Research Strategy: Residential Ductless Heat Pumps Research and Evaluation Subcommittee Christian Douglass and Josh Rushton January 8, 2016.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Proposed Revision to Energy Star New Homes Deemed Savings September 19, 2008.
Advertisements

Ductless Heat Pumps in Manufactured Homes with Zonal Electric Resistance Heat Adam Hadley Regional Technical Forum February 18, 2015.
Ductless Heat Pumps in Residential Applications Proposed Research Plan.
Deeming Savings for Ductless Heat Pumps in Manufactured Homes Regional Technical Forum January 4 th, 2011.
Residential Clothes Washers and Dryers Technical Subcommittee Ryan Firestone & Christian Douglass Regional Technical Forum March 10, PM.
Electric “Grid” Savings and Non-Electric Benefits for Residential HVAC-effected UES Measures Regional Technical Forum March 20, 2013.
Prescriptive Duct Sealing UES Measure Proposal Regional Technical Forum Subcommittee July 8, 2013.
DHP Supplemental Fuel Screen Subcommittee Meeting Regional Technical Forum December 10, 2013.
Manufactured Homes Calibration: Existing and New Homes Mohit Singh-Chhabra & Josh Rushton RTF Update March 17, 2015.
Manufactured Homes Calibration: Existing and New Homes Mohit Singh-Chhabra & Josh Rushton RTF Update May 12, 2015.
BPA Pre-Pilot, Monmouth  14 homes with installed DHP, single zone, single compressor.  11 Monmouth, 2 Moses Lake, 1 Tacoma  Savings.
Research Strategy Review: Heat Pump Water Heaters Thermostatic Restriction Valves Jennifer Anziano RTF R&E Subcommittee July 8, 2015.
Heat Pump Water Heater (HPWH) Subcommittee Christian Douglass Regional Technical Forum June 18, 2015.
DHP for Houses with Electric FAF Provisional UES Measure Proposal Adam Hadley, Ben Hannas, Bob Davis Regional Technical Forum January 21, 2015.
EvergreenEcon.com Heat Pump Water Heater Model Validation, Market Progress Assessment, and Process Evaluation RTF HPWH Sub-Committee Meeting October 15,
Manufactured Homes Calibration: Existing and New Homes Mohit Singh-Chhabra & Josh Rushton RTF MH Calibration Subcommittee February 27, 2015.
Manufactured Homes Calibration: Existing and New Homes Josh Rushton & Mohit Singh-Chhabra RTF Update June 16, 2015.
Capacity Impacts of Energy Efficiency What We Know and What We Don’t Know March 11, 2014.
1 NORTHWEST ENERGY EFFICIENCY ALLIANCE Creating a DHP UES Measure Ecotope, Inc. July 16, 2013.
DHP for Houses with Electric FAF Research Plan: Revisions Adam Hadley, Ben Hannas, Bob Davis, My Ton R&E Subcommittee February 25, 2015.
RTF Staff, Subcommittee and Work Updates October 23, 2012.
1 NORTHWEST ENERGY EFFICIENCY ALLIANCE Northwest Ductless Heat Pump Pilot Project Impact & Process Evaluation: Billing Analysis Ecotope, Inc. February.
Delivery Verification Jennifer Anziano Regional Technical Forum March 17, 2015.
RTF Management Update Jennifer Anziano Regional Technical Forum April 14, 2015.
Ben Larson 28 September th Avenue NE, Seattle, WA (206) Fax: (206)
Oregon ENERGY STAR Homes Measure Update Adam Hadley Regional Technical Forum March 17, 2015.
Residential Single Family and Manufactured Home Heat Pump Water Heaters Christian Douglass Regional Technical Forum 4/14/2015.
SEEM Calibration: Phase-2 Adjustments for Failed VBDD Fits Regional Technical Forum August 12, 2014.
BPA M&V Protocols Overview of BPA M&V Protocols and Relationship to RTF Guidelines for Savings and Standard Savings Estimation Protocols.
Path for Multi-Family (MF) Weatherization and NC Measures Christian Douglass 8/18/2015.
SEEM Calibration: Phase II Single Family Heating Energy Regional Technical Forum September 17, 2013 Presented By: Josh Rushton and Adam Hadley Subcommittee.
SEEM Calibration: Phase II Single Family Heating Energy Regional Technical Forum August 20, 2013 Presented By: Josh Rushton and Adam Hadley Subcommittee.
Ductless Heat Pumps (DHP) in Single Family Homes with Zonal Electric Heat Proven UES Measure Proposal Regional Technical Forum November 19, 2013.
1 NORTHWEST ENERGY EFFICIENCY ALLIANCE DHP Costs & NEBs Ecotope, Inc. August 20, 2013.
1 NORTHWEST ENERGY EFFICIENCY ALLIANCE DHP UES Key Issues & Decisions Ecotope, Inc. May 21, 2013.
Research Strategy Review: Advanced Power Strips MH HVAC Related Measures Jennifer Anziano RTF R&E Subcommittee August 6, 2015.
Residential Duct Insulation New Deemed Measure Proposal – A Second Look Regional Technical Forum May 4 th, 2010.
Implementer’s Group July 2015 RTF Meeting Debrief and Upcoming Meeting Prep July 29, 2015.
Variable Speed Heat Pumps Provisional UES Proposal Presentation to the Regional Technical Forum September 18, 2012 Presentation by Kacie Bedney, Bonneville.
Evaluation of Wood Smoke Quantification and Attribution RTF PAC October 17, 2014.
SEEM Calibration for Manufactured Housing Regional Technical Forum December 13, 2011 Analysis Performed ByAdam Hadley Cursory Reviews ByTom Eckman, Ben.
Wood Smoke Study: RTF Report Technical Subcommittee Meeting September 26 th,
Residential New SF Energy Star Homes UES Measure Update December 17th, 2013.
Electric “Grid” Savings and Non-Electric Benefits for Residential HVAC-affected UES Measures Regional Technical Forum March 20, 2013.
PTCS Commissioning, Controls & Sizing Update of UES Measure Category and/or Status Regional Technical Forum July 15, 2014.
Ductless Heat Pumps (DHP) in Single Family Homes with Zonal Electric Heat UES Measure Update Regional Technical Forum March 18, 2014.
1 Proposed Changes to the RTF’s Heat Pump Deemed Savings and Cost- Effectiveness Draft 6th Plan Assumptions April 7, 2009.
Ductless Heat Pumps (DHP) in Single Family Homes with Zonal Electric Heat Proven UES Measure Proposal Regional Technical Forum October 16, 2013.
Working Towards Better Savings Estimates for HVAC and Weatherization Measures Regional Technical Forum September 16, 2014.
ENERGY STAR and Eco-Rated Homes: Planning Estimates and Research Strategy Regional Technical Forum December 8 th, 2015 Josh Rushton & Mohit Singh-Chhabra.
Multifamily Homes: Calibration Update Regional Technical Forum December 8 th, 2015.
New Construction Calibration Preliminary Research and a Request for Guidance on Issues Raised in December Regional Technical Forum January 22, 2013.
Applying SEEM Updates, Calibration, and Measure Interaction Decisions to: Manufactured Homes Weatherization UES Measures Regional Technical Forum December.
Where did it go? Lost savings found in real-world data SEEM Calibration for the Northwest Power and Conservation Council’s Regional Technical Forum (RTF)
Research Strategy: New-Construction Manufactured Home Measures Research and Evaluation Subcommittee Josh Rushton November 19, 2015.
Idaho and Montana Residential Single Family New Construction Measures Mohit Singh-Chhabra Regional Technical Forum October 20 th, 2015.
RTF New Homes Subcommittee February 11, 2016 Next Step Homes Update.
RTF Management Update Jennifer Anziano Regional Technical Forum July 21, 2015.
Non-Proven Residential Duct Sealing Measures: Research Strategy Josh Rushton and Adam Hadley Research and Evaluation Subcommittee October 7, 2015.
Implementer’s Group December Meeting Debrief and Upcoming Meeting Prep January 6, 2015.
RTF Management Update Jennifer Anziano Regional Technical Forum March 17, 2015.
Implementer’s Group October 2015 RTF Meeting Debrief and Upcoming Meeting Prep October 29, 2015.
Research planning at the RTF and Research check-ins & sunset extensions: Commissioning, Controls, and Sizing of Ducted Heat Pumps Ductless Heat pumps for.
RTF’s Engagement with Research Jennifer Light RTF Policy Advisory Committee February 19, 2016.
Heat Pump Water Heaters: Interior, Ducted Installations Presentation to the Regional Technical Forum December 13, 2011 Ben Larson, Ecotope
IR-sensing Advanced Power Strips; Weatherization for Existing Multi-family homes Research and Evaluation Subcommittee Josh Rushton March 4, 2016.
Ductless Heat Pumps (DHP) in Single Family Homes with Zonal Electric Heat UES Measure Update Regional Technical Forum June 17, 2014.
Single Family New Construction Measure: Slab Insulation Mohit Singh-Chhabra Regional Technical Forum April 19 th, 2016.
Manufactured Homes: Heat Pump Related Measures Regional Technical Forum Presentation August 18 th, 2015.
Working Towards Better Savings Estimates for HVAC and Weatherization Measures Regional Technical Forum September 16, 2014.
Presentation transcript:

Research Strategy: Residential Ductless Heat Pumps Research and Evaluation Subcommittee Christian Douglass and Josh Rushton January 8, 2016

Overview This presentation focuses on a Research Strategy related to residential ductless heat pumps (DHPs) Research would affect multiple RTF measures – Residential Heating/Cooling – DHP for Zonal Heat SF (Proven UES) Residential Heating/Cooling – DHP for Zonal Heat SF – Residential Heating/Cooling – DHP for Zonal Heat MH (Small Saver UES) Residential Heating/Cooling – DHP for Zonal Heat MH – Residential Heating/Cooling – DHP for Forced Air Furnace SF and MH (Planning UES) Residential Heating/Cooling – DHP for Forced Air Furnace SF and MH – Any other measures that may require a DHP to be modeled (e.g., ENERGY STAR home with DHP, weatherization in homes with DHPs) Research needed to support savings for higher-performance DHPs Seeking subcommittee feedback/recommendations: Is the outlined research approach reasonable? – Likely to succeed as advertised? – Does estimated cost range match outlined research? – Recommended modifications or alternative approach? Is more research really needed for Proven category? 2

Outline Background – Addition of higher DHP efficiency tiers – Existing data and scope of update – Uncertainty in savings for high-performance DHPs Research Strategy – Objectives – Straw-man approach 3

Background 4 – DHP Background

Proposed Addition of DHP Efficiency Tiers Current RTF DHP measures assume a single, minimum efficiency level of 9.5 HSPF NEEA interested in offering multiple DHP efficiency “tiers”: – Tier 1: HSPF 9.5 to 11 – Tier 2: HSPF 11 to 12.5 – Tier 3: HSPF >12.5 For Tiers 1 and 2, we already have calibrated, reliable savings estimates based on empirical data from the NEEA DHP pilot project (field study 1 and billing analysis 2 ) We do not have empirical in situ data for Tier 3 5 – DHP Background 1 NEEA, Ductless Heat Pump Impact & Process Evaluation: Field Metering Report, prepared by Ecotope, May 2012.Ductless Heat Pump Impact & Process Evaluation: Field Metering Report 2 NEEA, Ductless Heat Pump Impact & Process Evaluation: Billing Analysis Report, prepared by Ecotope, August 2013.Ductless Heat Pump Impact & Process Evaluation: Billing Analysis Report

Existing Data and Scope of Update NEEA pilot project was a major effort that collected many pieces of data, most of which do not need to be updated under this research strategy – Site characteristics data – Pre-/post-billing data – Sub-metering of DHP, resistance heat, DHW – Measurement of fraction of heat load met by DHP – Survey of supplemental fuel use – Measurement of in-situ COP, output capacity 6 – DHP Background Only part that would need updating

Uncertainty in Savings How much uncertainty would we introduce if we estimated Tier 3 savings based on figures published by manufacturers? Published figures suggest 5-7% more energy consumption in first generation Fujistu DHP (top performer in NEEA field study) than third generation Fujitsu (currently available) – Heating COP of first generation unit: 4.39 – Heating COP of third generation unit: 5.33 RTF UES values for DHPs are around 2000 kWh/year for zonal homes and 4000 kWh/year for FAF homes – Published figures therefore suggest about 120 kWh more savings per unit for zonal and 240 kWh for FAF – If we split that uncertainty range in half, uncertainty in savings would be +/60 kWh to 120 kWh per year, per unit (for zonal and FAF, respectively) – 60 kWh/year times 500k potential units plus 120 kWh/year times 225k potential units yields about 7 aMW (range of uncertainty) 7 – DHP Background IMPORTANT: Research strategy states nearly 20%, but we found an error in our math.

Research Strategy 8 – DHP Research Strategy

Research Objective Empirically estimate the in-situ COP and output heating capacity of >12.5 HPSF DHPs over a wide range of outdoor temperatures Not objectives of this research strategy: – Fraction of heating load met by the DHP versus other heating sources (know this well enough from NEEA field study) – Effects of wood heat (known well enough from NEEA billing analysis) 9 – DHP Research Strategy

Straw-man Approach Approach based on detailed metering of small number of units Meter data: Study units equipped with “COP monitoring instruments” same as in NEEA field study, logged at five minute intervals: – DHP power usage, supply air temperature, return air temperature, indoor unit airflow, outside air temperature Analysis: Use interval-level power consumption, heat output, and outdoor temperature to estimate COP as a function of outdoor air temperature – Code this function into SEEM to model >12.5 HSPF DHP systems – UES values then estimated similar to existing DHP for Zonal Heat measures (same baseline and “calibration” factors) 10 – DHP Research Strategy

Straw-man Approach (continued) Metering period: Minimum of 30 days during the winter to capture a wide range of outdoor temperatures Sample size: Staff proposes sampling 5 units – Small sample because we are only after in situ COPs (not after usage patterns, etc.) Sample disposition: No particular needs called out in research strategy Estimated cost range: $25,000 and $100, – DHP Research Strategy

Analyst Recommendation Although estimated range of uncertainty in regional savings potential is not trivial (0-7 aMW), the estimated increment in savings per unit is small and could be difficult to detect Based on this, CAT thinks it is reasonable to: – make a minor extrapolation from the Tier 2 unit consumption to represent Tier 3 unit consumption – propose the Tier 3 DHP measure as Proven 12

Additional Slides 13 – DHP Additional Slides

How Data Feeds into Savings Estimates DHP performance characteristics – Data from NEEA field study: Detailed in situ metering data for 95 DHPs (efficiencies ranging from 8 to 12 HSPF) – Used to estimate COP curves and output capacity – Developed SEEM parameters for three DHP options (8, 10, 12 HSPF) Tie SEEM-modelled savings to differences between pre and post billing data – Data from NEEA field study: Site characteristics and pre- and post-DHP billing data for sample of electrically heated homes (screened to eliminate wood heat) – This step accounts for possible comfort take-back and things like systematic error in SEEM’s estimate of the portion of load being met by the DHP – Idea: Relationship between calibrated-SEEM (DHP) and post-DHP billing data must reflect relationship between calibrated-SEEM (ER-zonal) and pre-DHP billing data Account for effect of wood heat in actual program homes – Data from NEEA billing analysis: Square footage, wood heat indicator, and pre- /post-DHP billing data for ~3000 homes – Idea is to quantify this: When DHP is installed, electric heating kWh/ft 2 decreases a lot in homes without wood heat and only a little in homes with wood heat 14 – DHP Additional Slides Part we propose updating

What is a Research Strategy? Clarifies knowledge gaps in non-Proven measures Focuses on high-priority research objectives – What does the RTF need for the measure to be proven? – Anything researchers should pay special attention to? Outlines a straw-man approach to data collection and analysis – Demonstrates one feasible least-cost research path – Research Sponsors develop final Research Plan Sponsors can work with RTF staff to ensure plan addresses RTF needs RTF reviews final Research Plan later (at Provisional  Planning step) Calls out approaches that probably wouldn’t suffice (optional) Provides a rough cost estimate (based on straw-man approach) Research Strategies try to be BRIEF: Critical items shouldn’t get lost in a sea of helpful suggestions 15 – DHP Additional Slides