11 Office of Institutional Integrity Fiduciario Forum 29 April – 3 May 2008 1300 New York Avenue, Washington, DC 20577 Phone (202) 623-2874 Fax (202) 623-157901.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Bridgetown, Barbados–2013 Integrity in IDB Group Operations Inter-American Development Bank.
Advertisements

International Aid Transparency Initiative Some Code of Conducts TAG meeting Brussels, 3 June 2009.
Red Flags Rule BAS Forum August 18, What is the Red Flags Rule? Requires implementation of a written Identity Theft Prevention Program designed.
World Bank Financial Management Sector September 2010.
OLAF.D.2 – Fraud Prevention Unit
Lobbying and interest representation EU institutions must operate in an OPEN fashion (principle stated in article 1 of the Treaty on EU) Lobbying and.
Public Private Partnerships MUNICIPAL PPP CONFERENCE Date: 18 February 2010.
Identity Theft “Red Flags” Rules Under the FACT Act Reid Fudge CISSP, CISA Pulte Mortgage, LLC November 2008.
AGENCY FOR PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION AND COORDINATION OF FIGHT AGAINST CORRUPTION mr.sci. Vladica Babić - Assisstent.
Corruption Sten Ström Sida/Asdi Embassy of Sweden, Managua.
Office of Inspector General (OIG) Internal Audit
Human Rights Advocacy “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has.”
ADB Support of Public Procurement Reform Presented By: Amr J. Qari, Procurement Specialist Seventh Regional Public Procurement Forum, May , 2011.
BRIEFING TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON THE DPSA’S RISK MANAGEMENT STRATEGY PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE 12 MAY
A PROCUREMENT ASSESSMENT MODEL Joel Turkewitz World Bank April 2003.
Using Country Systems to Manage Climate Change Finance A Global Forum M onitoring Tracking quantity and quality of climate expenditure, accountability.
Islamic Republic of IRAN’s Country Report: Evaluation On Current Situation Of Anti-Corruption 10th ASOSAI Research Project (AUDIT TO DETECT FRAUD AND.
AUDIT TO DETECT FRAUD AND CORRUPTION: EVALUATION OF THE FIGHT AGAINST CORRUPTION AND MONEY LAUNDERING The 10th ASOSAI Research Project Atty. ALEXANDER.
Using the UN Convention against Corruption as a Basis for Good Governance.
Internal Auditing and Outsourcing
Regional Accreditation Workshop For Latin America & Caribbean Region Panama City, Panama th Nov, 2011.
The World Bank Department of Institutional Integrity 1 Business Integrity and Anticorruption Initiatives of the World Bank Department of Institutional.
Medical Device Compliance Congress: Emerging Compliance Issues in Asia Anne Trimmer.
Establishing A Compliance Program: It Makes Sense
Preconditions for Effective Implementation of Anti-Corruption Measures Jane S. Ley Deputy Director U.S. Office of Government Ethics Global.
1 The Auditor’s Perspective Division of Sponsored Research Research Administration Training Series Presented by: Joe Cannella Audit Manager,
Session 7 Development of a Water Sector Integrity Vulnerability Mitigation Plan Maria Jacobson, UNDP Water Governance Facility, SIWI Marie Laberge, UNDP.
1 Action Planning to Address Corruption in Water Supply and Sanitation (WSS) Dr. Donal O’Leary Senior Advisor, TI Secretariat.
World Bank and Statistical Capacity Building PARIS21 Task Team Meeting Washington, DC September 10, 2001.
The Anti-Corruption Guidelines and Sanctions Reform Fiduciary Forum March 26, 2008 Presented by: LEG: Lisa Lui, Senior Counsel Alison Micheli, Senior Counsel.
A REPORT ON GOVERNMENT IMPLEMENTATION OF THE 1999 SUMMIT RESOLUTIONS : 26 TH MARCH 2003 A review and revision of legislation COMBATING CORRUPTION A review.
New Identity Theft Rules Rodney J. Petersen, J.D. Government Relations Officer Security Task Force Coordinator EDUCAUSE.
Chapter 19: Ethical Responsibilities Chapter 19 Ethical Responsibilities.
EXPERIENCE SHARING ON LOCAL PFM & CURRENT REFORM INITIATIVES Babu Ram Shrestha, MOFALD.
The Audit as a Management Tool Vermont State Auditor’s Office – April 2009.
Custom Corporate Consulting and Training Fraud: Detecting and Preventing Presented October 30, 2010 To University of Texas at Arlington Executive MBA Students.
MOSCOW, NOVEMBER 12 – 14, THE RESEARCH 1.Respondents 8 respondents from SAI Indonesia : auditor, investigator, R &D 2.Time 3 weeks (Sept to Oct.
Enhancing Integrity in Public Procurement FIDIC seminar, Brussels, 26 June 2012 Elodie Beth, Head of Procurement Unit, OECD Public Sector Integrity Division.
Anti Corruption Policy “Corruption hurts the poor disproportionately – by diverting funds intended for development, undermining a government’s ability.
Astana Economic forum - May 2012 Prevention of corruption systems and institutional frameworks Francesco Checchi, UNDP Anti Corruption Specialist.
An Overview: The Role of the Audit Committee in Monitoring, Oversight, and Compliance Derry Harper, Inspector General and Director of Compliance.
Consultant Advance Research Team. Outline UNDERSTANDING M&E DATA NEEDS PEOPLE, PARTNERSHIP AND PLANNING 1.Organizational structures with HIV M&E functions.
Tax Administration Diagnostic Assessment Tool MODULE 11 “POA 9: ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY”
Copyright © 2015 Raytheon Company. All rights reserved. Customer Success Is Our Mission is a registered trademark of Raytheon Company. Fine Tuning Anti-Corruption.
1 INETGRITY FOR BETTER RESULTS Fiduciary Forum, March 2010 Leonard McCarthy Integrity Vice President.
1 Use of Country Procurement System (UCS) HIGH LEVEL PROCUREMENT FORUM V. S. (Krish) Krishnakumar Regional Procurement Manager Africa Region - The World.
BNAO ROLE FOR EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT OF PUBLIC FINANCES Tzvetan Tzvetkov, CIA, CGAP, CRMA - President of the Bulgarian National Audit Office.
Procurement & Fiduciary services Department Development Bank African The 1 THE HIGH LEVEL FORUM ON PUBLIC PROCUREMENT REFORMS IN AFRICA Progress, Challenges,
The MESICIC Experience & Civil Society Participation.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 32 – Financial Control Bilateral screening:
Inter-American Development Bank BIMILACI 2007 QUALITY PROCUREMENT Third Party Review May 2007 Project Procurement Division.
RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR CONVERGING MULTIPLE STAKEHOLDER’S EXPECTATIONS Organised by National Treasury Presented by WELEKAZI DUKUZA CEREBRO.
1 Use of National Systems in Mexico Mrs. Gloria Coronel Fiduciary Forum April 29 – May 3, New York Avenue, Washington, DC Phone (202)
Regional Accreditation Workshop For Asia and Eastern Europe Manila, Philippines th March, 2012.
Internal Audit Section. Authorized in Section , Florida Statutes Section , Florida Statutes (F.S.), authorizes the Inspector General to review.
1 Country Systems Chilean Experience 1300 New York Avenue, Washington, DC Phone (202) Fax (202) Inter- American Development Bank.
Red Flags in Procurement BIMILACI 10 & 11 May 2007 IADB – DEV/PRM & PRE/OII.
1 Corruption Prevention Strategies. 2 Specific Objectives: 1. Corruption Loopholes 2. Corruption Prevention Strategies 3. Conclusions.
Fifteenth Board Meeting Geneva, April 2007 Ethics Committee Annual Report Professor Sheila Dinoshe Tlou, M.P., POH (Chair) Dr Brian Brink (Vice Chair)
TNK-BP:Fraud Risk management process International Business Leaders Forum Feb 28, 2007.
Fraud Awareness Audit, Business & Technology Committee September 23, 2004.
Corruption Warning Signs Is your Project at Risk?
Red flags OLAF.D.2 – Fraud Prevention, Reporting and Analysis Unit
Office of Internal Audits
Red Flags Rule An Introduction County College of Morris
the Public Procurement Audit Practical Guide
Infrastructure Governance at the OECD
Corruption Measures for Identifying and Reducing Fraud and Corruption Risks in Public Procurement.
UNCAC Chapter II Overview Prevention of Corruption under the United Nations Convention against Corruption 8-10 April 2019 Addis Ababa.
Presentation transcript:

11 Office of Institutional Integrity Fiduciario Forum 29 April – 3 May New York Avenue, Washington, DC Phone (202) Fax (202) Inter- American Development Bank VPC/PDP

2 Communication Investigation Prevention OII’s Mission

3 Allegations of fraud and corruption related to contracts financed by the Bank or with any other Bank activity. Allegations of violations by Bank Staff of the Code of Ethics or the Staff rule 323 “Respect in the workplace” …. solely when required by the Ethics Officer. What does OII investigate?

4 PRIORITIZE AND INVESTIGATE 1.Is the activity IDB financed? 2.Is it fraud or corruption? 3.Is the allegation credible? Preliminary review REFERRAL IF RELEVANT Multiple portals Confidentiality Internal and external sources Reception The investigative process

5 Investigation methods: interviews and analysis of the documents Standard of proof: if evidence is sufficient to confirm that the person who is investigated was involved in an act of fraud or corruption related with a project fincanced by the Bank. Possible results: Substantiated: when the evidence is sufficient to conclude that a violation of the Bank’s anticorruption policies occurred Unsubstantiated: when the evidence is insufficient to confirm or deny the allegation of fraud and corruption. Unfounded: when the allegation proves false. The investigation process

6 The result: If OII finds that the evidence is sufficient to prove that the person who is investigated committed acts violating the Bank’s administrative anticorruption policy, OII can recommend to the OCFC that a sanction be taken by the Bank. These sanctions are administrative in nature and may disqualify the sanctioned firm/individual from participating in activities financed by the Bank. They may also consist of extending an admonition letter to the individual/firm in question. The investigation process (Cont.)

7 The investigation process

8 Political Party Selection Committee Mayor Winning firm Losing Firm Order Selection Manipulated bid A typical case

9 External Auditing Of the project Detects inflated costs Providing firm Ex-employee Of the provider Denouncing non-payment Alerts Inflation of salaries, Creation of employees, Non-payment of the Social charges. Payment of Third-person for Inexisting Services Diversion of the funds Other typical case

10 Internal Activities: Review of the Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct Support in the selection of the Ethics Officer and Ombudsperson Supporting the system for the Declaration of Interests Red Flags system on fraud and corruption in procurement activities financed by the Bank Portfolio review of investigations to analyze trends and lessons learned for OII and the Bank Data Mining Implementation of the Guides on Due Diligence in operations with the Private Sector and special training Prevention: Fiduciary Function

11 External Activities: Support to the implementation of the International Conventions Against Corruption (OEA, ONU, OECD) Special Fund for access to information and control of corruption Technical Cooperation to strengthen the OSC Action Plan to support Anti-Corruption Activities Anticorruption Harmonization with international organizations Annual Report Publication of the list of Sanctions Prevention: Fiduciary Function

12 Red Flags Matrix

13 OII cases (substantiated and unsubstantiated if relevant facts) Information from other Divisions in the IDB ( Project database, monitoring reports, experience of the officials) Local information (Controlling Organs, NGOs, Media) Identification of conditions favoring fraud and corruption Recommendation to optimize investigation of cases Recommendation on ways to reduce the risks of fraud and corruption in projects. Description of the cases and their pattern Recommendations Best Practices OII’s analysis Inputs Sources Prevention – Support to the fiduciary function

14 Bidding firms and individuals participating in too many bidding processes and making, in turn, “losing” proposals. Narrow specifications and unjustified disqualifications. Inconsistent TORs with the project. Contracting of Consulting Services not well defined and which impact is impossible to foresee/evaluate. Falsification of the Contracts of consulting services: the same individuals are systematically contracted, even where there is a larger offer. The assumed short-listed losers deny having participated in a bidding process. Alert Signals

15 Augmenting number of protests from users claiming they have not received the goods or services supposedly covered. Systematic increase of the budget and delays for infrastructure works justified by “unexpected events” High discrepancy between the prices for similar products. Payments diverted to foreign accounts, and more specifically in jurisdictions where Bank information is confidential (Hong King, Cyprus, …) Alert Signals (Cont.)

16 Keep in mind the alert signals and most common cases Use professional discretion. Do not rely on appearances: thoroughly analyze the documentation. Communicate all doubts and questions to OII. What can the fiduciary specialist do?

17 Red Flags Pilot and implementation; Dissemination of lessons learned to mitigate fraud and corruption in Projects; Pro-active participation in the analysis of the portfolio Review of the Due Diligence Framework for the Private Sector; Triage OII’s Program for 2008