Managing the risk of unconscious bias in admissions 3b UCAS Admissions Conference, 21 March 2016 Dan Shaffer, Head of Professionalism in Admissions Lizzy.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
University admissions practices: What is right? What is wrong? How should they change? Steven Schwartz.
Advertisements

HEPI Conference – 7 October 2008 Developments in Higher Education Applications and Admissions: Implications for Universities, Schools and Colleges Anthony.
THE ADMISSIONS POLICY. WHY AN ADMISSIONS POLICY ? To ensure that the University is compliant with the QAA Code of practice: Admissions to Higher Education.
SPA, admissions issues and feedback
What do enquirers and applicants need to know? PSRB Forum on Public Information 16 December 2011 Leslie Currie, Senior Project Officer.
Outcomes from the SPA Fair Admissions Task and Finish Group What does it mean for your institution? SPA event 19 June 2012 Professor Mary Stuart, Vice-Chancellor,
Evidence & Preference: Bias in Scoring TEDS-M Scoring Training Seminar Miami Beach, Florida.
Aspiration and Frustration A Brief Overview. mobilising business for good Aspiration and Frustration Research objective: To find out how certain industries.
Orientation for New Site Visitors CIDA’s Mission, Value, and the Guiding Principles of Peer Review.
Understand the concepts of equality, diversity and rights in relation to health and social care It is really important in this learning outcome that you.
SPA’s Good Practice for Admissions Policies Admissions Policy and the QAA Quality Code – Are you ready? Peter Chetwynd, Admissions Support and Development.
Teachers’ Appraisal and Pay Pete Gaskin Julie Chow Alison Trehearn Paula Shaw 1 12 July 2013.
Supervising Students in Social Work Placements in Wales and the U.K. Paula McCreary. Tutor and Placement Coordinator, Dept. of Applied Social Science,
THE MULTICULTURAL CHALLENGE AND PACE UNIVERSITY Becoming a Multicultural University May 16, 2005.
Level 5 NVQ Diploma in Occupational Health & Safety Practice
The LCVP is funded by the Department of Education and Science under the National Development Plan Preparing students for Work Experience.
Into Teaching Promoting access for disabled people Tony Stevens How do you make change happen? LINK Conference, Antwerp July 2011.
Diversity management in New Zealand’s changing workplaces.
SMSC and Inspection Spiritual Moral Social & Cultural.
CPD4k Skills Competitions, CIF & PS
The new competitive environment: How can the use of contextual data aid fair admissions SPA event 19 June 2012 Janet Graham, Director of SPA.
Training and Learning Needs Analysis (TLNA) a tool to promote effective workplace learning & development Helen Mason, Project Worker, Unionlearn Representing.
The common inspection framework: education, skills and early years.
A summary of feedback from service users and carers: Adult Social Care – what does good look like?
The New Scottish Teacher Education Professional Standards and the Development of the Professional Update System Tom Hamilton Director of Education and.
Introduction to the Applicant Experience The Applicant Experience in Wales, 4 June 2014 Peter Chetwynd, Admissions Support and Development Manager.
Association for Biblical Higher Education February 13, 2013 Lori Jo Stanfield Evaluator Team Training for Business Officers.
Skills Evaluator Orientation Course Revised: October 2011.
Impact of Perceptions and Biases on Race, Ethnicity and Religion Snéha Khilay Blue Tulip Training.
Chapter © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall.
Promoting the Success of a New Academic Librarian Through a Formal Mentoring Program The State University of West Georgia Experience By Brian Kooy and.
Fair access and widening participation – the view from SPA OCNLR Access to HE Conference Thursday 24 March 2011 Annie Doyle, Senior Project Officer, SPA.
Values based recruitment Ruth Auton & Janine Hackett * Strategic Workforce Development Manager Directorate of Workforce, Education.
Programme Objectives Analyze the main components of a competency-based qualification system (e.g., Singapore Workforce Skills) Analyze the process and.
Raising standards, improving lives The use of assessment to improve learning: the evidence 15 September Jacqueline White HMI National Adviser for Assessment.
Recruiting and Retaining Staff Dr Lee Gruner1. Principles of Recruitment and Retention Aimed at ensuring that the organisation has competent, high performing.
Recruitment, Retention, Selection Development and Retention of Personnel Educ 567 Summer 2009 Thomas DiPaola, Ph.D.
LESSONS 11 & 12 INTERVIEW TECHNIQUES.
Kerry Cleary An evaluation of the impact of Values Based Interviewing at the OUH Values Based Conversations and wider engagement strategies.
Contextual data in admissions: is it right to use it; is it wrong not to? FACE Conference 2 July 2009 Dan Shaffer, Senior Project Officer.
This workshop is being recorded in video/audio format by the University of Greenwich The recording may be used by the University of Greenwich for the purposes.
Who do MyKindaCrowd work with? Today’s Challenge is set by:Let’s get to know them a little… #LiveYourValues.
Do you like the idea of getting a new qualification or learning new things? NO YES Is Higher Education Right For You? Answer the questions below to find.
Bias Tidbits Multidisciplinary Work A forthcoming paper in the American Journal of Evaluation by Irwin Feller discusses the issues, noting that in disciplines.
Dr. Salwa El-Magoli Chairperson of the National Quality Assurance and Accreditation Committee. Former Dean of the Faculty of Agricultural, Cairo university.
Managing mistakes in admissions decision-making 2a. UCAS Admissions Conference, 21 March 2016 Jeni Clack, Admissions Support and Development Advisor.
The Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education ‘Tutoring for the 21 st Century’ 28 January 2015 Harriet Barnes Natalja Sokorevica Standards, Quality.
Fair admissions ▪Fair admissions system should: ▫Be transparent ▫Seek to minimise barriers ▫Strive to use reliable and valid assessment methods ▪How is.
Partnerships between institutions: competition, collaboration and issues to consider for admissions 4b. UCAS Admissions Conference, 22 March 2016 Janet.
Legal Basis of Equality Impact Assessments (EQIAs)  Requirement in Scotland under Equality Act 2010 to:  Assess the impact of applying a new or revised.
Managing the risk of unconscious bias in admissions.
WORKSHOP 2: BEING AN INCLUSIVE PASS LEADER/AMBASSADOR PASS Leader Conference 2016.
Managing unconscious bias in student recruitment and admissions
Fitness and Conditioning
Kate Fairweather CMCAust Marketing QAC Assessor & IQA
AUA-SPA Applicant Experience Network
Joining up approaches between your recruitment and admissions 1b
HE White Paper (England): SPA overview and action on unconscious bias
Orientation for New Site Visitors
Implementing and reviewing additional admissions assessments
Good practice in entry requirements
Partnerships between institutions: competition, collaboration and issues to consider for admissions 4b. UCAS Admissions Conference, 22 March 2016 Janet.
Our Vision Our vision is to be recognised nationally and internationally as a leader in qualification, assessment and verification.
Safeguarding Objective Decision making
Values and behaviours-based recruitment
Matthew McCullagh Linking the Principles of Assessment to the QA Criteria.
Lifelong learning of librarians – learning outcomes and flexibility
Our Commitment.
CEng progression through the IOM3
Presentation transcript:

Managing the risk of unconscious bias in admissions 3b UCAS Admissions Conference, 21 March 2016 Dan Shaffer, Head of Professionalism in Admissions Lizzy Woodfield, Admissions Support and Development Manager

What is SPA? Set up in 2006 following the Schwartz Report Fair Admissions to Higher Education: Recommendations for Good Practice 2004 ‘The Group recommends the creation of a central source of expertise and advice on admissions issues. Its purpose would be to act as a resource for institutions who wish to maintain and enhance excellence in admissions. Such a centre could lead the continuing development of fair admissions, evaluating and commissioning research, and spreading best practice.’

“Equal opportunity for all individuals, regardless of background, to gain admission to a course suited to their ability and aspirations.” Fair, in principle 1. Be transparent. 2. Enable institutions to select students who are able to complete the course as judged by their achievements and their potential. 3. Strive to use assessment methods that are reliable and valid. 4. Seek to minimise barriers to applicants. 5. Be professional in every respect and underpinned by appropriate institutional structures and processes.

Imagine you’re going out for a meal What is unconscious bias? Do you: a)Run away? b)Strike first? c)Pause to consider who this person is? Perhaps he’s the chef. Maybe he’s had an unfortunate accident and needs your help. He might just be passing by.

What is unconscious bias? Unconscious bias refers to a bias that we are unaware of, and which happens outside of our control. It is a bias that happens automatically and is triggered by our brain making quick judgments and assessments of people and situations, influenced by our background, cultural environment and personal experiences. But…in student recruitment unconscious bias can lead to unfairly discriminating against individuals.

Here’s what the Royal Society says…

What does the evidence say? Very little research about unconscious bias in HE student recruitment...but for staff recruitment… Applicants with typically white British names more likely to be shortlisted for jobs than those with names associated with minority ethnic backgrounds. Staff in a science faculty rated male applicants for a lab manager role as more competent than equally qualified females. Chose a higher starting salary for males.

Risk areas for unconscious bias

Applicant and adviser bias I’m not academic enough… I won’t fit in on this course… Pupils from our school don’t go to that type of university…you’d be better off at…. I better not tell them I’m dyslexic, it might count against me…

HE provider bias Their application was strong but they seemed really under-confident at interview… This school has a great track record of pupils successfully applying to my course… I’ve not heard of this qualification before – surely it’s not suitable preparation for this course…

Mitigating the risk - group exercise Using the templates provided: Add in any more examples from your own experience. How could you mitigate against the risk of unconscious bias?

Five recommendations 1.Create a culture of equality Having written equality and diversity policies is insufficient; policies need to be put into practice. Managers should make it clear that they are committed to equality, holding themselves and others to account. 2.Ensure transparency Ensure that all decisions, including interviews, are properly documented in a standard and consistent manner, and that they demonstrate why decisions were made. This will make providing feedback easier, facilitate any auditing process and help protect against legal challenges. 3.Reduce stereotypes Look for situations where you can promote counter- stereotypical images of underrepresented groups, without misleading applicants. This should apply not just on the website and in marketing materials, but also around the institution where they would be encountered by visitors. 4.Prepare individual selectors Consider introducing training in a supportive, unthreatening environment to give staff the chance to think about their biases in a constructive way. Familiarity with non- stereotypical student, academic or career examples will implant an intention to counter bias and promote a conscious effort toward equality. 5.Ensure the qualities of different candidates are valued in the same way Before any selection decisions are made, all involved should be clear about what they are looking for, adhering to a robust admissions policy and consistent admission criteria that should not change within any period of equal consideration.

Next steps? SPA’s review and action plan:review and action plan What already exists? What needs to be created, updated or expanded? Who will be responsible? What’s the timeline? How will we measure success?

Thank you More information from or