June 11, 2008 Jennifer Wielinga
Will including weekly mini-lessons about elaboration and supporting details improve student scores on district writing assessments in the sub-category of “Content and Ideas”?
Mini-lessons, presented on a regular basis Topics to include (but not be limited to): 1)Show, Don’t Tell 2)Adding Anecdotes 3)Adding Snapshots 4)Adding Thoughtshots
Still no discernable trend in number of details in daily writing (because they are random?) Increase in # proficient (5-7) I also looked at ALL Q3 scores- 46/75 had proficient subscores More MEANINGFUL practice Different data collection- # of details was hard to measure and didn’t tell me much Start RIGHT AWAY with mini-lessons and workshop structure Incorporate Nancie Atwell mini-lessons also
One of the nine research-based strategies is “homework and practice” Practice should have a clearly articulated purpose and desired outcome Should be focused when students are practicing a complex process, like writing
Burke gives guidelines for effective mini-lessons: Specific Timely Brief but adequate(10-25 minutes) Not isolated: the idea or skill needs to be revisited and reinforced over time Planned ahead Structured Scaffolded Uses student writing whenever possible Interactive Modeled Integrated with assessment
In the context of a writing workshop: Mini-lessons allow flexibility Include teacher modeling Allow opportunity to showcase student work Atwell has found them to be at least as effective as individual conferences