1 International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Roger Burkhart INCOSE MBSE Workshop January 2012 Jacksonville, Florida Modeling Standards Activity Team

2 International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Roger Burkhart INCOSE MBSE Workshop January 2012 Jacksonville, Florida Modeling Standards and Solutions Architecture Activity Team

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Modeling Standards Wiki Page Key goals of the Modeling Standards MBSE Activity include: Maintain a taxonomy and roadmap of modeling standards of importance for MBSE. Identify gaps in the roadmap which still need to be filled by new standards development projects. Work with the INCOSE Standards Initiative to maintain liaisons and agreements with organizations that develop standards within the taxonomy and roadmap. Serve as a voice of the Systems Engineering user community to provide requirements to new modeling standards and to evaluate them during their development process. Encourage cross participation, communications, and collaboration across the MBSE community and standards development organizations and projects.

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Modeling Standards Wiki Page Taxonomy of modeling standards. Following are some initial, but incomplete, classifications for modeling standards: modeling languages, frameworks, and information models, such as SysML and AP233. mappings between languages, such as the AP233-SysML mapping and the SysML-Modelica Transformation. domain-specific libraries, models, and data, such as standard units, mechanical libraries, and diagrams.

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Modeling Standards Wiki Page Roadmap of modeling standards of importance for MBSE: modeling standards already being developed under formal liaison between INCOSE and other organizations, such as SysML (OMG) and AP233 (ISO TC184/SC4 STEP). modeling standards being developed by other organizations for which INCOSE liaison does not currently exist. directory and timeline of modeling standards currently being developed or maintained, including versions and expected dates. gaps in coverage of modeling standards that need to be filled by new standards development activities.

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE Standards in INCOSE INCOSE has been driving development of needed standards for MBSE since 2001 –Memorandum of Understanding with OMG and ISO TC184/SC4 (STEP), which led directly to SysML and AP233 –Model-Driven System Design Working Group (MDSD WG) With last year’s IW, the activities of MDSD merged into the activities of the MBSE Initiative

IW 2010 Technical Operations 7 Model Driven System Design (MDSD) WG IW 2010 “Quad Chart” MDSD Charter: Enable effective and efficient use of models throughout the systems engineering life cycle. MDSD WG Chairs : Phil Spiby Roger Burkhart Number of Members: INCOSE Connect address: INCOSE Web page: Published Products: Requirements, evaluation, & user feedback for AP233, SysML, & other modeling frameworks White paper on AP233 & SysML relationship SE Conceptual Model originally used to provide requirements to AP233 and SysML - Neutral terminology and structure to support content across languages, models, and tools - To be republished using semantic modeling technologies to define valid usage and structure Portfolio of mappings across MBSE languages and models (AP233, SysML, Modelica, OPM,...) Planned Work: Organize electronic communications and work sites Develop and publish products, examples, inputs to support MBSE Initiative Publish mapping specification to define AP233 and SysML relationship Develop roadmap for progressive coverage of model-driven methods, including PLM support of MBSE Interacting with OMG, ISO, ECCMA, and other modeling standards organizations

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA MBSE needs standards Languages and frameworks to express and communicate models –For understanding and interpretation by people –For analysis and processing by computer programs Integration of models across multiple domains and communities –Mappings across multiple sources and forms of models Problem-specific frameworks, models, reference data –Generated and shared by user communities for specific system and problem types

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Adoption of MBSE needs architecture and roadmaps Classify types of solutions which must be put in place for MBSE adoption Identify sources and possible timing of available solutions Implement plans to develop, adopt, and deploy new solutions and to phase out old ones

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA An taxonomy of modeling solutions an organization needs to support model-based engineering A roadmap which identifies the phase-in of emerging sources for these solutions and the phase-out of old ones Needed by every organization seeking to manage their MBSE/MBE adoption in a systematic way The INCOSE MBSE Initiative is one of the organizations that needs such a solutions architecture MBSE-related standards are a particular class of solutions for which it has specific responsibility Modeling Solutions Enterprise Architecture

11 International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Modeling Solutions Enterprise Architecture

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA Modeling Solutions Taxonomy “Modeling Solution” as the most general taxon Additional substructure to cover: –Processes, methodologies, metrics (methods to adopt MBE in specific projects) –Modeling languages, frameworks, metamodels (underlying capability to express modeling content) –Reusable models, libraries, and related data (specific resources to be reused in user models) –Supporting services, such as model management

International Workshop Jan 21– 24, 2012 Jacksonville, Fl USA The following slides were from the outreach to all other Activity & Challenge Teams as presented at the 2011 Workshop …

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA Taxonomy and Roadmap Catalog of Classifications for Modeling Standards –Modeling Languages and Frameworks o Modeling Language, Metamodel, Model Exchange Format, Constraint Language, Query Language, Transformation/Mapping Language, Representation Model (Diagrams, Documents), Model Management Service, … –Mapping Specifications –Problem-specific frameworks, models, reference data o Architecture Modeling Language, Hardware/Software Systems, Continuous System Dynamics, … Catalog of Standards Development Organizations (SDOs) Catalog of Standards Projects/Specifications –Schedules, Contacts, Liaisons –Placeholder if no project exists

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA Example: Object Management Group Standards Development Organization: OMG –Modeling Language: SysML –Metamodel: Meta Object Facility (MOF) –Model Exchange Format: XMI –Constraint Language: OCL –Transformation/Mapping Language: QVT –Representation Model: Diagram Definition –Model Management Service: MOF Versioning –Mapping Specification: SysML-Modelica Transformation –Mapping Specification: Ontology Definition Metamodel (ODM) –Architecture Modeling Language: UPDM –Business Modeling Language: BPMN –Real-Time Software: MARTE

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA Telescope Challenge Team Contact: Robert Karban DocBook, MARTE, AADL, AUTOSAR, Modelica, Methods: OOSEM, State Analysis, SYSMOD, fUML, ALF

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA Space Systems Challenge Team Contact: TBD Reference Frames / Coordinate Systems, Time (ISO 8601, MARTE) Simulations (Timesteps, Triggers, HLA: High-Level Architecture, Parameters & Model Versions, …) Systems of Quantities and Units

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA Modeling and Simulation Interoperability Challenge Team Contact: Russell Peak Math Libraries Additional Value Types, Modelica Standard Library

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA System of Systems/Enterprise Activity Team Contact: Matthew Hause UPDM, BPMN, SoaML, SPEM Non-OO Methodologies, e.g. RDD-100 and Core

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA System of Systems/Enterprise Activity Team Contact: Matthew Hause UPDM, BPMN, SoaML, SPEM Non-OO Methodologies, e.g. RDD-100 and Core

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA Model Management Activity Team Contact: Joszef Bedocs ISO STEP (AP203, AP214, AP233, AP239) Eclipse CDO Model Repository, Open Services Lifecycle Collaboration (OSLC)

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA MBSE Usability Activity Team Contact: David Lempia No specific standards identified at this time.

International Workshop 28 Jan – 2 Feb 2011 Phoenix, AZ, USA Ontology Activity Team Contact: Hans-Peter de Koning Languages: RDF, RDFS, OWL, SPARQL, SWRL, ISO/IEC Common Logic Mappings: ODM Ontologies: Systems of Quantities and Units, OMG Date-Time, JPL Systems Engineering, ECSS Space Systems Engineering, Dublin Core Annotations, ISO Process Specification Language