Integrated Analysis of Storm Tidal Surge, Sea Level Rise, Precipitation and Low Impact Development for Flood Hazard Assessment in a Coastal Urban Watershed 2016 FLORIDA FLOODPLAIN MANAGERS ASSOCIATION (FFMA) CONFERENCE MARCH 30 TH,2016 PRESENTERS: JUSTIN JOYCE, MASTERS STUDENT, DEPT OF CIVIL, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA NI-BIN CHANG, PH.D, P.E., DEPT OF CIVIL, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA RAHIM HARJI, P.E., PINELLAS COUNTY THOMAS RUPPERT, ESQ, FLORIDA SEA GRANT PROGRAM
Introduction Purpose of Analysis Evaluating the results of various scenarios of SLR, storm-tide, and rainfall Drivers for Analysis Senate Bill 1094 Pinellas County Results
Background: Risk Coastal Hazards Cyclonic storms (Storm surge/storm tide) High Tide Rainfall runoff Vulnerability Site Characterization Infrastructure system Exposure Flood hazard mapping Adaptive Capacity
Infrastructure Resilience to Flood Hazards Resilience: Ability of infrastructure systems to absorb disturbance and bounce back after a disturbance Reduced vulnerability Greater adaptive capacity
Case Study: Cross Bayou Watershed Sensitivity to coastal flooding hazards County’s efforts to implement improved stormwater management within the watershed County’s desire to evaluate long-term impacts of SLR and climate change
Case Study: Cross Bayou Watershed
Vulnerable Areas of the Cross Bayou Watershed. “Highpoint” residential area(top right) “Mariners Cove residential area (bottom right).
Hazards Current: Stormwater Runoff High tide events (Cross Bayou Canal) Future: Tropical cyclones Storm surge/storm tide Sea Level Rise Source: National Geographic (top image). NOAA National Hurricane Center (bottom image )
Hazards: Sea Level Rise Source: Tampa Bay Climate Science Advisory Panel
Hazards: Tropical Cyclone TrackTime Period IntensityLandfall Location Direction of Approach RMW near landfall (km) 1 October 2030 Cat. 5 Indian Rocks Beach, FL SW-NE35 2 October 2030 Cat. 5 Tarpon Springs, FL S-NE35 3 October 2030 Cat. 5 Tallahassee, FL SE-NW35
Exposure: Flood Hazard Mapping
Hazards: Storm Events Storm Event ClassificationPeriod Small Storm Event Historical Record Median Storm Event Large Storm Event Small Storm Event+SLR Future Period 2030 Median Storm Event+SLR Large Storm Event+SLR
Storm Event Classification Date Frequency of Rainfall Data Frequency of Tidal Data Period Small Storm EventJuly minHourly Historical Record Median Storm Event Feb 1-4, minHourly Large Storm Event July 10-13, minHourly Small Storm EventAug 4-6, minHourly2030 Median Storm Event Dec 3-5, minHourly Large Storm EventOct 12-14, minHourly
Adaptive Capacity and Drainage System Resilience Low Impact Development (LID) implementation Decrease runoff Decrease stress to drainage system
LID Siting & Choice Drainage Area/Outfalls Soil Hydrologic soil grouping Groundwater Table Land Use Local codes/standards Stormwater manuals
LID Implementation Simulation TypeDescriptionLocation Existing No LID implementation Not applicable LID Alternative 1 Pervious pavement only High Point Elementary School Pinellas County Jail complex parking lots LID Alternative 2 Pervious pavement Green Roof Swales High Point (green roof, pavement and swales) areas surrounding Pinellas County Jail (pavement only) LID Alternative 3 Pervious Pavement (w/ underground storage) Green Roof Dry Detention pond Swales High Point (green roof, pavement, swales and detention pond) Areas surrounding Pinellas County Jail (pavement + storage)
Proposed LID Sites Site #Site LocationProposed LIDLID Sizing 1 High Point Elementary School 58 th St N Green Roof & Pervious Pavement (parking lot) 1.6 acres (green roof) 2 acres (pervious pavement) 2High Density Residential AreasBioswales0.35 acres 3South of 150 th Ave (High Point)Detention Pond2.8 acres 4Pinellas County Jail-Parking LotsPervious Pavement9.3 acres
Quantitative Resilience Metrics Interconnected Channel & Pond Routing (ICPR) software v.4 (Streamline Technologies, Inc., 2015) Graphic of ICPR Cross Bayou Watershed Model
Points of Interest
Resilience Metrics- Peak Outflow Reduction
Summary Resilience tied to flood risk assessment Quantitative metrics can be useful Resilience must cover multiple aspects Engineering Social Planning Policy
Summary Importance of groundwater LID implentation Sea level rise concerns Complexity of Florida rainfall Convective vs. frontal rain Future Projections
References Chang, N., 2010: Hydrological Connections between Low-Impact Development, Watershed Best Management Practices, and Sustainable Development. J. Hydrol. Eng. 15, SPECIAL ISSUE: Low Impact Development, Sustainability Science, and Hydrological Cycle, 384–385. Egbert, G. D., Bennett, A. F., and Foreman, M.G.G.,1994: TOPEX/POSEIDON tides estimated using a global inverse model. Journal of Geophysical Research 99 (C12): Holling, C.S., 1973: Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annual review of ecology and systematics, pp. 1– 23 Jones Edmunds and Associates, Inc., 2013: Floodplain Analysis, Cross Bayou Watershed Management Plan. Pinellas County Board of County Commissioners and Southwest Florida Water Management District. Kivett, J. R., 2015: Impacts of Sea Level Rise on District Operations. Water Resources Advisory Commission. South Florida Water Management District. February 5, Omer. M., 2013: The resilience of networked infrastructure systems. World Scientific. Pinellas County Planning Department, 2012: Pinellas County Comprehensive Plan. Accessed July [Available online at Stream Technologies, Inc., 2015: An Integrated Surface Water-Groundwater Model of the Cross Bayou Watershed. Wilby, R.L, Dawson, C.W., Barrow, E.M., 2002: SDSM—a decision support tool for the assessment of regional climate change impacts Environ. Model Softw., 17 (2): 145–157
Questions?