Anne Manuel  Introduction – What do we mean by ‘quality’ ?  What’s wrong with using Google?  Havens of academic quality.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Finding and Evaluating Web Resources AV1003: Introduction to Digital Humanities.
Advertisements

Introduction to Online Resources Aeronautics & Astronautics, Mechanical Engineering and Ship Science Michael Whitton November 2011 & February 2012 University.
ITIS 1210 Introduction to Web-Based Information Systems Internet Research Three Browsing Subject Guides.
Advanced Guide to Searching the Internet. Think about the best way to find legal information Three ways of locating information on the internet Three.
June 2010 Introduction to using the internet for academic purposes.
Accessing Sources Of Evidence For Practice 4 Introduction To Electronic Resources Janette Colclough University of York Library & Archives.
Best Web Directories and Search Engines Order Out of Chaos on the World Wide Web.
WISER Social Sciences: Education Kate Williams and Judy Reading January 2007.
Mastering the Internet, XHTML, and JavaScript Chapter 7 Searching the Internet.
Best Web Directories and Search Engines Order Out of Chaos on the World Wide Web.
Search strategies Literature reviews Information searching Research Skills.
Going Beyond Google Using the internet for your studies and research.
Information Literacy Jen Earl: Academic Support Librarian- HuLSS.
SOURCES finding & evaluating them. Evaluating the AUTHORITY of a source – what questions should we ask? Is the author or organization identified? What.
Going Beyond Google: using the internet for your PhD.
RESEARCHING TIPS & STRATEGIES Summer 2008 Melanie Wilson Academic Success Center MSC 207.
Doing your literature review: an overview Katy Jordan Librarian, Economics & International Development Library & Learning Centre.
LEDDY LIBRARY Managing Employees Help Is Always Available! You can , phone, or just drop by and see me: Katharine Ball Business Librarian.
Information Lecture 2 – Evaluating Information Sources CSC Introduction to Computers and Their Applications.
Lecture Five: Searching for Articles INST 250/4.  What are LCSH? ◦ Why should one hyperlink on the LCSH in the Library catalogue search?  Subject vs.
Website Evaluation Using the internet for research.
Using sources in your Advanced Higher Investigation.
Using the Internet as a Research Tool. Group Work Why is it important to evaluate web sources? Why is it important to evaluate web sources? How do you.
Lecture Four: Steps 3 and 4 INST 250/4.  Does one look for facts, or opinions, or both when conducting a literature search?  What is the difference.
Bio-Medical Information Retrieval from Net By Sukhdev Singh.
RESEARCHING & EVALUATING Summer 2008 Melanie Wilson Academic Success Center MSC 207.
EVALUATING SOURCES. THE NEED FOR EFFECTIVE SOURCES Lend credibility to your arguments Support your points with researched information A source is only.
Anne Manuel  Introduction – What do we mean by ‘quality’ ?  What’s wrong with using Google?  Havens of academic quality.
1 © Netskills Quality Internet Training, University of Newcastle Search Engines and Other Animals © Netskills, Quality Internet Training, University of.
University of Antwerp Library TEW & HI UA library offers... books, journals, internet catalogue -UA catalogue, e-info catalogue databases -e.g.
SEARCH ENGINES Jaime Ma, Vancy Truong & Victoria Fry.
Finding and Evaluating Sources.  Online Catalog: Search ALL the resources of the library; access through library computers or remotely through Internet.
Strategies for Conducting Research on the Internet Angela Carritt User Coordinator, Oxford University Library Services Angela Carritt User Education Coordinator,
WISER Social Sciences: Finding Quality Information on the Internet Angela Carritt and Penny Schenk Bodleian Law Library.
EVALUATING ONLINE SOURCES. GOAL Identify criteria to evaluate websites. Evaluate websites to determine their usefulness for research & your own personal.
Introduction to Website Evaluation Patricia Heeter EME6415.
Online Products From Oxford University Press This presentation gives a brief description of Oxford Bibliographies It tells.
Uncovering the Invisible Web. Back in the day… Students used to research using resources hand-picked by librarians and teachers. These materials were.
Doing your literature review: an overview Katy Jordan Librarian, Social & Policy Sciences Library & Learning Centre.
1 Smart Searching Techniques Fall 2006 the Library.
Independence Middle School MEDIA CENTER /7.
Introducing Communication Research 2e © 2014 SAGE Publications Chapter Four Reading Research: To Boldly Go Where Others Have Gone Before.
WISER : Education Kate Williams, Education Librarian February 2009.
Evaluating Web Pages Techniques to apply and questions to ask.
Web Search Integrating Technology in Classroom Dhaka July 2006.
Databases vs the Internet. QUESTION: What is the main difference between using library databases and search engines? ANSWER: Databases are NOT the Internet.
Chapter 7 Researching Your Speech. Researching your speech: Introduction Researching your topic and providing strong evidence for your claims can make.
W orkshops in I nformation S kills and E lectronic R esources Oxford University Library Services – Information Skills Training Finding quality information.
Chapter 7 Researching Your Speech. Researching your speech: Introduction Researching your topic and providing strong evidence for your claims can make.
Research skills for your EPQ Where to begin. Choosing a subject Choose a broad subject area and carry out some basic research to find out how much material.
Year 12: Workshop 2: Finding and evaluating information LSE Library / CLT / Widening Participation This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial.
Research Skills for Your Essay Where to begin…. Starting the search task for real Finding and selecting the best resources are the key to any project.
Information Literacy Learn to find and critically evaluate information sources. Increase your information literacy skills, to more effectively search,
1 RESEARCHING USING ONLINE SOURCES _____________________________ A Guide to Searching for and Evaluating Web Pages on the Internet.
U SING INTERNET SOURCES IN ACADEMIC INQUIRY Sources: COTTRELL, Stella (2008). The study skills handbook (3 rd ed). New York, Palgrave Macmillan. TALBOT,
Searching the Web for academic information Ruth Stubbings.
Information Literacy Program Critically Evaluating
Evaluating of Information
For Teachers and Students by Nicole Slinger
Information Sources for Academic Work: Beyond Google and Wikipedia
Finding Resources Lucy Fleming Learning Resources Adviser
Are my Sources Reliable?
Evaluating Sources.
Evaluating Web Resources
WISER Social Sciences: Key Search Skills
Researching Your Speech
What is one thing you look for to determine if a website is reliable?
ABC’s of Research.
Questioning and evaluating information
Presentation transcript:

Anne Manuel

 Introduction – What do we mean by ‘quality’ ?  What’s wrong with using Google?  Havens of academic quality on the Internet  Searching for quality in the visible and invisible web  How to recognise a quality resource  Hands-On

 A resource fit for purpose –in academic settings that might mean peer-reviewed, but might just mean credible – e.g. information found on the British Library website  In some circumstances could be informal sites, news sites or sites expressing an opinion  Still some criteria which can be universally adopted to evaluate whether sites are worth using

 Google Searches are often just what is needed  E.g. British Library website  Not always helpful for academic research  Too many hits, too unfocussed, sorting is by ‘popularity’ some types of site e.g. news sites are favoured  Also, websites are not evaluated, results compiled by robots, what is being searched?  Web is big! Important to use a portfolio of methods as nothing is or can be comprehensive

An example : You want to compare the ways that governments of different countries address the issue of ‘music piracy’ i.e. illegal uploading and downloading of music on the Internet  Music Piracy  Google Google  Gateway  Specialist search engines

 Ring-fenced field of web resources that are selected and catalogued by subject and also often by resource-type – often using controlled vocabulary. Makes browsing particularly useful.  Pros – Hand-picked by experts, transparent selection procedure, browsability, searching using thesaurus, can potentially reach invisible web  Cons – labour intensive, expensive, relatively small pool of resources.

  Intute is a free online service created by a consortia of 7 universities in the UK  Subject specialists (academics and librarians) review and evaluate thousands of resources and add them to the Intute database, annotated, classified and indexed

  Similar setup to Intute but US based  Compiled by librarians, specialists etc  Fairly small database

 Dmoz Open Directory Project  Ipl2  Edited by selected volunteers and self-policed but abides by policies and procedures for inclusion of sites  Some useful sites, well organised but not necessarily of academic quality – though should conform to evaluation criteria – i.e. current, reliable source, verifiable information etc

 Visible web – that which can be reached by ‘spider’ robots crawling and indexing websites. E.g. Conventional search engines including Google Scholar  Google scholar Pros ▪ Useful, focussing on academic websites ▪ May often pick up book chapters which can be hard to find ▪ Has been researched and shown to find a high proportion of the items that bibliographic databases find ▪ Can download to reference manager software ▪ Can link in though Find it in Oxford  Google Scholar Cons ▪ Can be inaccurate (picks up items from bibliographies) ▪ Often randomness about results ▪ Won’t go into all institutions/databases/repositories ▪ Older items often listed first as more often linked to

 Invisible web – items that are not found by conventional search engines because:  Within sites that have been blocked by owners  Spiders cannot penetrate them  Created dynamically by the searcher  Are not linked to by other sites so not found by spider  Examples – institutional repositories, databases, many commercial sites

 OAIster  Solo (though only searching Oxford University resources)

 Virtual Training Suite   60 subject specific guides E.g. ‘Internet For American Studies’  Key sites, what to look for and how to use what you find  Libguides (Oxford University) 

Many sites that will teach you about this : e.g. Internet Detective Dmoz – website evaluation Key considerations:  Authority – who has written it? What are their credentials? What institution are they affiliated to (if any)? Is it peer reviewed? Who else thinks this is good?  Currency – when was this written? When updated? Are the links live?  Reliability/Verifiability – Are there references to other credible sites/publications? Are statements backed up? Who is allowed to edit/add to the site?  Standpoint – what’s the purpose of the site? Why has the author written it? Are there obviously unbalanced arguments?  Fit for purpose – Is the information of an appropriate breadth and depth for your purposes? Who is the intended audience? Does the information add to information obtained from other sources?

 Things to look out for:  Authority  URL –.edu.ac.gov address?  ‘About ‘ section  Other publications/references by the author  Institution home page  Link: feature in Google to find out who links to it

 Currency – things to look for  Updated date (often small print at the bottom)  Test a few links  Dates of any references  References to current events

 Reliability/verifiability - things to look for  Sponsoring site (check URL stem)?  Adverts?  Links to the page  Typos/ mistakes/inaccuracies/popular myths  Contact details – where? Who?

 Standpoint – things to check  Google author  Google URL  Read content!

 Fit for Purpose – things to look for  Original content?  Statement of intention/intended audience  Title/author/ date – minimum needed for citation  Site map – to give an overview

 Before searching the Internet consider  Purpose – why use the Internet? Would Solo be better? Or a bibliogrpahic database?  Strategy – think through what sort of information you want and where you might expect to find it. Make sure you are clear and focussed about your research area – time wasting is very easy on the Internet  To0ls – Use a range of Internet tools (gateways and specialist search engines) and consider them as starting points to find journals/authors/research centres that you can then browse more systematically