Comment: Ultimate Ownership Structure and Bank Regulatory Capital Adjustment: Evidence from European Commercial Banks Chung-Hua Shen Department of Finance.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Risk and the Organization of Bank Foreign Affiliates Giovanni DellAriccia (IMF and CEPR) Robert Marquez (Arizona State University) The views expressed.
Advertisements

2005 CUHK International Conference on Corporate Governance in China and Asia Discussion of: Tycoons Turned Leaders: Market Value of Political Connections.
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT EUN / RESNICK Second Edition 16 Chapter Sixteen International Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital Chapter Objective:
How Much Should a Firm Borrow?
1 Investments: Financial Statement Analysis (review) Professor Scott Hoover Business Administration 365.
1 (of 30) IBUS 302: International Finance Topic 18-Capital Structure Lawrence Schrenk, Instructor Note: Theses slides incorporate material from the slides.
Corporate Governance and Financial Distress: Evidence from Taiwan Tsun-Siou Lee and Yin-Hua Yeh 2002 NTU International Conference On Finance.
1 The Effect of Non-Performing Loans: A Threshold Method University of Birmingham David Dickinson Yixin Hou.
KeyCorp’s Top Down & Bottom Up Capital Reconcilement.
Sandy Lai SMU 1 Real Effects of Stock Underpricing Harald Hau University of Geneva and SFI
Common Stock Valuation
Dividend Policy and Retained Earnings (Chapter 18) Optimal Dividend Policy Conflicting Theories Other Dividend Policy Issues Residual Dividend Theory Stable.
Chapter 14 Distribution to shareholders: dividends & repurchases
SUOMEN PANKKI | FINLANDS BANK | BANK OF FINLAND Comments on ”The global roots of the current financial crisis and its implications for regulation” Seppo.
Optimal Debt Financing and the Pricing of Illiquid Assets Antonio Bernardo and Ivo Welch Discussion.
Chapter 13 Common Stock Valuation Name two approaches to the valuation of common stocks used in fundamental security analysis. Explain the present value.
Sandy Lai SMU 1 Real Effects of Stock Underpricing Harald Hau University of Geneva and SFI
Securitization and Credit Risk Taking: Empirical Evidence from US Bank Holding Companies Discussed by: Mascia Bedendo Bocconi University 1Emerging Scholars.
Romano (1993): Public Pension Fund Activism n 1996: Public pension funds own over $300 billion; 30% of corporate equity. n Political pressure on Public.
Chapter 4. We will want to answer questions about the firm’s n Liquidity n Efficient use of Assets n Leverage (financing) n Profitability.
General Description Of Assets In Each Of The Four Risk Categories.
Chapter 13.
International Financial Management Vicentiu Covrig 1 International Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital International Capital Structure and the Cost.
The impact of Solvency II regulation on the ability of insurance companies to provide long-term financing: Issues for discussion Dario Focarelli Director.
(Eun and Resnick chapter 17)
DETERMINANTS OF THE CAPITAL STRUCTURE OF RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY COMPANIES Björn-Martin Kurzrock Frieder Mokinski Felix Schindler Peter Westerheide.
SMALL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT Chapter 7 Financing the Small Business.
Professor Thomas Cosimano Department of Finance. Housing Prices.
“The Empirical Relationship Between Average Asset Correlation, Firm Probability of Default, and Asset Size” by Jose A. Lopez Discussion by George Pennacchi.
Raising capital Class 14 Financial Management,
11.1PPS t/a Carnegie et al; Accounting: Financial and Organisational Decision Making © 1999 McGraw-Hill Book Co. Aust. ACCOUNTING Financial and Organisational.
Inside Debt and Bank Performance During the Financial Crisis DNB 2012 Sjoerd van Bekkum.
Chuang-Chang Chang Keng-Yu Ho Yu Jen-Hsiao 2012/12/07 1.
Credibility of Non-Insurance and Governance as Determinants of Market Discipline and Risk-taking in Banking Penny Angkinand University of Illinois, Springfield.
1 The Asian Banker Summit 2004 Capital Management After Basel II Simon Topping Executive Director (Banking Policy) Hong Kong Monetary Authority 5 May 2004.
Copyright  2004 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd. PPTs t/a Accounting by Jackling et al Prepared by Courtney Clowes 10-1 Chapter 10 Accounting and Financial.
Weighted Average Cost of Capital
EBIT/EPS Analysis The tax benefit of debt Trade-off theory Practical considerations in the determination of capital structure CAPITAL STRUCTURE Lecture.
1 Financial Crisis and Corporate Cash Holdings: Evidence from East Asian Firms Discussant I-Ju Chen, Yuan Ze University, Taiwan The NTU International Conference.
CASMEF seminars Discussion of : The Recapitalization of Banking and Insurance during the Credit Crisis Zeno Rotondi – Head of UniCredit Research.
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT EUN / RESNICK Fifth Edition Copyright © 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Pyramidal Ownership Structure, Overinvestment, and Firm Performance in China Chao Chen Fudan University Donglin Xia Tsinghua University Song Zhu Beijing.
BASLE 3 (Over Basle2) PHILIPPE CARREL
Why Were Canadian Banks More Resilient? Lev Ratnovski and Rocco Huang IMF WP 09/152.
Corporate Governance in the Financial Crisis: Evidence from Financial Institutions Worldwide Yale University SOM November 12, 2010 Comments by.
Comm W. Suo Slide 1. comm W. Suo Slide 2  Basic Types of Models Balance Sheet Models Dividend Discount Models Price/Earning Ratios 
Loan Loss Provisioning and Economic Slowdowns: Too much, Too Late? By Luc Laeven and Giovanni Majnoni Finance Forum 2002 June 19-21, 2002.
Finance Theory II (15.402) – Spring 2003 – Dirk Jenter Capital Structure: Informational and Agency Considerations.
How Banks Work CHAPTER TWO. The Role of Banks A bank is a financial intermediary that accepts deposits from savers and makes loans to borrowers. By making.
SMALL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT Chapter 7 Financing the Small Business.
Michiel Bijlsma CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis.
Does the market discipline banks? New evidence from bank capital mix October 27, 2006 Adam B. Ashcraft Federal Reserve Bank of NY.
1 Economic Research Department 1The New International Financial Map for LAC Alicia García-Herrero Chief Economist Emerging Markets Economic Research Department,
Submitted By: Aaina Aman Bhaskar Ram Submitted to: Prof. Pawan Gupta.
Ratio Analysis…. Types of ratios…  Performance Ratios: Return on capital employed. (Income Statement and Balance Sheet) Gross profit margin (Income Statement)
© 2001 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 7 Common stock: characteristics, valuation, and issuance.
SS.8.FL.5.3Discuss that when people buy corporate stock, they are purchasing ownership shares in a business that if the nosiness is profitable, they will.
C. Fritz Foley Harvard Business School. US MNE US MNE Foreign Sub Foreign Sub Repatriates $80 Owes US tax of ($100 x 35%)=$35, less foreign tax credit.
Corporate governance practices and capital structure
Bank Liability Structure
World Islamic Finance Forum 2016 By: Saqib Sharif IBA-Karachi
(includes a few oral comments from presentation)
General Description Of Assets In Each Of The Four Risk Categories
Minimum Capital Requirements across Capital Categories
Common Stock: Characteristics, Valuation, and Issuance
Ratio Analysis - Gearing
Complex Ownership and Capital Structure
Discussion Demian Berchtold July 6, 2018.
Capital structure, executive compensation, and investment efficiency
Behavioral Corporate Finance
Presentation transcript:

Comment: Ultimate Ownership Structure and Bank Regulatory Capital Adjustment: Evidence from European Commercial Banks Chung-Hua Shen Department of Finance National Taiwan University

Four contributions 1.new data on UOs’ voting and cash-flow rights of 405 commercial banks across 17 Western European countries during – Previous studies: only focus on the largest publicly listed banks at a given point in time (one year) – This study: for both publicly listed and privately owned banks for the years 2004, 2006 and Whether control/ownership divergence affects bank's capital adjustment speed: it has not been addressed before. 3.focusing on Europe  Wedge is more acute in Europe compared to other countries with more diffused ownership (La Porta et al. 1998)  draw policy implications 4.regarding core Tier 1 and draw potential implications.

Rationale max shareholders’ value  adjust capital structure  capital adjustment to target capital ratio  issuing new equity might dilute controlling shareholder’s (UO) control while repurchasing equity might enhance it  high expropriation costs ( control dilution costs ) ∵ fear control dilution  UO with high wedge might have stronger incentives to avoid financing decisions which could threaten their position  ∴ – lower adjust speed if the bank has to adjust its equity capital upwards  imply the reluctance to increase equity capital – higher adjust speed if a downward adjustment is required During crisis  ∵ fear bank failure, UO might intervene to support (prop up) the bank  ∴ the reluctance to increase equity capital should be less apparent

purpose whether a bank's decision to adjust its capital is influenced by the existence of a divergence between the voting and the cash-flow rights of its ultimate owner.

Methods 1.Partial capital adjustment model – It needs to estimate the Target Capital Ratio 2.Ownership Augmented Capital Adjustment Model – We introduce flexibility to allow for asymmetric upward and downward adjustment speeds.

Ownership Augmented Capital Adjustment Model

Very Interesting Paper, my comment is simple Why are we interested in K/A but not CAR? That is, why is there an optimal K/A, not not optimal CAR? Authors say: because of these adjustment costs, banks usually hold capital buffers, i.e. regulatory capital ratios above the minimum requirement and are likely to adjust their capital ratios by modifying the size of their balance sheets and/or by changing their risk exposure by substituting safe assets to risky assets Do we call it leverage ratio?

The authors discuss the capital adjustment from the view of optimal capital structure in non-financial firms, and use this idea to investigate banking industry. However, what is optimal capital structure in banking industry? Is optimal capital structure a main concern to banks?

2. The authors argue that banks would adjust capital upwards slowly due to the fear of duiltion of control power. The presumption is that banks have target capital ratios which are proxied by Tier 1 ratio. however, most banks do not need to adjust upwards because they meet the requirement of Tier 1 regulatory ratio, otherwise, they would be imposed PCA. Only few bankswould adjust upwards. The reason could possible be that they are in distress.