Neutrino oscillations with radioactive sources and large detectors Wladyslaw H. Trzaska on behalf of: Yu.N. Novikov, T. Enqvist, A.N. Erykalov, F. v.Feilitzsch, J. Hissa, K. Loo, D.A. Nesterenko, F. Thorne, J.D. Vergados and M. Wurm
Sources of neutrinos for oscillation studies Sun Power reactors Accelerators – Super-beams – Neutrino factory – Beta-beams – Decay at rest neutrino sources (produced with an ~800 MeV p) Sanjib K. Agarwalla GLA2011 Radioactive sources NNN11W.H.Trzaska2
Beta Decay vs. Electron Capture Beta decay: – Emission of two particles – Each particle with a wide energy spectrum Electron capture: – Emission of one particle – Monoenergetic electron neutrinos NNN11W.H.Trzaska3
Possible sources of monoenergetic electron neutrinos NNN11W.H.Trzaska4 NuclideT 1/2 (d) Q (keV) E (keV) E e,max (kev) Irradiatio n material intensity (kg-1 s - 1) 37 Ar Ar8.3 x Cr Cr2.3 x Se Se1.1 x Sn Sn8.0 x Sm Sm2.0 x Yb Yb1.1 x 10 15
51 Cr NNN11W.H.Trzaska5 90.1% E ν = 747 keV
62 PBq 51 Cr source for GALLEX NIMA 378 (1996) kg of enriched Cr containing ~14 kg of 50 Cr Produced by Kurchatov Institute (CrO 3 ) Electrolyzed in Saclay to obtain metal tubes Tubes were crushed into coarse chips ~1 mm 3 Chips were put inside 12 irradiation cells Cells were placed around the reactor core Siloé reactor at Grenoble was specially reconfigured for this 23.8 days irradiation Activated chromium was sealed in a tungsten shield with 8.5 cm thick walls The source resided in the center of the GALLEX detector between June 23 and October 10, 1994 irradiating the gallium target with neutrino intensity well above the solar neutrino background. Fall 1996 2 nd irradiation 69 PBq NNN11W.H.Trzaska6
75 Se NNN11W.H.Trzaska7 94.5% E ν = 450 keV
Oscillation length vs. energy NNN11W.H.Trzaska8 Fermilab plot 0.085(51) Double Chooz
(ν x,e - ) scattering cross section as a function of neutrino energy [keV] NNN11W.H.Trzaska9
BOREXINO spectrum NNN11W.H.Trzaska10
Neutrino oscillometry Simultaneous measurement of θ 13 and L 32 L 32 ≈ detector length/height E ν [keV] ≈ L 32 [m] Calculated scenarios – LENA (100 m tall) + 75 Se θ 13 and L 32 – LScint (R > 3 m) + 51 Cr sterile neutrinos Next step – antineutrino oscillometry NNN11W.H.Trzaska11
source Distance to top Horizontal axis = Our calculations are based on this kind of scenario: 75 Se 6 x 120 days E ν =450 keV 14 C thr:200 keV Be-7 neutrinos ≈ 100 m NNN11W.H.Trzaska12
75 Se: 6 x 120 days with different sin 2 (2θ 13 ) With solar Be-7 background No systematics NNN11W.H.Trzaska13
If 14 C background could be reduced NNN11W.H.Trzaska14
Detector length is essential! NNN11W.H.Trzaska15
Hunt for θ 13 16ANT'11Wladyslaw H. Trzaska
Following slides show cumulative events detected inside of a hemisphere, with a radius = r. Source is put straight to the top of detector. Sterile neutrino examples source r Source: 51 Cr 3 x 28 days E ν =747 keV NNN11W.H.Trzaska17
Example: 3+1 neutrino case Signal Is way above 6sigma statistical level NNN11W.H.Trzaska18
Example: 3+2 neutrino case NNN11W.H.Trzaska19
Some of the candidates for antineutrino oscillometry NNN11W.H.Trzaska20 Requirements: Q β - > 1.8 MeV T 1/2 >10 d and ΔE ν < 500 keV (ΔE ν = E ν keV) Assumed reactor irradiation time: 0.1 year for 113 In and 123 Sb 1 year for 153 Eu E th = 1.8 MeV
154 Eu source T 1/2 = 8.6 years %β - = Q - = MeV – 10.3 % feeding to 123 keV 2 + state in 154 Gd The rest goes to higher excited states – – = MeV NNN11W.H.Trzaska21 E th = 1.8 MeV
144 Ce Pr NNN11W.H.Trzaska22 Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, (2011) Proposed Search for a Fourth Neutrino with a PBq Antineutrino Source
Conclusions Radioactive sources provide attractive and complementary addition to LBNO for the study of neutrino properties via oscillations – Monoenergetic, sub-MeV neutrinos – Very compact, removable source – Entire oscillation curve; not just a 2 point sample The proposed 50 kton, liquid scintillator LENA detector would be well suited for such studies thanks to the low energy threshold, high detection efficiency, and uniquely slender design (100 m high tank!) – Very promising for sterile neutrino studies! NNN11W.H.Trzaska23