ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF HOLDING FEEDINGS DURING PRBC TRANSFUSION ON THE INCIDENCE OF TRAGI Justin Ayala Delaine Winn Rachana Singh, MD, MS Robert Rothstein, MD
OVERVIEW NEC Background Previous / Future Studies Our historical prospective chart review
NECROTIZING ENTEROCOLITIS (NEC) Acute necrosis of the intestinal mucosa leading to bacterial translocation and infection of gut Results in death of bowel tissue Affects 7-13% of all very low birth weight (VLBW) infants 1 Incidence in US = / 1000 births 1 Mortality rate = 10-44% 1 Treated medically (antibiotics) or surgically X-ray of an infant with NEC showing pneumatosis intestinalis
PREVENTING AND CARING FOR NEC Incidence of NEC inversely proportional to gestational age (GA) Etiology unknown – thought to be multifactorial Known risk factors include: Prematurity Anemia of Prematurity (AOP) Early and rapid advancement enteral feeds Use of post-natal steroids PDA and indomethacin treatment Breast milk vs. formula feedings Presence of umbilical catheters
No preventative measures known Efforts include: - Slow feeding advancements - Promote breast milk feedings - Limit antibiotic use Adverse long-term outcomes 5 Failure to thrive Short Gut Syndrome (SGS) Neurodevelopmental Disability Intestinal stricture Malabsorption Intestinal autopsy showing NEC and pneumatosis intestinalis (image via CDC) PREVENTING AND CARING FOR NEC
PREVIOUS STUDIES Transfusion Associated Necrotizing Enterocolitis (TANEC) 2006: First study linking PRBC transfusions to NEC 2 Subsequent studies confirm relationship NEC onset has temporal relationship with Tx <48 hrs post Tx Of all NEC cases, 20-35% are transfusion associated 3,4
TRANSFUSION RELATED NEC (TANEC/TRAGI) “TANEC/TRAGI” now an established Dx = A sub- class of NEC seen in healthy growing preterm infants Link between AOP and NEC also established 1 AOP = low hct = higher risk of NEC PROBLEM: Anemia = NEC risk Tx = NEC risk Tx = Intervention for anemia
RESEARCH GAPS How can the risk of TANEC be minimized? Feedings may play role Transfusion may start a cascade of inflammation by unknown mechanisms Enteral Feedings during transfusion may cause additional stress QUESTION: Do feedings affect incidence of TANEC?
RESEARCH GAPS Recent studies show incidence of NEC increases when patient is fed before, during, and after transfusions 6 Randomized control trials = ideal Ongoing study 6 : Withhold feeds peri-transfusion: ≤2 before, 2 after, 1 during Most NICUs lack special feeding protocol for time surrounding Tx Difficult to analyze relationship
OUR STUDY Intervention : 2011 Protocol change – withhold feeds during and 24 hrs after a PRBC transfusion Outcomes : Compare incidence of TRAGI before and after the intervention Hypothesis : “PRBC transfusions may increase the occurrence of TRAGI and withholding feeds during transfusions will result in lower incidence of TRAGI”
OUR STUDY What’s different about our study? Cohort size: Largest cohort (appx pts) of any study looking at association of TANEC and withholding feeds Time of feeds held: Longest length of time (24 hrs) holding feeds at tx initiation
METHODS / DATA DESCRIPTION Cohort inclusion: All neonates admitted to NICU ( ) ≤34 weeks GA = ~1600 subjects Exclusion: Known congenital heart disease / chromosomal anomalies Comparison groups: Infants receiving PRBC transfusions in the pre and post intervention
DATA COLLECTION Demographics: GA, BW, Gender Clinical Data: Mat. History APGARs/MOD/Resuscitation Mechanical ventilation Feeds started/discharge (BM, Formula), TPN Central line placement Use of Antacid Other risk factors: Hypotension, SGS, DIC, ROP, IVH, CLD, PDA, Cholestasis, Positive blood culture, SIP Note all transfusions (excluding transfusions ≤7 days after NEC diagnosis)
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS Frequency distributions for categorical variables Means and standard deviations for continuous data Medians and ranges for count/ordinal data Logistic regression to compare odds of TRAGI in both time periods
RESULTS - DEMOGRAPHICS VariablePrePostTotalp-value Gestational age(weeks) 31.26(3.00)31.47(3.02)31.36(3.01) Gender (%) Males Females Birth weight (Grams, mean & SD) (576.82) (572.70) (574.63) Mode of delivery (%) C-section Vaginal Apgar score at 1min (median, mean, SD) 8, 6.70 (2.3) 8, 6.68 (2.35) 8, 6.69, Apgar score at 5 mins (median, mean, SD) 9, 7.92 (1.69) 9, 8.0 (1.54) 9, 7.95 (1.62) Maternal history: PIH PPROM Chorioamnionitis Prenatal steroids 16.29% % %
RESULTS - DEMOGRAPHICS Demographics & Maternal History data equivalent between pre/post groups No Selection bias Chorioamnionitis = only statistically significant difference Higher incidence in pre- intervention group
RESULTS – OUTCOME VARIABLES VariablePrePostTotalp-value Diagnosis of NEC (%) NEC stage (n) 1, Suspicious 2, Medical NEC 3, Surgical NEC Dx of NEC (n) Transfusion 48 hrs prior to Dx of NEC (n) % TANEC12.5%0%6.1 % % TANEC cases feeding at time of Tx 100 % (n=2)N/A (n=0) Surgery for NEC (n) 134
RESULTS – OUTCOME VARIABLES Overall incidence of NEC = similar (16 pre vs. 17 post) Incidence of TANEC pre = 12.5% of all NEC cases 100% (2/2) TANEC patients also feeding at time of Tx Incidence of TANEC post = 0% of all NEC cases Statistically significant difference
RESULTS – SECONDARY OUTCOMES VariablePrePostTotalp-value SGS (n, %)3 (0.36)1 (0.13)4 (0.25) Discharge Status (%) Alive Dead Mean age at discharge (days) (26.69)28.10 (26.34)29.96 (26.58) Age at death (med, mean, SD) in days 7, (19.48)4, (37.15)7, (28.73) Mechanical Ventilation (Yes, %) <0.001 Diagnosis of CLD (%) <0.001 Steroid use for CLD(%) DX of PDA (%) Dx of DIC (%) Dx of IVH (%) <0.001 Dx of ROP (%) Dx of Cholestasis (%)
RESULTS – SECONDARY OUTCOMES Between post and pre groups: Statistically significant decrease in incidence of CLD, PDA, IVH Statistically significant decrease in mean discharge age and mean length of use of mechanical ventilation
CONCLUSIONS No patient admitted to NICU developed TANEC from 12.5% (2 of 16) of NEC patients ( ) were actually of the subset TANEC Both patients were feeding at time of tx (feeds were not held) 0% (0 of 17) of NEC patients ( ) belonged to this subset This preliminary analysis suggests likely association between withholding feeds during/after tx and low incidence of TANEC
LIMITATIONS Preliminary data
APPRECIATIONS Summer Student Scholars Program Rachana Singh, MD, MS Robert Rothstein, MD Krishna Vemuri, MD Paul Visintainer, Ph.D. Alexander Knee, MS NICU staff
REFERENCES 1 Singh R, Visintainer PF, Frantz III ID, Shah BL, Meyer KM, Favila SA, et al. Association of necrotizing enterocolitis with anemia and packed red blood cell transfusions inpreterm infants. J Perinatol 2011;31:176–82. 2 Mally P, Golombek SG, Mishra R, La Gamma EF, Nigam S, Mohandas K et al. “Association of necrotizing enterocolitis with elective packed red blood cell transfusions in premature neonates. Am J Perinatol 2006; 23(8): 451–458.” 3 Christensen RD, Wiedmeier SE, Baer VL, Henry E, Gerday E, Lambert DK et al. Antecedents of bell stage III necrotizing enterocolitis. J Perinatol 2010; 30: 54– 57. 4 Christensen RD, Wiedmeier SE, Baer VL, Henry E, Gerday E, Lambert DK et al. Antecedents of bell stage III necrotizing enterocolitis. J Perinatol 2010; 30: 54– 57. 5 5 Springer, Shelley C. "Necrotizing Enterocolitis." Necrotizing Enterocolitis. N.p., 23 Apr Web. 09 July 6 6 "Withholding Feeds During Red Blood Cell Transfusion and TRAGI (Tx-TRAGI)." Withholding Feeds During Red Blood Cell Transfusion and TRAGI. Zekai Tahir Burak Maternity and Teaching Hospital, 17 Apr Web. 09 July