TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Report from Workshop on UOCAVA Remote Voting Systems Nelson Hastings National Institute of Standards and Technology

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Military and Overseas Voters – Ready for the General Election! September 2014 Brad King Co-Director, Indiana Election Division 2014 Election Administrators.
Advertisements

TGDC Meeting, December 2011 Usability and Accessibility (U&A) Research Update Sharon J. Laskowski, Ph.D.
12/9-10/2009 TGDC Meeting Ballot On Demand David Flater National Institute of Standards and Technology
IEEE P1622 Meeting, Oct 2011 IEEE P1622 Meeting October 24-25, 2011 Overview of IEEE P1622 Draft Standard for Electronic Distribution of Blank Ballots.
DECEMBER 2010 ELECTIONS DIRECTORS CONFERENCE A Guide to Post-Election Surveys.
TGDC Meeting, July 2011 Review of VVSG 1.1 Nelson Hastings, Ph.D. Technical Project Leader for Voting Standards, ITL
Observation of e-enabled elections Jonathan Stonestreet Council of Europe Workshop Oslo, March 2010.
United States Election Assistance Commission Pilot Program Testing and Certification Manual & UOCAVA Pilot Program Testing and Certification Manual & UOCAVA.
2009 Indiana Election Administrator’s Conference Statewide Voter Registration System (SVRS) Project Update December 2,
12/9-10/2009 TGDC Meeting TGDC Recommendations Research as requested by the EAC John P. Wack National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, December 2011 Andrew Regenscheid National Institute of Standards and Technology Update on UOCAVA Risk Assessment by.
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 UOCAVA Pilot Projects for the 2012 Federal Election Report from the UOCAVA Working Group Andrew Regenscheid National Institute of.
TGDC Meeting, July 2011 Overview of July TGDC Meeting Belinda L. Collins, Ph.D. Senior Advisor, Voting Standards, ITL
Absentee Voting I.C. Title 34, Chapter 10. No Excuse Voting Any registered elector may vote absentee.
TGDC Meeting, July 2011 Update on the UOCAVA Working Group Andrew Regenscheid Mathematician, Computer Security Division, ITL
United States Election Assistance Commission EAC UOCAVA Documents: Status &Update EAC Technical Guidelines Development Committee Meeting (TGDC)
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 VVSG 2.0 and Beyond: Usability and Accessibility Issues, Gaps, and Performance Tests Sharon Laskowski, PhD National Institute of.
12/9-10/2009 TGDC Meeting Vote-by-Phone David Flater / Sharon Laskowski National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, July 2011 UOCAVA Roadmap Update Nelson Hastings, Ph.D. Technical Project Leader for Voting Standards, ITL
Electronic Voting Support Wizard 2010 voting assistance wizards.
TGDC Meeting, July 2011 IEEE P.1622 Update John P. Wack Computer Scientist, Software and Systems Division, ITL
Federal Voting Assistance Program Technology Programs and 2012 Cycle Initiatives Technical Guidelines Development Committee EAC-NIST January 13, 2011.
NIST HAVA-Related Work: Status and Plans June 16, 2005 National Institute of Standards and Technology
Making every vote count. United States Election Assistance Commission HAVA 101 TGDC Meeting December 9-10, 2009.
12/9-10/2009 TGDC Meeting NIST Research on UOCAVA Voting Andrew Regenscheid National Institute of Standards and Technology
UOCAVA Report Overview and Status July 2008 Andrew Regenscheid Computer Security Division National Institute of Standards and Technology.
IEEE P1622 Meeting, Feb 2011 Common Data Format (CDF) Update John P. Wack National Institute of Standards and Technology
Improving U.S. Voting Systems Security Breakout Session Improving U.S. Voting Systems Andrew Regenscheid National Institute.
Federal Voting Assistance Program Voting Initiatives and MOVE Act Joint Election Officials Liaison Committee January 7 th, 2010.
TGDC Meeting, December 2011 IEEE P1622 Common Data Format Standardization Update John P. Wack National Institute of Standards and Technology
UOCAVA Voting in Four States A Study of Election Administration.
Usability and Accessibility Working Group Report Sharon Laskowski, PhD National Institute of Standards and Technology TGDC Meeting,
Briefing for NIST Acting Director James Turner regarding visit from EAC Commissioners March 26, 2008 For internal use only 1.
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Accessibility and Usability Considerations for UOCAVA Remote Electronic Voting Systems Sharon Laskowski, PhD National Institute.
Page 1 June 2009 Internet Voting Panel - CFP Conference – OVF Presentation May 15, 2008 OVF Solutions Tour and Demonstration Daemmon Hughes, Technology.
12/9-10/2009 TGDC Meeting Auditing concepts David Flater National Institute of Standards and Technology
12/9-10/2009 TGDC Meeting Usability and Accessibility Progress and Challenges Sharon Laskowski, PhD National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, July 2010 Security Considerations for Remote Electronic UOCAVA Voting Andrew Regenscheid National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, July 2010 Report of the UOCAVA Working Group John Wack National Institute of Standards and Technology DRAFT.
Internet Voting Ashok CS 395T. What is “E-voting” Thomas Edison received US patent number 90,646 for an electrographic vote recorder in Specific.
NIST Voting Program Page 1 NIST Voting Program Lynne Rosenthal National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, December 2011 Overview of December TGDC Meeting Belinda L. Collins, Ph.D. Senior Advisor, Voting Standards
TGDC Meeting, July 2011 Voluntary Voting System Guidelines Roadmap Nelson Hastings, Ph.D. Technical Project Leader for Voting Standards, ITL
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Help America Vote Act (HAVA) Roadmap Nelson Hastings National Institute of Standards and Technology
UOCAVA What we know What works Dr. Donald S. Inbody Texas State University.
TGDC Meeting, July 2010 Report on Other Resolutions from Dec 2009 TGDC Meeting John Wack National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, July 2010 Report on Logging Requirements in VVSG 2.0 Nelson Hastings National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Common Data Format (CDF) Update John P. Wack National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Review of UOCAVA Roadmap Nelson Hastings National Institute of Standards and Technology
1 DECEMBER 9-10, 2009 Gaithersburg, Maryland TECHNICAL GUIDELINES DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE Commissioner Donetta Davidson.
Medicaid/SCHIP Technical Assistance for Health IT/HIE 2008 AHRQ Annual Conference Presented by: Linda Dimitropoulos, RTI International.
NIST VOTING PROGRAM MARY BRADY, PROGRAM MANAGER TGDC MEETING: FEBRUARY 2016.
© 2011 TGDC Meeting Scope of Standards and Testing Washington, DC February 8-9, 2016.
TGDC Meeting, July 2010 Overview of NIST Activities and TGDC Meeting Agenda Martin Herman, PhD National Institute of Standards and Technology
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Development of High Level Guidelines for UOCAVA voting systems Andrew Regenscheid National Institute of Standards and Technology.
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Path Forward for FY11 UOCAVA Activities Nelson Hastings National Institute of Standards and Technology
Briefing for the EAC Public Meeting Boston, Massachusetts April 26, 2005 Dr. Hratch Semerjian, Acting Director National Institute of Standards and Technology.
TGDC Pre-Meeting July , 2015 NIST Facility - Gaithersburg, Maryland Members : Designated Federal Official Matthew V. Masterson, EAC Commissioner,
P1622 Voting Systems Electronic Data Interchange Arthur Keller, chair (self employed at Minerva Consulting, Affiliated with Univ. Calif., Santa Cruz) 1IEEE.
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 VVSG 2.0 and Beyond: Usability and Accessibility Issues, Gaps, and Performance Tests Sharon Laskowski, PhD National Institute of.
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 UOCAVA Pilot Projects for the 2012 Federal Election Report from the UOCAVA Working Group Andrew Regenscheid National Institute of.
TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Accessibility and Usability Considerations for UOCAVA Remote Electronic Voting Systems Sharon Laskowski, PhD National Institute.
12/9-10/2009 TGDC Meeting Alternatives to Software Independence Nelson Hastings National Institute of Standards and Technology
National Institute of Standards and Technology
Internet Voting Resources and Reports
UOCAVA Electronic Blank Ballot Delivery Use Case
Voting Assistance Element 49.
Element 49 Page 217.
Military and Overseas Voters
Colorado Department of State
Presentation transcript:

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Report from Workshop on UOCAVA Remote Voting Systems Nelson Hastings National Institute of Standards and Technology

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 2 Overview Held in Washington, DC on August 6-7, 2010 Co-sponsored by the Election Assistance Commission (EAC), DoD’s Federal Voter Assistance Program (FVAP), and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) About 100 attendees from federal agencies, state and local election offices, industry, and academia Explored technical issues associated with remote electronic absentee voting systems for military and overseas voters

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 3 Original Goal Establish a comparative threshold for an acceptable level of risk by identifying accepted risks of the current UOCAVA voting process Develop measures and/or criteria for comparing risks of remote electronic absentee systems to those of the current system.

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 4 Day One Opening address by FVAP on Challenges and Issues Keynote and Invited Talk on Technical perspectives on UOCAVA voting systems Panel on Maintaining Effectiveness in a Hostile Environment Presentation from a UOCAVA manufacturer Two Invited Talks on Lessons learned from previous UOCAVA pilot projects These sessions set the stage for discussions during breakout sessions on day two

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 5 Updated Goal Evaluate the level of security, usability, accessibility and access of the UOCAVA voting process using the postal mail to return marked ballots Identify desirable properties of future UOCAVA voting systems.

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 6 Day Two Attendees were asked to participate in one of three day long breakout sessions to explore specific areas in more detail Voter Authentication and Privacy Auditability Network and Host Security The breakout sessions had three co-chairs that represented the election, security, and accessibility and usability communities

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 7 Day Two (2) Voter Authentication and Privacy session Discussed when is authentication needed Identified architectures for blank ballot delivery Push verse pull models Identified characteristics of blank ballot delivery systems Mapping voters to ballot style Authentication ballots on return Ballot accounting

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 8 Day Two (3) Auditability session Discussed auditing issues in the current UOCAVA system Transcription of voted ballots Identified end-to-end voting systems as away to provide auditability throughout the election process Identified properties of auditable system Audit of system performance Confirming ballots were counted correctly Integrity of records Public transparency

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 9 Day Two (4) Network and Host Security session Discussed demographics of UOCAVA voters Who they are Where are they located Discussed risk of mail based and electronic transmission of ballots Consensus was timely delivery of ballots could be greatly improved using electronic methods Consensus was ballot returned via was least secure method Brainstormed ~60 desirable properties (-ilities) Interoperability Auditability Forens-ability

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 10 Workshop Outcomes Report from Workshop on UOCAVA Remote Voting Systems Summary of the plenary session and the discussions in the breakout groups Draft of report has been reviewed by Co-chairs of breakout sessions Will distribute to workshop participants for comment Final report released March 2011

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Page 11 Workshop Outcomes (2) Workshop on Secure Ballot Delivery San Francisco in February/March 2011 Develop draft requirements for secure ballot delivery for consideration by FVAP, EAC, and NIST Organized by participants of the August 2010 workshop Workshop on End-to-End Cryptographic Voting Systems for UOCAVA Voters August/September 2011

TGDC Meeting, Jan 2011 Discussion Page 12