Encouraging families to attend Sure Start: a field experiment Sarah Cotterill, University of Manchester (with Laura Humber, Peter John, Alice Moseley and.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The community Café is open everyday for public use from 9am-1pm. Serving breakfasts, snacks, lunch and refreshments. We can also help with: Sign posting.
Advertisements

Sarah Cotterill, Peter John, Liz Richardson Institute for Political and Economic Governance Presentation to Randomised Controlled.
Sarah Rock Oct Health Visiting in Shropshire Shropshire Community Health NHS Trust North Shropshire South Shropshire Shrewsbury and Atcham North.
Parent-Child Interaction in School Aged Children with SLI. By Jessica Allen & Chloe Marshall.
HOME BASED CARERS (Childminders) Implementing Birth to Three Matters Frame Work.
Engaging Young Parents in Barry Area Gill Joyce – Specialist Midwife for Teenagers Kim Jones – Specialist Flying Start Health Visitor.
Birth - 14 days6-8 weeks2, 3 & 4 monthsPre birth 6 mths -1 year Pregnancy confirmed. Appointment with Midwife at 12 weeks. Other supports HP - smoking.
25 November 2009 WHHT Maternity Services - Overview & Scrutiny Committee Overview & Scrutiny Committee Maternity Services Review Margaret Cronin Head of.
Potential for interventions in the early years to tackle health inequalities Karen MacNee Health ASD.
The Neighbourhood Nursery Initiative – Policy into Practice? Eddie McKinnon, Principal Researcher Pen Green Research, Development and Training Base EECERA.
Palatine Contraception and Sexual Health Service - Newton Heath Children's Centre. Mon/Wed/Thu/Fri 12.30pm -2.30pm Tues - Thu 3.30pm – 6.30pm (Drop-in.
WEST REDCAR COMMUNITY SATISFACTION SURVEY 2004 The survey model, and results obtained NESS North East Workshop 25 June 2004.
Our babies and children education and health our babies and children education and health.
CYP IAPT, MindEd and other opportunities to promote the mental health of young people leaving care Dr Cathy Street, National Children’s Bureau (NCB) Research.
RHEA Phase 1 Storyboard. Purpose This provides a high level overview of the solution, in a simple story format.
Welcome to Sunderland Children’s Centres Volunteer Information Session.
DYKE HOUSE SCHOOL The school at the centre of the community. John R Taylor Deputy Headteacher Hartlepool - England.
Health Visiting and the Healthy Child Programme 0-5
WINNUNGA NIMMITYJAH Wiradjuri language meaning STRONG IN HEALTH.
Creating a service Idea. Creating a service Networking / consultation Identify the need Find funding Create a project plan Business Plan.
Suki Norris/Kristie Hill/Bernice Cooke Somerset Partnership
JOURNAL CLUB U.NIRANJAN ST6 Paediatrics. Article Effectiveness of home based early intervention on children’s BMI at age 2: randomised controlled trial.
Sheffield's 0-5 strategy The best start for Sheffield's Children and Families Briefing event for Governors 11 February 2011.
NEPEAN YOUTH ACCOMMODATION SERVICES Young Parents Program.
Needs Assessment: Young People’s Drug and Alcohol Services in Edinburgh City EADP Children, Young People and Families Network Event 7 th March 2012 Joanne.
Child, Youth and Family Programs. What existed in 2003 Family Resource Centre Family Resource Centre Summer Camp Summer Camp Teen Drop In Teen Drop In.
Real-world effectiveness of nicotine replacement therapy in pregnancy Leonie S. Brose, PhD Andy McEwen, PhD & Robert West, PhD University College London.
Bridlington Children’s Centres Development Plan East Riding Children’s Centres Bridlington “working in partnership”
Objectives 1. Children will be supported in an integrated way through the establishment of a Start Right Community Wrap- Around Programme in the target.
Activities in Burnage – April to June 2015 Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Childminders Drop-in 9.15 a.m. – a.m. (Last Entry a.m.)
Engaging Pregnant Women to Stop Smoking – Creating Effective Referral Pathways and Increasing Quit Rates By Hayley Bates and Catherine Sixsmith.
Growing Up in Scotland: Using the findings in a local context ScotStat Survey Conference 16 th March 2010 Lesley Kelly, GUS Dissemination Officer CRFR,
CHILDREN & YOUNG PEOPLE’S PLAN ‘MAKING A DIFFERENCE IN MEDWAY’ Sally Morris Assistant Director of Commissioning and Strategy NHS Medway/Medway.
Charlestown Sure Start Children’s Centre September to December 2015 Higher Blackley Sure Start Children’s Centre 160 Victoria Avenue Higher Blackley Manchester.
Program 1 Healthy Start, Healthy Life. ‘To enhance the effective implementation of evidence-based techniques, tools and resources that support the delivery.
An Evaluation of the Fathers’ Development Work Programme.
More than a literacy programme— Bookbug is building families Bookbug Assertive Outreach scottishbooktrust.com.
The Health Visitor’s role in Leading the Healthy Child Programme – Health Review 2 Southampton Sue Wierzbicki Locality Lead Co-ordinator – South cluster.
KNOWSLEY YOUNG CARERS PROJECT 68 HILLSIDE ROAD, HUYTON Merseyside L36 8BL
Brief Update 0-19 Prevention Service
Children and Families Network Routine Enquiry About Adversity in Childhood (REACh) REACh Project Lead Lesley M. Banner.
Nottinghamshire Children and Families Partnership (NCFP) Commissioned to provide Children’s Centre services in Nottinghamshire from 1st June 2013.
Healthy Weight Strategy for Nottingham: Sarah Diggle Public Health Development Manager, NHS Nottingham City Chris Wallbanks Healthy Schools Manager,
Domestic abuse – Learning Lessons Sarah Khalil Designated Nurse for Adult Safeguarding.
Delivering cost effective quality services Children’s Integrated Speech and Language Therapy Service for Hackney and the City Annabelle Burns Children’s.
Jane Young Nottinghamshire Children’s Centres Speech and Language Therapy Lead Language For Life Strategy Lead.
Being in Care. Joint priorities remain to… Improve outcomes for children, young people and families in Birmingham. In particular: Protect children from.
National Early Years Conference Edinburgh Conference Centre Heriot Watt Campus October 2010.
IMPROVING THE HEALTH AND WELLBEING OF YOUNG CHILDREN.
Providing World Class Local Community Services Health Visiting – A Call to Action The Health Visitor Implementation Plan Bernice.
The Early Years Service. Working with the Early Years Service Structure of the Early Years Service Regulatory Bodies Early Learning and Childcare and.
Does mobilization increase family engagement with Sure Start? Sarah Cotterill, University of Manchester Peter John, University College London Alice Moseley,
Higher Blackley & Charlestown Summer 2017
Please contact us on Phone:
What’s Burnage Sure Start October-December 2016
Baby One Program: Delivering preventative primary health care to young families in Cape York Indigenous communities.
What’s Levenshulme Sure Start Oct-Dec 2017
What’s Burnage Sure Start Oct-Dec 2017
Higher Blackley & Charlestown Autumn/Winter 2016/7
Please contact us on Phone:
RHEA Phase 1 Storyboard.
What’s Burnage Sure Start July- September 2016
Higher Blackley & Charlestown Autumn/Winter 2017
+ Contextualised ESOL course developed by Shipley as part of EIF – 3 year project in Bfd. Health literacy. 10 hour course, 5 sessions + regular stork walks.
Please contact us on Phone:
What’s Levenshulme Sure Start Oct-Dec 2017
What’s Burnage Sure Start January-March 2018
Please contact us on Phone:
What’s Burnage Sure Start April-June 2019
Presentation transcript:

Encouraging families to attend Sure Start: a field experiment Sarah Cotterill, University of Manchester (with Laura Humber, Peter John, Alice Moseley and James Rees) The Manchester Women’s Conference. Evidence into Practice: Promoting mental health and wellbeing for mothers and families, 23 rd June 2011

Contents Manchester Sure Start. How families find out about Sure Start. Who attends Sure Start? Recent research with Manchester City Council: can doorstep visits or leaflets encourage families to attend?

Manchester Sure Start Services for all Manchester families, pre-birth and up to age 5. Emphasis on early engagement. 40 Sure Start centres. Sure Start services in libraries, community centres, schools, health, private nurseries. Variety of provision, tailored to local needs. Services for all, combined with targeted support for vulnerable families.

Manchester Sure Start - activities Services vary from centre to centre, but can include ….. Day nursery; creche. Child Health – antenatal care, baby clinics, parent preparation classes, health checks, immunisations… Play sessions – various, for variety of ages. Adult education – e.g. numeracy, English as a second language.

Manchester Sure Start - activities Babies – new baby group, rhyme & sign, baby massage, breast is best. Toddlers – busy bodies. Pre-school preparation. Parenting – e.g. early years survival course, dads and dudes, young parents group. Childminder drop-in. Adult health – counselling, smoking cessation, self esteem.

How do families find out about Sure Start in Manchester? Family and friends - word of mouth. NHS appointments - antenatal, baby clinics, health checks etc. Midwives, health visitors, other professionals. Birth registration. Day care enquiries. Promotion & outreach. Publicity & web pages.

Manchester Sure Start – Who attends? Register of births: 8,347 children born in Manchester during the 18 months up to September ,903 families (59%) already registered. 3,444 families (41%) not registered with Sure Start. We find only small differences between registered and non-registered families: No difference in mean age or sex of child; Families from deprived neighbourhoods are more likely to register.

Manchester Sure Start – Who attends? Mother’s place of birth Registered with Sure Start Not registered with Sure Start Total families Manchester38%37%3,121 Outside Europe34% 2,840 Rest of UK16%13%1,204 Gtr Manchester6% 486 Europe – non UK6%9%593 Total families4,9033,444 (Mother’s place of birth missing for 103 families)

Research Study Randomised Controlled Trial in partnership with Manchester City Council.

Objectives The primary research objective is to test the randomised controlled trial method as a tool to evaluate local authority interventions and services. The second objective is to evaluate the effectiveness of home visits and leaflets on the take up of Sure Start services: Is a visit from an outreach worker providing verbal and written information about Sure Start more effective than written information alone or the usual service in encouraging attendance at Sure Start?

Background Doorstep visits have been shown to be effective in Get Out the Vote campaigns (John & Brannan 2008; Gerber & Green 2008). Leaflets can also be effective. Doorstep visits found to raise household recycling rates (Cotterill et al 2009); Can visits and leaflets raise take-up of a local service?

Study Methods The research took place in Manchester in October 2010 It included all households with a child aged 0-18 months that were not already using Sure Start services. Manchester City Council researchers identified families from the register of births and checked against the Sure Start e-Start database. 3,444 families took part in the study. (Ardwick, Hulme and West Didsbury excluded).

Experimental Design Households were randomly assigned to one of three groups: Visit Group - Outreach staff from the local Sure Start Centre undertook short doorstep visits to provide information about local Sure Start services and encourage families to attend. Contact rate = 168 out of 363 families (46.3%). Leaflet Group - The A5 sized leaflet encouraged families to call into a Sure Start Centre and find out about the range of opportunities available. Control Group - Families in the control group received the usual service.

Randomisation and Power Visit group 363 families. Leaflet group 625 families. Control Group 2,456 families. Total 3,444 families. Adequate statistical power to detect a difference of 5% between visit and control, and a difference of 3% between leaflet and control group. After randomisation, the characteristics of the three groups were similar. Randomisation done by York Trials Unit.

Study implementation Families in the treatment groups received the usual service plus either a leaflet or a visit. The usual service comprises all the ways families might find out about Sure Start centres, including word of mouth, invitations to health sessions, birth registration, referrals from professionals, and promotional activity. The usual service varies between Sure Start Centres and between families. Sure Start centres monitored attendance by families over a five-week period in October – November Using these attendance records, we were able to compare attendance between the visit, leaflet and control groups.

CHILD 0-18 MTHS, NOT REGISTERED ON E-START 3,444 households CONTROL GRP 2,456 households VISIT GRP 363 households CONTROL 168 VISITS (46% visited) ATTENDANCE 31 (8.5%) ATTENDANCE 195 (7.9%) LEAFLET GRP 625 households 19 leaflets returned (97% received) ATTENDANCE 61 (9.8%) Sure Start RCT – Flow Diagram

Results The effect of the treatments on attendance at Sure Start Control Group Visit Group Leaflet Group Total Attended Sure Start 7.9% % % % 287 Total Number of Families 2, ,444

Findings Visits: The treatment effect for visits is 0.6%, with a 95% confidence interval from -2.5% to 3.7%. The study indicates that home visits, of the type conducted in this study, are not an effective way of promoting Sure Start to families who are not already engaged: the effect of the visits was not significantly different to the effect of the usual service.

Findings Leaflets: The treatment effect for leaflets is 1.8, with a 95% confidence interval of to 4.38 (p < 0.1). Results suggest leaflets have a small effect on attendance at Sure Start. We used a A5 leaflet with simple design and generic message – addressed, but without the family name.

Summary Sure Start in Manchester attracts a cross section of families in terms of child’s age & sex and mother’s place of birth. It attracts more families from deprived areas. Register of births can be used to identify families to target for Sure Start. Brief doorstep visits not shown to be an effective way to promote Sure Start. Leaflets have a small effect in raising attendance.