The Relationship Between Emotional Intelligence among Supervisors and Conditions of Trust among staff at the Kentucky Department for Public Health Jennifer.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Bar-On Emotional Quotient Inventory (EQ-i)
Advertisements

Emotional Intelligence
Developing Organizational Commitment to Cultural Competence
Intelligence Step 5 - Capacity Analysis Capacity Analysis Without capacity, the most innovative and brilliant interventions will not be implemented, wont.
Emotional Intelligence Connecting the dots By Everett Marshall, Marshall Wagner Associates.
Introduction to Emotional Intelligence
Parents as Partners in Education
Campus-wide Presentation May 14, PACE Results.
1 Improving School Leadership - Guidelines for Country Background Reports - Education and Training Policy Division Directorate of Education.
Comprehensive Organizational Health AssessmentMay 2012Butler Institute for Families Comprehensive Organizational Health Assessment Presented by: Robin.
The Business Case for Emotional Intelligence Lee Elliott Vice President for Human Resources and Fund Development Saint Francis Medical Center Grand Island,
Purpose The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between Cross-Cultural Adaptability and Emotional Intelligence to determine if there.
Emotional Intelligence Dr. Neil Katz Executive Education Programs, Program on the Analysis and Resolution of Conflicts Maxwell School, Syracuse University.
SUPERINTENDENT AND BOARD OF EDUCATION MEMBER PERCEPTIONS REGARDING PREFERRED LEADERSHIP BEHAVIORS FOR SUPERINTENDENTS IN WEST VIRGINIA Keith A. Butcher.
Family Resource Center Association January 2015 Quarterly Meeting.
Emotional Intelligence, Leadership & Lebron James
Correlates of Job Satisfaction among Public Health Nurses in Six Local Health Departments L. Michele Issel, PhD, RN, Hilary Kirk, MPH, Kathy Baldwin PhD,
Effect of Staff Attitudes on Quality in Clinical Microbiology Services Ms. Julie Sims Laboratory Technical specialist Strengthening of Medical Laboratories.
Group Members: Anum Baig Hassaan Khalid Gauhar M. Bhatti.
Healthcare Human Resource Management Flynn Mathis Jackson Langan
Competency Assessment Public Health Professional (2012)-
The Emotional Intelligence Profile of Surgical Residents: A Descriptive Study AR Jensen, MD, AS Wright, MD, A Lance, MBA, K O’Brien, MA, C Pratt, MS, DJ.
The Business Case for Emotional Intelligence Lee Elliott Vice President for Human Resources and Fund Development Saint Francis Medical Center Grand Island,
Understanding Emotional Intelligence. EI = Emotional Intelligence The ability to recognize and manage: ◦Moods ◦Emotions ◦Attitudes Research shows a connection.
Workplace Intelligence Necessities
Emotional Intelligence At Work Purpose Audience ◦ This one day training impacts the welfare of your employees Competency ◦ Understand and practice developing.
A Presentation on Emotional Intelligence By E I S A emotional intelligence strategies and applications.
HOGAN REPORT OPTIONS November HoganSelect reports use personality assessment to: Identify candidates’ work style Understand their core drivers Recognize.
Leadership Communication for Authentic Colleague Engagement __________________________ March 7, 2008 CCI/CCM Symposium on Colleague Engagement Judi Glova.
Maximizing “Human Capital” Performance Management: Mentoring, Team Analysis & 360 Peer Reviews Assessments USA & Canada
Kirkpatrick model of evaluation to assess public health workforce preparedness training American Public Health Association November 5, 2013 Boston, MA.
Missouri Family Development Training and Credentialing Program (FDC) Evaluation of a training program for family service workers.
Succession Planning Who will replace your leaders? Presented by Jacquelyn Thorp, MSHR/SPHR -CA.
Leveraging Emotional Intelligence to Enhance Police and Law Enforcement Leadership David Cory, B.Ed., M.A and Steve Watt, MBA.
Emotional Intelligence. What is Intelligence? Typically focused on Typically focused on analytic reasoning analytic reasoning verbal skills verbal skills.
HiPerf Team Coaching HiPerf, Inc. Helping you bridge the gap between strategy and success 5416 Edenfield Drive Kernersville, NC
SOCIAL AWARENESS... PRESENTATION BY: RITIKA NAIR.
Developing Cross-Disciplinary Mental Health Teams in Integrated Care Settings C athy M. Hudgins, PhD, LPC, LMFT Director, NC Center of Excellence for Integrated.
Julie R. Morales Butler Institute for Families University of Denver.
Crosswalk of Public Health Accreditation and the Public Health Code of Ethics Highlighted items relate to the Water Supply case studied discussed in the.
Management of Community Nutrition Services Chapter 19.
1 Mental Health in US Adults: The Role of Positive Social Support and Social Negativity in Personal Relationships Elizabeth M. Bertera, PhD Associate Professor.
Assessing local public health capacity and performance in diabetes prevention and control Deborah Porterfield, MD MPH University of North Carolina-Chapel.
DEVELOPEMENT OF A HOLISTC WELLNESS MODEL FOR MANAGERS IN TERTIARY INSTITUTIONS Petrus Albertus Botha Tshwane University of Technology Polokwane Delivery.
EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE. 2 Emotional Intelligence at Work.
Current Trends in Leadership Research and Implementation Dr. Paul Chinowsky University of Colorado-Boulder.
Chapter 16 Implementing Quality Concepts Cost Accounting Foundations and Evolutions Kinney, Prather, Raiborn.
Patrick Psaila, PsyPotential Workshop 5 - Emotion Matters.
Emotional Intelligence. Gardner’s Multiple Intelligences Intelligence is defined as a group of mental abilities  Logical / Mathematical  Verbal / Linguistic.
Health Management Dr. Sireen Alkhaldi, DrPH Community Medicine Faculty of Medicine, The University of Jordan First Semester 2015 / 2016.
Lincoln Trail District Health Department Strategic Plan Our Foundation Strategic Goals & Objectives Measures of Success Mission: The Lincoln Trail District.
1 A Multi Level Approach to Implementation of the National CLAS Standards: Theme 1 Governance, Leadership & Workforce P. Qasimah Boston, Dr.Ph Florida.
2009 Annual Employee Survey U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development December 29,2009 (updated January 8, 2010)
Emotional Intelligence. Background 1985 Reuven Bar-On Defines EQ –“Are there factors that determine one’s ability to be effective in life?” 1990: John.
Jayne Schaefer, BA Workforce Programs Manager Mather LifeWays Evanston, Illinois Toward Building a Sustainable Long-Term Care Workforce: LEAP.
Which is which? Intelligence or knowledge?. IQ Q - A number that signifies the relative intelligence of a person; the ratio multiplied by 100 of the.
An Assessment of Emotional Intelligence in Emergency Medicine Resident Physicians Dimitrios Papanagnou, MD, MPH, EdD Candidate; Kathryn M. Linder, ScB;
Management Academy for Public Health SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH ● ● KENAN-FLAGLER BUSINESS SCHOOL The Management Academy For Public Health: Developing Entrepreneurial.
Emotional Intelligence as a High-Potential Identification Tool:
Emotional Intelligence Skills
Impact-Oriented Project Planning
Items in red require your input
The importance of emotional learning within communication between the staff Project Number: RO01-KA
EMOTIONS Anger,  Disgust,  Fear,  Happiness,  Sadness, and  Surprise.
Items in red require your input
EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE, a Rapidly emerging key job skill
Items in red require your input
“It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most intelligent, but THE ONE MOST RESPONSIVE TO CHANGE” – Charles Darwin.
Emotional Intelligence
Evaluating AETC NCRC Partnerships for Impact
Presentation transcript:

The Relationship Between Emotional Intelligence among Supervisors and Conditions of Trust among staff at the Kentucky Department for Public Health Jennifer Redmond, DrPH University of Kentucky November 8, 2010 James W. Holsinger, MD, PhD, William A. Mase, DrPH, MA, Heather Bush, PhD, Martha Riddell, DrPH

Presenter Disclosures (1)The following personal financial relationships with commercial interests relevant to this presentation existed during the past 12 months: Jennifer Redmond No relationships to disclose

Background and Significance 1-3  #8 Essential Public Health Service  Assure a competent public and personal health care workforce  Domains of Public Health Practice (8)  Leadership and Systems Thinking  The Future of the Public’s Health in the 21 st Century report  Federal, state…public health agencies should prioritize leadership training, support and development….

Public Health Performance Logic Model 4 Macro Context Local Public Health System Capacity (Inputs) Public Heath System Purpose and Mission: Performance of core functions: assessment, assurance, policy development Processes (EPHS) Outputs (Programs & Services) Process outcomes (Performance) Community Health Outcomes

Importance of Emotional Intelligence (EI)  EI is the ability to improvise, adapt, and overcome.  EI helps us participate more consciously in what we feel and how we respond, rather than just reacting in the same old patterns.  EI is about understanding emotions and using emotions to be more effective in problem solving, decision making, and influencing others – you CAN learn to become more emotionally intelligent.  Emotional intelligence helps with:  Having more effective relationships.  Being more effective at customer service.  Being a more effective team member.  Becoming a more effective leader.

Leadership and EI  High levels of EI associated with:  Participative management  Putting people at ease  Self-awareness  Work/Life Balance  Straightforwardness/Composure  Building/Mending Relationships  Doing what it takes  Decisiveness  Confronting problem employees  Change management

Trust 6-8  Willingness of a person to be vulnerable to another based on the expectation that the other person will act in a way that is important to the person being vulnerable, regardless of the ability to monitor or control behavior  Trust is the highest form of motivation. It brings out the very best in people. – Stephen Covey  Trust in specific person more predictive than general trust in others  Level of trust related to level of perceived risk  More trust required when risk is higher  Trust enhanced when leaders model behavior leading to trust  As trust increases, so do “win-win” outcomes  Some evidence that trust leads to improved performance

Methodology  Conducted a study on the relationship between emotional intelligence and trust with Kentucky Department for Public Health staff  Pilot: Commissioner and Division Directors  Full: Branch Managers and staff who report directly to them  Survey methodology  Emotional Quotient Inventory (EQ-i®) for supervisors  Multi-health systems (MHS) online survey tool  Conditions of Trust (CTI) for staff  REDCap electronic survey tool developed by Vanderbilt  Quantitative analysis  Descriptive statistics  Linear regression  Pearson correlation analysis  Mixed model analysis

BarOn EQ-i® (Emotional Intelligence) 5  Total EQ  Intrapersonal  Interpersonal  Stress Management  Adaptability  General Mood  Self regard  Emotional Self-awareness  Assertiveness  Independence  Self-actualization  Empathy  Social responsibility  Interpersonal relationships  Stress tolerance  Impulse control  Reality testing  Flexibility  Problem solving  Optimism  Happiness Red text indicates the measures used in correlation and mixed model analysis

Emotional Intelligence Median Scores: Branch Managers (Supervisors) EQ ScaleOverall (Q 1, Q 3 )Male (Q 1, Q 3 )Female (Q 1, Q 3 ) Total EQ:109 (101,116)110 (100, 115)108 (104, 116) Intrapersonal109 (101, 116)109 (95, 116)109.5 (107, 116) Interpersonal106 (94, 112)108 (94, 111)106 (102, 112) Adaptability 108 (101, 113) 105 (101, 111)110 (103, 118) Stress Management 110 (104, 116)110 (104, 114)111.5 (107, 116) Standard ScoreInterpretive guideline High – well developed emotional capacity Average – adequate emotional capacity Interpreting EQ-i® Scale Scores 4

Conditions of Trust 8 : Mean scores of staff who directly report to the Branch Managers Trust ConditionOverall (sd)Male (sd)Female (sd) Overall Trust3.8 (1.20)3.6 (1.21)3.9 (1.20) Availability4.2 (0.82)4.3 (0.88)4.2 (0.78) Competence4.1 (0.97)3.8 (1.03)4.2 (0.95) Consistency3.6 (1.10)3.6 (1.03)3.7 (1.14) Discreetness3.9 (0.94)3.9 (0.74)4.0 (0.96) Fairness4.0 (1.02)4.1 (0.93)4.0 (0.99) Integrity3.9 (1.12)3.7 (1.19)4.0 (1.10) Loyalty3.7 (1.13)3.6 (1.01)3.8 (1.14) Openness3.6 (1.0)3.2 (1.32)3.8 (0.87) Promise Fulfillment3.8 (1.0)3.6 (1.15)3.9 (0.99) Receptivity4.0 (1.08)4.0 (1.20)4.0 (1.08)

Combined Results: Emotional Intelligence and Trust  There was not a relationship between overall trust and total EQ  Must be other factors related to overall trust among staff than the direct supervisor’s total EQ  As the total emotional intelligence of the supervisor increased, the perception by staff that their supervisor was open increased by 0.11 units, p≤0.1when adjusting for demographic characteristics  As the total emotional intelligence of the supervisor increased, the perception by staff that their supervisor was available decreased by 0.09 units, p<0.05, when adjusting for demographic characteristics

Strengths and Limitations  First study evaluating emotional intelligence, trust and public health  Provided potential prioritization of leadership competencies as well as future training opportunities  Limited generalizability due to non-randomized cross- sectional type of study  Self-reported survey data  Did not include organizational context/climate information

Implications for Public Health  Tailor leadership training opportunities  Gender, age, years of service  Leadership principles are important independently  Important foundations for a workforce  Recruitment  Retention  Performance

THANK YOU  Kentucky Department for Public Health, especially Dr. William Hacker, Commissioner  Center of Excellence in Public Health Workforce Research and Policy at the University of Kentucky  My dissertation committee, now colleagues!

Questions??   (859) x252

References 1. CDC. 10 Essential Public Health Services July 26, Available from Tilson, H., Gebbie, K.M. The Public Health Workforce. Annual Review of Public Health (1): IOM. The Future of the Public’s Health in the 21 st Century. 2002; Available from: Scutchfield, FD., Research Questions and Data in PHSSR, an oral presentation at the Academy Health PHSR Interest Group meeting, July 1, 2009, Chicago, IL. 5. Bar-On, R. EQ-i ® BarOn Emotional Quotient Inventory: Technical Manual North Toawanda: Multi-Health Systems. 6. Mayer, R.C., Davis, J.H., Schoorman, F.D., An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust. The Academy of Management Review (3): Covey, S.R. The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People New York: Simon & Schuster. 8. Butler Jr., J.K. Toward Understanding and Measuring Conditions of Trust: Evolution of a Conditions of Trust Inventory. Journal of Management (3):