Indonesia in Perspective’s Study Case Corruption in IndonesiaCauses of CorruptionLesson Learned.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Roots of Corruption Eric M. Uslaner Department of Government and Politics University of Maryland--College Park College Park, MD USA
Advertisements

GAMBIA COMPETITION COMMISSION GAMBIA COMPETITION COMMISSION Levelling the Field for Development BY : EXECUTIVE SECRETARY 5 TH JUNE 2013.
Government’s Role in Economy
INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR CONSERVATION OF NATURE. 2 Implemented in 12 countries of Africa, Asia, Latin America and the Middle East, through IUCN regional.
Can global integrity indicators identify operational entry points for anticorruption reforms? 1 Course on Actionable Governance Indicators: Making AGIs.
Competition Culture The Key to Successful Competition Regime 3 rd BRICS International Competition Conference New Delhi, November 21-22, 2013 Pradeep S.
Towards a Unified Methodology for Measuring Corruption Global Forum V on Fighting Corruption and Safeguarding Integrity 2 – 5 April 2007 Johannesburg,
Preconditions for Effective Implementation of anti-corruption measures.
Korea’s Integrity Perceptions Index Sub-Theme 2: Taking Stock through Monitoring and Evaluation Workshop on “Monitoring the Prevalence of Corruption” Geo-Sung.
6 August 2015 Rule of law: implementing a comprehensive and integrated approach in prevention and fight against corruption in the Danube region,
PRIVATE SECTOR APPROACHES TO FIGHTING CORRUPTION Ruslan Stefanov Coordinator of the Economic Program Center for the Study of Democracy, Sofia, Bulgaria.
International Corruption laws & Culture HCA 457i Michelle Wheeler, Miyeon Kim.
Georgia's Best Practice in Fight Against Corruption Otar Kakhidze
Using the UN Convention against Corruption as a Basis for Good Governance.
Corruption Perception Index David Fenjves and Matias Molina.
Measuring & Monitoring Governance in Developing Countries Stephen Knack The World Bank 2 nd International Roundtable Marrakesh, Feb
Bratislava October 2007 PAR - AC CoP Meeting Anti Corruption Regional Programme Regional Programme.
INDONESIAN CSO S ’ EXPERIENCES IN ADVOCATING FOI LAW Josi Khatarina Henri Subagiyo Indonesian Center for Environmental law Coalition for Freedom of Information.
Module 3 Why measure corruption? Assessment anxiety? vast diversity of approaches that serve different purposes UNCAC reporting mechanism asks countries.
Managing the sways of corruption: The role of a Prosecutor in an International Hybrid Court Robert Petit.
Compliance and Corporate Social Responsibility 6th CIS LOCAL COUNSEL FORUM Mr. Alexander Bolkvadze, Partner, BLC Law Office - Tbilisi.
IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL NORMS UN Convention Against Corruption as a tool for behavioural change.
Introducing and Implementing Anti-corruption Monitoring System in Bulgaria and in the SEE region International Conference “Cooperation of the National.
CORPORATE LIABILITY UNDER GERMAN LAW FROM A TRANSPARENCY INTERNATIONAL- PERSPECTIVE Berlin – ABA 2015 Europe Forum Mechtild Lauth.
Anti-Corruption, the Swedish way Gunnar Stetler Head of the Swedish Anti-Corruption Unit
THE AUDIT BOARD OF INDONESIA. THE RESEARCH 1. Respondents 157 persons from 16 agencies : 8 government agencies, National Police Department, Attorney General.
Global Corruption Barometer 2010 Dhaka 9 December 2010.
The National Development Plan, Iraq 6 July 2010 “Developing Objectives & Indicators for Strategic Planning” Khaled Ehsan and Helen Olafsdottir UNDP Iraq.
Activity 1 Experiences vs. perceptions of corruption 2 minute challenge: Write a question you could ask in a survey, to find out about: people’s experiences.
Transparency International Bangladesh Measuring Corruption in Bangladesh: Can Communication Work? Iftekhar Zaman Executive Director.
CURBING CORRUPTION IN LOCAL GOVERNMENTS IN UGANDA : EXPERIENCE OF BUSHENYI DISTRICT Presented by Bitarabeho Johnson Chief Administration Officer, Bushenyi.
Political economy of tax regimes in South Asia: The Context By G. Shabbir Cheema Director Asia-Pacific Governance and Democracy Initiative East-West Center.
CORRUPTION. International standards in criminal law – what do we need? National legislation – what do we have? What is corruption? Manifestations of corruption.
Ratification of the United Nations Convention against Corruption in Lithuania A Review of the Compliance of the Lithuanian Legal and Institutional Framework.
C N A O AUDIT TO DETECT FRAUD AND CORRUPTION: EVALUATION OF THE FIGHT AGAINST CORRUPTION AND MONEY LAUNDERING National Audit Office of the People’s Republic.
Relief effort in Aceh, TI Indonesia activities as model of Civil Society Engagement.
Capacity Development Results Framework A strategic and results-oriented approach to learning for capacity development.
Overcoming the Resource Curse in African States: Examining the Effectiveness of the Developmental State Framework on Economic Development in Resource-Rich.
Measures of corruption
Competition Advocacy: Need and Importance Udai S Mehta Director, CUTS International.
Governance in Central and Eastern Europe Cheryl W. Gray Europe and Central Asia Region World Bank.
Crime Control Measures, Individual Liberties and Crime Rates: An Assessment of 40 Countries Jay S. Albanese, Ph.D. Virginia Commonwealth University
The Role of Civil Society in Improving Transparency and Acccountability in Mozambique Centre For Public Integrity work.
Measuring and Monitoring Levels of Corruption in Bulgaria and South East Europe Methodology, Results and Public Impact.
Corruption in Vietnam Definition, Characteristics, Legal Framework and Prevention Associate, Professor. Hoang Van Hoan, PhD Vice- President of Academy.
Fighting against corruption in Central America Chapter 8, State of the Region Report (2008) 13th Global Anticorruption Conference. Athens, 2008.
Module 3: Civic Initiatives for Judicial Reform and Countering Corruption September 16, 2005.
Civil Society Participation and Contribution to the UNCAC Review Process Towards Transparency – TI National Contact Vietnam UNCAC Self Assessment Process:
A.I. Т URCHINOV The Public Service of Russia: condition and problems of its development Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration.
Justice for the Poor Indonesia From Research to Operations
What is Democracy?.
ETHICS AND CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY IN A GLOBAL CONTEXT
Local Government : Concept and Theoretical Overview Dr
Corporate Integrity System (CIS)
Corruption Diagnostics
FIGHTING CORRUPTION AND POVERTY: ARE WE GETTING IT RIGHT?
Београд, 9. јул Belgrade, July 9th 2013
GOOD GOVERNANCE AND FIGHT AGAINST CORRUPTION
Practicing law in transforming Indonesia
Corruption- A Theoretical Perspective
Andrew N. Vorkink Country Director for Turkey
Business in Partnership Against Corruption
Empowerment and Decentralization: The Demand Side
Causes of Corruption – George Benson
Government’s Role in Economy
Boris Divjak Transparency International BiH Sarajevo, g.
The role of Supreme Audit Institutions in fragile situations: initial findings Research by David Goldsworthy and Silvia Stefanoni of Development Action.
The European Anti-Corruption Report
CORRUPTION AND DEVELOPMENT SIMAD UNIVERSITY LECTURER: MOHAMED SHEIKH AHMED.
The Economics of Corruption and Bribery
Presentation transcript:

Indonesia in Perspective’s Study Case Corruption in IndonesiaCauses of CorruptionLesson Learned

Indonesia in Perspective’s Study Case Corruption in IndonesiaCauses of CorruptionLesson Learned Overview Extent of Corruption Forms of Corruption The Most Affected Sector

Overview. After the fall of General Suharto, Indonesia has underground a successful transition from authoritarian rule to become one of the largest democracies in Asia and in the world. Even the local government has been empowered and the judiciary has been granted greater independence and a national campaign again corruption has been initiated, corruption is still a major problem in Indonesia. OverviewExtent of CorruptionForms of Corruption The Most Affected Sector

Extent of Corruption. All available data and country reports indicate that corruption remains widespread, permeating all levels of society. Recent anti – corruption efforts such as the establishment of strong anti corruption agency have led to conviction of several high – ranking public officials, but lack of institutional capacity and weak rule of law combine with poor regulatory quality still create fertile grounds for corruption. The situation reflected in the major worldwide government indicators, Indonesia ranked 100 out of 183 countries assessed by Transparency International's Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) on scale 3 out of 10 (10 is highly clean). OverviewExtent of CorruptionForms of Corruption The Most Affected Sector

Forms of Corruption. Both bureaucratic and grand corruption are present in Indonesia. Bureaucratic is exacerbated by Indonesia’s weak administrative capacity, low salaries and the lack of oversight. In this context bureaucratic and administrative forms of corruption are widespread across all public services and agencies. OverviewExtent of CorruptionForms of Corruption The Most Affected Sector

The Most Affected Sector. The police sector, according to the Indonesia Corruption Perception and Bribery Index, 48 % of the respondents confess that they have bribes the police. The judiciary, similarly to the police 52 % of Indonesians surveyed in the global Corruption Barometer perceive that the judiciary is corrupt. Parliament and Political Parties are also perceived as highly corrupt according to the Indonesians statement in the latest Global Corruption Barometer survey for 52 %. OverviewExtent of CorruptionForms of Corruption The Most Affected Sector

Indonesia in Perspective’s Study Case Corruption in IndonesiaCauses of CorruptionLesson Learned Theoretically Main Causes

Theoretically Studies have shown a correlation between corruption and low GDP, inequality of income, inflation and lack of competition. A few scholars have developed theoretical models, Nye (1967) and Rose – Ackerman (1999) highlighting that corruption is the result of the equilibrium between resources and cost, balancing potentials benefits against costs and consequences. In 1998 Klitgaard defines corruption with a formula : “Corruption = Rent + Direction – Accountability”. TheoreticallyMain Causes

Main Causes : Structural Factors. Often let the lower level employee to handle important task such as income levels, income inequality, openness to trade and long exposure to democracy.. Historical Factors. Indonesia passed through many years of authoritarian regime when Suharto ruled the country surrounded by networks of patrons and clients. In exchange for support Suharto ensured that his relatives, friends, partner or family were granted benefits. inadequate. TheoreticallyMain Causes

Main Causes : Decentralization. Scholars have also found that the form of decentralization may also affect levels of corruption. Empowering the local governments are also to ensure that the local government has enough money to do their services, which is tend to corruption. Quality of Business Regulations. There is also a strong correlation between regulatory and corruption. Higher regulatory leads to lower level of corruption. TheoreticallyMain Causes

Main Causes : Public Sector Wages. People tend to try corruption to get more money when they not satisfied with their wages. Judiciary. Bribes are often paid to influence prosecutions convictions, sentencing in civil and criminal case National Resources. Studies have also found that abundance of natural resources may be a cause of corruption it creates rent – seeking where law enforcement mechanism are inadequate. TheoreticallyMain Causes

Indonesia in Perspective’s Study Case Corruption in IndonesiaCauses of CorruptionLesson Learned Conclusion Question and Answer Credits

Conclusion. The existing institutions seems incapable due to lack of political will, qualified personnel will enforce the rules in place at all levels. In Order to prevent and combat corruption accountability and transparency should be enhanced. Similarly important, it is to reform the political system as to strengthen the country’s democracy, ensuring, for instance, that the role money has been playing in politics does not distort the political process. In addition a well functioning judiciary is a pre – requisite for ending the culture of impunity reigns in the country. Finally, a culture shift – from clientelism to universalism is instrumental in allowing such reforms to be implemented fully and rapidly. Conclusion Question and Answer Credits

Q & A Conclusion Question and Answer Credits

This presentation is belong to group # 13 : Natasya Sakinah Irma Yunita Rudy Rachmadi Conclusion Question and Answer Credits