Disruption: Breakdown following court orders Special Guardianship, residence or adoption Judith Masson MA PhD Professor of Socio-legal Studies, University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Implementing NICE/SCIE guidance
Advertisements

Building futures for our most vulnerable children What do we need to change in law, policy and practice? Professor Gillian Schofield School of Social Work,
The Impact and Avoidance of Delay in Decision Making.
The Post Adoption Support Challenge Hugh Thornbery CEO Adoption UK and Chair of the Adoption Support Fund Expert Advisory Group.
Leadership and Supervision. Reflective Practice and Critical Analysis Supervision provides an opportunity for reflection, challenge and the testing out.
CIPFA North West Audit Group
Towards an ideal of gender equity? Simon Lapierre, Ph.D. School of Social Work McGill University, Montreal Child protection.
Managing the risks and benefits of contact. The Legal Context The Children Act local authorities must promote and support contact between LAC and.
Subsidized Guardianship Permanency Initiative. SG Introduction Focuses on improving permanency outcomes for children in out-of-home care through a comprehensive.
BREAKING THE LINK BETWEEN LOCAL AUTHORITY CARE AND HOMELESSNESS Jamie Harding, Northumbria University.
Child Welfare Services Family centered services to achieve well- being through ensuring self-sufficiency, support, safety, and permanence. Dual tracks-
Nina Biehal and Jim Wade Department of Social Policy and Social Work University of York England.
Assessment, Analysis and Planning Further Understanding the contribution of extended family P17 1.
1. Kinship Breakdowns: Causes and Prevention ACWA Conference 2-5 August 2010, Sydney Lynne McCrae Wendy Frayne 2.
The streamlined legal framework for looked after children Implementation of Care Planning and placements regulations and guidance November 2010.
Healthier Horizons Improving Healthcare of Looked After Children in NW
1 Consent for treatment A summary guide for health practitioners about obtaining consent for treatment Bridie Woolnough Resolution Officer Health Care.
The Family Drug and Alcohol Court Sophie Kershaw Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust Copyright presentation: FDAC Team.
Private Fostering “Someone else’s Child”
Tower Hamlets - Supporting Families Livia Culiceanu Kathy Nuza 27 th March 2014.
Safeguarding Young People Barbara Williams Independent Chair of North Tyneside Local Safeguarding Children board.
The Heart of the Matter: supporting family contact for fostered children.
Private Fostering – “Someone else’s Child”
Walsall Children & Young People’s Partnership Private Fostering To make growing up in Walsall as good as it can be.
Draft Code of Practice – General Consultation / Implementation Sue Woodgate.
Transition Planning North Tyneside. Transition Planning and the SEN Code of Practice Year 9 – aged 14 Multi – agency Annual Education (Transition) Review.
Childhood Neglect: Improving Outcomes for Children Presentation P17 Childhood Neglect: Improving Outcomes for Children Presentation Understanding the contribution.
CARE PROCEEDINGS REFORMS: An Overview Statutory Guidance and Public Law Outline Training.
Walking the Tightrope Balancing the needs of children and management.
Is all contact between children in care and their birth parents ‘good’ contact? Stephanie Taplin PhD NSW Centre for Parenting & Research 2006 ACWA Conference.
Care Matters: Time for Change A home with someone who cares.
The local authority view: current looked after children policy and outcomes Andrew Christie Director of Children’s Services London Borough of Hammersmith.
Seeing Around Corners: An Assessment Model For Families Who Parent From Permanent Care To Adoption ACWA Conference 2014.
Caring beyond the now An NDIS Participant Readiness activity funded by the Department of Communities, Child Safety and Disability Services.
CORPORATE PARENTING “If this were my child….”. “the collective responsibility across services and across councils to safeguard and promote the life chances.
Association of Childrens Welfare Agencies Conference 2006 Improving Care Through Accreditation- The Role of the NSW Children’s Guardian.
Implementation of the SEND Reforms – a national perspective A Time for Change – Working Together Waltham Forest Parent Carer Forum Conference Tuesday 17.
Mixing methods to research policy and practice Judith Masson Professor of Socio-legal Studies University of Bristol 2014 Legal Research Methods and methodologies.
Care planning and permanence Improving outcomes for looked after children.
SEN support in mainstream school Angie Fenn – Contact a Family.
Understanding Permanence Bruce Clark and Janet Boddy CAFCASS and University of Sussex.
© British Association for Adoption and Fostering 2015 Should you wish to reproduce or adapt or exhibit in public this material, please get in touch with.
Why Adopted Children need and deserve the support of Virtual Schools Gareth Marr Virtual School Governor Special School Director Independent Member Berkshire.
Office of the Guardian for Children and Young People Preventing abuse and improving the support for children who have been victims of crime while in care.
Bridie Woolnough Resolution Officer Health Care Complaints Commission
Adoption. jackman-on-adoption-in-australia-its-almost-like-they- try-to-put-you-off
Oral presentation to the Portfolio Committee on Social Development Submission to the Children’s Second Amendment Bill [B ] 25 th of September, 2015.
Presentation to Children’s Partnership Board 17 th July 2012 by Jill Forrest Head of Family Placements and Resources Slough Looked After Children, Young.
Rescue, Restore and Return. Is it possible for children through ONE Kinship Care Placement with little community assistance? Karen Lizasoain Samaritans.
ACWA Conference 2010 Barnardos Find-a-Family Working Together – Promoting Positive Relationships to Enhance Permanency Lisa Velickovich and Laura Ritchie.
Acknowledging the Past and Securing the Future. Working with birth families when Barnardos case plan is adoption Presenters Elizabeth Cox – Senior Manager.
Network Name Celebrating Good Practice Louise Burton & Jane Bhatti Safeguarding Health Practitioners 24 January 2012.
Families and Disability. At the beginning… Watch the following video and think about the following questions: What do you think the needs of these parents.
Being in Care. Joint priorities remain to… Improve outcomes for children, young people and families in Birmingham. In particular: Protect children from.
Roles and Responsibilities of the IRO. Role and Responsibilities of IRO When consulted about the guidance, children and young people were clear what they.
Placement Stability & Permanence. What is Permanence 'a sense of security, continuity, commitment and identity a secure, stable and loving family.
In Limbo Adoptive Placements and Large Sibling group adoptions
University College Cork 17 January 2013
The Children Act 1989 Allocates duties to local authorities, courts, parents and other agencies in the United Kingdom to ensure children are Safeguarded.
Child / Adult Y – Guernsey Serious Case Review
Care into practice: the legal framework
This briefing is intended to give you an understanding of:
Managing the risks and benefits of contact
Jade Purtell Stewart Muir
Placement Stability & Permanence
Mike Stein Research Professor
Disguised Compliance.
Placement Stability & Permanence
The Impact and Avoidance of Delay in Decision Making
The experiences and outcomes of children and young people from Wales receiving Secure Accommodation Orders 7 MINUTE BRIEFING.
Presentation transcript:

Disruption: Breakdown following court orders Special Guardianship, residence or adoption Judith Masson MA PhD Professor of Socio-legal Studies, University of Bristol ISS Conference Melbourne April 20161

Presentation 1.Outline the orders for permanency available in England and Wales Adoption Special guardianship (since 2005) Residence (now Child Arrangements) 2.Outline the changing use of these orders for children in OOHC (LAC) 3. Examine the different breakdown rates and reasons for them ISS Conference Melbourne April 20162

N children leaving care for adoption, Special Guardianship or residence orders (E) ISS Conference Melbourne April 20163

Use of Special Guardianship In child protection proceedings to secure care by relative (alternative legal arrangement: CO with relative as foster carer) For child in OOHC to provide permanency with foster carer For child on edge of care to secure care by relative (local authority promotes arrangement) As private family arrangement instigated by carer (most relative carers have no court order) ISS Conference Melbourne April 20164

Disruption rates (Selwyn et al 2014) All rates are low Definition ‘Return to care after order’ Risk at 5 years RO 147: 1000 SGO 57: 1000 AO 7: 1000 RO SGO AO ISS Conference Melbourne April 20165

Factors related to order disruption Cox P.H. model; not significant (Selwyn et al. 2014) Residence orderSpecial guardianship Order Adoption Order Age at entry to careReason for entry to careAge since order Number of moves Age at adoptive placement Placement is not with kin Time between placement and order Age since orderGender Reunified with parents beforeAge at placementWhether adopted by foster carers Legal status at entry to careTime from entry to ad. placement Age since order ISS Conference Melbourne April 20166

Understanding disruption: comparing SGO and Adoption (Selwyn et al 2014; Wade et al 2014) Commitment Assessment Preparation Transition Support ISS Conference Melbourne April 20167

Commitment Most SGO carers are very committed Higher breakdown risk for non-relatives suggests kin are more committed Selwyn noted exceptional commitment by many adopters Refusing to give up in the face of huge challenges child to parent violence Severe sibling conflict Breakdown of marriage etc Isolation because of loss of friends Only half of birth parents positive Most reluctantly accepted order ‘Zero support for us as a family. We hang on in there somehow for her sake because she deserves it, and we cannot contemplate the alternative. But it is at a huge cost to our emotional, physical and financial health.’ (Selwyn AUK survey) ISS Conference Melbourne April 20168

Assessment Far less rigorous for SGOs than adopters Uncertainty about how to assess kin Failure to recognise additional difficulties of abused/ neglected child Time constraints – superficial assessment Quality assurance more limited than for adoption The LA’s concerns were not always accepted by the court Concerns: new assessment regulations Greater focus on permanency – care to adulthood Greater focus on risks from parents who have abused or neglected child ISS Conference Melbourne April 20169

Preparation Lack of preparation for kin carers In Wade’s study Half guardians did not feel fully prepared 15% had not cared for child before order 20% felt pressure to agree 10% did not feel special guardianship was right order for them/ child ‘My mother was very manipulative, and unfortunately she kind of manipulated me into it, I believe. Because if I had thought about it properly, I don’t think I would have had the children…cos I’ve never actually wanted children’ ‘We didn’t really sit and discuss it with them at that time, cos I thought they were a bit young…We just told them they were going to be here a long time…I think they understood that.’ ISS Conference Melbourne April

Transition Adoption introductions are planned 30% adopters in breakdown study said introductions poorly handled (Selwyn) Statistically related to premature end of adoptive placement 15% of children were not living with special guardian before order Some of these had little pre-existing knowledge of child Issue for children too Outcome was better for children who had lived with carer before order At follow up (20-92 months post order) (Wade) 92 % special guardians thought children well integrated in the family 59% said things had gone very well for the child since the order Only 10% said ‘not very well ‘ or ‘not at all well’ ISS Conference Melbourne April

Support Little support for relative carers in UK More support for adopters – high on government agenda In Selwyn’s study adopters noted inadequate therapeutic support Some special guardians have a right to assessment Where children have been OOHC LA must assess Support package commonly agreed before order made: (80% in Wade study) Support tends to decline over time eg only 8% still had support with contact Financial support is means-tested Key supports: to manage child’s challenging behaviour; to cope with child’s complex needs; for birth family and with contact; finance. Need for contingency ISS Conference Melbourne April

Conclusion: improving kin care Recognise that children needing kin care have additional needs And make sure carers, agency and court knows what these are Recognise that kin care is not always best Ensure that those offering care are thoroughly assessed Understand that carers are pressured to offer Recognise that children and carers need preparation for the move Ensure that children and carer feel placement is right before making order Accept and prepare carers and agency for difficulties Develop accessible services ISS Conference Melbourne April

References Department for Education (2015), Children looked after in England (including adoption and care leavers) SFR 34/15 National Tables, available at Department for Education (2015) Special Guardianship Review d_Report.pdf Department of Education (2016) Special Guardianship Statutory Guidance available at _guidance.pdf Harwin et al. (2015) A national study of the usage of supervision orders and special guardianship over time ( ) Briefing paper no 1: Special guardianship orders Nuffield Foundation available at: Selwyn J. and Masson J. (2014) ‘Adoption, special guardianship and residence orders: a comparison of disruption rates. Family Law Journal, 44(12), pp Selwyn, J, Wijedasa, D. and Meakings, S. (2014) Beyond the adoption order: challenges, intervention and adoption disruption London: Department for Education available at research brief available at Wade J., Sinclair I., Stuttard l. and Simmonds, J. (2014). Investigating special guardianship: experiences, challenges and outcomes (Research Report DFERR372). Available from: ISS Conference Melbourne April