MAP Assembly Investigation A project summary for discussion during 4/11/2014 meeting.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
ZTF Mechanical Walkthrough Matthew Hoff ZTF Technical Meeting 1.
Advertisements

FEA Reference Guide See additional material herehere.
ModICE Modular Integrated Connector Enclosure
Click on this image to open the full PDF document.
Lucas Air Mass Meter Stripdown sequence and technical information.
Joseph Epperson, Materials Group Chairman Metallurgical Findings.
1 Bolts in Tension pt1 Andrei Lozzi. The flanges at the end of the two turbine shafts seen above, are bolted together to form a very rigid friction coupling.
MP Prototype 2 1IWF-EXP/ÖAW GRAZ  Smaller Size  Outcome of the test results with MP-P1 was the need for a reduced cross section  Rectangular Shaped.
Longitudinal Expansion of RFQ Vane Ends at Section-to-Section Interface.
D. Peterson, “LC-TPC LP endplate”, LC-TPC group meeting at ALCPG07, 21-October Discussion for the LP endplate See also:
Screws, Fasteners, and the Design of Nonpermanent Joints
Progress on the MICE 201 MHz Cavity Design Steve Virostek Lawrence Berkeley National Lab RF Working Group Fermilab August 22, 2007  automatic.
MICE RFCC Module Update Allan DeMello Lawrence Berkeley National Lab MICE CM26 at Riverside California March 26, 2010.
NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION– INDUSTRY/UNIVERSITY COOPERATIVE RESEARCH CENTER Dimensional Measurement and Control in Manufacturing COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING,
FE calculations for the bolted helium vessel May 6th 2015
Screws, Fasteners, and the Design of Nonpermanent Joints
Lathe.
Influence of the Gravity, Vacuum and RF on CLIC Module T0 Behavior R. Raatikainen.
Ken YoussefiMechanical Engineering Dept., SJSU 1 Introduction to Fundamentals of Assembly.
Allan DeMello Lawrence Berkeley National Lab RFCC Module Design Review October 21, 2008 RFCC Module and Subcomponents Mechanical Design.
SLAC workshop 7-10 July 2009 WP1: microwave-based accelerators Progress towards a new standard X-band high-power flange G. Riddone, (contribution.
NCSX Vacuum Vessel Joint Design Mike Viola PPPL July 1 st, 2003.
13-3 Powder Metallurgy -the process of making parts by compressing & sintering various metallic and nonmetallic powders into shape Briquetting machines-
GLAST LAT ProjectDOE/NASA Mechanical Systems Peer Review, March 27, 2003 Document: LAT-PR-0XXXX Section 5.1 Grid Box Design 1 GLAST Large Area Telescope:
RFCC Module Design Update  automatic tuners  cavity suspension  cavity installation Steve Virostek Lawrence Berkeley National Lab MICE Collaboration.
PETS EuCARD. Present status and precision assembly L. Sánchez, F. Aragón, J. Calero, J.L. Gutiérrez, E. Rodríguez, F. Toral, CIEMAT 26/10/2011.
1 LARP Phase II Secondary Rotatable Collimator Evolution of design changes 3 rd March, 2010.
Modular Coil Assembly Bolted Joint PDR 2/22/07. Objectives The review objectives include... Define the location of additional inboard bolts Finalize the.
1 HER Arc RF seals M. Sullivan MAC Review Oct , 2006 Status of HER Arc RF Seals M. Sullivan For the PEP-II team Machine Advisory Committee Review.
SLAC RC Status Report 30 August 2010 LHC Collimation Working Group Meeting Tom Markiewicz/SLAC BNL - FNAL- LBNL - SLAC US LHC Accelerator Research Program.
Copyright  2012 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd PPTs t/a Engineering Drawing 8e by Boundy 10-1 Chapter Ten Drawing Analysis.
Comparing 2D and 3D Structural Analysis Workshop 4.2.
Lower Structure Revised Catcher. Catcher Mechanism The lever arm is adjusted so that the clamp is at its full height above the mass. An Allen key is.
DPT 312 METROLOGY CHAPTER 3 MEASUREMENT AND TOLERANCES
1 Bolts in Tension pt1 Andrei Lozzi. The flanges at the end of the two turbine shafts seen above, are bolted together to form a very rigid friction coupling.
An Analysis of Shell Structure for Dead Load H.M. Fan PPPL September 16, 2005.
Mass Simulator Concepts Robert Besuner 12 October 2005.
Grapple Housing Top Sub Grapple Collet Seal Housing Bottom Sub Seal Housing Metal Seal Ring.
Main features of PETS tank J. Calero, D. Carrillo, J.L. Gutiérrez, E. Rodríguez, F. Toral CERN, 17/10/2007 (I will review the present status of the PETS.
Nonlinear Analyses of Modular Coils and Shell structure for Coil Cool-down and EM Loads Part 1 – Results of Shell Structure and Modular Coils H.M. Fan.
Andrew Biehl.  The objective of this project is to develop a method for determining the nut factor of a bolted joint using the finite element method.
Learning Objectives • Create sweep features. • Create lofted features.
CHAPTER TWO : Geometric Tolerances
MICE RFCC Module Update Steve Virostek Allan DeMello Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory MICE CM27 at RAL, UK July 8, 2010.
SEPT 20, 2006 T. Brown, M. Cole, P. Fogarty, P. Goranson, K. Freudenberg, D. Williamson NCSX STAGE 2 COIL TO COIL ASSY.
D. Peterson, for discussion of LC-TPC LP, interface of Endplate and Field cage, Discussion of the LP endplate and field cage geometry A version.
Train Body The next series of slides will guide you through the construction of the train body. Start a new drawing and save it as Train Body.
LARP LHC PHASE II COLL RC1 TESTS - S. Lundgren 30 Jan 2007 No 1 /13 LARP Phase II Secondary Collimator RC1 Collimator Development and Test Program Status.
Composite Joining Techniques: Bolted Joints LBNL Composites Workshop February 29-March 3, 2016.
Comparing 2D and 3D Structural Analysis Winter Semester
Introduction to mechanical design of the SPES RFQ Ferrari Luigi, Technical Review, 09/21/15 Design review, 09/21/20151.
ME 307 Machine Design I ME 307 Machine Design I. ME 307 Machine Design I ME 307 Machine Design I 8-1 Thread Standards and Definitions 8-2The Mechanics.
Bolt Pretension with Contact. Nonlinear Structural Analysis Goals Goal: – In this workshop our goal is to investigate the behavior of the pipe clamp assembly.
Prototype Cryomodule FDR Ken Premo 21 – 22 January 2015 High Power Coupler Design.
طراحی اتصالات Joints design. انواع وسائل ايجاد اتصال.
Radiation Shutter Re-Purposing Roy Preece STFC RAL 18 th December 2014.
Elasto - plastic behavior of beam-to- column connections with fillets of steel bridge frame piers.
Assembly of the doorknob
CANTY QUICKPORTS™ “How they work”
Discussion for the LP endplate
Geometric Dimensioning and Tolerancing
Fasteners, Powers Screws, Connections
23 April 2012 Tom Markiewicz/SLAC
Welcome! Drafting 2323: Pipe Drafting
Gaskets and Packing An introduction to Gaskets Packing
LARP Phase II Secondary Collimator RC-1
Strathclyde gun bead-pull results
Part II Design of Fasteners and Joints
Pipe fitting Threads on pipe fittings are tapered and rely on the stress generated by forcing the tapered threads of the male half of the fitting.
SNS PPU CRYOMODULE PDR Cleanroom Assembly Katherine Wilson
Presentation transcript:

MAP Assembly Investigation A project summary for discussion during 4/11/2014 meeting

Summary During assembly and RF test it was noted that the cavities behavior was not as designed, and varied with changes in end plate fastener torque. – For details of the behavior, see the summary by Daniel Bowring Priorities for recovery of the modular cavity 3/24/14 A meeting was held on 4/2/2014 to discuss the current findings, the proposed actions, and prioritize those actions agreed upon.

Planned Actions for SLAC In simplified form – Measure flange distortion as clamped – Measure flange distortion assembled but with relaxed fasteners – Remove one end plate Visually examine installed end plate, try to obtain photos, perhaps using borescope – Cause no harm during inspection – Remove other endplate and: Measure cavity flanges Endplate flatness and RF contact features Take photos – Prepare gaskets of fully annealed copper (~.03” thick) Provide details so that the geometry can be simulated if desired – Assemble and cold test w/o the helicoflex vacuum gaskets – Review results establish additional steps as needed Defer adapter and window tests until the soft gasket assembly cold tests are reviewed.

Results and Proposed Plan Revisions A summary of measurements are presented on the next few slides The measurements are followed by some mechanical simulation results Discussion of next steps sequence/schedule of work etc. is then open for discussion

Review of Existing Geometry Note key points

View of Assy

Measurements of Clamped Assembly Datum Structure established as shown

Distance to Face of Water Rings Nominal 1.5” spacing measures flat w/in.007 on one end and flat w/in.003” on the other

Distance to Cavity and Clamp Flanges The measurement is somewhat compromised by the tapered distortion and probe access but roughly the dimensions are: measures measures to 2.912

Profile along outside of Clamped Flanges CMM measurements confirm significant flange distortion Image shows OD of cavity “flange” on the lower left and the OD and end face of the clamp ring (called “endplate”) The red lines show deviation from a perfect cylinder with perpendicular end face (shown in black) The ~.015” of flex over ~1” of end plate indicates ~1° of flex

Profile along outside of Released Flanges CMM measurements confirm significant plastic distortion Image shows OD of cavity “flange” on the lower left and the OD and end face of the clamp ring (called “endplate”) The red lines show deviation from a perfect cylinder with perpendicular end face (shown in black) The roughly.005” over 1” on the end plane indicates ~.3° residual flex

Flange Contact Feature Measurement The profile of the cavity flange was measured at several points around the circumference Measurements are consistent with a expected plastic deformation

Circumferential Distortion The flange rotation is constrained at the two support arm attachment points resulting in “problematic” local distortion

End Plate RF contact marks Will need to obtain stylus measurements and high magnification images Inspection by loupe reveals variation and areas of little/no? marking

Mechanical Simulations Initial simple model to see how bad things were RF and Helicoflex loads applied as pressures on annular areas Clamp bolt load applied as a traction load on the flange bolt holes, so the model doesn’t account for clamp bolt bending stiffness which would lessen the flange rotation Very large flange rotation that would completely unload RF seal

Diagnostic Assembly Desire is to verify system geometry and RF “seal” Approach is to reduce the required flange loads by assembling with a “soft” RF gasket and without the Helicoflex vacuum seal Concerns include: – We don’t know precisely the relationship between clamp conditions and cavity performance (low pressure, periodic opens, fissures, etc.) – We do have some experience with clamped cavities and do “know” that the transition from quite poor contact to design contact can occur rather suddenly implying that relatively small contact deficiencies are significant – Want very compliant RF gasket, thickness is limited to ~.04” thick – Maximum variation for RF seal is still a maximum of ~.007” (probably considerably less) – Variation at support ties may be very significant. It is conceivable that that local variation in stiffness is a “spoiler” – We will be clamping to RF performance with still very springy components.

Potential Solution After considering various constraints a possible solution was simulated Stiffen the cavity flange with external rings pre-clamped to the cavity flange, separate clamp bolts to close the end plates – This works very well with only RF contact loads – Simulation shows that this approach is limited by the 24 available cavity ring threaded holes. Significant improvement may be made by welding a stiffener ring to the cavity flange – The approach is detailed in the following slides Two rings: – Extender ring welded at ID to existing flange – Clamp ring bolted through extender to existing flange 24x and to extender ring 24x – RF contact and Helicoflex joints closed with 48 clamp screws bearing against the back of the cavity end plate – OD of new rings extended to keep joint between the extender and clamp rings closed under the cavity end plate clamping reaction

Axial Displacement (Uy)

Contact surfaces remain closed (good)

Pre-weld test assembly with RF contact pressure only

Pre-weld test assembly with RF and Helicoflex contact pressure

Open Discussion Add notes