Xi-Zhen Wu 2, Jie Meng 3 Isospin effect in Weizsaecker-Skyrme mass formula ISPUN14, , Ho Chi Minh City 1 Guangxi Normal.
Jet quenching and direct photon production F.M. Liu 刘复明 Central China Normal University, China T. Hirano 平野哲文 University of Tokyo, Japan K.Werner University.
J. Su( 苏军 ) and F.S. Zhang( 张丰收 ) College of Nuclear Science and Technology Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China Tel: ,
Probing the density dependence of symmetry energy at subsaturation density with HICs Yingxun Zhang ( 张英逊 ) China Institute of Atomic Energy JINA/NSCL,
Ln(R 12 ) N Alan McIntosh, Yennello Research Group, TAMU-CI. Nuclear Physics Town Meeting, Aug 2014, College Station, TX Asymmetry Dependence of Thermodynamic.
Probing the isospin dependence of nucleon effective mass with heavy-ion reactions Momentum dependence of mean field/ –Origins and expectations for the.
F. Sammarruca, University of Idaho Supported in part by the US Department of Energy. From Neutron Skins to Neutron Stars to Nuclear.
Presentation by T. Gogami 2015/6/15 (Mon). Equation state of neutron matter.
BNU The study of dynamical effects of isospin on reactions of p Sn Li Ou and Zhuxia Li (China Institute of Atomic Energy, Beijing )
M.Di Toro, ECT*/Eurisol Jan.06, Isospin Dynamics in Heavy Ion Collisions at Fermi Energies: EOS-sensitive Observables Dissipative Collisions.
Probing the symmetry energy with isospin ratio from nucleons to fragments Yingxun Zhang( 张英逊 ) China Institute of Atomic Energy The 11 th International.
Zhuxia Li (China Institute of Atomic Energy) Collaborators: Yinxun Zhang (CIAE), Qingfen Li (FIAS), Ning Wang(CIAE) Probing the density dependence of the.
Ning Wang An improved nuclear mass formula Guangxi Normal University, Guilin, China KITPC , Beijing.
Three-body force effect on the properties of asymmetric nuclear matter Wei Zuo Institute of Modern Physics, Lanzhou, China.
Isovector reorientation of deuteron in the field of heavy target nuclei The 9th Japan-China Joint Nuclear Physics Symposium (JCNP 2015) Osaka, Japan, Nov.
Z.Q. Feng( 冯兆庆 ), W.F. Li( 李文飞 ), Z.Y. Ming( 明照宇 ), L.W. Chen( 陈列文 ), F. S. Zhang ( 张丰收 ) Institute of Low Energy Nuclear Physics Beijing Normal University.
Pion-Induced Fission- A Review Zafar Yasin Pakistan Institute of Engineering and Applied Sciences (PIEAS) Islamabad, Pakistan.
Hua Zheng a and Aldo Bonasera a,b a)Cyclotron Institute, Texas A&M University b)LNS-INFN, Catania-Italy Density and Temperature of Fermions.
Effective Nucleon Masses in Compressed and Expanding Neutron-Rich Matter: Motivation Multiple simulations suggest sensitivity of the n/p single and double.
Cluster emission and Symmetry Energy Constraints with HIC observables Yingxun Zhang ( 张英逊 ) 2015 年 12 月 15 日, Shanghai China Institute of Atomic Energy.
Tetsuya MURAKAMI For SAMURAI-TPC Collaboration Physics Using SAMURAI TPC.
1 Z.Q. Feng( 冯兆庆 ) 1 G.M. Jin( 靳根明 ) 2 F.S. Zhang ( 张丰收 ) 1 Institute of Modern Physics, CAS 2 Institute of Low Energy Nuclear Physics Beijing NormalUniversity.
Production mechanism of neutron-rich nuclei in 238 U+ 238 U at near-barrier energy Kai Zhao (China Institute of Atomic Energy) Collaborators: Zhuxia Li,
Current status and future direction on symmetry energy determination using Heavy Ion Collisions How does this subfield intersect with other subfields?
Density-dependence of nuclear symmetry energy
Detector Design and Data Analysis for Heavy Ion Collision Experiments
FAST IN-MEDIUM FRAGMENTATION OF PROJECTILE NUCLEI
Shalom Shlomo Cyclotron Institute Texas A&M University
Mean free path and transport parameters from Brueckner-Hartree-Fock
Transverse and elliptic flows and stopping
University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK, July 7-9, 2014
Structure and dynamics from the time-dependent Hartree-Fock model
Institute of Modern Physics, CAS
Anisotropic flow at RHIC: How unique is the NCQ scaling ?
JLab6: Cluster structure connects to high-momentum components and internal quark modification of nuclei Short-Range Correlations (SRCs) dominated by np.
Nuclear masses of neutron-rich nuclei and symmetry energy
Symmetry energy coefficients and shell gaps from nuclear masses
Symmetry energy with non-nucleonic degrees of freedom
Tests of the Supernova Equation of State using Heavy Ion Collisions
Zhao-Qing Feng (冯兆庆) Institute of Modern Physics (IMP), CAS
Nuclear Stopping and Nuclear Equation of State
Zbigniew Chajęcki Western Michigan University
Department of Physics, Sichuan University
HIC: probing different B regions
The Mass and Isotope Distribution of Limiting Temperatures
Presentation transcript:

Constraints on symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting with HICs Yingxun Zhang ( 张英逊 ) 合作者: Zhuxia Li (李祝霞) China Institute of Atomic Energy, Hang Liu (刘航) Texas Advanced Computer center, University of Texas, M.B.Tsang (曾敏儿) NSCL/Michigan State University China Institute of Atomic Energy IWND2012, Dec , Shenzhen, China

Outline 1, Symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting 2, Probing symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting with new version of ImQMD A, new version of ImQMD (ImQMD-Sky) B, Ri and Ri(y) C, DR(n/p) D, DR(n/p) at higher beam energy 3, Conclusions

Isospin asymmetric Equation of State S( r ) is the density dependence of symmetry energy, it is a key ingredient of the isospin asymmetric EOS. However, S( r ) uncertainty It is a fundamental properties of nuclear matter, and is very important for understanding properties of nuclear structure properties of neutron star properties of heavy ion reaction mechanism S( r ) (MeV) 1, Symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting

Besides depending on the nuclear density, the symmetry energy also depends on the momentum or energy of a nucleon. S(  )=K+S loc (  )+S nlc ( ,k) For cold nuclear matter

Constraining Symmetry energy with heavy ion collisions Heavy Ion Collisions large regions of r, T, d, measure isospin sensitive observables, such as: the N/Z ratios of the emitted particles (n/p ratios, isospin diffusion, t/He3, N/Z ratios of IMFs, flow, pi-/pi+, ……) 1.the symmetry energy information can be extracted. Indirectly! (depends on models) compare with the prediction from the transport model,

Recent progress: constraints on symmetry energy at subsaturation density Ri: M.B. Tsang, Yingxun Zhang, LWChen, BALi, M.Colonna, Coupland et al DR(n/p): Famiano, BALi, Yingxun Zhang, S.Kumar, YGMa, ZQFeng, …… IAS: Danielewicz, et.al., PDR(Pb): A. Klimkiewicz, …. N-Star, A.Steiner, …. FRDM: P. Moller,.. ; Mass: M. Liu, FSZhang, et.al., M_12, F.Amorini, ……. ……. ImQMD (DR, Ri, R 7 ) 50MeV/A, 35MeV/A, Challenges in the constraints on symmetry energy: Different in detail ! M.B.Tsang, Yingxun Zhang, et.al., PRL2009 different NN interactions or EDF (Skyrme, Gogny, …..) or cross sections are adopted among these models

Momentum dependence of symmetry potential is the most important one among these factors ……momentum dependence of symmetry potential, which would lead to very different magnitude and density …, effective mass of nucleons…, is expected to significantly affect the n/p ratios, ….. Y.X.Zhang, et.al., PLB664, 145(2008); from BALi, et.al., PRL and PLB Example, However, Momentum dependence of symmetry potential (n/p effective mass splitting)is Uncertainty! We need to constrain it as well as density dependence of symmetry energy.

Several works has been done for proposing the HIC observables which are sensitive to the momentum dependence of symmetry potential(or n/p effective mass splitting). J.Rizzo, et.al., Phys.Rev.C (2005), n/p (p_t) H.H.Wolter, et.al.,; t/He3 (p_t) ; Z.Q Feng, et.al. PLB2012, DR(n/p), DR(t/He3),.. ……. Here, we would like to use the MSU data to constrain the symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting simultaneously by comparing with the transport model calculations. Constraints on the n/p effective mass splitting (mn*>mp*) has been obtained by analyzing nucleon-nuclei optical potential data. (B.A.Li, C. Xu, et.al., PRC2006,2010).

1.The Skyrme parameter sets have been adjusted for fitting the properties of nuclear matter, binding energy, actinide fission barrier, masses, …… Thus, E 0, K 0, S 0, L, K sym, m*_s, m*_v, ……. are correlated. 2.In Skyrme EDF, one can easily choose different values S 0, L, K sym, m*_s, m*_v for similar K_0. 3.If one use the Skyrme interaction in transport models, one could get the constraints on Skyrme parameters, also on symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting from reaction data simultaneously. One of best choices in transport models is to use full Skyrme EDF

New version of ImQMD YX Zhang, Li, Liu, Tsang(2012) Changes: 2, Probing the symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting

Para. Rho_0 E0E0 K0K0 Q0Q0 JLK sym m*_s m*_n/m*_p SLy <1 SkI <1 SkM* >1 Gs >1 Small LLarge L m_n*<m_p*SLy4 (L=46MeV)SkI2 (L=104MeV) m_n*>m_p*SkM* (L=46MeV)Gs (L=93MeV) Select four parameter sets K 0 = 230 ± 20MeV, S 0 = 32 ± 2MeV, different L and n/p effective mass splitting.

Density dependence of symmetry energy, and the symmetry potential as a function of nucleon energy The Larger the L is, the smaller the symmetry energy at <rho0 is. The larger the U sym is, the larger the n/p ratio is Zhang, Li, Liu, Tsang (2012)

Isospin diffusion and isospin transport ratios as a function of rapidity For m* n <m* p, the isospin diffusion process is accelerated due to larger Lane potential at subsaturation density. R i =(2X-X AA -X BB )/(X AA -X BB ) In absence of isospin diffusion R=1 or R=-1, R~0 for isospin equilibrium Isospin diffusion occurs only in asymmetric systems A+B, and diffusion ability depends on the symmetry energy and n/p effective mass splitting. Ri(SLy4, L=46MeV, m*_n m*_p) m*_p) R i is more sensitive to L than n/p effective mass splitting. A=124Sn, B=112Sn

Chi-square analysis on Ri(y) Chi-Square SLy49.41 SkM*1.62 SkI Gs22.52 The Ri(y) data fit the results from SkM* among four parameter sets. SkM*: S 0 =30MeV, L=46Mev, K sym =-156MeV, m*=0.79 and m* n >m* p The calculated results of Ri from SLy4 and SkM* can fall in the data range. For SLy4 and SkM*, they have S 0 =30-32MeV, L=46MeV

n/p and DR(n/p) ratios as a function of kinetic energy E beam =50AMeV, 124 Sn+ 124 Sn, 112 Sn+ 112 Sn DR(n/p)=R n/p (124)/R n/p (112) The Larger the L is, the smaller the n/p ratio is. m* n <m* p enhance the Y(n)/Y(p) ratios at higher kinetic energy region. DR(n/p) ratios are sensitive to the n/p effective mass splitting. Y(n)/Y(p) and DR(n/p) are more sensitive to n/p effective mass splitting than L

n/p and DR(n/p) at different beam energy For higher beam energy, the Y(n)/Y(p) obtained with m* n >m* p are greater than that with m* n <m* p cases. The sensitivity of DR(n/p) to n/p effective mass splitting decrease due to more and more violent NN collisions. Cross over SLy4 (S 0 =32MeV, L=46MeV, m* n <m* p ) SkM*(S 0 =30MeV, L=46MeV, m* n >m* p )

3, Conclusion 1, neutron proton effective mass splitting (isospin dependent MDI) plays an important role on the Y (n)/Y (p) ratios of transverse emitted nucleons at high kinetic energy. 2, The Ri and Ri(y) support the SLy4 and SkM* interactions, they have L=46MeV. 3, Isospin diffusion data Ri(y) prefer to SkM*, the neutron effective mass is greater than proton effective mass (mn*>mp*), but it is not a strong constraint with deep chi-2 minimum. (SkM*parameter set, S 0 =32, L=46, Ksym=-156, m*/m=0.69 and mn*>mp*). 4, The n/p effective nucleon masses should be further studied at incident energy below 200 MeV per nucleon and more calculations are needed.

Thanks for your attention!

Charge distribution Weak dependence on the parameters we selected E beam =50AMeV