Choice and Diversity? John Curtice Strathclyde University/ScotCen.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Delivering Equitable Care in Mental Health Services A Clinical Area Based Approach Itai Nyamatore Clinical Team Manager O.B.M.H.

Advertisements

The Role of Welsh Health Libraries in Supporting Information Provision to NHS Users Anne Cleves AWHILES Conference 14 th July 2009.

1 Developing Care Markets for Quality and Choice.

MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES: Challenges and opportunities in the context of social care.

Market Position Statements. About IPC We work for well run evidence based public care We are part of Oxford Brookes University We work with national and.

All-Age Integrated Commissioning Strategy (Health and Wellbeing) CAS Voluntary Sector Forum workshop 17 July 2014.

April 2014 The four health systems of the United Kingdom: how do they compare?

Professor Jeanne Keay University of the West of Scotland.

A charity registered in England and Wales (no ) and in Scotland (no. SC039299). A company Limited by Guarantee (Number ) Genetic Alliance.

All-Age Integrated Commissioning Strategy (Health and Wellbeing) CAS Voluntary Sector Forum workshop 17 July 2014.

Almagro 26 October 2006 Dr L J Patterson OBE MB FRCP Dr L J Patterson Consultant Physician OBE MB FRCP Quality of Care in UK National Health Service.

Alcohol Commissioning Learning Programme City University, London – 21/22 September 2010.

Can the English National Health Service learn from the Dutch reforms? Meeting the medium term challenge of the financing of health & aged care in England.

EASPD CONFERENCE 2006 FINANCING STRATEGIES AND THEIR EFFECTS ON EQUITY, CHOICE, EFFECTIVENESS AND SUSTAINABILITY RAPHAEL WITTENBERG 8 JUNE 2006, GRAZ.

Testing Social Change John Curtice Strathclyde University.

Economic Issues in the NHS John Appleby Chief Economist King’s Fund.

PAHO/WHO Seminar Brasilia October 2002 PAHO/WHO INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR ON CHALLENGES FOR COMPREHENSIVE PHARMACEUTICAL SERVICES BRASILIA, OCTOBER 2002 Experience.

Economic Issues in the NHS John Appleby Chief Economist King’s Fund.

Can Government policies improve local public services? An assessment of the impacts of top-down reform strategies Dr James Downe Cardiff Business School.

Government.unimelb.edu.au The future of local public services - implications for local government Professor Helen

Measuring the Quality of Long-Term Care in England Juliette Malley Personal Social Services Research Unit LSE Health and Social Care London School of Economics.

Alcohol Commissioning - The role of Public Health - A view from Tower Hamlets Chris Lovitt- AD Public Health Rachael Sadegh- DAAT Joint Commissioning Manager.

Different policies, Different attitudes? John Curtice Strathclyde University/NatCen.

WEEK 8 – IS THE UNITED KINGDOM BREAKING UP?. 2 THE CASE FOR DEVOLUTION … “The United Kingdom is a partnership enriched by distinct national identities.

Research, Ethics, Governance: the evolving regulatory landscape Jonathan Montgomery Professor of Healthcare Law, University of Southampton Chair, Health.

Positive Engagement: a local government perspective Andrew Cozens Strategic Adviser, Children Adults & Health Services 19 September 2006.

HEAL HSYSTEMS SOLUTIONS UK health service update.

Making every contact count Knowing your service Policy context – background to reforms 1989 – Working for patients creates internal market in NHS 1997.

Active People Survey HOUSEHOLD INCOME Up to £15,599£45,800 or more 3 x 30 sport9.3%25.6% Zero sessions of sport73.6%38.9% Volunteering2.5%7.0% Club Membership15.0%35.8%

Outcomes from service inspection Is the quality of care in Scotland improving? October 2007.

The impact of regulation on quality in UK nursing homes. Professor Ciaran O’Neill School of Policy Studies, University of Ulster, Northern Ireland. Supported.

Evaluating market reforms in the English NHS: introduction to the reforms and the Health Reform Evaluation Programme Nicholas Mays Professor of Health.

Lesley Rimmer, Chief Executive Colin Angel, Head of Policy and Communication UKHCA ADASS 10 th January 2009 Back to the Future? Homecare Provision in the.

No man’s land or promised land? The lure of local public service delivery contracts for social enterprise Alex Murdock London South Bank University London.

QUESTIONS TO DEBATE Chapter 13, Instructor’s Manual.

Marketing of Services Chapter 12 MR2100. Why are Services Different? Services are different than other “products” because they are Intangible. Intangibility.

Class 8: Challenging assumptions that support demand theory; how skepticism regarding these assumptions are fueling the current health policy debate at.

Commissioning Quality Care Improving Lives Commissioning Quality Care 1.

Delivering. Purpose… Seven key functions 1.Gathering views and understanding the experiences of patients and the public 2.Making peoples’ views known.

Gathering Fact, Removing Doubt Employee Health what employers want from PMI Health Claims Bureau Group Presented by John Gillman.

The Patient Protection and Affordability Act (ACA): Legal Challenges and Lessons Learned To Sustain Health Care Reform Mary P. Kivlighan, J.D., M.A.P.A.

 No economic system is completely command or completely market.  There’s a mixture of government in a market economy.  There’s also a mixture of markets.

Health Care Reform SF 183: Introduction. Health Care Reform Health care/insurance industry, Republican leaders: maintain a private system: No Public options.

© 2010 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.

Healthwatch Derby. Healthwatch Healthwatch Derby Locally Healthwatch England Nationally “Healthwatch will be the new consumer champion for both health.

Learning from Work Choice and the Work Programme. Sarah Foster, Senior Researcher, Inclusion

Housing market between choice and chance Housing allocation ‘by lottery’ in the rental market of Eindhoven M.I.K. Leussink J.J.A.M. Smeets.

SUPPORTING A WORLD FIRST The Active Travel (Wales) Act 2013 David Graham Head of Strategy (Schools and workplaces) October 2015.

Role of Palliative Care Clinical Nurse Specialist Sheila McConville Community Specialist Palliative Care Nurse Southern Health and Social Care Trust.

Market Facilitation The Strategic Context Christina Naismith, JSC Programme Manager, JIT 6 th August 2013.

Health Works National Forum 26 January 2012 Realising Work Potential Lisa Greer National AHP Lead Vocational Rehabilitation/Mental Health.

By Anne Mirkovic. Contents Introduction Background Aims & Audience Campaign Methods Material Tools Conclusion: Monitoring & Further Developments.

Devolution Differences? John Curtice Strathclyde University/ScotCen.

Faith in Education? The Changing Role of Religion in English Schools Peter J. Hemming School of Social Sciences Cardiff University.

Competition in adult social care What do we know, what don't we know, and can it ever improve the quality of care? 11 September Dr Steven Proud.

Extra care housing in Wales: A state of the nation report.

THE HEALTHCARE SUPPORT WORKER

Salford’s Market Position Statement

Strategies to build capacity

Theory to Practice Integrated Care with the Voluntary Sector Tuesday 17 June 2014 Dr Abigail Barkham RGN, Dip. PHCN, BSc(Hons.) Integrated Services.

QUESTIONS TO DEBATE Chapter 9, Instructor’s Manual

Key messages for Northern Ireland

Le collège en France LI: Today we are learning to talk about the differences between French schools and Scottish schools.

Market Economy 6 Traits.

Is competition and choice in health care a good thing

Health Care Reform SF 183: Introduction.

Digital Health and Care - collaboration, with citizens

Dr John Parry General Practitioner Clinical Director SystmOne

Integrated Care – The Shape of Adult Social Care in Torbay

US Health Care Reform Debate

Presentation transcript:

Choice and Diversity? John Curtice Strathclyde University/ScotCen

Project Design zHow should services be delivered? zDoes how they are delivered matter? zParticular interest in ‘choice’ debate, zAnd ‘natural experiments’ of within UK variation. zFocus on education, health and social care.

Evidence zSurveys of public opinion in all four parts of the UK in 2007 zBritish Social Attitudes (2,022; 1,735 in E) zScottish Social Attitudes (1,508) zNorthern Ireland Life & Times (1,179) zSpecial Welsh survey (884)

(English) Elite Arguments z‘diversity of supply is a necessary condition of choice’ (Audit Commission) z‘it is necessary to have both user choice and provider competition’ (Le Grand) z‘widen diversity of supply to create new incentives for…more choice for patients’ (Brown)

Demand for Choice

Facilitating Choice

Importance of Choice

Meaning of Choice?

Within State Diversity?

Should business run…?

Should charities run…?

Attitudes to quasi-markets

Choice and Within State Diversity

Choice and Private Provision

Choice and Quasi-Markets

Conclusion zChoice and Quasi-markets may go together in the minds of elites… z..but we should not assume they do in the minds of the public. zDemand for choice is a demand for good (and diverse?) publicly provided services. zEngland should embrace markets less - but Scotland promote choice more?