1 Mitko Chatalbashev ECL Conference, Warsaw “One-stop shops” as effective collective management solutions in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) Mitko CHATALBASHEV.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

MULTI-TERRITORY LICENSING: MULTI-TERRITORY LICENSING IN THE LIGHT OF THE JULY 16th EC DECISION (Case COMP/C2/ – CISAC) Colman Gota Thompson SGAE.

Advertisements

« Work-life balance and PHS : what are the impacts of recession and austerity ? Eric Schneider Development Director O 2

SGEUR Mitko CHATALBASHEV (CISAC) WIPO/CISAC National Seminar Tashkent, 03/04/2012 – 04/04/2012 Original language : English Collective management.

Hungarian Association of OTP Pension Funds Pension Funds ‘STABILITAS’ Reform Experiences in Eastern Europe HUNGARY Csaba NAGY.

THE PUBLIC LENDING RIGHT SITUATION IN EUROPE JIM PARKER APRIL 2011.

Modern Banking in Syria The Role of International Best Practice by Peter Hayward Damascus,2 July 2005.

EC Action Plan: a brief history G8 Asia FLEGT ministerial declaration UK-Indonesia memorandum of understanding International pressure and the work of GW,

Beyond enlargement: The EU’s “new neighbours” Ben Slay Director, UNDP Regional Centre Bratislava UNECE Executive Forum: Competing in a Changing Europe.

1 Comparison between Lao PDR Trade Portal and And National Trade Repository.

Technical Cooperation to Improve Transparency and Accountability of Public Procurement in Transition Countries MICHEL NUSSBAUMER Head of Legal Transition.

IEKA - Albanian Institute of Authorized Chartered Auditors Towards application of new standards on accounting and auditing – Albanian challenge on implementing.

Kernochan Center for Media Law and the Arts - Columbia Law School Collective Management of Copyright: Solution or Sacrifice? New York, 28 January 2011.

Enterprise and Industry A better functioning food supply chain in the EU? The interplay between the food industry and the primary production. Can the right.

August 2003 Investor Relations Online and Surveys of Reporting on Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in 11 Central and Eastern European (CEE) Countries,

NIGERIA’S FINANCIAL SYSTEM STRATEGY 2020 PERSPECTIVES ON BUILDING AN INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL CENTRE: EXPERIENCE OF SINGAPORE.

COMMISSION FOR PERSONAL DATA PROTECTION, BULGARIA Central Eastern Europe Data Protection Authorities (CEEDPA) 15 th Meeting, th of April 2013, Belgrade.

THE ROMANIAN THE ROMANIAN SOCIAL SECURITY SYSTEM SOCIAL SECURITY SYSTEM IN THE GLOBAL CONTEXT IN THE GLOBAL CONTEXT Doina Domnica Pârc ă labu General Director.

PENSION REFORM EXPERIENCES IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Agnieszka Chlon-Dominczak Ministry of Economy, Labour and Social Policy, Poland Kiev, May 28th,

1 SECURITY OF SUPPLY IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ENERGY COMMUNITY Energy Community Secretariat VISION OF EUROPEAN SERBIA International Conference organized by.

Center for Economic and Social Development (CESD), supported by Open Society Institute-Assistance Foundation(OSIAF), Presented on July, 20 th, 2011, Azerbaijan.

August 2003 Investor Relations Online and Surveys of Reporting on Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in 11 Central and Eastern European (CEE) Countries,

FINIDINGS OF A SURVEY ON RROs AND OTHER CMOs IN ARIPO MEMBER STATES Keitseng Nkah Monyatsi Copyright Officer African Regional Intellectual Property Organisation.

HEARING ON LOCAL AND REGIONAL DEMOCRACY IN ARMENIA 5 JUNE 2014 BRUSSELS EUROPEAN CHARTER PROVISIONES ACTUAL IMPLEMENTATION IN ARMENIA DAVID TUMANYAN MEMBER.

MiFID: challenges and opportunities for the Asset Management industry October 24, ECMI Seminar Jean-Baptiste de Franssu CEO INVESCOEurope Vice-President.

Public and private sector cooperation Observations and reflections from a Baltic Sea Region Perspective Ulf Johansson Sweco Eurofutures AB.

An introduction to Public Lending Right Jim Parker, PLR UK September 2010 Standard Presentation.

FLEG Process and ENPI FLEG Regional Program Alexei Slenzak World Bank Budapest November

and Project  Outsource2Lithuania” Baltics ICT:  Lithuania – Aiming the Europe.

GovernEE GovernEE – Good Governance in Energy Efficiency Legal constraints and opportunities for improving EE of public and historic buildings.

Challenges & Opportunities Prepared by Rajesh Padmanabhan Managing Director-Prowl Germany.

1 Seminario de Capacitación Regional IAIS – ASSAL – FIDES Lima 2009 Regulation, Supervision and Policy Issues for Microinsurance in Brazil.

ETF Conference, Building & Financing European Transport Infrastructure, Brussels, 23rd Oct Building & Financing European Transport Infrastructures.

MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT IN ROMANIA “Achievements and Barriers” Dr.eng. Alexei Atudorei ISWA Board Member Representative of ISWA - RDN Southeast.

Christophe Depreter, CEO SABAM, Belgium Seminar AEPO-ARTIS Panel discussion 3 - Collective management of rights in a globalised environment Role and challenges.

The Competitiveness and Innovation Framework Programme ( ) Enterprise and Industry Directorate-General European Commission.

Bangkok, Thailand, 25 Aug 2014 Mongolian ICT sector standardization Chuluunbat Tsendsuren Type Approval Officer Communications Regulatory Commission of.

Finance Banking regulation and supervision.

Experience of the Slovak Republic Budapest April 16, 2015 European Grouping of Territorial Cooperation.

EnterpriseConsulting Turkish Accession, EU Funding & British Opportunities Alex Weston Head of Brussels Office Tuesday 16 October 2007 Enterprise plc.

Presentation by Anatoly Chubais Chief Executive Officer RAO «UES of Russia» October 2001Moscow.

POLISH PENSION FUNDS CHAMBER PENSION REFORMS IN CENTRAL & EASTERN EUROPE 1ST INTERNATIONAL PENSION FUND CONFERENCE MADRID,

Iveta Prostrednik Austrian Financial Market Authority Challenges of Collective Investment Business in CEE October 2011 – Kyiv Workshop – 3rd session.

Identifying obstacles in the Single Market: Tom CORRIE, MARKT.B.TF1 Baltic Sea Strategy and the Internal Market conference 17 September 2010 The role of.

EU Labour Mobility – A Gift or a Burden? 27 October 2015 EESC Building, Brussels Presentation by Kinga JOO, EESC member.

Experience of the Slovak Republic European Grouping of Territorial Cooperation.

Public Benefit Status of NGOs: Basic Questions Nilda Bullain European Center for Not-for-Profit Law (ECNL)

Labour law in contemporary world: discussion of selected issues in light of European experiences Corinne Vargha International Labour.

ATRIP May 25 Dias 1 Centre for Information and Innovation Law ATRIP Conference May 2010 The Necessity to collectivize copyright - and dangers thereof Professor.

Implementing Copyright Collective Management: A Comparison of Malaysia and Thailand Supatchara Distabanjong สุพัชรา ดิษฐบรรจง.

The Private Enforcement Reform A Look Back. Original Reform Team Commercial Law Reform Program – funded by USAID Project of local and foreign professionals.

REAL ESTATE VALUATION IN TURKEY: FUTURE DIRECTIONS 2016 World Bank Conference on Land And Poverty, Washington DC, March 14-18, 2016 Mehmet CETE, Turkey.

FINANCIAL CONGLOMERATES AND BANK STABILITY: THE CHILEAN CASE Enrique Marshall Superintendent of Banks and Financial Institutions, Chile Washington, D.C.

1 M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 9 – Financial Services Bilateral.

Criteria for the Determination of the Tariffs Victoriano Darias.

Intellectual Property and Public Policy: Application of Flexibilities in the International IP and Trade system --Limitation and Exceptions for Education.

WORKSHOP ON COPYRIGHT – COLLECTIVE MANAGEMENT INT MARKT IND/EXP organized in co-operation with the Ministry of Culture of the former Yugoslav Republic.

How to counter democratic backsliding in CEE? Peter Golias INEKO Director, Slovakia June 21st 2016 Warsaw, Poland.

Regime to apply regarding financial services, such as banking, credit and insurance Audrius LINARTAS Deputy Chairman Insurance Supervisory Commission of.

Extended Collective Licensing Conference March 2016 Application in different areas: Out-of-Commerce Works (OOC)

Lecturer in Political Science

Presentation of the Hungarian Chamber System Péter Dunai Secretary General Hungarian Chamber of Commerce and Industry Brussels, 23rd May 2013.

Template for country interventions (5 min)

From: Where do we go from here

MANAGEMENT OF RIGHTS IN MUSICAL WORKS - HOW TO BUILD IT FROM BOTTOM UP

Cohesion Policy and Cities

The Amended ESS Statistical Law - Regulation (EC) 223/2009

Annual newly diagnosed HIV infections per million population

e-Governance in small states and islands

The Commission’s NPL Package and the Directive on Credit Servicers, Credit Purchasers and Collateral Recovery.

A Business-Oriented Overview of Intellectual Property for Law Students

Presentation transcript:

1 Mitko Chatalbashev ECL Conference, Warsaw “One-stop shops” as effective collective management solutions in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) Mitko CHATALBASHEV (CISAC/BIEM) Source language: English

2 Outline About CISAC One-stop shop features Music market in CEE Need for one-stop shop solutions Role of state regulation Collections’ statistics Conclusions

3 CISAC - Worldwide Presence Headquarters: Paris, France Regional Offices: Hungary Burkina Faso Chile China

4 CISAC members in CEE Key figures European Committee & European Regional Office 102 European members 41 CEE members 79,2% 122,1 Million EUR 19,84% 418,5 Million EUR

5 One-stop shop features Legal scheme (statutory or voluntary) under which a user can obtain from a single CMO all (or nearly all) the rights he needs to carry out seamlessly his business (Key) condition: only one CMO per category of rights of the same right holders in a given sector Effect: de iure or de facto monopoly Safeguards: self-regulation, competition law and/or state supervision

6 Specificities of the (music) market in CEE Lack of solid (private) copyright traditions Small and mid-size CMOs Lack of (original) music publishing business Rule of law and enforcement challenges Economic difficulties CMOs - main or only voice/defender of creators’ interest

7 (Practical) need for one-stop shops in CEE Prevailing legal model: de iure or de facto monopoly The OSA Case (C-351/12) The Russian accreditation system Lack of proper one-stop shops: - Kazakhstan, Moldova, Turkey, Ukraine

8 The role of state (over!)-regulation Supervision and good governance Compulsory one stop shops Tariffs approval/setting, minimum Tariffs, Tariff ”caps”, Royalties exemptions Management expenses “caps” Limitations on social&cultural deductions

9 Collections from Public Performance Music (per capita) CEE Societies (2014) Source: CISAC I&E declaration / World Bank Data Base 2014

10 Collections from Public Performance Music (per capita) European Societies (2014) Source: CISAC I&E declaration / World Bank Data Base 2014

11 Collections from Public Performance Music (per GDP) European Societies (2014) Source: CISAC I&E declaration / World Bank Data Base 2014

12 One-stop solutions such as ECL have been implemented with success in most of CEE, for the benefit of creators, users and the public at large Most legislators remain sensitive and responsive to the need of the market for having proper one-stop shops There is a risk of over-regulation e.g. via imposed statutory one stop shops between authors’ and related rights CMOs or unjustified interference in some economic parameters Some conclusions

13 thank you