Workshop for Bureaux of Standards 27.2.2013 Bay Garden, St. Lucia EASTERN CARIBBEAN ENERGY LABELING PROJECT Christoph Menke Consultant CREDP/GIZ ECELP.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
European Commission n° 1 Energy labelling Jonathan Claridge European Commission 21 October 2003.
Advertisements

Ministry of Development BRASIL Workshop on Labelling (A Learning Event) Committee on Technical Barriers to Trade October 2003 A. Mariante President.
December 2005 EuP Directive : A Framework for setting eco-design requirements for energy-using products European Commission.
Cosa è ?. Mandatory labelling EU Energy Labelling Voluntary labelling EU Ecolabel EU Energy Star programme.
ENERGY STAR ® Most Efficient Appliance Sales Associate Training March 26, 2013.
Energy Using Products Directive Mark Shayler. Why? ? Rising level of electrical waste Shift in legislation Waste disposal and clean-up costs Resource.
1 NRCS presentation to: PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON ENERGY THEME: Exploring solutions to challenges on financing and certification on locally produced renewable.
A joint initiative of Australian, State and Territory and New Zealand Governments. Electric Motors Energy Efficiency in Australia – Moving forward Sara.
Harnessing the power of the sun: SHAMCI (Solar Heating Arab Mark and Certification Initiative) Presentation by: Rim Boukhchina Technical expert - RCREEE.
LOT30 Task 8: Scenario-, policy-, impact- and sensitivity analysis First Draft.
BP Biofuels a growing alternative Name Bob Saunders Title Russian Standards Conference, DBERR, 14 th Nov 2008.
REMODECE Project: WP6: Strategies for Market Transformation and Recommendations to Policy Makers Markogiannakis Georgios Centre for Renewable Energy Sources.
UAE Energy and Water Efficiency and Labeling Programs
So it all boils down to ‘$ and Sense’ No matter what your motivation energy conservation can be argued form both the dollar and sense position.
1 Renewed EU Sustainable Development Strategy EU Environmental Legislation 2.VII.2008 Warsaw, Poland “Business Support Programme for Bulgaria, Romania,
The International Task Force on Harmonization and Equivalency in Organic Agriculture (ITF)
10. Workshop ERFP Uppsala, June 4, 2005 Proposals for an ERFP contribution to FAO Regional consultation on SoW- AnGR Hermann Schulte-Coerne.
The Energy Labelling of Household Appliances: the EU policy framework Conference-roundtable: Towards the Introduction of the EU Energy Label for Household.
National Considerations for the Preparation and Application of Conformity Assessment Procedures Conformity assessment procedures implemented by local and.
Standards and Benchmarking for Energy Efficient Products Rod Janssen HELIO International and eceee September 23, 2009 Geneva.
An introduction to the IEA Implementing Agreement on Efficient Electrical End-use Equipment (4E) Hans-Paul Siderius (SenterNovem) Chair 4E ExCo.
INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL COOPERATION
E NERGY S TAR ® Refrigerated Beverage Vending Machine Industry Meeting Rachel Schmeltz, US EPA Georgia World Congress Center October 22, 2002.
1 REPUBLIC OF TURKEY PRIME MINISTRY UNDERSECRETARIAT OF FOREIGN TRADE General Directorate of Standardization for Foreign Trade Presented by Selin ÖZŞAHİN.
1 Leveraging the WTO/TBT Agreement New Delhi, India September 11, 2008 Elise Owen Representative for China and India Affairs American National Standards.
Standardization system in the European Union Werner STERK Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology Unit “Standardization, Conformity Assessment, Metrology”
CECED - EUROPEAN COMMITTEE OF DOMESTIC EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURERS Baltic WEEE Workshop Taking on the e-waste challenge in the Baltics 1 October Tallin,
Report on the Energy Efficiency Ad Hoc Group (EEAHG) IEC TC 100 AGS May 20, 2009 Jean Baronas INTERNATIONAL ELECTROTECHNICAL COMMISSION TECHNICAL COMMITTEE.
International Model for Technical Harmonization Earth-Moving Machine Safety Dan Roley/Jan Mimer/Kenzo Tanaka November 3, 2008.
The use and administration of ICSMS in Sweden UNECE MARS meeting in Bratislava, 12 September 2012 Amina Makboul.
China Energy Label Center, Ms. Zhang Shaojun Director of energy efficiency lab in CNIS Vice manager of China Standard Certification Co.,Ltd March.
Korea’s Testing & Compliance for Standards & Labeling February 27-28, 2012 Jennifer KIM KEMCO.
Safety of Electrical Products and the IEC Conformity Assessment Schemes A presentation to Regional Workshop in Conjunction with COPANT May, 2004.
1 Feb 27-28, th Meeting of the APEC Expert Group on Energy Efficiency & Conservation Sydney, Australia Testing and Compliance for Standards and.
Sensitisation Workshop for Communications and Media Practitioners November 2012 Dominica State College, Roseau, Dominica THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN ENERGY.
Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA) ADVANCING GLOBAL COMMUNICATIONS.
PRELIMINARY DRAFT EXCERPT RECOMMENDATIONS ON MEASUREMENT AND VERIFICATION METHODS IN THE FRAMEWORK OF DIRECTIVE 2006/32/EC ON ENERGY END-USE EFFICIENCY.
TESTING AND COMPLIANCE FOR STANDARD AND LABELLING Indonesia The 39 th APEC EGEEC Meeting Sydney, Australia, March 2012.
ECELP Policy Workshop 25 February 2013 Rodney Bay, St. Lucia POLICY AND REGULATORY FRAMEWORK FOR ENERGY EFFICIENCY STANDARDS AND LABELLING Detlef Loy Consultant.
Tim Farrell Appliance Energy Efficiency Branch November 2012 Australia’s Clean Energy Future and the role of energy efficiency 1.
IEC System of Conformity Assessment Schemes for Electrotechnical Equipment and Components.
1 New Energy Efficient Products Requirements: What Federal Purchasers Need to Know Joan Glickman Federal Environmental Symposium May 3, 2006.
Conference “Experience of Conformity Assessment (Notified) Bodies in the EU and Slovenia” Ljubljana, April 19, 2016   TCL Experience as a Conformity.
T Mr.Willy Musinguzi, EAC. .Overview of EAC SQMT Infrastructure How EAC standards are Harmonized and Implemented How EAC Quality Infrastructure relates.
SEAD-funded APEC-CAST Project Proposal Solicitation Update 39 th Meeting of the APEC Expert Group on Energy Efficiency & Conservation 28 February 2012.
ECELP Workshop for Bureaux of Standards February Bay Gardens Hotel, Rodney Bay, St. Lucia EASTERN CARIBBEAN ENERGY LABELING PROJECT Johanna Carstens.
Presentation to EU & ECEEE Expert Seminar on Measurement & Verification EU Proposed Directive on Energy Efficiency and Energy Services “The UK Energy Efficiency.
REGIONAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY STAKEHOLDERS WORKSHOP COMESA/SADC – Examples of Best Practice Policies for EE promotion Presentation by Luc Kevo Tossou Energy.
Country : Brazil Certification Name : PBE Brazil-EE-General Rev. 2.1 Date May. 31, 2013.
ISO17799 / BS ISO / BS Introduction Information security has always been a major challenge to most organizations. Computer infections.
APEC-ASEAN Harmonization of Energy Efficiency Standards for Air Conditioners: Phase 1 APEC EGEE&C 40 Taipei, Chinese Taipei Naoko DOI The Institute of.
Mauritius Standards Bureau
Renewable energy support schemes in the Republic of Moldova
Mauritius Standards Bureau
The IECEE Global Motor Energy Efficiency Programme
Electrical Energy Efficiency (E3)
Session 1 National Retailer Training Programme
The EAC Quality Infrastructure and WTO TBT Agreement.
The IECEE Global Motor Energy Efficiency Programme
Establishing an APEC MV&E Network
Ecodesign and Energy Labelling In Europe
Cheng Jianhong,China National Institute of Standardization (CNIS)
Private Sector Perspective: Key “Best Practices” that Strengthen Protection of Environment, Health and Safety while Facilitating Trade and Economic Development.
APEC – SHINE Facility EWG53 – Singapore – April 2017
U.S. Standards and Conformity Assessment System
Standardisation - What to expect from it?
New Zealand Testing and Compliance for Standards and Labelling
ETSI Standardization Activities on Smart Grids
ELECTROTECHNICAL – REGULATIONS IN SOUTH AFRICA Presented by Thabo Mabena 8/24/2019.
Overview of Energy efficiency sector
Presentation transcript:

Workshop for Bureaux of Standards Bay Garden, St. Lucia EASTERN CARIBBEAN ENERGY LABELING PROJECT Christoph Menke Consultant CREDP/GIZ ECELP WHICH APPROACH WOULD COUNTRIES CHOSE IN OECS FOR STANDARDIZATION AND LABELLING

We need to discuss which way to go?  Products come in from Latin America with labels from Argentina and EU and USA.  See next table: Refrigerators in St. Lucia Key Question:  Shall we follow one of the big LA countries or EU or USA or?  Is COPANT able to establish a regional standard (test protocol / Norm with MEPS) on which base then countries can issue their labels? THE FRAMEWORK FOR OECS

OVERVIEW ON FRIDGES CURRENTLY SOLD IN ST LUCIA COUNTRY OF ORIGINA MEXICO ITALY USA UK GERMANY CHINA LABELS FROM: EU USA (ENERGY GUIDE) ARGENTINA

 Currently in LAC countries many different national labels based on different standards are used.  Into the OECS countries appliances with any kind of label or even without any label are imported and sold. Assumption:  The OECS countries are too small to issue national standards and require that all imported items are tested according to their national standards.  If there is no national standard with testing, then does it make sense to issue a national label. Correct?  The OECS countries need to take over a regional or international widely known standard as a base to issue their national labels. BACKGROUND OF THE SITUATION - 1

 Most appliances in the OECS countries are coming from Latin- American countries, some from the US and EU and some from Asia. All with different labels!  Some products are coming in without any label!  COPANT is the regional standard organisation that has started to issue regional standards  But only when COPANT standard are up-to date and are widely adopted in the Region, then they can have an impact on market development/transformation of household appliances towards more efficient ones.  Only when the COPANT standards are widely recognized by many countries in LAC as a base for issuing the national labels, then the manufacturers will be interested to get their products tested based on COPANT standards as well in addition to EU and/or US standards. BACKGROUND – ROLE OF COPANT

 So far it is not clear if countries in LAC are using COPANT standards to issue their national labels  St. Lucia is currently adopting the COPANT standard  Currently the EU has a regular updating of its standards (directives) for household appliances to transform markets;  It seems that COPANT is following the EU directives approach only after some time, e.g. for refrigerators it is the norm from 2005(?)  The US has the energy star system and the Energy Guide system, which are different and are not used to issue comparative national labels based on A-G concept from EU and COPANT easily.  Mexico and Central American countries follow this concept. BACKGROUND – 3: EU OR US?

Which way shall OECS follow?  Latin America: Brazil/Chile/Argentina (EU approach) for:  Lab-test protocol (ISO, IEC, etc.)  Standards based on Min. Energy Performance Stand.  Issuing categorical comparative labels, like EU  Or Mexican, Central American approach (US) for:  Lab-test protocol (ANSI-ASHRAE, US)  Standards based on Min. Energy Performance Stand.  Issuing us labels based on Energy Guide, like the US  Or wait on COPANT to issue regional standards NEXT STEPS – WHAT DO WE HAVE TO DISCUSS/DECIDE?

 Mexico, Central America follow US concept  Have different test protocol, different standard, different label  Are based on Mexican and/or US conditions  LA countries, follow EU concept, but standards would in best case be based on e.g. Brazilian conditions (Minimum of life cycle costs for Brazil)  and may not be applicable for Caribbean conditions  Therefore categories of labels may not fit for OECS situation to transform the market here CHALLENGE WITH ANY LAC APPROACH

 Do we want to do our own economic market analysis to set e correct the categories for labels to achieve the Minimum life cycle costs?  Or do we want to use some label from an other country or Region (EU)?  Do we have the resources to do this “trimming” of standards regularly for major appliances?  Because if not, then we shall just take over some standard and label and follow their way  Is COPANT a solution?  But is it recognized by countries and manufacturer? OWN MARKET RESEARCH FOR LABEL SETTING?

 On which base(standards) are countries in LAC are issuing their national EE labels, e.g. Brazil, Mexico, Chile?  Are the national standards based on COPANT standards?  COPANT: The principle of COPANT is that all countries members shall adopt COPANT standard as basis for national standards, but this is not always the case, and our members could maintain their National Standards.  The COPANT standards are based on international standards ISO and IEC, consequently are aligned with ISO and IEC.  Beside, COPANT is looking to reduce the elaboration of regional standards and to motivate our members to actively participate in the international standardization process and to adopt international standards. ARE COPANT STANDARD USED ANYWHERE? QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS - COPANT

 Are any Latin American countries using standards according to COPANT standards?  COPANT: Yes, by recommendation of COPANT’s Board of Directors (?)  Are they using the COPANT standard e.g. for refrigerators (dated 2006)  COPANT: During the last meeting of the COPANT TC 151 Electrotechnic and SmartGrid and TC 152 Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energies, held in Buenos Aires, on November 2012, the coordinators recommended all COPANT members to adopt the COPANT harmonized standards as basis for their national standards.  “please take into consideration that the technical work of both technical committees is to identify the deviations regionally or nationally of the IEC standard, and pointed it in the COPANT Standard” QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS - COPANT

 Or do the countries use their own standards? Do they have a common standard that can be applied in the OECS as well?  COPANT: We do not have information about this.  At COPANT General Assembly to be held in Saint Lucia, on April 2013, we will have the opportunity to discuss with all Caribbean countries and, in special the participants of OECS, how to adopt COPANT standards as basis of their national standards, and more specially to motivate them to actively participate on COPANT Technical work. QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS - COPANT

 How well-known is COPANT in the Region?  Are manufacturers/ suppliers already get the certification according to COPANT standards in addition to the EU/US one? E.g. For refrigerators?(NORMA COPANT )  COPANT: Each country adopts certification based on its own national standards.  We know that the national standards are based on ISO and IEC standards.  There is no certification with COPANT Standard, normally is with an international or national standard. IS COPANT STANDARD RECOGNIZED? QUESTIONS FOR COPANT

Assumption:  So far LAC countries are members of COPANT but still develop their own national standards..  Key Question: Is their a chance/expectation that this will change in the near future?  COPANT: We are not looking for a regional certification, but for an harmonization of the conformity assessment criteria in line with international standards, and harmonization of standards where there is no International Standards, or where they don’t fill the needs in the Region. QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS - COPANT

 What does COPANT plan in regard to issuing EE standards for household appliances in the future?  For what kind of appliances does COPANT plan to issue standards?  COPANT: Refrigerators, freezers and combined household appliances; Air conditioners type “window” and type "split"; Tubular, circular and compact fluorescent lamps; Electrical three-phase induction motors; Ballasts for discharge lamps; Washing clothes machines for household use; Fixed electrical appliances for instantaneous water heating; Electrical boiler water heaters for domestic use; Solar heaters; Standby of electronic appliance; Electrical pumps; Boiler gas water heaters; Gas cooking appliances – stoves and ovens; Instantaneous gas water heaters; Electrical monophasic motors; Energy Efficiency of building; LED lamps.  Does COPANT have a timeline until when the standards will be issued?  COPANT: The timelines will be established according the list above. FUTURE PLANS OF COPANT? QUESTIONS FOR COPANT

 Does COPANT want to use EU directives as guidance for their standards?  COPANT : Yes, it will be considered during COPANT harmonization processes.  How quickly do they plan to adopt EU directives? (E.G. the current refrigerator standard is quite old compared to the current EU directive.)  COPANT : It depends on item B above.  Does COPANT plan, that the standards issued by COPANT will be the base for national labelling programmes in all member countries?  COPANT: Yes, it is the recommendation on item 1C above.  Is that realistic, seeing, that Brazil and Mexico do have already their own national standard and labelling system established?  COPANT: Yes, the experiences of Brazil and Mexico, as well from Argentina, are being considered on COPANT’s discussions.  What is the plan to achieve a regional synchronisation for standards?  COPANT At several meetings of TC 152, we will highlight the need of adopting the harmonized COPANT standards as basis for national standards.  The issue of regional standards will be synchronized with IEC and ISO standards. QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS - COPANT

 “In Barbados, the BNSI is expecting to publish its first energy labeling standard, entitled,  Labeling – Energy labeling of household appliances and products  which will require and or mandate that an energy label be affixed to every household appliance at the point of sale.  Their standard is flexible to allow for the use of recognized energy labels from other countries and regions such as the EU, South America and the US to name a few.  Additionally, Barbados has designed its own energy label based on the US Federal Trade Commission Energy Guide.”  Is this concept appropriate and does it serve the purpose? B’DOS CONCEPT: IS THAT A SOLUTION FOR A FIRST STEP?

 “If the product or its packaging contains any energy efficiency label by manufacturer, this label shall be displayed at the point of sale;  for the following product groups only such products that carry energy efficiency labels, which have been awarded according to official specifications and whose conformity is certified by accredited test laboratories, may be imported and/or sold:  refrigerators, freezers, refrigerator-freezer-combinations, air conditioning systems, washing machines, tumble dryers, washer-dryers, televisions, computer monitors and illuminates;”  Is that way appropriate? DOMINICA CONSUMER PROTECTION APPROACH:

 Do we have in OECS enough “man power and money” to set own standards and labels and update them regularly?  Will COPANT be the regional leader and their standards are recognized and used in LAC one day?  Or can we mandate to have only one standard from one LA or EU or US accepted here? (would be easy for consumers)  Or do we go for “Quick and Easy” – Any recognized label is accepted.. (would be more difficult for consumer) but products would get better anyway worldwide because of the EU/US standards  And then we do just cross checking and a lot of consumer awareness through random testing of appliances and PR work SUMMARY FOR THE DISCUSSION

For more information please contact: Christoph Menke, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR ATTENTION