Feminist Epistemologies of Science D. Gruber STS 214.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Gender & Education. Gender differences in attainment In the past, boys used to achieve far more in education than girls In the past, boys used to achieve.
Advertisements

Gender Role Development
Short conclusions from the (so far) 18 interviews made by Agneta, Emma and Suzanne: lab and section leaders (5) researchers/teachers (6) doctoral students.
NSF NC STATE. NSF ADVANCE: Increasing the Participation and Advancement of Women in Academic Science and Engineering Careers The goal of the.
Women‘s employment in the context of culture and work-family arrangements in a comparative perspective Birgit Pfau-Effinger, University of Hamburg.
Single-Group Studies Based on C.E. Sleeter & C.A. Grant (2003). Making Choices for Multicultural Education (4 th Ed.)
Planning an essay.
Gender Roles In this section, we continue to pick apart ideas about how sexual/affectional orientation relate and interact with gender. We’ve been talking.
Nature’s Body Londa Schiebinger. The Introduction 1.Why investigate natural history? 2.Why choose gender?
© 2008 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. 1 CHAPTER 5 Sociocultural Diversity.
Nature’s Body Londa Schiebinger. The Introduction 1.Why investigate natural history? 2.Why choose gender?
Gender and Families Sex and gender Gender role theories Biosocial Psychoanalytic Cognitive development Social learning/socialization Conflict (sex/gender.
Breast Cancer Awareness Month October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month. While most people are aware of breast cancer, many forget to take the steps to.
Girls, Women and Mathematics in Spain A gender study on teaching, learning and research in Mathematics Sara Silvestre and Mario Barajas University of Barcelona.
The Multicultural Classroom
An Interactive Workshop on Gender Sponsored by PEARL2 and Isis International – Manila Understanding Gender.
Gender Equity in Computing Rita M. Powell Department Manager Dept. of Computer & Information Science.
Introduction to Literary Theory, Feminist and Gender Criticism
Socialization: Gender Identity
Chapter 8, Gender Inequality
Introduction to Literary Theory, Feminist and Gender Criticism
Chapter 6 Education and Achievement ___________________________.
Gender identity and subject choice
 Lesson 14: Gender and Sexism Social Problems Robert Wonser 1.
FACES OF INDIAN WOMEN.
1 Family Sociology Race, Ethnicity, & Families. 2 Race, Ethnicity & Families How do we define race? How do we define ethnicity?
COLLEAGUES IN ENGINEERING, THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT AND SCIENCE WELCOME! HANNELIE NEL 29 AUGUST 2007.
Atypical: From Biology to Gender Performance. Quick Review Gender Identity / SexGender Roles / Performance Sexual Orientation.
UNDERSTANDING GENDER 1.GENDER FORMATION –developing a sense of who you are as boys or girls through everyday interactions with family, friends, media,
LO - TO Apply Research Into Gender Development Equal Opportunities in Education, Work and Leisure.
Figure 3. The average interest of males and females pursuing a science career comparing pre-adolescence and adolescence. Averages were not significantly.
Chapter 10 Sex, Gender and Sexuality. Chapter Outline  Sexual Differentiation  Perspectives on Gender Inequality  Gender as Social Construction and.
Gender, Technology & Higher Education Nov 6 th, 2006.
Discuss with your neighbors… What did you see on TV last night? Did you watch any obvious TRADITIONALISM (men do this, women do that)? Were there any shows/
Chapter 10 Gender Issues for adolescents. Gender and Gender Role n The sociocultural dimension of being male or female n Gender is a psychological phenomenon.
Feminist Theories of Education Feminist perspectives focus on gender inequalities in society. Feminist research has revealed the extent of male domination.
Chapter 10, Sex and Gender Sexual Differentiation Perspectives on Gender Equality Gender in the United States.
Gender Stereotypes. Gender Stereotypes: What are They? Gender Stereotypes are generalizations about a specific gender’s roles, attributes, differences,
Chapter 10 Sex and Gender Sex: The Biological Dimension Gender: The Cultural Dimension Gender Stratification in Historical and Contemporary Perspective.
 If you have an X on your card, please stand up.
3-5 Barriers to Women’s participation in Science & Engineering.
EDUCATION CURRENT GENDER STATUS STEM Fields. NATIONAL EDUCATION TRENDS  About 20.1 million women have bachelor's degrees, compared to nearly 18.7 million.
Girls and Technology. From infancy, our culture teaches us what it means to be a boy or a girl. It dictates the color of clothes we wear, the type of.
ROMAN KUHAR UNIVERSITY OF LJUBLJANA, SLOVENIA It’s the end of the world as we know it: Sociological perspective and research on equal marriage and parenting.
List differences between women and men and consider:
Unit 2 Chapter 4, Section 4 Gender Roles and Differences Mr. Young Psychology.
Chapter 12 Gender ED502-Child and Adolescent Psychology By Terri Pardo.
How can we explain the gender gap in educational achievement? How can explain the differences between female and male subject choices at GCSE, A level.
Look at the following fonts. Are they masculine or feminine? GENDER.
Gender Identity Boy? Who am I? Girl? Gender Role SEX.
THE IDEAL MIDDLE SCHOOL CLASSROOM FOR BOYS AND GIRLS.
1 Gender. 2 GENDER ROLE EXPECTATIONS  Then:  Think back in history and outline what the gender expectations were for both males and females.  Give.
Gender and Sexual Orientation Diversity
I can analyze and explain how gender bias is embedded in our culture and society.
Gender, Age, and Health Original Content Copyright © Holt McDougal. Additions and changes to the original content are the responsibility of the instructor.
CCHE 680 Denise Zambos. The student’s college choice… After high school, the student must decide if they will go to college and what college they will.
Learning and Gender Week 2, lesson 2 – Subject choice differences and gender role socialisation.
DISCLAIMER The content, logos, graphics, and images in this presentation are the sole property of Utah Career and Technical Education (CTE) in conjunction.
Gender Development Module 49. Key Terms Sex - the biological category of male or female; sexual intercourse Gender - cultural, social, and psychological.
Gender Roles Chapter 4. Boy or Girl? Read the description of the person. Hold up the blue card if you think the person is a boy. Hold up the pink card.
 A developmental psychologist who, in the mid- 1960s, devoted the majority of his career to the nature of infantile love.  Went to Stanford University.
Gender.
Feminism In Education.
Nature and Nurture What makes us who we are?.
Nature and Nurture What makes us who we are?.
Nature and Nurture What makes us who we are?.
1. When do children develop their gender identity?
Human Diversity.
Unit 1: Foundations
49.1 – Discuss gender similarities and differences in psychological traits.
Presentation transcript:

Feminist Epistemologies of Science D. Gruber STS 214

Women face difficulties in the practice of science and technology – What are those difficulties? – What are their effects? – What’s the response / action needed? Preview

Representation is a good place to start Q: In what Sci & Tech fields are women under- represented? And why?

A Local Perspective Consider the NC State data on female faculty and female student populations See NCSU data Website for details Red represents % of women faculty in NCSU colleges – which fields have the lowest representation?

Some reasons… Less female role models in Science and Tech fields Less female faculty in Science and Tech Departments in Colleges – Less recruitment and less networking among women Less aggressive self-promotion among women in Science and Math (USF, Women in Science & Math) Lower self-confidence ratings in Science and Math classes among women (USF, Women in Science & Math) Other known factors: – Many parents don’t encourage girls to pursue these careers – Science and Tech have been traditionally thought of as a machinic and industrial enterprise requiring physical strength; there can be a “boy’s club” atmosphere; there is a “conquering” socialization (Sismondo, p. 75) – Women report feeling the need to work overtime and “prove yourself” or “be tough” in these fields when also expected to be at home (GMU women in science). – Women are perceived as “less technically competent” when in management positions despite performance (AnitaBorg Institute Survey, ) See: & (consult the report: “leveling the playing field, 2011” & “climbing the technical ladder, 2009”)

Some perpetual myths Girls are less-interested in science and math Parents can’t do much to get girls interested in science and math Girls are naturally less capable with Science and Math – they just don’t think that way! Science and Math teachers are no longer biased toward their male students

Against the myths Few girls are exposed to engineering and computer science from a young age or are encouraged to pursue it. Those who do pursue it often report being encouraged or having parents who were in the field. There is no difference in drop-out rates between men and women in these fields. Women receive 1/3 of doctoral degrees in Science and Math. So they succeed when involved. There is no doubt that if social conditions changed, women would be as involved in all areas of Science and Math. Info provided by: Women in Science, AWIS. org

So what? What are the effects? What are the effects of this disparity? Q: Why should we care?

Sociology and Nature fold over “What counts as knowledge and what comes to be made depends on many social and historical factors. Therefore, we should expect that feminist science and technology would be different from current science and technology.” – Sismondo, p. 73 Content would change Knowledge is constructed by those making it

Consider this… Consider how our views of Nature and our views of social roles and gender fold over and affect each other.

Example #1: cultural assumptions are embedded in the language of biology. Those descriptions of “the Natural” have effects that reverberate through culture and return to issues in science and technology. – Consider the case of mammals. Sociology and Nature fold over

The Effect of “Mammals” In 1758, Carl Linnaeus studies species as categories, which represent *real orders. He connects breasts and breast-feeding with a category to which humans belonged. He defined humans as “mammals.” Of the breast. What is the (social / gender roles) result of this seemingly small reorganization of thought about what defines humans in relation to other animals? See: History of Infant Feeding, Forsyth, D., 1911 Also see: why mammals are called mammals by Schiebinger

Some background to understand the effect of “Mammals” Women nursed for much longer periods of time. Wet-nurses were common from the middle ages - early 1800s. Cow’s milk and Goat’s milk was considered taboo and unsanitary for a long time. In some cases, beer-soup or boiled cows milk with oatmeal were fed. Wet-nurses in the late 1700s were increasingly connected to depravity (mother-abandonment) and fell out of fashion. Deplorable social standings were thought to have connection to personality or perhaps family lineage--many were of a lower-class than the biological mothers. – Children were (now again) thought to lose traits of biological mothers 1820s-1860s “mammas” and “sucking bottles” with rubber teats were invented and adopted. Women’s role further defined as “mothers” in a particular sense. “Nature” and sociology interact here.

Example #2: Donna Haraway shows how “biologizing” gender differences naturalizes them and legitimates them. She critiques the constant drive to glue sex to gender roles. She says there is a biological determination of social positions with a long insidious and often ridiculous history. Sociology and Nature fold over See: Haraway, D. “Animal Sociology and a Natural Economy of the Body Politic” 1978 in Signs.

Naturalizing Gender Roles As an example, Haraway shows how Clarence Carpenter in the 1930s 1) organized monkey groups hierarchically by aggressive behaviors overlooking other forms of social integration and dominance behaviors; 2) further, dominance was measured by thinking of the monkeys as “pairs” and as either “heterosexual” or “homosexual” pairs. 3) The researcher also assumed that monkeies were unfaithful or homosexual because they received favors (assuming a ‘right’ social order that looked like a contemporary Western human one). 4) Finally, the researcher assumed a loss in the “alpha males” would result in less territory, less food, higher mortality.

Sociology and Nature fold over Clarence Carpenter’s study of monkeys claimed to be built from transparent observations. But it started out with assumptions about social relations, making the monkeys “fit” into a particular historical and culturally-defined human model of sociality.

Take another example (#3): Dr. Jordynn Jack has recently shown that Autism has been characterized as a condition of “the extreme male brain.” More male than male? She shows that the major Autism studies used as support for this view primarily choose male participants to establish this fact. And female Autism is highly under-diagnosed. Sociology and Nature fold over

What’s the point of saying Sociology & Nature fold over? Science and Technology are not a “Natural kind.” Diversity matters in the production of knowledge and the understanding/shaping of the world.