LINE 69H REBUILD AND CONVERSION PROJECT ERCOT Regional Planning Group April 21,2016.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Southwest Rhode Island Transmission Supply Study Long Term Needs and Solutions.
Advertisements

October 16, 2009 RPG Meeting ERCOT RPG Project Review Update Jeff Billo.
Jan 22, 2013 RPG Meeting Sharyland Atlas-Driver Load Integration Project – EIR update.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Company LOGO Cleco Planning Process. Models Cleco uses SPP’s annual series of models to determine the NERC reliability violations. Cleco uses SPP or VST.
Regional Planning Group Project
La Crosse 161 kV Capacitor Addition Northern MAPP Subregional Planning Group April 3, 2007 Daniel Kline.
April 16, 2010 Regional Planning Group RMR Exit for Spencer 5 – Remedial Action Plans Chris Ngai Jay Teixeira.
Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
KURTEN SWITCH PROJECT (BRYAN/ COLLEGE STATION AREA UPGRADES) Technical Advisory Committee December 1, 2005 Transmission Services.
Oncor Electric Delivery Company LLC TOGETHER WE DELIVER ODESSA UPDATE Jan 22, 2013 Presentation to ERCOT Regional Planning Group Austin, TX Mike Juricek.
Houston Region Import Capacity Project August 27, 2013 Regional Planning Group Meeting.
Xcel Energy Projects From 2008 Reliability Assessment.
January 5, 2012 TAC Cross Valley 345 kV Project Jeff Billo Manager, Mid-Term Planning.
OPERATING IN THE EAGLE FORD SHALE
1 Local Area Planning Update to TRANSAC – July 29, 2015 Mitigation Update, Uncertainty Scenarios, and Next Steps.
© 2000 PACIFICORP | PAGE 1 WYOMING WEST AREA STUDY DECEMBER 2013 Seongtae Kim/Jeremy Viula.
Xcel Energy Smaller Scale Transmission Projects Northern MAPP Subregional Planning Group April 3, 2007 Srinivas Vemuri, Jason Standing, and Daniel Kline.
RTP Update RPG Meeting July 21, RTP update  Reliability analysis for the contingencies where load shed is not allowed is complete.
New Richmond Load Serving Study Northern MAPP Subregional Planning Group August 16, 2006 Daniel Kline.
Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004
Jan 13, 2012 RPG Meeting El Campo – Vanderbilt 69 kV Project – Status report Ehsan Ur Rehman Planning Engineer ERCOT.
October 12, 2007 ERCOT Regional Planning Group Meeting RPG-CREZ Task Force Status Report Warren Lasher System Assessment.
1 Entergy Mississippi, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Report on the NCTPC 2006 Collaborative Transmission Plan Mark Byrd, Manager – Transmission Planning Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc January 25, 2007.
JACKSBORO TO WEST DENTON 345-kV PROJECT Presentation to Technical Advisory Committee April 8, 2004 Transmission Services Operations.
Rocky Mountain Power Sub Transmission Five Year Study Findings and Kick Off Attachment K Meeting September 10, 2015.
1 The following are the planned transmission project at SCL for the next ten year. All the projects has no major impact to the bulk transmission system.
Long Term Study Task Force Update Transmission Study Practices and Methodologies April 5th,2011 LTS.
Managing West Texas Wind SWEDE 2008 Conference May 2, 2008 Presented by Paul Hassink AEPSC Texas Transmission Planning.
1 Entergy Mississippi, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Transmission Planning Summit.
1 Entergy Texas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 29, 2008.
Lyndonville Electric Department Feasibility Analysis Review December 2,
1 Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
Aug 17, 2012 RPG Meeting KEC & MEC – Load Addition Project – ERCOT Independent Review Ehsan Ur Rehman Planning Engineer ERCOT.
John Dumas Director of Wholesale Market Operations Jeff Billo Manager of Mid Term Planning Dan Jones Director with Potomac Economics, the ERCOT IMM Board.
October 16, 2009 RPG Meeting ERCOT 2009 Five-Year Transmission Plan Update Jeff Billo.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
1 Entergy Gulf States Louisiana, L.L.C. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects.
Jones Creek Project Submitted to RPG on July 7, 2014 July 22, 2014 Regional Planning Group Meeting.
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (South) & Entergy New Orleans, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans,
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (South) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
April 16, 2010 RPG Meeting Lamesa Area Upgrades ERCOT Independent Review Jeff Billo.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 31, 2007.
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (North) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
JACKSBORO TO WEST DENTON and WEST LEVEE TO NORWOOD 345-kV PROJECTS April 20, 2004 Transmission Services Operations.
Jeff Billo Manager, ERCOT Transmission Planning Kenedy to Nixon to Seguin Line Upgrade Project Regional Planning Group (RPG) Review; ERCOT Independent.
AEPSC Live Oak County Transmission Project – ERCOT Independent Review TAC September 24, 2015.
TRANSMISSION CONSTRAINTS KENNETH A. DONOHOO, P.E. Manager of System Planning, Technical Operations
Transmission Voltage Management Ross Owen Oncor Electric Delivery.
Transmission Capital Project Updates. Transmission Expansion Plan Sigurd to Red Butte 345 kV line in-service May, 2015 Permitting activities continue.
© 2000 PACIFICORP | PAGE 1 SOUTHWEST UTAH AREA STUDY SEPTEMBER 2014 Nathan Wilson/Talmage Daley Need to review the LOADS before Friday.
Jeff Billo Manager, Transmission Planning
September 1, 2011 TAC Lower Rio Grande Valley Regional Planning Group Project Jeff Billo Manager, Mid-Term Planning.
June 3, 2010 Technical Advisory Group RMR Exit for Spencer 5 – Remedial Action Plans Jay Teixeira.
1 Entergy Mississippi, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
Transmission Services Report: North and West RPG Projects Bill Bojorquez TAC July 7, 2005.
1 Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 29, 2008.
June 26, 2008 Technical Advisory Committee American Electric Power Service Corporation Presidio Area Reliability Improvements Project James Teixeira Manager,
1 Entergy Arkansas, Inc. Proposed Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 31, 2007.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Texas) Approved & Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy/ETEC Subcommittee Meeting The Woodlands, TX November.
Sep 16, 2011 RPG Meeting Cross Valley Brownsville Loop Project – Status report.
Freeport Area Master Plan Project
Freeport Area Master Plan Project -
Barrilla Junction Area Transmission Improvements Project
Rocky Mountain Power Five Year Study Findings & Kick Off Meeting
Electric Utility Master Plan Update
RMR Exit for Spencer 5 – Remedial Action Plans
I-5 Corridor Reinforcement Project
Presentation transcript:

LINE 69H REBUILD AND CONVERSION PROJECT ERCOT Regional Planning Group April 21,2016

TNMP SERVICE AREA

PRESENT WEST TEXAS NORTH(WTN) AREA

PREVIOUS TNMP RPG SUBMITTALS FOR WTN AREA REBUILD LINE 69D(WINK – PECOS) TO 138KV STANDARDS (OPERATE AT 69KV) IN-SERVICE REBUILD LINE 69E(WINK – PECOS) TO 138KV STANDARDS (OPERATE AT 69KV) IN-SERVIVE PIG CREEK 138KV TIE TO AEP BP2017

WTN AREA BP2017 ONE-LINE DIAGRAM

LOAD FORECAST FOR WTN AREA Total Coincident Peak Load Forecasts Not Including Pending Agreements Year MW Total Coincident Peak Load Forecasts Including Pending Agreements Year MW Year NET MW INCREASE

WTN SYSTEM PERFORMANCE THERMAL VIOLATIONS MIN CONTINGENCYVIOLATION RATE C WICKETT - PYOTE 69V CKT.IH-20 - COLLIE FIELD TAP 69KV CKT.(Line 69H) IH-20 - COLLIE FIELD TAP 69KV CKT.WICKETT - PYOTE 69V CKT.(Line 69H)XX PYOTE - WORSHAM 69KV CKT.(Line 69H)XX WORSHAM - QUITO DRAW 69V CKT.(Line 69H) X BARILLA TAP - FLAT TOP 138V CKT.TNMP WINK - ONCOR WINK 138KV CKT. X WICKETT - PYOTE 69V CKT.(Line 69H) X IH-20 - PECOS 69V CKT.XX FLAT TOP - AEP PIG CREEK 138V CKT.TNMP WINK - ONCOR WINK 138KV CKT. X WICKETT - PYOTE 69V CKT.(Line 69H)XX IH-20 - PECOS 69V CKT.XX

WTN EXISTING SYSTEM PERFORMANCE VOLTAGE VIOLATIONS MIN VOLTAGE CONTINGENCYDROPDEVIATIONDROPDEVIATIONDROPDEVIATION BIRDS OF PREY - COLLIE TAP 69KV CKT. X IH-20 - COLLIE FIELD TAP 69KV CKT.XXXXXX IH V AUTOTRANSFORMERXXXXX IH-20 - BARILLA TAP 138KV CKT.XXXXX BARILLA TAP - FLAT TOP 138V CKT. XXX TNMP WINK - ONCOR WINK 138KV CKT. X FLAT TOP - AEP PIG CREEK 138V CKT.XXXX X IH-20 - FLAT TOP 138KV CKT.XXXXX

PREFERRED SOLUTION DETAILS  Rebuild Line 69H from IH-20 – Wickett to 138kv standards utilizing Cumberland 1926 ACSR conductor(408 MVA) ~ 39 miles  Convert existing substations(3) along Line 69H to 138kV standards  Connect to IH kV substation  Build Wickett 138kV ring bus substation  Install Wickett 138/69kV autotransformer  Build Wickett – ONCOR Wolf 138kV transmission line utilizing 1926 ACSR conductor(408 MVA) ~ 6 miles

PREFERRED SOLUTION BP2018 ONE-LINE DIAGRAM

PREFERRED SOLUTION COST SUMMARY Rebuild Pyote 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$3,600,000 Rebuild Worsham 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$3,600,000 Rebuild Collie 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$1,700,000 Install New Wickett 138kV Ring Substation With Three Breaker Positions And 138/69kV Autotransformer$9,350,000 Install Single Breaker Position at IH kV Substation$1,700,000 Install Single Breaker Position at ONCOR Wolf 138kV Substation(ONCOR Estimate)$552,160 Rebuild IH-20 - Wickett 69kv Transmission Line with 1926 ACSR Conductor (~ 39 Miles)$24,648,583 Build Wickett - Wolf 138kV Transmission Line with 1926 ACSR Conductor(~6.0 Miles)$5,485,000 Total Cost =$50,635,743

ALTERNATIVE 1 DETAILS Rebuild Line 69H from IH-20 – Wickett to 138kv standards utilizing Cumberland 1926 ACSR conductor(204 MVA) ~ 39 miles but remain energized at 69kV Convert existing substations(3) along Line 69H to 138kV standards Install 20 MVAR of capacitance support on Line 69H

ALTERNATIVE 1 BP2018 ONE-LINE DIAGRAM

ALTERNATIVE 1 COST SUMMARY Rebuild Pyote 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$3,600,000 Rebuild Worsham 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$3,600,000 Rebuild Collie 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$1,700,000 Rebuild IH-20 - Wickett 69kv Transmission Line with 1926 ACSR Conductor (~ 39 Miles)$24,648,583 Install 20 MVAR Capacitor Bank at Collie 69kV Tap Substation$3,000,000 Total Cost =$36,548,583

ALTERNATIVE 2 DETAILS Create 138kV tie connection to ONCOR Yucca Drive - Sand Lake – Culberson 138kV transmission line ISD ~ 2016 Build 138kV Ring Substation at tie location Build new 69kV Ring Substation at tie location Install 138/69kV autotransformer at tie location Rebuild Line 69H from new 138kV Ring Substation - IH20 to 138kv standards utilizing Cumberland 1926 ACSR conductor(408 MVA) ~ 37 miles Convert existing substations(3) along Line 69H to 138kV standards

ALTERNATIVE 2 BP2018 ONE-LINE DIAGRAM

ALTERNATIVE 2 COST SUMMARY Rebuild Pyote 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$3,600,000 Rebuild Worsham 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$3,600,000 Rebuild Collie 69kV Tap Substation to 138kV Standards$1,700,000 Install New 138kV Ring Substation With Six Breaker Positions(ONCOR Estimate)$6,461,769 Install Two Breaker Positions at New 69kV Ring Substation$2,993,778 Install New 138/69kV Autotransformer (ONCOR Estimate)$4,940,700 Install Single Breaker Position at IH kV Substation$1,700,000 Rebuild IH-20 - New 138kV Ring Substation Transmission Line with 1926 ACSR Conductor (~ 37 Miles)$23,384,553 Total Cost =$48,380,800

PROJECT COMPARISON Capacity69 kV PhaseInconsistent ConfigurationCost for FutureOut Planwith AdjacentR.O.W. UncertaintyLoadConsistencyTSP Plans forRequired Growth the Area Preferred$50,635,743MinimalBest NoYes Solution Alternative 1$36,548,583MinimalPoor No Alternative 2$48,380,800ConsiderableBestGoodYesNo

QUESTIONS?