Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research ICES Symposium on management strategies - SFMS-25 FLEET-BASED SHORT-TERM.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Ecosim Beth Fulton Time dynamic Ecopath = initial conditions Define Duration Environmental drivers Contaminants option Fleet dynamics option ECOPATH,

Advertisements

(Western) Channel Fisheries UK Finlay Scott, Trevor Hutton, Alyson Little, Aaron Hatcher cemare.

COBECOS mid-term meeting, 2-3 September 2008, San Sebastian Italian case study: GSA 9 bottom trawling fishery Status of model estimation at September 2008.

Fisheries management; problems - solutions Sarah B. M. Kraak University College Cork Marine Institute Ireland.

Icelandic cod HCR - lessons learned Einar Hjörleifsson Marine Research Institute Reykjavík, Iceland.

(Western) Channel Case - study Channel Fisheries Model cemare.

Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences Status of Mediterranean resources in European Waters in 2012 Results for stocks in GSA 1-29 (Mediterranean.

Key approaches that will inform the development of the research include Chai (1991), Casey (1996), Harley (2000), Dingsør (2001), Palsson (2003), McBride.

1 1 Per Sandberg and Sigurd Tjelmeland Harvest rules and recovery strategies The case of Norwegian spring spawning herring.

The current status of fisheries stock assessment Mark Maunder Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission (IATTC) Center for the Advancement of Population.

Harmonisation of Data. Objectives Develop a standard data description applicable to all fisheries Provide data necessary for the estimation of theoretical.

GS1 Multispecies models Issues and state of art in modelling Issues in interpretation and implementation Gunnar Stefansson Marine Research Institute/Univ.

458 Population Projections (policy analysis) Fish 458; Lecture 21.

Multispecies Models-II (Including Predation In Population Models)

Generic Harvest Control Rules for European Fisheries Rainer Froese, Trevor A. Branch, Alexander Proelß, Martin Quaas, Keith Sainsbury & Christopher Zimmermann.

Fishing Effort: fishery patterns from individual actions Dr. Darren M. Gillis, Biological Sciences, University Of Manitoba, Winnipeg,

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research The overlap between Science and Advice; the example of North Sea cod.

Terms of Reference #5 and #7 Overview/Relation to Management Deirdre Boelke, NEFMC Staff, Scallop PDT Chair March 17-19, 2015.

IREPA Onlus – Istituto Ricerche Economiche Pesca e Acquacoltura The Relationship between Fleet Capacity, Landings, and the Components Parts of Fishing.

Standardizing catch per unit effort data

Gunnar Stefansson Marine Research Institute/Univ. Iceland

Joint assessment of demersal species WG demersal spp Sept Graham Pilling Cefas.

2nd Meeting of the MariFish Bycatch and Discards Scientific Committee Madrid, 5-6th October 2009 Work Package 7: Collaborative Research Programmes Thematic.

Pacific Hake Management Strategy Evaluation Joint Technical Committee Northwest Fisheries Science Center, NOAA Pacific Biological Station, DFO School of.

Pacific Hake Management Strategy Evaluation Joint Technical Committee Northwest Fisheries Science Center, NOAA Pacific Biological Station, DFO School of.

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research An EXCEL-based software toolbox for stochastic fleet- based forecast.

The Cod Day Marine Laboratory, Aberdeen, 2 October 2012 The Cod Day - Science Coby Needle, Nick Bailey, Rui Catarino, Steven Holmes Marine Laboratory Aberdeen.

DEEPFISHMAN Using bioeconomic modeling for evaluation of management measures – an example Institute of Economic Studies.

ICES Advice for 2015 – Sea bass Carmen Fernández, ICES ACOM vice-chair For Inter AC Sea bass workshop (Paris, May 26, 2015)

CLIOTOP WG4 ↔ WG5 Integrating biophysical and socio- economic models to address the Challenge(s) of Change.

MARIFISH COLLABORATIVE PROGRAMME THE IMPORTANCE OF TACKLING DISCARDS: A FISHERY MANAGER’S VIEW Concepción Sánchez Trujillano General Subdirector of Fishery.

Sustaining global capture fisheries production Ray Hilborn School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences.

Slide 1 Max Nielsen FOI, University of Copenhagen, Denmark Ola Flaaten University of Tromso, Norway Staffan Waldo AgriFood Economics Centre, department.

Harvest control rules in context – limits, possibilities and the ICES experience Poul Degnbol IFM, Denmark & ICES Workshop on Harvest Control Rules for.

Development of Fishery Management Programs Fishery management is necessarily complicated because of the nature of the industry and the need to safeguard.

The Landing Obligation in the European Union Common Fisheries Policy

Report workshop influencing behaviour Chair: Mary MacAllen Rapporteur: Nathalie Steins Presentation: Fred Normandale.

West Atlantic bluefin tuna Executive Summary. Biology Continued progress in knowledge of bluefin biology, but the complex behaviour of this species means.

Atlantic bluefin tuna Two management units since 1981 Complex spatial dynamics with mixing between both stocks (investigated by BFT-SG since 2001) Spatial.

1 Climate Change and Implications for Management of North Sea Cod (Gadus morhua) L.T. Kell, G.M. Pilling and C.M. O’Brien CEFAS, Lowestoft.

PARTICIPANTS NCMR (Responsible Institute), IMBC [Greece] IREPA[Italy] U. Barcelona, U. Basque, UPO[Spain] EFIMAS MEETING NICOSIA CRETE 2004 APRIL

Technical University of Denmark Danish Institute for Fisheries Research MODSIM Conference 10/13 December 2007 Christchurch, New Zealand Evaluation of management.

EFIMAS - Operational Evaluation Tools for Fisheries Management Options EUROCEAN 2004, GALWAY, IRELAND, slide EU FP6 SSP8-CT EFIMAS Objectives.

1 IMPACT OF THE NEW CFP IN THE MEDITERRANEAN: THE ROLE OF RBM Massimo Spagnolo - IREPA Onlus IMPACT OF THE NEW CFP IN THE MEDITERRANEAN: THE ROLE OF RBM.

CPUE analysis methods, progress and plans for 2011 Simon Hoyle.

Hake/nephrops mixed fisheries in the Bay of Biscay PARAMETRIZATION.

Species Interactions in the Baltic Sea -An age structured model approach PhD Student Thomas Talund Thøgersen.

The Latest ECOST Economic Model Pierre Failler, Haoran Pan and Francis Laloe CEMARE and UMR C3ED November 12-16, FIFTH PROJECT MEETING, PUNTA CANA, DOMINICAN.

Quantifying Fisher Behavior Under Restrictions Hans van Oostenbrugge, Jeff Powell and Jos Smit.

Fish stock assessment Prof. Dr. Sahar Mehanna National Institute of Oceanography and Fisheries Fish population Dynamics Lab November,

Powerpoint Templates Page 1 EU-FIN PROJECT EUROPEAN UNION FISHING NETWORK The three main fishing activities exercised by Pegeia’s fishing fleet. Marios.

The Bio-Economic Model of European Fleets (BEMEF) Griffin Carpenter, New Economics Foundation.

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research ICES Symposium on management strategies - SFMS-32 Integrating fishing.

Mixed fisheries issues for North Sea Cod Clara Ulrich, Katell Hamon, (Stuart Reeves) DTU Aqua. National Institute of Aquatic Resources Danmarks Tekniske.

EU-FP6-EFIMAS Participatory Fisheries Management Evaluation Frameworks

Fisheries Management: Principal Methods, Advantages and Disadvantages

ELFSim: a fisheries decision support tool for coral reef line fish on the Great Barrier Reef of Australia Rich Little MSEAS 2016 Oceans and Atmosphere.

Mixed fisheries issues for North Sea Cod

Special Session: Landing Obligation

Pacific-Wide Assessment of Bigeye Tuna

Policy Evaluation I (Performance Measures and Alternative control systems) Lecture 6.

K:09 Mixed fisheries forecasts – lessons learned from their initial application to North Sea fisheries. Steven J. Holmes, Clara Ulrich & Stuart A. Reeves.

Identifying chokes Stuart Reeves

Sophie Gourguet, O. Thébaud

Policy Evaluation II (Feedback strategies)

Introduction The WCPO region comprises many different countries and territories, all of whom have direct or indirect fisheries based economic interests.

Potential indicators for fish and fisheries

Setting ABC in Scallop A15 Summary of updated ACL section since Feb SSC meeting August 11, 2009.

Beverton and Holt’s yield per Recruit Model

Research outline for CPUE data used in WCPO stock assessments

Presentation transcript:

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research ICES Symposium on management strategies - SFMS-25 FLEET-BASED SHORT-TERM ADVICE IN MIXED FISHERIES – THE F 3 APPROACH Clara Ulrich, B.S. Andersen, H. Hovgård, P. Sparre (DIFRES), A. Murta (IPIMAR), D. Garcia (AZTI), J. Castro (IEO)

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Background – ICES WKMIXMAN Needs to find a method for mixed-fisheries advice to replace MTAC. Issues raised: –Mismatch between the allocation of effort to individual fleets and the relative stability within European fisheries –Constant catch compositions of fleets in the forecast –High sensitivity of results to the inputs, both in terms of fleet/fishery catch data and policy weightings –No respect of management objectives for all stocks Requirements for alternative methods (MoU) : –Simple model –Based on currently available and accessible data –Account for changes in fishing practices

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Background - TEMAS model and TECTAC project Modelling management strategies in multifleet multispecies fisheries Year Y With data Y-1 With effect Y+1 Y+1 ?

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research F 3 – Fleet and Fisheries Forecast Cornerstone : catch AND effort data Fleet AND métiers (fisheries) Fleet (vessels)Métier (trips) Species (catches) EFFORT CATCHABILITY Data : catch and effort database : each vessel to a fleet, each trip to a fishery F and biomass estimates by stock Forecast by stock

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research F 3 - Main assumptions F=qE A vessel in a fleet can engage in several metiers during the year The catchability of a metier can be measured and assumed known – but not the catchability of a vessel (fleet) The overall catchability of a vessel (fleet) is forecasted as weighted mean of catchability by metier and time spent in each metier The relative stability by country also applies at the fleet level (especially in right-based regimes) The fleet will balance its total effort according to its quota shares, and overquota catches might occur Options : MAXEFFORT : fish until last quota exhausted / MINEFFORT : stop fishing when first quota exhausted

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research F 3 - Overview Assessment F(St)Effort (Fl,Mt)Catches (Fl,Mt,St) PartialF(Fl,Mt,St) Q(Fl,Mt,St) ForecastQ(Fl,Mt,St) EffortDistr(Fl,Mt) ForecastEffortDistr(Fl,Mt) ForecastQ(Fl,St) Forecast F(St) Rel. Stab (Fl,St) ForecastF(Fl,St) Forecast Effort (Fl,St) Management rule Forecast Effort (Fl) Forecast Catches (Fl,Mt,St)Forecast OverQuota (Fl, St) (MAX,MIN,WEIGHTED MEAN Effort bound…) Forecast B(St) Forecast TAC(St) assumptio n Forecast F (Fl,Mt,St) Forecast landings (Fl, St)

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research F 3 – WGHMM06 – Southern Stocks – Trial runs 8 Stocks –MEGRIM (*2), HAKE, ANGLERFISH, NEPHROPS (*4) 6 Fleets and 13 Fisheries: –PT artisanal : 3 fisheries (target species) –PT trawl : 2 fisheries (target species) –SP artisanal : 2 fisheries (areas) –SP gillnet : 3 fisheries (gear*target species) –SP longline : 1 fishery –SP trawl : 2 fisheries (areas) 3 scenarios –2005 ACFM proposal –2006 TAC –Southern Hake recovery plan (reduce F by 10%)

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Southern Stocks – Sc1 ACFM proposal (trial runs) LDBFsq HKEZero catch MEGFsq MNZZero catch NEP 25Zero catch NEP 26-27Zero catch NEP f80 t NEP m120 t MAX EFFORT MIN EFFORT (bounded) NOT COMPATIBLE!!

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Southern Stocks – Sc2 TAC 2006 (trial runs) LDB1129 HKE6661 MEG139 MNZ1955 NEP NEP NEP f116 NEP m174 MAX EFFORT MIN EFFORT Effort by fleet, MINEFF vs MAXEFF

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Southern Stocks – Sc2 TAC 2006 (trial runs) MAX EFFORTMIN EFFORT F landings F total

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Southern Stocks – Sc3 Hake recovery plan (trial runs) MAX EFFORTMIN EFFORT

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research F 3 –Southern Stocks - conclusions Single-species TAC are not efficient tools for reducing F. They induce unaccounted fishing mortality and bias in assessment Single species management plans cannot be achieved without considering mixed-fisheries interactions It would be possible to formulate mixed-species TAC by fleet including some management objectives and priorities Mixed-fisheries management should ideally be at the fleet/vessel level, rather than at the fishery or stock level, to account for changes in activity No good input and assessment data – results are only used for demonstration

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research F 3 - Discussion A process model; mathematically simple, transparent.  Assume relationship between F and E, needs reliable single species forecast Uses landings and effort (better use of existing data than MTAC)  Good data requirements. Requires preliminary work to define exhaustive fleets and fisheries Compatible with relative stability  Assumption on fixed quota share allocation between fleets Based on manageable units, links with economics and with effort regulation  Sensitivity to aggregation level and fleet-fisheries definitions? No assumptions on fixed catch composition (only fixed catchability by metier)  Catchability varies between vessels, time period etc. Measured on landings! Can account for finer analyses  More complexity would make it less tractable

Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research F3 – Future developments Needs additional testing and sensitivity analysis Link with economics – relation with the EIAA model used for economic advice How to deal with age-based approach? Improvement of the relationships between effort and mortality : better effort definitions and catchability estimates (cf TECTAC, CAFÉ…) Inclusion of flexibility in effort allocation by fishery – behavioral analysis of metier choice (cf Andersen et al., SFMS 32) Is that of use for management? Can we implement mixed species TACs for the individual fleets?