An Accuracy Assessment of the Polar MM5 Snow Accumulation Model Jared Carse Mentors: Dr. David Braaten, Dr. Claude Laird Graduate Mentors: Aaron Gilbreath,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Introduction to data assimilation in meteorology Pierre Brousseau, Ludovic Auger ATMO 08,Alghero, september 2008.
Advertisements

A thermodynamic model for estimating sea and lake ice thickness with optical satellite data Student presentation for GGS656 Sanmei Li April 17, 2012.
Accumulation Layer Picking Using FMCW CReSIS Radar and North-Central Greenland Ice Core Data Renee’ Butler, David Braaten, Sam Buchanan, Kyle Purdon Center.
Mass Balance: Theory and Application Steve Wilson South Cascade Glacier
WFM 6202: Remote Sensing and GIS in Water Management © Dr. Akm Saiful IslamDr. Akm Saiful Islam WFM 6202: Remote Sensing and GIS in Water Management Akm.
Coupled NMM-CALMET Meteorology Development for the CALPUFF Air Dispersion Modelling in Complex Terrain and Shoreline Settings Presented at: European Geoscience.
Alberta Rainfall-Runoff Analysis September, 2002.
AMS 25th Conference on Hydrology
Spatial variability of interior ice-sheet accumulation determined with an FM-CW radar and connections to the NAO David Braaten, Prasad Gogineni, Claude.
The Use of High Resolution Mesoscale Model Fields with the CALPUFF Dispersion Modelling System in Prince George BC Bryan McEwen Master’s project
SEAT Traverse The Satellite Era Accumulation Traverse (SEAT) collected near-surface firn cores and Ultra High Frequency (UHF) Frequency Modulated.
High variability of Greenland temperature over the past 4000 years estimated from trapped air in an ice core Takuro Kobashi National Institute of Polar.
Do strain rates determine the spatial density of crevasses on the Greenland Ice Sheet? Brandon Scott Saint Augustine’s College Mentor: Kristin Poinar University.
Evaluating Spatial, Temporal, and Clear-Sky Errors in Satellite CO 2 Measurements Katherine Corbin, A. Scott Denning, Ian Baker, Aaron Wang, Lixin Lu TransCom.
Circulation changes on Antarctic Peninsula from ice cores Liz Thomas 1, Gareth Marshall 1 Joe McConnell 2 & Paul Dennis 3 1.British Antarctic Survey 2.Desert.
Expressions of ENSO and the SAM in Modeled Antarctic Surface Temperatures The Transantarctic Mountains, A. Huerta, 2003 David B. Reusch EMS Earth and Environmental.
Analyses: Mean Monthly snowdepth and NAO Fifteen cm is a physically meaningful snowdepth where any additional snow does not change the albedo effect of.
Day 1-3. Variable Selection and GIS Processing 1.Discuss V mapping goals, targeted system (what is vulnerable?), framework 2.Choose data layers (criteria:
David Schneider and Eric Steig Isotopic Records in US-ITASE Cores: A preliminary report WAIS Workshop September, 2003 University of Washington.
Climatology and Predictability of Cool-Season High Wind Events in the New York City Metropolitan and Surrounding Area Michael Layer School of Marine and.
CARPE DIEM Centre for Water Resources Research NUID-UCD Contribution to Area-3 Dusseldorf meeting 26th to 28th May 2003.
Regional Climate Modeling in the Source Region of Yellow River with complex topography using the RegCM3: Model validation Pinhong Hui, Jianping Tang School.
On the Retrieval of Accumulation Rates on the Ice Sheets Using SAR On the Retrieval of Accumulation Rates on the Ice Sheets Using SAR Wolfgang Dierking.
Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute SE Norrköping, SWEDEN COMPARISON OF AREAL PRECIPITATION ESTIMATES: A CASE STUDY FOR A CENTRAL.
Comparative analysis of climatic variability characteristics of the Svalbard archipelago and the North European region based on meteorological stations.
A Statistical Comparison of Weather Stations in Carberry, Manitoba, Canada.
Progress in climate-glacier-ice sheet modelling Jeremy Fyke (LANL) Bill Lipscomb (LANL) Bill Sacks (NCAR) Valentina Radic (UBC, Canada)
TRENDS IN U.S. EXTREME SNOWFALL SEASONS SINCE 1900 Kenneth E. Kunkel NOAA Cooperative Institute for Climate and Satellites - NC David R. Easterling National.
Development of an object- oriented verification technique for QPF Michael Baldwin 1 Matthew Wandishin 2, S. Lakshmivarahan 3 1 Cooperative Institute for.
Figure 12: An image in ArcMap ® of the 2009 Operation IceBridge flights (represented by the colored lines), the ITASE core sites (represented by the black.
5. Accumulation Rate Over Antarctica The combination of the space-borne passive microwave brightness temperature dataset and the AVHRR surface temperature.
The climate and climate variability of the wind power resource in the Great Lakes region of the United States Sharon Zhong 1 *, Xiuping Li 1, Xindi Bian.
This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. ANT Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations.
LMWG progress towards CLM4 –Soil hydrology CLM3.5 major improvement over CLM3 (partitioning of ET into transpiration, soil evap, canopy evap; seasonal.
Variations in mass balance and snow and firn densities along a transect in the percolation zone of the Greenland Ice Sheet Vicki Parry (1), Peter Nienow.
A glacier forms when winter snowfall in an area exceeds summer melt and therefore accumulates year after year. Snow is compacted and converted to glacial.
Model Evaluation Comparing Model Output to Ambient Data Christian Seigneur AER San Ramon, California.
Ed Maurer Partitioning precipitation into rain and snow for event-based hydrologic modeling in the Pacific Northwest U.S. Edwin Maurer Civil Engineering.
University of Kansas S. Gogineni, P. Kanagaratnam, R. Parthasarathy, V. Ramasami & D. Braaten The University of Kansas Wideband Radars for Mapping of Near.
A New Inter-Comparison of Three Global Monthly SSM/I Precipitation Datasets Matt Sapiano, Phil Arkin and Tom Smith Earth Systems Science Interdisciplinary.
MODIS Snow and Sea Ice Data Products George Riggs SSAI Cryospheric Sciences Branch, NASA/GSFC Greenbelt, Md. Dorothy K.
J. Lapazaran A. Martín-Español J. Otero F. Navarro International Symposium on Radioglaciology 9-13 September 2013, Lawrence, Kansas, USA On the errors.
Canada Centre for Remote Sensing Earth Sciences Sector Influence of ice dynamics on firn layer stratigraphy Laurence Gray (1), Ed King, (2), Howard Conway.
CBH statistics for the Provisional Review Curtis Seaman, Yoo-Jeong Noh, Steve Miller and Dan Lindsey CIRA/Colorado State University 12/27/2013.
1 National HIC/RH/HQ Meeting ● January 27, 2006 version: FOCUSFOCUS FOCUSFOCUS FOCUS FOCUSFOCUS FOCUSFOCUS FOCUSFOCUS FOCUSFOCUS FOCUSFOCUS FOCUSFOCUS.
Based on the Mezentsev-Choudhury-Yang equation (with n representing catchments characteristics): and water balance equation R = P ─ E, Yang et al. [2011]
Yvonne Rinne, Departement of Physics, University of Oslo Mesoscale transient flow channels observed in the cusp ionosphere by the EISCAT Svalbard Radar.
Preparing input for the TOPKAPI (TOPographic Kinematic Approximation and Integration) model PRASANNA DAHAL.
METR February Radar Products More Radar Background Precipitation Mode: -Volume Coverage Patterns (VCP) 21: 9 elevation angles with a complete.
Effects of Annual Snowmelt on the New York City Water Supply Adam Czekanski 29 November 2005.
Office of Research and Development National Exposure Research Laboratory, Atmospheric Modeling and Analysis Division October 21, 2009 Evaluation of CMAQ.
1 Validation for CRR (PGE05) NWC SAF PAR Workshop October 2005 Madrid, Spain A. Rodríguez.
Long-term temperature records in Antarctica: The view from ice cores David Schneider Department of Earth and Space Sciences University of Washington Seattle,
Point Comparison in the Arctic (Barrow N, 156.6W ) Part I - Assessing Satellite (and surface) Capabilities for Determining Cloud Fraction, Cloud.
Perspectives on Historical Observing Practices and Homogeneity of the Snowfall Record Kenneth E. Kunkel NOAA Cooperative Institute for Climate and Satellites.
Estimating the Surface Mass Balance of the Antarctic coastal area for climate models validation 1 – Coastal area SMB & sea level rise 2 – SMB observation.
An Overview of Satellite Rainfall Estimation for Flash Flood Monitoring Timothy Love NOAA Climate Prediction Center with USAID- FEWS-NET, MFEWS, AFN Presented.
Global Ice Coverage Claire L. Parkinson NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Presentation to the Earth Ambassador program, meeting at NASA Goddard Space Flight.
Verification methods - towards a user oriented verification The verification group.
Daoxun Sun Outline Background Data Technical details Result EOF of chlorophyll data Correlation with possible factors Summary.
Global vs mesoscale ATOVS assimilation at the Met Office Global Large obs error (4 K) NESDIS 1B radiances NOAA-15 & 16 HIRS and AMSU thinned to 154 km.
NOAA Northeast Regional Climate Center Dr. Lee Tryhorn NOAA Climate Literacy Workshop April 2010 NOAA Northeast Regional Climate.
Indicate the length up to one estimated value…. A. B. C.
Application of Probability Density Function - Optimal Interpolation in Hourly Gauge-Satellite Merged Precipitation Analysis over China Yan Shen, Yang Pan,
IFSAR and terrestrial LIDAR for vegetation study in Sonora, Texas
E R Thomas, E W Wolff and R Mulvaney
TURBULENT MIXING IN THE MIXED LAYER/THERMOCLINE TRANSITION LAYER
Assimilating ocean colour and other marine ECVs
Evaluation of Gridded Snow Products Using CloudSat Snowfall Estimates
Synoptic Patterns Responsible for Snowfall
Presentation transcript:

An Accuracy Assessment of the Polar MM5 Snow Accumulation Model Jared Carse Mentors: Dr. David Braaten, Dr. Claude Laird Graduate Mentors: Aaron Gilbreath, Mitch Oswald

Polar MM5 Model Fifth Generation Mesoscale Model modified for polar climates Developed by Burgess et al. – “ A spatially calibrated model of annual accumulation rate on the Greenland Ice Sheet (1958–2007)” Calibrated using firn cores and meteorological station data Spans year Raster data set

3 of XX

Radar Traverse 375 kilometer traverse from NGRIP to NEEM Snow Accumulation Radar Layers traced in MatLab 4 of XX NGRIP NEEM

5 of XX

Converting Radar data Extract the thickness of between annual traced layers Convert the water equivalent units using ice core density profiles Density interpolated between NGRIP and NEEM density profiles 6 of XX

Import Radar Data into ArcGIS Each layer extracted from MatLab has Lon/Lat coordinates Projected into the same coordinate system that the Model raster data uses 7 of XX

Convert Radar Data to Raster Same spatial resolution is needed to accurately compare between radar and model –Mean of points that lie in each pixel Raster Calculator used to form error assessment 8 of XX

Model Error and Bias 9 of XX Average RMSE = mm

10 of XX Model st. dev. = mm Radar st. dev. = mm

11 of XX

12 of XX

NAO - Radar 13 of XX Correlation = Photo extracted from /

NAO – Ice Cores 14 of XX correlation Correlation

Summary of NAO From ice core data –Negative NAO year produce higher accumulation at NEEM –Positive NAO years produce higher accumulation at NGRIP To be statistically significant –At alpha = 0.10 –Correlation =.243 –The largest correlation occurs at NGRIP ice core with correlation = –Therefore the relationship between NAO and accumulation is not significant. A larger sample size is needed, i.e. more years need to be measured 15 of XX

How well does the model perform? Ice core bias = mm Radar bias = mm Model compared to both radar and ice cores, consistently over-predicts 16 of XX

Future uses of model Could be used as tool to help trace layers –Model corresponds with ice cores fairly well –Large-scale coverage rather than point sources that ice cores give us 17 of XX

Caveats The model accumulation is set annually, January 1 – December 31 Radar layers can be variable –Large storms could produce layers that appear to be annual Model appears to be less variable than accumulation detected through radar 18 of XX

19 of XX