. Climate Problems & Climate Solutions for Low Income Customers and Disadvantaged Communities Presentation to Low Income Oversight Board by Robert Freehling.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
EDISON INTERNATIONAL® SM Green Technology and Renewable Energy Opportunities 4 th Annual India Trade Conference, June 23, 2011 Cerritos CA Gary Barsley.
Advertisements

California’s MASH Low Income Solar PV Incentive Program October 5, 2011 Melanie McCutchan Senior Analyst California Center for Sustainable.
California GHG policy and implications for the power sector APEX Sydney Conference October 13, 2008 Anjali Sheffrin, PhD.
SMUD Sustainable Energy Supply Progress in Carbon Reduction POU 101: CMUA Briefing of Legislative Staff February 26 th, 2015 Obadiah Bartholomy Powering.
Workshop for Proposed EPIC Triennial Plans Investor Owned Utility Programs July 31, 2014.
Energy Efficiency and Arizona’s Energy Future Jeff Schlegel Southwest Energy Efficiency Project (SWEEP) April
Connecticut’s Energy Future Removing Barriers to Promote Energy Sustainability: Public Policy and Financing December 2, 2004 Legislative Office Building.
State Energy Office NC Department of Administration Energy and Environmental Initiatives in North Carolina – Accelerating Change Bob Leker.
DRA Advocacy Joe Como, Acting Director. 2 DRA Facts The Voice of Consumers, Making a Difference! 3  History: CPUC created DRA (formerly known as the.
Containing the Cost of California’s RPS Yuliya Shmidt, Senior Analyst February 2, 2012.
1 CPUC Responsibilities for Renewable and Energy Efficiency Resource Commitments by Investor-Owned Utilities and Ratepayers Hearing on Public Goods Charge.
CHEAPER AND CLEANER: Using the Clean Air Act to Sharply Reduce Carbon Pollution from Existing Power Plants, Delivering Health, Environmental and Economic.
CCPUC Annual Meeting Commission Policy and Wall Street Bill Nusbaum Managing Attorney TURN October 5, 2009.
PLS WORKSHOP September 18, 2012 Greg Miller Ice Energy Terry Andrews CALMAC Manufacturing Corp.
Energy Policy Levers. 2 State as a Taxing Authority Income tax credits or deductions Income tax credits or deductions Residential Alternative Energy Tax.
Renewable Energy: Legal and Policy Issues Frank Prager Vice President, Environmental Policy Xcel Energy November 20, 2009 Frank Prager Vice President,
NH Utilities Programs/ Carbon Reduction Opportunities Thomas Palma, Esq., CSDP Project Development Executive.
COPYRIGHT © 2010 BALLARD POWER SYSTEMS INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED B A L L A R D P O W E R S Y S T E M S PUTTING FUEL CELLS TO WORK NOVEMBER 2010 Utilizing.
A Balanced Energy Plan for Alaska’s Railbelt Opportunities for End-Use Efficiency/Conservation and Renewable Energy Prepared for the Alaska Clean.
24 Jan What is Energy Policy?ECONOMICS ENVIRONMENT ENERGY SECURITY.
1 Managing Renewables Integration Valerie Fong Utilities Director Power Association of Northern California September 17, 2013.
C A L I F O R N I A E N E R G Y C O M M I S S I O N California Energy Commission’s Energy Efficiency Research Activities Related to the HVAC Industry David.
Renewable Energy in New Jersey’s Clean Energy Program Scott Hunter Renewable Energy Program Administrator, Office of Clean Energy in the New Jersey Board.
Legislation Crossfire Setting the Stage Legislation Crossfire Setting the Stage David K. Owens AABE Chair Legislative Issues and Public Policy Committee.
Climate Change Actions taken by the California Public Utilities Commission.
Energy Action Plan “Report Card” and the AB32 “Umbrella” CFEE ROUNDTABLE CONFERENCE ON ENERGY Julie Fitch California Public Utilities Commission Director.
How the State of California Can Play A Greater Role in Addressing Global Warming Leonard Robinson – Chief Deputy Director California Department of Toxic.
California Energy Efficiency Retrofit Market Size Estimates, Alongside Solar and Demand Response Options Reference material for October 12, 2012 Governor’s.
STATE WATER EFFICIENCY AND ENHANCEMENT PROGRAM Jenny Lester Moffitt Deputy Secretary.
New Jersey Board Of Public Utilities Office of Clean Energy Air Innovations - Chicago August 10,2004 NJBPU - OCE New Jersey’s Solar Program An Integrated.
AB 32 “ “I SAY THE DEBATE IS OVER! “ AB 32 “GLOBAL WARMING SOLUTIONS ACT OF 2006 ” BY 2020, 30% REDUCTION TO 1990 LEVELS BY 2050, 80% REDUCTION TO 1990.
Creating and Sustaining Clean Energy Markets Sustainable Energy Fund Energy Service Provider Conference Hershey, PA January 29, 2011.
California Energy Commission 2015 IEPR Self-Generation Forecast Sacramento, CA 7/07/2015 Asish Gautam Demand Analysis Office Energy Assessments Division.
Federal Policy Impacts on California Energy Policy California Conference of Public Utility Commission Attorneys Monterey, California October 5, 2009 Commissioner.
An Overview of the Smart Grid David K. Owens Chair, AABE Legislative Issues and Public Policy Committee AABE Smart Grid Working Group Webinar September.
Distributed Energy Resources The Energy Challenge of the 21 st Century.
Investing in America’s Electric Future Morry Markowitz Group Director, External Affairs New Mexico Utility Shareholders Alliance October 7, 2009.
Legislative Summary For The Low Income Oversight Board (LIOB) Meeting on 24 March, 2009, at Burbank.
Community Choice Energy as a Community Development Strategy for Oakland March 30, 2010.
California Takes Charge: Policies and Incentives for Energy Storage February 11, 2015 Rebecca Feuerlicht, SGIP Project Manager, Center for Sustainable.
January ‘06Advice to Minister1. January ‘06Advice to Minister2 Understanding Climate Change Climate Change Action Plan Elements Climate Change Action.
1 Update on the California Solar Initiative Molly Tirpak Sterkel California Public Utilities Commission December 8, 2008.
CPUC Role in AB 32 Implementation LIOB – 2 nd June, 2010 San Diego, CA.
AEE So Cal September 24, 2015 Integrating Renewables and The Distribution Grid of the Future 1.
Southern California Edison The San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station April 14, 2011.
Utilities’ Update on Energy Savings Assistance Program Studies Ordered in D LIOB Meeting August 21, 2013 Sacramento, California.
More Than Smart – A Distribution System Vision © 2011San Diego Gas & Electric Company. All copyright and trademark rights reserved. Dave Geier – VP Electric.
Marin Clean Energy Choice and Competition - Driving Innovation towards Environmental Goals May 2015.
California Energy Commission 2015 IEPR Self-Generation Forecast Sacramento, CA 12/17/2015 Asish Gautam Demand Analysis Office Energy Assessments Division.
California Energy Action Plan December 7, 2004 Energy Report: 2004 and 2005 Overview December 7, 2004.
CEC Public Workshop Order Instituting Informational and Rulemaking Proceeding (08-DR-01) March 3, 2008.
Renewables Portfolio Standard Status Report California Public Utilities Commission February 26 th, 2008.
Greenhouse Gas Initiatives: progress and perspective Sandra Meier Environmental Energy Alliance of New York.
Overview of SB 350 California Public Utilities Commission Melicia Charles, Energy Division February 23,
© 2016 Portland General Electric. All rights reserved. I NTEGRATED R ESOURCE P LAN 2016 OPUC Meeting April 21, 2016.
Connecting the Dots: Policy, Markets and the Clean Energy Future New England Restructuring Roundtable Boston, MA September 30, 2016.
Sustainable Future – Trends and Reality
Integrated Resource Plan 2016
Clean Energy Federalism
San Francisco’s Community Choice Program
SMUD - Whole Foods Energy Storage System
Presented to the NARUC 2013 Winter Meeting
The Transition to a High DER Future
Opportunities in the Changing Energy System
Bridging State Policy to Local Implementation
Forging Sustainable Solar (and Storage) Incentives for New England
Metropolitan Mayors Caucus Illinois Energy Bills
Longmont’s Renewable Energy Future: We’re out in front!
Independent Energy Producers (IEP) Steven Kelly, IEP Policy Director
Medium & Heavy Duty Electric Transportation Rate Designs at SCE
Presentation transcript:

. Climate Problems & Climate Solutions for Low Income Customers and Disadvantaged Communities Presentation to Low Income Oversight Board by Robert Freehling February 23, 2016

Global Warming & Low Income Customers Problems of Global Warming Climate—Higher temperatures, More extreme weather events Resources—Water, Food, Energy, Environmental Services Public Health & Safety—Fire, Flood, Pollution, Disease

Global Warming & Low Income Customers Electric Utility System Problems Increased Demand-- for Air Conditioning Lower Efficiency– A/C, Power Plants (NG, Solar, Wind), Vehicles, Grid Wires More Natural Gas Plants—over 20,000 MW new in California since 2000, local reliability, back up variable renewables = More Air Pollution, Higher Bills & Price Risk, Reduced Energy Security, Greater Environmental & EJ Burden

Climate Change: Demographic Problems Disadvantaged Communities Face Cumulative Challenges Low Income High Unemployment High Pollution Health Problems Identified by Cal EPA EJ Screening 

Climate Change: Demographic Problems “’effect modifiers’…can increase health risk…from 3-fold to 10-fold or greater, depending on the combination of pollutants and underlying susceptibilities. ~California Environmental Protection Agency CalEnviroScreen

Program Alternatives & Demographics Customers on CARE Rate Customers with Low Income Customers in Disadvantaged Communities Three Categories overlap but not identical

Program Alternatives & Demographics Customers on “CARE Rate” < $40,180/yr Customers with HUD “Low Income” < $84,500 SF Co < $41,700 Kern Co Categories overlap but not identical Maximum Income for 3 Person Household

Problems with Climate Solutions Cap & Trade—Local polluting sources continue Rates—Increasing utility costs, Complex rate structures, Increased risk Energy Conversion—Access to electrification of transportation & domestic natural gas Clean Energy—Developed in other geographic locations, remote for large scale, disproportionally higher income for DERs

Problems with Climate Solutions California Solar Initiative CA Climate Plan—3000 MW Rooftop Solar; SB 1 Investment—$3.5 Billion Program; ~$12 Billion Customers Low Income—SASH & MASH, 45 MW, $200 Million Program; (<10% of CSI Funds; only ~3% of MW) Net Meter—Low rate for CARE & low usage tiers

Challenge: Income & Net Metering Average income of net metering customers is 68% higher than California average, 34% greater than IOU service territories’ average. California Net Energy Metering Ratepayer Impacts Evaluation, California Public Utilities Commission, October 2013, p CARE Rate in person household upper limit: $39,580 Average income of net metering customers = $91,210 per year

Challenge: Income & Net Metering California Net Energy Metering Ratepayer Impacts Evaluation, CPUC, October 2013, Appendix E, Income Analysis, Advent Consulting Associates, p. E-15. Lowest incomes under-represented in Net Metering by factor of ~2 to 3 Highest incomes over-represented in Net Metering by factor of ~2 to 3

Problems with Climate Solutions Solar Barriers Cost—Residential Solar Costs ~$25,000 Credit—Lease requires credit score of 650 Tax Subsidy—30% federal ITC requires sufficient taxable income Net Meter Rules—Limit siting & bill credit options

New Programs Solar Solutions SASH & MASH II—Additional $100 M; 50 MW Shared Renewables (SB 43, Wolk)—includes 100 MW located in disadvantaged communities Net Meter 2.0 (AB 327, Perata)—Requires alternatives for residential customers in disadvantaged communities Multifamily Solar (AB 693, Eggman)—300 MW goal for low income residential & disadvantaged communities; 10% IOU C&T funding w/max $100 M/year for 10 years

New Programs Program Needs SASH & MASH II—Program already running out of funds Shared Renewables (SB 43, Wolk)—Program provides no funding; strict rules against cost shifting; may need funding Net Meter 2.0 (AB 327, Perata)—Defining options in CPUC Phase II; Virtual NEM, Other?; may need more funding Multifamily Solar (AB 693, Eggman)—Counts toward NEM 2.0; work out design & benefit allocation

New Programs Opportunities Program Integration—Coordinate DERs, solar, DR, EE, smart grid, local reliability, public safety Funding Options—Cap & Trade, environment penalties, SGIP, IOU Procurement (EE, RPS, DR, Storage), public goods $$ Strategies to Lower Cost—Scale deployment, storage w/solar, etc. Community Coordination—Low income & EJ groups, IOUs, CPUC, local government

Extra Slides