Chapter 7 Nature of evidence types of evidence internal / external consistency recency/relevancy expertise / bias Fallacies of evidence non-comparable.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Argumentation.
Advertisements

Communication for Managers Testing the Evidence What is the source of the evidence? Is the source valid and credible? Is the evidence accurate, current.
Why We Do Research Chapter 1. Ordinary Versus Systematic Biased Question: A question that leads to a specific response or excludes a certain group Nonscientific.
The results of repeated observations and/or experiments concerning a naturally occurring event (phenomenon) are reasonably the same when performed and.
Chapter 8 How Good is the Evidence: personal experience, testimonials & appeals to authority?
What is argument? Beyond hair pulling, dish throwing, yelling, and other in-your-face actions.
Evaluating an Author’s Argument. © 2008 McGraw-Hill Higher Education Chapter 11: Evaluating an Author's Argument 2 Author’s Argument An author’s argument.
The aim of this tutorial is to help you learn to identify the types of fallacious reasoning discussed in Chapter 6. Chapter 6 discusses fallacies of insufficient.
Understanding Logical Fallacies
Best Practice Precepts [... next] Arguments Arguments Possibility of the Impossible Possibility of the Impossible Belief, Truth, and Reality Belief, Truth,
GPR VHS. Criteria of Credibility Can be used to assess the credibility of documents or individual sources. It has become standard to use the mnemonic.
Developing Arguments for the Science Classroom Kris Carroll CPDD Curriculum & Professional Development Division, Science Health & Foreign Language June,
Debate: Evidence. Review Valid: The conclusion of the argument follows logically from its premises. Sound: The argument is valid and all of its premises.
Critical Thinking: Chapter 10
Credibility of Evidence. Credibility of Sources Do you believe the source? Can you trust the claims being made?
LogicandEvidence Scientific argument. Logic Reasoning –Deductive –Inductive.
James A. Herrick Chapter 2
Writing effective arguments
{ Writing Arguments 1. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or.
Bias, Persuasion, and Propaganda From:
Chapter 11: Evaluating an Author’s Argument
Today Evaluating Reasoning Reasoning and Evidence Fallacies Evidence Discuss the midterm and review.
Debate: Claims. Claims Each claim is a statement within the argument that the arguer needs accepted. These statements are given to logically lead the.
Methods of Persuasion How do you convince a person or a group of people to feel, think, or do as you ask?
Visual Argumentation.
Thomas Freeman WRIT 122.  There are three ways in which a person can argue their position. These ways consist of ethos, logos and pathos.  These different.
Non Fiction Vocabulary MLA & Toulmin’s Argumentation February 2014.
PERSUASION. “Everybody Hates Chris”
EVIDENCE Definition???? Definition???? Support for a claim that is discovered from experience or outside authority (page 112) Support for a claim that.
Debate Basics: The Logical Argument. Argument An argument is a set of claims presented in a logical form. An argument attempts to persuade an audience.
Fundamentals of Communication Chapter 11- Being Credible and Using Evidence.
 Evidence – “ supporting material known or discovered, but not created by the advocate.” (Wilbanks, Church)  The minor premise of the classical logical.
Chapter 12 Informal Fallacies II: Assumptions and Induction Invitation to Critical Thinking First Canadian Edition Joel.
“There’s no time like the present.” Would you accept this claim? Why?
Invitation to Critical Thinking Chapter 12 Lecture Notes Chapter 12.
Suzanne Webb Lansing Community College WRIT122 January 11, 2010.
PERSUASION. Credibility: - Audience’s perception of how believable the speaker is - Factors of credibility: Competence- how the audience regards the intelligence,
Fact vs. Opinion ?.
Fallacious reasoning is “false thinking.” People use fallacious reasoning when they draw incorrect or false conclusions. Fallacious reasoning may be either.
Academic Vocabulary Unit 7 Cite: To give evidence for or justification of an argument or statement.
Errors in Reasoning. Fallacies A Fallacy is “any error in reasoning that makes an argument fail to establish its conclusion.” There are two kinds of fallacies.
 Induction is the process of drawing a general conclusion from incomplete evidence.  You consider evidence you have seen or heard to draw a conclusion.
OBJECTIVE (SWBAT): EVALUATE SCIENTIFIC EXPLANATIONS Initial Activity: A new species of crab has been discovered on the Galapagos Islands. Here we have.
METHODS OF PERSUASION Chapter 16. Credibility Ethos – the word that Aristotle used to describe what we now think of as a speaker’s credibility Credibility.
Chapter 26: Generalizations and Surveys. Inductive Generalizations (pp ) Arguments to a general conclusion are fairly common. Some people claim.
Rhetorical Devices and Fallacies
Logic & Reasoning.
Reading Arguments Critically
4 The Art of Critical Reading Reading Critically Mather ▪ McCarthy
TO PERSUADE.
Chapter 4: Inductive Arguments
Errors in Reasoning.
University of Northern IA
University of Northern IA
What is Science?.
Supporting Your Message
The meaning, association, or emotion that has come to be attached to a word is its connotation.
Visual Argumentation.
The Rational Appeal Sydney Czurak Mariah Felt.
Credibility of Evidence
Informational Text.
Developing Arguments for Persuasive Speeches
Titanic Unit Vocabulary
Methods of persuasion English Language Arts.
Concise Guide to Critical Thinking
Identifying Positions, Claims, and Support
Methods of persuasion English Language Arts.
SIMPLE Argument Terms.
S.M.E.L.L. Method For argument analysis.
Chapter 11: Whom Do You Trust?
Presentation transcript:

Chapter 7 Nature of evidence types of evidence internal / external consistency recency/relevancy expertise / bias Fallacies of evidence non-comparable units non-sequitor / begging the question unrepresentative sample

Evidence is vital in establishing the credibility of claims and arguments the arguer makes especially when the arguer is unknown to an audience: A. true B. false C. unless you are running for president D. unless you are George Bush

_________ is an objectively observable condition of the world-something we can simply see, hear, touch, feel and smell. A. reasoning B. claim C. evidence D. bias

Evidence can be divided into two broad classifications: fact and opinion as to fact. A. True B. False

Generally, there are two ways in which people come to believe something is a fact. The first is their own observation and the second is:. A. recency of the information B. relevance of information C. a common experience D. the reasoning used to make a conclusion

A reliable source is one that:. A. possesses a background of knowledge and information relevant to the subject matter B. refers to a source’s tendency to hold a fair and undistorted view C. is in agreement with other sources of information D. has proven to be correct many times in the past