Oral Corrective Feedback in Second Language Classrooms

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Hello I'll tackle this question from an ecological perspective. First, I'll (very broadly) describe an ecological perspective/approach: relationships between.
Advertisements

Oral Production and Error Correction Amongst Arab Learners of English
KRISTINE SOGHIKYAN YEREVAN STATE LINGUISTIC UNIVERSITY EPOSTL AS AN ADMINISTRATOR'S GUIDE TO INTERNAL QUALITY ASSURANCE IN UNIVERSITY LANGUAGE INSTRUCTION.
Corrective Feedback – pronunciation errors How effective it is in learning L2 oral communication Nguyễn Thị Tố Hạnh.
What role do individual differences play in the way L2 learners respond to corrective feedback? Rod Ellis University of Auckland.
Oral Corrective Feedback in Language Pedagogy and SLA
Oral Feedback in Classroom SLA
Presented by Sarah Waters and Kate Lunde. To study corrective feedback as an analytic teaching strategy. To determine which types of corrective feedback.
Masatoshi Sato Universidad Andrés Bello TBLT, November 19, 2011
THEORY OF SECOND LANGUAGE LEARNING
Krashen’s “monitor model” The acquisition-learning hypothesis The monitor hypothesis The natural order hypothesis The input hypothesis The affective.
How Languages Are Learned 4th edition
Chapter 4 Key Concepts.
Takehiro Iizuka.  CF has significant and durable effects on target language development (Lyster & Saito, 2010) What type of CF benefits L2 acquisition??
Topic: Learning and teaching activities
Continuing dominance of “language of instruction” debate.
Communicative Language Teaching
14: THE TEACHING OF GRAMMAR  Should grammar be taught?  When? How? Why?  Grammar teaching: Any strategies conducted in order to help learners understand,
LANGUAGE ACQUISITION AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS KNOWLEDGE BASES PLANNING STANDARDS KNOWLEDGE BASES PLANNING.
Communicative Language Teaching (CLT)
Corrective Feedback and Learner Uptake Negotiation of Form in Communicative Classrooms Roy Lyster & Leila Ranta 1997.
Teaching language means teaching the components of language Content (also called semantics) refers to the ideas or concepts being communicated. Form refers.
Communicative Approach. Communicative Language Teaching.
Tony Lynch University of Edinburgh. Feedback in SLA (Lyster & Ranta 1997)  Explicit correction  Recast  Clarification request  Metalinguistic feedback.
Unit 6 Teaching Speaking Do you think speaking is very important in language learning? Warming-up Questions (Wang: 156) Do you think speaking has been.
Learning & Acquisition
Author: Younghee Sheen Reporter: NA1C0003洪志隆
How Languages are Learned and Acquired
Developing English Language and Literacy. Demographics.
16/11/ INCIDENTAL FOCUS ON FORM DURING DECISION MAKING TASKS AND THE EFFECTS ON ORAL AND WRITTEN PERFORMANCE Eva Alcón Soler Universitat Jaume I.
CONTENT BASED TASK BASED & PARTICIPATORY APPROACHES
GRAMMAR CORRECTION Penny Ur Various issues 1.Does it help? 2.What different kinds of correction are there? And which is the most effective? 3.What.
Audio Diaries for improved spoken proficiency Anthony Schmidt University of Tennessee, Knoxville
What is Communicative Language Teaching??. Communicative Language: Blends listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Is the expression, interpretation,
Current Issues in the Teaching of Grammar: An SLA Perspective Rod Ellis.
Second Language Acquisition Theories (A brief description) Compiled by: Nicole Lefever.
Chapter 6, part-2- Language Learning and Teaching Processes and Young Children.
SLA Effects of Recasts as Implicit Knowledge Young-ah Do Fall, College English Education.
Approaches to (Second) Language Acquisition. Behaviorism (Theory) tabula rasa (to be filled with language material) children learn language by imitation;
1 ACCURACY AND CORRECTING MISTAKES Penny Ur 2006.
COURSE AND SYLLABUS DESIGN
Communicative Language Teaching Approach
1 Taiwan Teachers’ Professional Development Series: Oral & Written Communication in your FL Classroom.
Input, Interaction, and Output Input: (in language learning) language which a learner hears or receives and from which he or she can learn. Enhanced input:
PROJECT PAPER Successful English Language Learning Inventory Prepared by, Noraishah Intan bt Othman P69255 GE6533 Language Learning Strategies Instruction.
Ch. 19 Teaching Speaking Teaching by Principles by H. D. Brown.
How Languages Are Learned
Unit 7 Teaching Grammar Objectives: Know the importance and role of grammar in ELT Know how to present grammar Know how to guide students to practice grammar.
CISELT TRAINING ERRORS AND MISTAKES CTLI 27 JUNE 2015.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Error Correction Techniques
Theories of Language Acquisition
Second Language Acquisition & English Teaching
Corrective feedback L2 in the classroom
ELT for a Day 2017: Current Trends Saturday 20th May 2017
Theories of Language Acquisition
Theories of Language Acquisition
Teresa R. Bell Brigham Young University SWCOLT 2017
Approach, Design, & Procedure The Weakness & Strength
Oral Corrective Feedback during ELL Academic Conversations
Noticing and Text-Based Chat
Defense Language Institute Foreign Language Center
Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Error Correction Techniques
Giving explicit feedback on spoken errors - the more the better
شرح مفردات مفاهيم التربية الإسلامية الصف العاشر ج1
Areas of Language Development Theories of Language Development
Communicative Language Teaching
ACTFL's Core Practices for Effective Chinese Learning
Investigating the Empirical Links between Learner Uptake and Language Acquisition through Task-Based Interaction Wenchi Haung 2019/1/16.
Chapter 10 Perspectives on SLA
PASSWORD: workshopsfeb2019
Presentation transcript:

Oral Corrective Feedback in Second Language Classrooms Roy Lyster, Kazuya Saito, and Masatoshi Sato (January 2013) Critical Discussion by Yasmine Kataw and Elizabeth Abell

What is Corrective Feedback. It’s purpose. What are the types What is Corrective Feedback? It’s purpose? What are the types? How does it effect learners? Theoretical Issues What is peer-peer CF?

CF L2 Growth “When, what, and how to correct”(p.30) It’s purpose? CF L2 Growth “When, what, and how to correct”(p.30)

Clarification Requests What are the types? 6 Types of CF Lyster &Ranta 1997 Reformulations Prompts Elicitation Repetition Explicit Correction Recasts Clarification Requests Metalinguistic Clues

Conversational Recasts What are the types? CF Types Sheen & Ellis 2011 Implicit Explicit Prompts Reformulation Prompts Reformulation Repetition Didactic Recasts No Communication breakdown Conversational Recasts Communication breakdown Metalinguistic Clues Clarification Requests “Pardon?” Elicitation Wh-question Explicit Correction With/without Metalinguistic Explanation Paralinguistic signal

Categorizing CF Activity What are the types? Categorizing CF Activity As a student learning your second language, what type of CF did you prefer? Would you correct your students in the same way and why? What type of feedback do you find yourself giving the most and why?

Overall: CF > No CF BUT! Explicit CF > Implicit CF How does it effect learners? Overall: CF > No CF Explicit CF > Implicit CF Prompts > Recasts In terms of noticing (by ext. repair) BUT! In the long term Implicit CF > Explicit CF

How does it effect learners? Why are CF preferences important? 1. Influences learning behaviors 2. Avoid mismatches between teacher’s intentions and learner’s interpretations resulting in negative effects on learning. Conducted research has shown clear evidence that learners express preference for receiving CF over having their errors ignored. When teachers take this into consideration, they become aware of when to offer CF and what types. Different cultural backgrounds, learners’ personalities, proficiency levels and age all play a role in what type of CF is best/most effective to offer.

Why would teachers be reluctant to offer CF? How does it effect learners? Why would teachers be reluctant to offer CF? Motivation killer - Not wanting to stop flow of conversation Learners could lose face So how do we “…close the gap between students’ preferences for receiving CF and teachers’ reluctant to offer it.” (p. 9) ?

Different Types of Feedback for Different Students on the same error?

Interactionist versus Skill Acquisition Theory Theoretical Issues Interactionist versus Skill Acquisition Theory Recasts (implicit) Prompts (explicit)

Theoretical Issues Learner Uptake Learner's response to recasts: Provide opportunity for learner to respond to recast Be aware that their responses may be “red herrings” New vs. partially acquired knowledge “It remains unclear, however, how a recast can be provided on a form about which the learner has zero knowledge; if the student produced the form, albeit erroneously, then some knowledge of the form exists.” (13) CF With or Without Instruction Intensive > Extensive CF (feedback focused on limited amount of errors is more effective then correcting everything)

Grammatical targets Lexical targets Phonological targets Theoretical Issues Linguistic Targets Grammatical targets Lexical targets Phonological targets Pragmatic Targets Not very effective… Effective when explicit Effective when explicit Very effective but must be explicit Age Studies have produced varied results- older learners may have an advantage with CF.

Learners benefit from both receiving and providing feedback… What’s peer-peer CF? Can occur between a native speaker and a non-native speaker or two non-native speakers Whereas native speakers tend to reformulate errors rather then give prompts, L2 learners provide each other with more prompts leading to more L2 development. Learners benefit from both receiving and providing feedback… … however, learners may not accept the CF from a peer. Peer CF may also lack effectiveness because learners often focus more on errors of meaning than form.

“One size does not fit all” (p. 30)