Ethics in Research A class discussion. What is Ethics in Research? and Why is it Important?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
INFORMED CONSENT IN BIO-MEDICAL RESEARCH INVOLVING HUMAN PARTICIPANTS Selina khatun MPH, Mphil Lecturer(Anatomy Department) MMC.
Advertisements

Susan Sonne, PharmD, BCPP Chair, MUSC IRB II
Ethical Principles in Human Subject Research
UH employees and students who conduct research involving human subjects are required to obtain approval from the Committee on Human Studies (CHS). John.
THE ETHICS OF HUMAN PARTICIPANT RESEARCH Office for Research Protections The Pennsylvania State University.
ICH GCP, the MHRA and PATHOLOGY PATHOLOGY QUALITY ASSURANCE Rob Wosley MRQA SEPTEMBER 2009.
Human Subjects Review The Evergreen State College Historical overview Codes and principles Categories of applications Review criteria Application processing.
How the Past Influenced Human Research Protection Regulations Shirley J. Hicks Director, Division of Education and Development Office for Human Research.
Detectives in the Classroom - Investigation 2-3: What's Wrong with This Picture? What's Wrong with This Picture?
FOUNDATIONS OF NURSING RESEARCH Sixth Edition CHAPTER Copyright ©2012 by Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Foundations of Nursing Research,
History and Ethical Principles
Ethics in Research involving Human Subjects Dr. Walid S. Abdelkader Head of Preventive Medicine and Primary Care Division IMC Feb
DO THE CODES APPLY TO MY RESEARCH?
Ethics In Scientific Research 12 th Feb 2014 Dr Fergal Grace.
Office of Research Integrity Assurance All rights reserved GTRC Presented by Georgia Institute of Technology Institutional Review Board Presented by Melanie.
IRB Discussion Consent and Assent Issues in Vulnerable Populations December
RESEARCH ETHICS 1.Violation of research ethics: History of violations of research ethics date back to 1930’s 1932 Tuskegee syphilis study conducted by.
1 Wheaton College INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARD (IRB)
A History of Human Research Protections and Institutional Review Boards Roger L. Bertholf, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Pathology Chair, University of.
Historical backgrounds of WHY U.S. regulations cover biomedical and social behavior Melody Lin, Ph.D. Deputy Director, Office for Human Research Protections.
BIOE 301 Lecture Eleven. Summary of Lecture 10 Difficulties associated with HIV vaccine: Many forms of the virus Virus mutates rapidly Virus attacks the.
Regulatory Authority Governing Clinical Trials Anthony J. Minisi, MD Director, Cardiology Fellowship Program.
Ethics In Research: Duties, Decisions and Dilemmas Colleen M. Gallagher, PhD, FACHE Chief & Executive Director Section of Integrated Ethics Associate Professor,
1 Copyright © 2011 by Saunders, an imprint of Elsevier Inc. Chapter 4 Examining Ethics in Nursing Research.
ADDRESSING BAD RESEARCH Rels 300 / Nurs October 2014.
Ethical Concerns in Research
INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARD HISTORY AND ETHICS. 2 Ethical History : Holocaust : Nuremburg Trials 1964: Declaration of Helsinki :
Human Subjects’ Research. Learning Objectives Discuss key ethical concerns The role of the IRB Principles and origin of Belmont Report Principle of informed.
HUMAN RESEARCH HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE. Objectives Identify the history events that lead to the development of principles, regulations, and guidance.
Supporting the Needs of Human Subjects in Research Carol Johnston, Chair, Bioscience IRB Mark Roosa, Chair, Social Behavioral IRB.
1 HUMAN RESEARCH PROTECTIONS Daniel R. Vasgird, PhD, CIP Office of Research Compliance West Virginia University (304)
Responsible Conduct in Research Fred Lombardo, Pharm.D.,MS Howard University.
Placebo-Controls in Short-Term Clinical Trials of Hypertension Sana Al-Khatib, MD, MHS Assistant Professor of Medicine Division of Cardiology Duke University.
© 2009 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. Clinical Research.
Research Methods Leadership 389.
Legal & Ethical Issues. Objectives At the completion of this session the participant will be able to: ◦ Describe the ethical principles associated with.
Institutional Review Board (IRB) What is our Purpose and Role for Ethical Research.
TERRENCE F. ACKERMAN, PH.D. PROFESSOR OF BIOETHICS CHAIR, UTHSC IRB.
Ethics Ethics Applied to Research. Ethics in Nursing Research Scientific Misconduct – a fabrication, falsification, plagiarism or other practice that.
The ethical conduct of research with human participants Nancy E. Kass, ScD Department of Health Policy and Management Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of.
Human Subjects Research at ASU An Overview. Overview Definitions Historical Framework Federal Guidelines Human Subjects Research at ASU.
Chapter 5 Conducting & Reading Research Baumgartner et al Chapter 5 Ethical Concerns in Research.
Research Ethics. Ethics From the Greek word, “Ethos” meaning character From the Greek word, “Ethos” meaning character Implies a judgment of character.
Research Ethics.
Ethics Ethics Applied to Research Back to Class 2.
The Ethics of Research on Human Subjects. Research Activity on Human Subjects: Any systematic attempt to gain generalizable knowledge about humans A systematic.
ETHICS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE RESEARCH
PA Profession ETHICS COMMITTEE RIGHT TO REFUSE TREATMENT Salvatore Barese, PA-C.
Consent Procedures. What is Informed Consent? Consent by a patient to a surgical or medical procedure or participation in a clinical study after achieving.
Unless otherwise noted, the content of this course material is licensed under a Creative Commons 3.0 License.
What Institutional Researchers Should Know about the IRB Susan Thompson Senior Research Analyst Office of Institutional Research Presented at the Texas.
A History of Unethical Research. In the USA, before the Pure Food and Drug Act was passed in 1906 there were no regulations on performing research on.
Objective 9/23/15 Today we will be completing our research methods unit & begin reviewing for the upcoming unit assessment 9/25. Agenda: -Turn in all homework.
Chapter 10 Research in the Schools: Ethical-Legal Issues Jacob, Decker, & Hartshorne 1.
Beyond Regulations: Ethical Considerations in Research
Chapter 5 Ethical Concerns in Research. Historical Perspective on Ethics Nazi Experimentation in WWII –“medical experiments” –Nuremberg War Crime Trials.
Pediatric Research Ethics and the Research Subject Advocate Tomas Jose Silber, MD, MASS RSA and Director, Office of Ethics, CNMC Professor of Pediatrics,
Historical Origins of Institutional Review Boards and Human Research Protections Susan M. Loess-Perez, MS, CIP, CCRC, Director of Research Compliance Office.
PRIMER: Human Subjects, Past, Present, and Future Susan Metosky, Arizona State University Debra Murphy, Arizona State University.
Lifespan 1 Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) and Human Subjects Research Protection Programs (HRPP)
Principles for the Protection of Human Rights Beneficence Primary goal of health care as doing good for clients under our care. Good care requires that.
CLINICAL TRIALS.
Examining Ethics in Nursing Research
Gulu University Research Workshop
Research Methods Leadership 389.
Mary Travis Director of Research Compliance
ETHICAL ASPECTS OF HEALTH RESEARCH
Research, Experimentation, & Clinical Trials
Ethics of human research
Presentation transcript:

Ethics in Research A class discussion

What is Ethics in Research? and Why is it Important?

Informed Consent Cases/Studies Tuskegee Syphilis Study ( ) Patients left with untreated syphilis for decades Nazi Medical War Crimes ( ) Physician-conducted experiments especially harmful to subjects Cold War Human Radiation Experiments ( ) Radiation Experiments on US Citizens The Wichita Jury Study (1955) Audiotaped Jury Deliberation Milgram Studies of Obedience to Authority (1960s) People do cruel and unethical things when authority tells them to Thalidomide Experience (1962) Birth defects in pregnant women Jewish Chronic Disease Hospital Study (1963) Live cancer cells injected into chronically ill patients Willbrook Hepatitis Study ( ) Infected mentally ill children with hepatitis without telling parents or children

Informed Consent Cases/Studies New England Journal of Medicine, Ethics of Clinical Research by Henry Beecher (1966) Described 22 trials that were unethical to focus attention to improve ethical standards. San Antonia Contraceptive Study (1970s) Indigent patients given a placebo without being told they were in a research study… so MANY unplanned pregnancies in control group Tearoom Trade Study (1970s) Gathered information about people interested in homosexual activity and breeched their confidentiality to families and in publications Albuquerque Tribunal publicizes Human Radiation Experiments (1993) Public newspaper acknowledges experiments Death of a Healthy Volunteer, Nicole Wan (1996) Lung Function study Apology to Tuskegee Experimental Subjects (1997) President Clinton issues a format apology. NBAC continues to investigate cases. Death of a healthy volulnteer, Jesse Gelsinger (1999) Lung Function study Death of a healthy volunteer, Ellen Roche (2001) Asthma Study

Informed Consent Laws Food and Drug Act (1938) Begins the need for human trials by requiring proof of safe drugs Nuremberg Code (1947) Voluntary & Informed Consent, Experiments must be scientifically necessary, Favorable risk/benefit analysis, Right to withdraw without penalty International Code of Medical Ethics of the World Medical Assembly (1949) Outlines duties of physicians First Federal Policy for Protection of Human Subjects (1953) Kefauver-Harris Bill – Expansion of Nuremberg Code (1962) Ban human trials until animal trials are conclusively safe FED Establishes Regulation 21 CFR130.3, later incorporated in 45 CFR 46 Certification of informed consent Helsinki Declaration signed by US (1964, expanded 1975, 1983, 1989) The interest of the subject has higher priority than society, Every subject should get the best known treatment, Requires independent review of all human subject research, Origin of Institutional Review Board (IRB) Congressional Hearings on Quality of Health Care and Human Experimentation (1973) Held in response to public concern about human subjects

Informed Consent Laws National Research Act (1974) Created National Commission for Protection of Human Subjects in Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Prompted establishment of IRBs at local level FDA Establishes Regulation 45 CFR 46 (1978) Protections for pregnant women, fetuses, and prisoners Belmont Report (1979) –Discussed further President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Commission ( ) Recommends federal agencies adopt human subject regulation of Dept of Health & Human Services Human Radiation Experiments Report (1995) From President’s Advisory Committee – special care must be taken when research must be secret Catalyzed establishing the National Bioethics Advisory Committee NBAC Charter is not renewed under Pres. Bush (2002) Secretary’s Advisory Committee on Human Research Protection

The Belmont Report What is the Belmont Report? List & Describe the three basic principles associated with The Belmont Report List and Describe the three applications of The Belmont Report

Nazi War Crimes & Mengele Twin Study Describe Each

Nuremberg Code Describe the 10 parts of the Code 1.Voluntary Consent 2.Fruitful results for good of society, unprocurable by other means 3.Designed and based on results of animal experimentation and results will justify experiment 4.Avoid all unnecessary physical and mental suffering/injury 5.Death/Disablement not an acceptable result of experiment 6.Degree of risk should not exceed humanitarian importance 7.Proper prep and adequate facilities provided to protect subject against even remote possibilities of injury, disability, or death 8.Conducted by only scientifically qualified persons 9.Subject is free to end the experiment/ Freedom to Withdraw 10.Scientist must be prepared to terminate the experiment if continuation of the experiment is likely to result in injury, disability, or death

Tuskegee Syphilis Study Describe Study Describe Concerns Describe Results

Institutional Review Board What is the IRB? What is the purpose of the IRB? When is consent from the IRB necessary?