Budget Community of Practice Program Budgeting Working Group (Concept) Nikolay Begchin Head of the Working Group Deputy Director Budget Policy Department.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Public Procurement in Transition Countries: Major Trends in Provision of Access to Justice 16 July 2014 UNCITRAL Standards for Transparency, Accountability.

Advertisements

1 Experiences of Using Performance Information in the Budget Process OECD 26 th March 2007 Teresa Curristine, Budgeting and Public Expenditures Division,

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP) Mid-Term Review of PEMPAL Strategy BCOP results and issues BCOP Executive Committee Cross-COP Executive Meeting, Vienna,

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP) Update on Progress Konstantin Krityan, BCOP Chair, BCOP plenary meeting, Armenia February 2015.

1 Public Expenditure Management Peer-Assisted Learning (The “PEMPAL” Project) Presented by Montenegro Assistant Finance Minister Nikola Vukicevic and Rich.

EBRD 2010 Regional Assessment – Scope, Focus & Main Findings on the Public Procurement Law and Practice in the EBRD region Eliza Niewiadomska Legal Transition.

Managing Public Investment Experiences of selected EU member states in managing transport infrastructure investments World Bank Public Investment Workshop.

The World Bank PREM Public Sector Governance 1 Public Expenditure Management: An Introduction Presented to: PREM – WBI Core Course on Public Sector Governance.

SMALL GROUP DISCUSSION SESSION GROUP 2.

Survey Results PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice Tbilisi, Georgia.

Strategies for Treasury Modernization in PEMPAL Member Countries thematic survey results Elena Nikulina, World Bank, June 2012.

Findings from forthcoming regional flagship report Skills, not just diplomas Findings from forthcoming regional flagship report Lars Sondergaard May 6,

Benchmarking Choices for BCOP Istanbul, February 25, 2008.

“RIA in EU Harmonization” 4 June 2009 EuropeAid/125317/D/SER/TR Session 4 RIA in accession negotiatons.

1 Bosnia and Herzegovina: Creating a Stable Decentralized Fiscal System The World Bank.

Implementing the GFSM 2001 System: Migration Paths & Experiences Government Finance Division Statistics Department IMF.

Budget Community of Practice Working Group on Public Sector Wage Bill Management Update on Progress Maya Gusarova, Public Sector Specialist and member.

R-UNDG ECA Working Group on Social Protection UNDG Europe and Central Asia Regional Directors Meeting Geneva, 12 May Progress to date.

REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA MINISTRY OF FINANCE CURRENT CHALLENGES IN BUDGET REFORM SOFIAMR. LYUBOMIR DATZOV 03 DECEMBER 2004DEPUTY MINISTER

Budget Literacy and Transparency Working Group Key Outcomes and Prospects Anna Belenchuk, Head of the Working Group February 25, 2016.

1 LAW On Public Finance and Budget and Tax Responsibility; Competences and Roles of Participants of the Budget Process # 181, of July 25, Plenary.

Results of (OECD) fiscal rules survey of PEMPAL countries Deanna Aubrey on behalf of BCOP Resource Team World Bank 24 February 2016.

1 Kishinev, Moldova June 1-3, 2016 Results of TCOP activities in FY 2016.

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP) Update on Progress Mikhail Prokhorik, BCOP Executive Committee Member, BCOP plenary meeting, Belarus, February 2016.

Future Planning for new BCOP Working Group Nicolay Begchin, MoF Russian Federation Leader of the PEMPAL BCOP Program and Performance Budgeting Working.

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP) Results Achieved Future PFM Priorities and Plans Cross-COP ExCom Meeting, Berne Switzerland, July 2016.

Expansion of OECD Performance Budgeting Survey to PEMPAL countries PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCOP) Nicolay Begchin, MoF Russian Federation Leader.

Overview of Program and Performance Budgeting Working Group

Nikolay Begchin, Deputy Director of Budget Methodology Department

PEMPAL Strategy Mid-Term Review of Implementation Progress

Results of TCOP activities in FY 2017

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

Performance Budgeting Survey 2016

Results Achieved Future PFM Priorities and Plans

Update on Progress PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

IFMIS ROLE IN BUDGET PROCESS

Money Bills Amendment Procedure and Related Matters Bill [B 75–2008]

DEMPA evaluations: Coordination of debt and cash management

PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

TCOP: outcomes for Baku, Azerbaijan April 10 – 13, 2018.

Update on Budget Literacy and Transparency Working Group Progress

Developments And Achievements In Implementing Public Internal Financial Control (PIFC) Reform In Armenia EDGAR MKRTCHYAN, PhD Chairman of Executive Committee.

PEMPAL in FY18 Budapest, Hungary July 5, 2018.

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

PEMPAL – Facilitating Practical Solutions in PFM across ECA

Insights from the Open Budget Survey 2017

Treasury Community of Practice Progress, Expectations, Challenges

Measuring and Monitoring Treasury Performance

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

Ronnie Downes Deputy Head, Budgeting & Public Expenditures OECD

PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

Measuring and Monitoring Treasury Performance

PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

Results of TCOP Activities in FY2018

PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

PEMPAL in FY18 Budapest, Hungary July 5, 2018.

Spending Reviews in PEMPAL Countries

Trends and best practice of spending review in OECD

PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCoP)

PEMPAL Budget Community of Practice (BCOP)

TCOP Activities in FY2019 Budapest, Hungary June 5, 2019.

Elena Nikulina, the World Bank

Elena Nikulina, the World Bank

Results and Plans for the Future

Kyrgyz Republic Ministry of Finance

Public Expenditure Management Peer Assisted Learning (PEMPAL) Network

Elena Nikulina, the World Bank

Budget Transparency in PEMPAL Countries

Presentation transcript:

Budget Community of Practice Program Budgeting Working Group (Concept) Nikolay Begchin Head of the Working Group Deputy Director Budget Policy Department Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation

Decision to Establish the Working Group: May 2014 – Cross COP Plenary Session; Initiated by: Russian FederationKyrgyz Republic Republic of BelarusRepublic of Armenia

9 responses out of 21 (excluding Uzbekistan and including three government levels in Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH): program budgeting (PB) and performance management (PM) are not taken into account for decision-making on budget appropriations 4 respondents suggest that PB and PM information is widely used 8 respondents suggest that PB and PM information is used but most decisions are driven by other factors Capitation financing is not fully used – at least at the central government level. 3 MOF Budget Appropriation Decisions Based on Programs and Performance

Program Budgeting: Implementation Challenges Financing volumes planned ex ante by program designers greatly exceed budget capabilities; Too many unaligned policy documents which make it difficult for line ministries to formulate their strategic plans; Unresolved terminology issues – difference between evaluation and monitoring; Using performance evaluation mainly as a “punishment or incentive” tool rather than as a means to effectively improve performance; Unsure about the merits of allowing more fiscal flexibility to line miniseries and managers for fear that it might compromise control over budget spending; Practically impossible to formalize spending adjustments on programs or actions depending on their performance evaluation.

Working Group Objectives: Identify key trends in: а) program budgeting implementation; б) spending revisions; Learn from specific PEMPAL country examples in these areas; + participate in an OECD survey of performance budgeting practices in 2016.

Action Plan: 1. Participating in the OECD performance budgeting survey March 2016 – February Working Group Meeting in the context of the XIIth CESEE SBO meeting in Slovenia June, Russia’s experience in implementing program budgeting (VC)April/ May, Presentation of the findings of the World Bank survey of countries implementing program budgeting (VC) September-October, Workshop on trends and challenges of performance budgeting across PEMPAL countries identified in the course of the OECD survey February, 2017 (during the BOP plenary) 6. Selected country cases -- to be confirmed (study tour)Fall 2016 /Spring, 2017

Core Team: Nikolay Begchin Maya Gusarova Deanna Aubrey Naida Čaršimamović Vukotić Ksenia Galantsova Participants: Countries represented in the BCOP Executive Committee (Albania, Russia, Armenia, Kyrgyz Republic, Croatia, Turkey, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina) Countries which will participate in the OECD survey in the spring of 2016