“THIS HAS BEEN THE WORST EXPERIENCE OF MY LIFE.” THE INTERNSHIP CRISIS AND ITS IMPACT ON STUDENTS Tyler C. Bradstreet, M.S., Mike C. Parent, Ph.D. – Texas.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Bridging Race, Income and Cultural Differences to Support Student Success.
Advertisements

Educational Reconstruction Efforts and the Well-being of Teachers in Postwar Liberia: When is Now? Janet Shriberg Doctoral Candidate Teachers College,
Developing the engagement, retention and success of Care Leavers Mike Hill Director of Academic Development Jayne Clanfield Education Liaison Manager Emily.
Mary R. Callahan, Ed. D.. Study Description Mixed-methods study (April, 2013) Use of survey (PSSDS,2009) and 10 semi-structured interview questions Three.
Maintaining Core Leadership Skills in Times of Crisis Presenter: Loni Davis, M.A. Davis & Associates Organizational Consulting Services.
Judith McNamara Catherine Campbell Emily Darling Moving beyond traditional clinics: creating a new legal clinic through community partnerships.
Entrepreneurial Mind-Set
Strengthening Families: An Effective Approach to Supporting Families.
Welcome to MindLab’s Tele-Training Self-Paced Tutorial for the Coping & Stress Profile ®
ADVANCE Implementation Mentors (AIM) Network Women of Color Survey and Interview Results Funding for this presentation was made possible through the National.
Genre Shift: Instructor Presence and its Impact on Student Satisfaction in Online Learning.
Bridges and Barriers in the Development of Faith, Identity, and Life Purpose in College Seniors Katie Byron Whitney Guthrie Cindy Miller-Perrin Don Thompson.
The experience of therapy trainees and therapists participating in research  Mark Widdowson, University of Leicester  Ref:- “Mark Widdowson.
ETHICAL RESEARCH © 2012 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
Mentoring is A Fine Balance
An investigation of the impact of student support initiatives on the retention of computer science students Clem O’Donnell 1, James Murphy 2, Abdulhussain.
Coaching and Providing Feedback for Improved Performance
METHODS IN BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH NINTH EDITION PAUL C. COZBY Copyright © 2007 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
Teachers mentoring teachers: A process of reflection and rejuvenation
Community College Survey of Student Engagement CCSSE 2014.
OPERATION Life Online Protective factors against suicide There are many factors in our lives that can help to protect us and others against suicide.
DR. SAFAA. Introduction It is clear, however, that learning a second language is a difficult time-consuming process. when students first enter the language.
Faculty Motivation Angie Cave Michelle Cotter Debbie Novalski Katya Zablotney.
An Evaluation of SLIS Student Satisfaction and its Global Impacts Christina Hoffman, MLS Dr. Samantha Hastings, Interim Dean The University of North Texas.
35 Evaluating Economic Development & Interfaith Peacebuilding: Challenges in Attribution.
CBR 101 An Introduction to Community Based Research.
TEMPLATE DESIGN © The Homework Effect: Does Homework Help or Harm Students? Katherine Field EdD Candidate, Department.
An Assessment of Health Care Needs and Barriers in a Rural Community of Haiti Justin Gerard 1 ; Dr. Jeffrey Van Laere 2 ; Nabil Othman 1 ; Terrie Ahn 1.
Reflective Practice as a Tool for Addressing High Levels of Psychological Distress in Australian Law Schools and the Legal Profession Rachael Field: Senior.
JENNIFER A. KUNTZ, M.ED HOLY FAMILY UNIVERSITY COUNSELING 511 Career Orientation and High School Students.
Successful Contract Training: A Grounded Theory for a Sustainable Business Model presented at the National Council for Workforce Education Conference by.
A qualitative investigation into the impact of parenthood: giving a voice to mothers with sight loss in the UK Helen Molden Doctorate in Counselling Psychology.
Disentangling the Relations between Discrimination, Cultural Orientation, Social Support, and Coping in Mexican American Adolescents Megan O’Donnell Mark.
From Student To Student: Strategies for Successfully Navigating Graduate School in Instructional Technology Publication Service Teaching Internships 2005.
Ebrahim Talaee Tarbiat Modares University (Tehran, Iran) and University of Bamberg (Germany) Hamideh Bozorg Tarbiat Moadares University, Tehran, Iran The.
Psychology Workforce Development for Primary Care Cynthia D. Belar, PhD, ABPP Executive Director, APA Education Directorate Collaborative.
Bryce E. Hughes and Sylvia Hurtado UCLA Association for the Study of Higher Education November 2013 St. Louis, MO.
Presentation Reprised from the NASFAA 2014 Conference By Pamela Fowler University of Michigan Ann Arbor Getting a Seat at the Table 1.
Introduction Advocacy for battered women often focuses on physical danger, but more attention need to be paid to other familial, financial, and emotional.
Evolution of Clinical Psychology
© American Psychological Association All Rights Reserved. Professional Psychology Education and Training (PPET) Working Group  Efforts related to.
Agile Method Paper Report 資工 4A 余修丞. 2 Agile methods rapidly replacing traditional methods at Nokia: A survey of opinions on agile transformation.
Student Nurses Learn Spiritual care in hospice and palliative care settings Lesline Lewinson
What is the Prevalence of Preparedness in the U.S.? Andrew Garrett MD MPH Columbia University National Center for Disaster Preparedness.
Introduction Negotiation is something that everyone does, almost daily 1-1.
Preparing for the One Year Anniversary David J. Schonfeld, MD Associate Professor of Pediatrics & Child Study Yale University School of Medicine National.
Shaping the future. ‘ People Say It’s Good to Talk…’
Instructional Technology Survey: Highlands School District Shawn Cressler, Summer 2013.
Janis L. Whitlock Cornell University.   Previous research show that human beings develop in multiple social ecologies but school connectedness and the.
Emotions, identity and recovery A short talk by Tim Leighton Director of Professional Education & Research, Action on Addiction Living Room Cardiff.
“ Parents have the right and the duty to be involved in the educational lives of their children ” (Segal, et al., 2006, p. 284) Welcome to Seminar: Professional.
Abstract Service Learning is a useful avenue in developing agency in college students, giving them the opportunity to interact with issues linking course.
College Essays & Personal Statements. Interesting Statistic “Each year, Illinois receives nearly 30,000 applications for its freshman class, which means.
Organisational relocation - the employee experience Peggie Rothe Ph.D. Student BES Research Group ERES 2011 June th, Eindhoven.
Initial Project Aims To increase the capacity of primary schools in partnership with parents to implement a sustainable health and sexuality education.
One Piece of the Puzzle “Helping you, help your child complete their puzzle of life.”
Faculty Member: Safina Binte Enayet Psychosocial Counselor and Lecturer Counseling Unit BRAC University
Making Practice Visible: The Impact of the FdA in Early Years
E. Mahan Cultural Competency Prof. Ozcan Spring 2006
What is the impact of conducting NCI interviews on surveyors?
IENG 451 / 452 Voice of the Customer: Analysis (KANO, CTQ)
WHERE DO WE STAND? DISAGREE AGREE Activity 2A Continuum
Opportunities for Growth
Introduction: There are events and times in our lives that we find difficult to deal with. In this assembly we’ll have the opportunity to think about those.
Parenting Program Dr. Rebecca Rahschulte, Ph.D., NCSP
Administering Behavioral CRFs
Imagine Success Engaging Entering Students Innovations 2009
Roles of the Mental Health Team:
STRESS RESILIENCE PROGRAM WEEK 4: STRESS AND YOU
Re-Framing Agendas: From the Personal to the Policy Level
Presentation transcript:

“THIS HAS BEEN THE WORST EXPERIENCE OF MY LIFE.” THE INTERNSHIP CRISIS AND ITS IMPACT ON STUDENTS Tyler C. Bradstreet, M.S., Mike C. Parent, Ph.D. – Texas Tech University Makenzie Wood, B.A., Eddy Ameen, Ph.D. – American Psychological Association, Jennifer L. Callahan, Ph.D. – University of North Texas Introduction Despite importance in training of psychologists, the internship process has been marked by a significant imbalance between number of applicants and available internship positions Although numerous authors have focused on legal or professional issues surrounding the internship crisis, there has been little attention on the impact of the internship crisis on doctoral students. The Crisis In the most recent match year (2014), there were 4335 applicants to internship who applied to a total of 3501 positions; enough for 81% of applicants. Only 2588 were accredited by the APA or CPA; enough APA/CPA internship spots for only 60% of applicants. The crisis has been described as the “single most important professional issue facing the field.” The Present Study Scholarship on the internship crisis not addressed the personal impact on students involved in the internship application process. The aim of the present study was to explore the concerns of internship applicants with the aim of using their voices to further scholarship and advocacy within and outside of professional associations, and to point toward problems and solutions as identified by the very persons currently in the midst of, and impacted by, the internship crisis. Method Participants were 1076 applicants for internship in 2011 who completed the qualitative item on the post-match survey administered by APPIC. The item was: "How has the current imbalance between applicants and positions affected you, personally and/or professionally? If you had the ear of the education and training community, what would you like to tell them about this issue? How has your life and the lives of others been affected? You may wish to share your own personal experiences, the impact on yourself, other students, and/or your academic program, suggestions for how to improve the situation, or other thoughts, feelings, and/or concerns." Results Through Grounded Theory, researchers sorted 64 open codes into 6 axial codes, grouped these into 3 clusters, found 2 emerging themes, and shaped these into theory to explain our data. Across participants, the crisis isn’t only seen as impacting one isolated area of their lives. Ultimately, the crisis looms over every aspect of professional training, from the very core of an applicant’s professional identity to the profession itself. Discussion Results reveal a negative reaction to the internship imbalance and the process of applying for internship in general. We present 4 themes: problems, solutions, issues of discrimination and bias, and the glimmering hope of resilience. Resiliency and Growth Some participants did report experiences of resiliency and growth. Some participants reported awareness of the crisis promoted strategic thinking about training (e.g., propose/complete dissertations prior to internship). Similarly, participants reported personal and professional growth as a result of the stress of internship applications. Participants reported support from family and faculty were assets during the stress of internship applications. Given the sense of sympathy among applicants, groups dedicated to mutual support could help applicants during this time. Faculty who are further temporally removed from their own training may do well to inform themselves about the present state of internship, to avoid perseverating from their own experiences with internship, which may not represent current experiences. Future Directions First, longitudinal work could explore different manifestations of stress and its impact on student learning and performance, as well as identify ways to help students cope with stress specific to the internship crisis. Second, students named many potential ways in which to reduce burden on applicants; this area might be further empirically explored to develop ways to minimize student stress and burden during applications. Third, resiliencies and opportunities for growth might be explored among applicants who did not match, to better help applicants maximize time between application cycles. Problems Applicants perceived crisis to be due to too few internships or too many applicants. Responsibility was placed on APA and other entities involved in training. Although APA has made efforts to combat the imbalance, respondents were unaware of these efforts or see them as inadequate. More named what too many applicants as the issue. This is not discussed as often as creation of more internship sites. Solutions Applicants reported need to better inform students about crisis as early as applying to doctoral programs. One method of addressing this is to require programs to post a statement about match rate within their disclosure data. Students expressed desire for applications to have reciprocal interaction; to obtain feedback from sites where they didn’t match. Participants overwhelmingly saw solution to crisis as reduction in number of applicants and increase in internships. By 2017, only students enrolled in accredited programs will be allowed to enter match. However, as only 212 of 2886 applicants (7%) to 2012 APPIC survey were from unaccredited programs, and 47% didn’t match, this step won’t resolve imbalance. Discrimination and Bias Applicants perceived discrimination/bias in application process. Two specific codes were identified; low SES, and non-accredited program. Low SES discrimination intersects with reports of financial strain for online application and interviews. Applicants suggested reductions in application fee, or movement to video-interviews. The most frequent code was discrimination- other, representing myriad factors, such as program type, physical ability status, and non-minority identities.