Mountain Pine Beetle Salvage Harvesting and Reforestation in British Columbia Brian Peter and Bryan Bogdanski Industry, Trade & Economics Program Pacific.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Canadian Forest Service Activities in Support of Growth & Yield Research in North-Central B.C. Phil Burton UNBC, 29 June.
Advertisements

Uneven-aged Regeneration Systems. Uneven-aged regeneration systems often referred to as selection systems also called – –“Selective" logging and "select-cut"
Type 4 Strategy Update Winter SISCO What’s done and what have we learned…. 1 February 25, 2014 Winter SISCO - Kamloops. BC.
Section 2 Land Based Investment Al Powelson & Kelly Osbourne Richmond: 9/28/20111.
Using expert judgments to explore robust alternatives for forest management under climate change By Tim McDaniels University of British Columbia and CEDM.
Outlook for Australia’s forestry and forest products industry
Progress report: FREP routine and intensive protocols for the FRPA timber value in partial cuts Patrick Martin February 26, 2007.
The Natural Disturbance Regime: Implications for Forest Management Glen W. Armstrong University of Alberta CIFFC Science Forum 4 November 1999.
Optimal Rotation Optimal Rotation.
WOOD 120 “Topics in Forestry” 1. 2 Global Distribution of Forests
The Economics of Climate Change Nicholas Stern 15 November 2006 Presentation to the Convention Dialogue, Nairobi.
Timber Supply Review and Species Management By: Paul Barolet, R.P.F., Stewardship Officer Stewardship Officer.
FORS 8450 Advanced Forest Planning Lecture 12 Tabu Search Change in the Value of a Medium-Sized Forest when Considering Spatial Harvest Scheduling Constraints.
FRST 318 / 537C March 3 rd Lab Midterm Review. Question 1 Governments in North America announce that wood is a preferred building material because it.
Is a big Renewable Natural resource business. It has important products, jobs and environmental concerns.
Modelling Natural Regeneration in Mountain Pine Beetle Affected Stands A Hybrid Model Approach Derek Sattler, M.Sc. Candidate Faculty of Forestry. University.
Forest Health Review Committee Prince George, BC January 30, 2008 Canadian Forest Service Forest Health Activities.
Impact of adjacency and green-up constraints on wood supply in Georgia, USA Michal Zasada, Chris J. Cieszewski, Roger C. Lowe, Don Reimer 2 nd International.
1 Merritt TSA Type II Silviculture Analysis Merritt, B.C. April 5th, 2007.
Investing in Forest Fertilization: tools, measures, analyses By Ralph Winter Forest Practices Branch July 25, 2005.
Mitigating timber supply impacts through strategic Forest Fertilization Ralph Winter Forest Practices Branch
Climate Change Impacts on British Columbia Shalina Bhagat Angela Lee Daniel Mundeva Katina Tam.
BCTS/FFT Reforestation Collaboration – March 2012 Thompson Okanagan Region Case study By Mike Madill, FFT FLNRO Thompson Okanagan Region And John Hopper.
A research study by Will Ondrik The Effects of the Mountain Pine Beetle in British Columbia.
Optimal Rotation. Biological vs. Economic Criteria  What age should we harvest timber?  Could pick the age to yield a certain size  Or could pick an.
Overview of Financial Analysis
Forest Valuation and Appraisal The major organization for consulting foresters who do appraisal work.
Centre for Non-Timber Resources Royal Roads University Victoria, BC Cost Benefit Analysis of Wildland Urban Interface Operations.
Chapter 28.1 Global Developments. Global Interdependence Global Interdependence means that people and nations worldwide depend on one another for many.
Risk Analysis Framework 1. Risk assessment Triggers pest commodity pathway ecosystem Identify threat Estimate likelihood of occurrence Estimate magnitude.
The stock is the present accumulated quantity of natural capital. It is a supply accumulated for future use; a store. The natural income is any sustainable.
FORS 8450 Advanced Forest Planning Lecture 21 Binary Search.
1 MPB Mitigation Silviculture Treatments To mitigate timber supply problems in management units affected by catastrophic mountain pine beetle Presentation.
Stefan Zeglen, Forest Pathologist, West Coast Region Jim Brown, Senior Analyst, Forest Analysis and Inventory Branch CSC Winter Workshop, Nanaimo, BCFebruary.
Forests For Tomorrow Species and sowing Provincial Meeting September 18, 2013 Allan Powelson Photo by Leon Duncan.
Forest Planning and Practices Regulation Amendments to Protect Secondary Structure Joint Presentation of: Joint Presentation of: Federation of BC WoodlotAssociationsFederation.
1 Timber Supply Impacts of Mountain Pine Beetle (MPB) in British Columbia, Canada Western Forest Economists May 8 th, 2007.
Unique Characteristics of Forests and Their Management (Economic) Implications.
Cruising Manual Highlights Ministry of Forests & Range 2009.
Effects of Regeneration Abundance on Predicted Development of Interior Douglas-fir Stands By Cornel Lencar Graduate Student, Faculty of Forestry University.
MPB Supply Side Implications Brad Stennes Canadian Forest Service Industry, Trade & Economics Victoria, BC.
Forestry and Resource Management
Future of Hardwoods in Oregon (and the Pacific Northwest) Glenn Ahrens Oregon State University Extension Forestry Clatsop and Tillamook County.
Alder Supply + Red Alder Plantation Growth and Yield RAP ORGANON Glenn Ahrens Oregon State University Extension Forester.
Key BC Silviculture Statistics ä Forest Practices Branch BC Forest Service September 8, 2009.
Beyond the Beetle – Managing BC’s Forest for Value and Sustainability 2014 SISCO Winter Workshop February 26, 2014 Dave Peterson, RPF ADM Tenures, Competitiveness.
Education and Research Committee Report Washington Hardwoods Commission Annual Meeting – 2008.
Southern Interior Forest Region Soils Plant Ecology Hydrology Geomorphology Silvicultural Systems Wildlife Ecology Forest Science Program Research, Consultation,
SILVICULTURAL PRACTICES. SILVICULTURE The application of various treatments such as; tree planting, pruning, intermediate cuttings and harvest cuts.
SAF 3/3/09 1 Potential Biomass Demand Impact on Forest Markets and Resources Bob Abt NC State University
Stakeholder meeting Floresteca Amsterdam, February 2016.
David R. Jackson Penn State Cooperative Extension February 10, 2009 “I Have Timber to Sell” Timber Sales and Marketing.
FORESTRY LAND USE Overview and Update Buckingham County Land Use Work Session September 18, 2017 Dean Cumbia Forest Resource Management Branch.
Tomas Lundmark SLU Sweden
René Alfaro, Jodi Axelson, Brad Hawkes, Lara vanAkker and Bill Riel
Forest Growing and Processing in Otago - Southland
Mountain Pine Beetle and Climate Change in British Columbia
Geography of Canada Forestry Geography of Canada
Forestry.
Shelterwood and clearcut
Prince George Timber Supply Area Timber Supply Review (PG TSA TSR V)
Young Stand Monitoring
Forestry Canadian Geography.
Conceptual Framework on Planning for Timber Supply
Forestry Geography of Canada.
Harvesting Early Good or Bad?
Unique Aspects of Forests and Their Management (Economic) Implications
Forestry Geography of Canada.
Geography of Canada Forestry Geography of Canada
CANADA’S RENEWABLE RESOURCES PART 2
Presentation transcript:

Mountain Pine Beetle Salvage Harvesting and Reforestation in British Columbia Brian Peter and Bryan Bogdanski Industry, Trade & Economics Program Pacific Forestry Centre, CFS, NRCAN Western Forest Economists Meeting May 7-9, 2007 Welches, Oregon

Outline: 1.Overview of the MPB Issue in BC. 2.What are some of the salvage and reforestation choices we are faced with? What tradeoffs are involved? 3.Some preliminary findings. 4.Summary and Conclusions.

Overview of the MPB Issue in BC Mainly in BC’s central interior, though recent expansion into Peace River region and Alberta is raising concern over the vulnerability of other regions, especially boreal jack pine stands.

Overview of the MPB Issue in BC Mainly in BC’s central interior, though recent expansion into Peace River region and Alberta is raising concern over the vulnerability of other regions, especially boreal jack pine stands. Lodgepole Pine Jack Pine Source: NRCan/CFS/PFC

Overview of the MPB Issue in BC Impact on BC forests: As of 2006, MPB has affected 582 million cubic metres of timber (includes green, red and grey-attack, as well as timber that has been harvested). By the end of the outbreak, 80% of the mature pine inventory is expected to have been killed. Salvaging is being used to capture economic values before decay sets in, and to help ensure productive stands are re- established for future timber supplies.

AACs in the southern and central interior have risen steadily since 2001: 2001 AAC: 45 million m 3 Overview of the MPB Issue in BC

AACs in the southern and central interior have risen steadily since 2001: 2001 AAC: 45 million m AAC: 62 million m 3 Overview of the MPB Issue in BC

Pine harvest as a proportion of total harvesting The emphasis on pine harvesting in this region has also grown. Overview of the MPB Issue in BC

Salvage and Reforestation Choices Difficult trade-offs are being grappled with: Trying to capture as much value as possible within the constraints of market conditions and the need to avoid undesirable impacts to non-timber values. Minimizing non-pine harvesting to preserve mid-term timber supplies, while considering operational/economic constraints and the needs of producers who may rely on non-pine volumes. Making the right silvicultural choices at the stand level to maximize social, ecological and economic values.

In pine leading stands…. Salvage and Reforestation Choices

In pine leading stands…. we can harvest the dead pine, and establish a productive new cohort of regeneration. However, if we choose not to harvest.... Salvage and Reforestation Choices

However, if we choose not to harvest…. Stand values will gradually deteriorate, Salvage and Reforestation Choices

However, if we choose not to harvest…. Stand values will gradually deteriorate. The dead over-story will “break-up”. Though future yields are uncertain. ? And fire may also pose risks… Salvage and Reforestation Choices

In mixed species stands…. Salvage and Reforestation Choices

However, partial cutting may be another option in these stand types. In mixed species stands…. we can harvest the dead pine, along with other merchantable timber, and establish a productive new cohort of regeneration. Salvage and Reforestation Choices

However, partial cutting may be another option in these stand types. By retaining non-pine volumes, allowing them time to release, and perhaps even encouraging some advance regeneration, we may be leaving a valuable legacy for the post-salvage era. Salvage and Reforestation Choices

But…does partial cutting make sense economically? Although it’s aesthetically appealing, do the numbers make sense? Or are we better-off sticking with conventional systems? And what about areas that cannot be salvaged? Should we be spending money to reforest these areas? And even where we can salvage profitably, are there some stand types that are better left unsalvaged? What economic/silvicultural assumptions produce higher stand values when salvaging is foregone? Salvage and Reforestation Choices

Future stand development can be estimated with existing yield data: SI 50 (Pl)=12 Salvage and Reforestation Choices

SI 50 (Pl)=15 Future stand development can be estimated with existing yield data: Salvage and Reforestation Choices

SI 50 (Pl)=18 Future stand development can be estimated with existing yield data: Salvage and Reforestation Choices

SI 50 (Pl)=21 Future stand development can be estimated with existing yield data: Salvage and Reforestation Choices

Comparisons of the long-term returns (NPV) resulting from our choices can be made based on assumptions of: Site productivity Current stumpage prices Future stumpage prices Initial harvest volumes (pine and non-pine) Silviculture and other forest management costs Natural regeneration delays, species and stocking Salvage and Reforestation Choices

Although there are many factors and uncertainties in analyses such as these, a few conclusions can be drawn: Some Initial Findings The salvaging decision can be fairly obvious where salvaging is profitable, and managed stands will outperform natural regeneration.

On the other hand, lower value stands with a positive outlook for natural regeneration may have greater value when salvaging is foregone. This may be especially true where: Advance regeneration is expected to release as the pine dies. The subsequent stand is expected to be of substantial value. Significant damage to the AR is expected if salvaging occurs. Some Initial Findings

From a purely financial perspective, rehabilitation likely makes sense on only a small portion of the landbase. Estimated Distribution of Site Indices on the Timber Harvesting Landbase (THLB) of the Prince George timber supply area. In addition to high productivity, candidate sites will need to have: minimal silviculture costs (likely including existing access) a poor outlook for natural regeneration. Some Initial Findings

Does partial cutting make sense economically? Some Initial Findings The key question that needs to be asked is: Do the benefits of retaining live merchantable volume outweigh the opportunity costs of foregoing immediate revenues? In most areas this depends on the outlook for growth in the residual stand, and the value of these volumes for mid-term timber supply. However, depending on the up-front costs and volumes available, it may be more profitable on some sites to defer harvesting altogether, and leave salvage volumes to decay on the stump. Photo:

This may be especially true of stands that require significant road development at the time of the initial stand entry. ? ? Some Initial Findings

Conclusions: There is room for further forest economics research in the context of BC’s mountain pine beetle outbreak. We hope to continue examining the economics of salvage harvesting and rehabilitation, such as: Taking a closer look at incorporating risks associated with various stand-level choices and their impacts on future benefits. Trying to explicitly include some key non-timber values, e.g. carbon. We’d welcome any comments or suggestions….