Complexity, individuation and function in ecology Part II, sec 3 Emergence in ecosystems and ecosystem levels Prof. John Collier

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Sustainable Communities Workshop Eight Principles Relating to Ecological Sustainability Alan Haney.
Advertisements

Theories, Values and Perspectives of Macro Social Work Generalist Macro Practice Generalist Macro Practice.
Phantom Limb Phenomena. Hand movement observation by individuals born without hands: phantom limb experience constrains visual limb perception. Funk M,
Earth as a System Chapter 3. I.General Info A. System - a set of components that function together as a whole (e.g. human body, a city, etc.) B. Earth.
Participatory Simulation & Emergent Behavior Author : Uri Wilensky Presenter : Krunal Doshi.
1 Predator-Prey Oscillations in Space (again) Sandi Merchant D-dudes meeting November 21, 2005.
LINEAR REGRESSION MODEL
Global Thinking Measurement and Development Marina P. Bonser, PhD.
Transport phenomena in chemical processes part II Michał Araszkiewicz PhD.
15 The Nature of Communities. 15 The Nature of Communities Case Study: “Killer Algae!” What Are Communities? Community Structure Interactions of Multiple.
System Theory A quick look at systems. General Systems Theory Ludwig von Bertalanffy Peter Checkland General Systems Theory: There are parallels found.
Ecological-Evolutionary Theory Who gets what and why?
Boyce/DiPrima 9th ed, Ch 11.2: Sturm-Liouville Boundary Value Problems Elementary Differential Equations and Boundary Value Problems, 9th edition, by.
The Conceptual Framework Lecture 8 1. Organization of this lecture Conceptual Framework: Role of the Conceptual Framework Theory: Source of Conceptual.
Syntax.
Lecture 10 Energy production. Summary We have now established three important equations: Hydrostatic equilibrium: Mass conservation: Equation of state:
The Dynamical Basis of Social Emergence John Collier Philosophy, University of KwaZulu-Natal Bertalanffy.
1.1 Biotic and Abiotic Factors in Ecosystems (sec 2.1 pg 21-24)
Two Dimensions and Beyond From: “ A New Kind of Science” by Stephen Wolfram Presented By: Hridesh Rajan.
Application of Methods of Queuing Theory to Scheduling in GRID A Queuing Theory-based mathematical model is presented, and an explicit form of the optimal.
Biodiversity. Are communities saturated? A closed system must balance the gains in energy from net production with those taken by consumers and decomposers.
ASCENDENCY Scharler, U.M.; University of KawZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa PETRA MAKORIČ March, 2015.
Infrastructure Development Challenges for Young Professionals? 22 November 2013 Didibhuku Wellington Thwala Department of Construction Management and Quantity.
Spatial Interaction & Spatial Behavior. -- Why do goods/people move from place to place? -- Personal examples of your “spatial interaction”? spatial interaction.
Two notions of biological hierarchy John Collier University of KwaZulu-Natal
Are genes signs and if so what are they signs of? John Collier Philosophy, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban 4041 South Africa
Department of Mechanical Engineering ME 322 – Mechanical Engineering Thermodynamics Lecture 3 Thermodynamic Concepts.
FUNCTIONAL COMPONENTS AS A BASIS FOR COMPLEX SYSTEM DESCRIPTION: SOME EXAMPLES AND DISCUSSION. D. C. Mikulecky Professor Emeritus and Senior Fellow  Center.
Mader: Biology 8 th Ed. A View of Life Chapter 1 Assignment # 2.
Information Can Preserve Structure Across Scientific Revolutions John Collier Philosophy and Ethics University of KwaZulu-Natal
Study Questions: 1) Define biology and science.. Study Questions: 1)Define biology and science. - Biology: The scientific study of living systems - Science:
Crosscutting Concepts Next Generation Science Standards.
EM 4103 Urban Planning II Lecture 9: Overview on Models in Planning and Use in Retail Planning.
To achieve a level 3 your work must show that: With some help you can gather information to help with designing your project You can draw suitable ideas.
Chapter 2 Human System Perspectives. Theoretical Frameworks for Practice Theories about human systems Theories and models of change No one practice framework.
TOWARDS THE EVALUATION OF THE SUSTAINABILITY OF A REGION, TAKING DIFFERENT SUSTAINABILITY CRITERIA INTO ACCOUNT. Bàrbara Sureda J.J. de Felipe Josep Xercavins.
Unit 1: Planetary Systems: Quest for Balance What is a system? - interdependency - impact of change on a system - our needs within a system - dynamics.
1 William P. Cunningham University of Minnesota Mary Ann Cunningham Vassar College Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for.
Project funded by the Future and Emerging Technologies arm of the IST Programme FET-Open scheme Project funded by the Future and Emerging Technologies.
H ij Entangle- ment flow multipartite systems [1] Numerically computed times assuming saturated rate equations, along with the lower bound (solid line)
1 William P. Cunningham University of Minnesota Mary Ann Cunningham Vassar College Chapter 02 Lecture Outline Copyright © McGraw-Hill Education. All rights.
Round Tables and Discussions Experiment + Theory + Numerical Simulations How to stay connected to reality?
FW364 Ecological Problem Solving Class 17: Spatial Structure October 30, 2013.
© 2014 Carl Lund, all rights reserved A First Course on Kinetics and Reaction Engineering Class 1.
Global Protected Areas Programme Protected areas.... Achieving quality.
Infrastructure planning in the UK – old and new stories November 2010.
Canonical Equations of Motion -- Hamiltonian Dynamics
2 Climate variability - change in average, variation, and/or extreme values.
Emergy & Complex Systems Day 2, Lecture 4…. Dynamic Emergy Accounting Simulation of emergy and transformity, network analysis of emergy, case studies.
Projection and the Reality of Routines – reflections of a computational modeller Bruce Edmonds Centre for Policy Modelling Manchester Metropolitan University.
Productivity and Quality Management Fifth Lecture.
1. How Biotic & Abiotic Factors influence the Biosphere/Ecosystem? 2. What impact Biotic & Abiotic factors have on biodiversity?
The Problem of Pattern and Scale in Ecology - Summary What did this paper do that made it a citation classic? 1.It summarized a large body of work on spatial.
Spring ÇGIE lecture 41 lecture 4: complexity simple systems, complex systems –parallel developments that are joining together: systems literature.
Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display. Chapter 1 Lecture Slides.
Complexity, individuation and function in ecology Part I, sec 1 Complexity and Organization Prof. John Collier (Departamento.
Dark Energy: Why Go Further Steven M. Kahn Stanford U./SLAC.
Complexity, individuation and function in ecology Part II, sec 1 Complexity in ecosystems, systems ecology Prof. John Collier
Methods of multivariate analysis Ing. Jozef Palkovič, PhD.
Complexity, individuation and function in ecology Part II, sec 4 Ecosystem Functionality Prof. John Collier (Departamento de.
Complexity, individuation and function in ecology Part II, sec 2 Individuation of ecosystems, stability, resilience Prof. John Collier
Sustainable Communities Workshop
Semester 4 - Chapter 3 – WAN Design
Community Ecology.
Chapter 02 Lecture Outline
Chapter 02 Lecture Outline
Synthesis of SISO Controllers
Chapter 1: Statistical Basis of Thermodynamics
Principles of Science and Systems
Chapter 02 Lecture Outline
Presentation transcript:

Complexity, individuation and function in ecology Part II, sec 3 Emergence in ecosystems and ecosystem levels Prof. John Collier (Departamento de Filosofia, Universidade de Kwazulu-Natal, África do Sul. Pesquisador Visitante do Laboratório de Ensino, Filosofia e História das Ciências (LEFHBio), Programa Ciência sem Fronteiras)

Outline Why we should expect emergent properties in ecosystems. Nesting of ecosystems – Do larger ecosystems emerge from smaller ones? – How are boundaries established? Levels of ecosystem properties – Macro and micro, intensive and extensive – Properties, their components and property fusion

Emergence in ecosystems Ecosystems are complexly organized (type IV) systems with flows and constraints. They also have an overhead (if healthy) which is uncommitted information. This permits self-organization incorporaiting some of the information in the overhead through including it in the forces and flows that contribute to system ascendency.

Emergence in networks My previous (Part I) account of emergence works most obviously for purely physical systems in which we can determine from the dynamics that they are radically non-Hamiltonian. Similar conditions in which work is done by the system on its boundary conditions was hypothesized to underlie other forms of self-organization. The problem is finding the correct dynamics for this to happen. Stable networks can be analyzed by traditional methods although they may be emergent and have emergent components. Emergence, necessarily, occurs in networks only when the number of nodes changes. Ulanowicz has developed a general theory of emergence in networks based on his approach to growth and development. However it gives only the conditions in which emergence is possible in a network, not a test for its existence.

Ulanowicz’ approach Ulanowicz uses a modification of MacArthur’s approach to the diversity of flow through a system’s pathways using his idea of total system throughput (for what the kind of throughput is relevant). Q i is T i /T, the probability of the rate of unit flow through the ith component of the system. K is an arbitrary constant. C is then the diversity of throughputs.

Growth and Development C as defined does not take into consideration network growth and development. Scale can be provided by setting K to T, the total system throughput. We also need to include the probability of a given rate of throughput between nodes, f ij : A is just the network ascendency. C > A > 0.

Recall that

Conditions for self-organization A = C – (S+E+R), in other words, the uncommitted capacity, though that can be increased through efficiency increase (-S and/or -E) or a reduction in redundancy (R). A is power if the units are energy. This gives the analogy to the physical case a stronger basis. (Think also about the economic case in which the flow is money.) Emergence can occur via organization within the overhead, which would produce new nodes (routes via which power or some other system product K) flows. This can be non-local (probably will be), but the treatment in terms of information theory avoids that issue. It might be interesting for other reasons, though. Emergence is an increase in system ascendency, typically through either greater T or an increase in some of the f ij.

Interior versus holistic emergence New phenomena can emerge at various scales. This can create sub-ecosystems, for example the invasion of termites that form a new mound with its own microclimate. But new phenomena can also emerge in the whole system, for example the self-sustaining rainfall of the Amazon rain forest. In both cases, however, the new phenomena can be treated as network nodes due to the mathematical magic of information theory.

Termite mounds

Convectional rainfall (Amazon)

Nesting of ecosystems New ecosystems can emerge within existing ones at a smaller spatial scale, but a larger scale than their previous component nodes. An example might be a termite mound (see above). New ecosystems can invade and establish themselves within larger ecosystems. This might be a reducible process, but if it is emergent it is of the previous type. This can occur at any number of levels. However, the boundary conditions of the new system must be compatible with its role as a node in the larger ecosystem. This gives us some way to identify ecosystem levels: some sub ecosystems act as nodes in a larger ecosystem network. We could include all their nodes in the network, but if it is possible not to without changing overall values, then they are somewhat independent. We would expect, then, that they have well-formed boundaries.

Boundary example, community criterion Generally when there are clear ecosystem boundaries only one criterion might be dominant, but this does not necessarily mean that there is only one applicable metamodel. One example is the separation of communities by in river gorges separated by difficult to traverse mountains. This keeps the communities and largely the populations separate physically. Note that cyclic, developmental (succession), physical constraints and evolutionary issues will still be involved in defining the ecosystem. However, the clear community boundary makes this less of an issue.

Intensive and extensive properties Like any other dynamical system, an ecosystem has various intensive (local) and extensive (global) properties. Unlike in classical thermodynamics, these are not measures of static quantities, but of flows and (possibly changing) constraints. Extensive: T, A, C, S, E, R Intensive: the various ij terms. Both can be measured, but measurement of both is required to get accurate diversity measures to put into Ulanowicz’ equations.

Properties and property components; fusion I will talk about this more in the final lecture, but properties also have components, not just objects. In a process oriented approach we just have nodes as objects, but they are defined by their interactions. So property structure becomes important, especially if we want to identify functional properties. When properties act together dynamically the original parts are constrained such the there is a new property that is called the fusion of the properties. Fused properties are real, their dynamical components are abstractions (consider the combination of gravitational and electromagnetic forces, for example).